Accuracy of 30-Minute Indirect Calorimetry Studies in Predicting 24-Hour Energy Expenditure in Mechanically Ventilated,Critically Ill Patients

Abstract

Background: There is no consensus regarding the optimal duration of measurement or time of day to perform indirect calorimetry (IC). Energy expenditure (EE) varies at different times of day and with different activity levels. We sought to assess the variability of EE in mechanically ventilated patients over a 24-hour period and the accuracy of 30-minute IC studies in predicting the 24-hour energy expenditure (EE24). Methods: The study was a prospective comparison between the resting EE obtained by 30-minute measurement of IC and EE values obtained from 24-hour measurements. Tests were performed in the Medical Intensive Care Unit (MICU) of a tertiary care, university hospital. Oxygen consumption (VO₂) and carbon dioxide production (VCO₂) were measured for 24 hours in eight ventilated patients. Measurements were made every 3 minutes and used to calculate 30-minute and 24-hour oxygen consumption values. EE24 was calculated using the modified Weir equation. Each 30-minute interval was compared with the value obtained from the 24-hour measurement. Results: Three hundred forty-one of 384 30-minute intervals remained for analysis. Average EE24 measured was 1490 ± 486 kcal/d. Average EE24 predicted by extrapolation from 30-minute studies was 1501 ± 503 kcal/d, with a mean difference of 0 ± 209 kcal/d from the measured 24-hour values (range: -1068 to + 585 kcal/d). Thirty-minute studies were within 20% of 24-hour measurements for 89% of intervals. The difference between 24-hour and 30-minute studies correlated with changes in minute ventilation (VE), heart rate, systolic blood pressure, and breath rate from their 24-hour means (p < .001). The mean error of EE estimate was greatest between 3 and 11 PM (p < .001). Conclusions: We conclude the following: (1) EE in MICU patients is variable; (2) 30-minute IC studies predict measured EE24 acceptably well for clinical purposes; and (3) accuracy is maximized if a 30-minute study is performed between 11 PM and 3 PM, and when VE, heart rate, systolic blood pressure, and breath rate are near the day's average. (Journal of Payenteral and Enteral Nutrition 21:168-174,1997)

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Gay PC , Dellinger RP , Shelhamer JH , et al: ACCP Council on Critical Care. The practice of critical care medicine-a national survey report. Chest 104:271-278, 1993

Daly JM , Heymsfield SB , Head CA , et al: Human energy requirements: Overestimation by widely used prediction equation. Am J Clin Nutr 42:1170-1174,1985

Cortes V. , Nelson LD : Errors in estimating energy expenditure in critically ill surgical patients . Arch Surg 124:287-290, 1989

Mann S. , Westenko DR , Houtchens BA : Measured and predicted caloric expenditure in the acutely ill. Crit Care Med 13:173-177, 1985

Makk LJK , McClave SA , Creech PW , et al: Clinical application of the metabolic cart to the delivery of total parental nutrition. Crit Care Med 18:1320-1327, 1990

Saffle JR , Medina JR , Raymond J. , et al: Use of indirect calorimetry in the nutritional management of burned patients. J Trauma 25:32-39, 1985

Weissman C. , Kemper M. , Askanazi J. , et al: Resting metabolic rate of the critically ill patient: Measured versus predicted. Anesthesiology 64:673-679, 1986

Hunter DC , Jaksic T. , Lewis D. , et al: Resting energy expenditure in the critically ill: Estimations versus measurement. Br J Surg 75:875-878, 1988

Van Lanschot JB , Feenstra BW , Vermeij CG , et al: Calculation versus measurement of total energy expenditure. Crit Care Med 14:981-985, 1986

10.

Saffle JR , Larson CM , Sullivan J. : A randomized trial of indirect calorimetry-based feedings in thermal injury . J Trauma 30:776-783, 1990

11.

Liggett SB , Renfro AD : Energy expenditures of mechanically ventilated nonsurgical patients . Chest 98:682-686, 1990

12.

Ireton-Jones CS , Turner WW , Liepa GU , et al: Equations for the estimation of energy expenditures in patients with burns with special reference to ventilatory status. J Bum Care Rehab 13:330-333, 1992

13.

Smyrnios NA , Curley FJ , Jederlinic PJ , et al: Indirect calorimetry in the medical ICU: Comparison with traditional practice and effects on cost of care (Abstr) . Am Rev Respir Dis 141:A581, 1990

14.

Vermeij CG , Feenstra BW , Van Lanschot JB , et al: Day to day variability of energy expenditure in critically ill surgical patients. Crit Care Med 17:623-626, 1989

15.

Rumpler WV , Seale WV , Conway JM , et al: Repeatability of 24 hour energy expenditure measurements in humans by indirect calorimetry. Am J Clin Nutr 51:147-152, 1990

16.

Kimoff RJ , Cheong TH , Cosio MG , et al: Pulmonary denervation in humans: Effects on dyspnea and ventilatory pattern during exercise. Am Rev Respir Dis 142:1034-1040, 1990

17.

Ultman J. , Burzstein S. : Analysis of error in the deternvination of respiratory gas exchange at varying FIO2. J Appl Physiol 50:210-216, 1981

18.

Weissman C. , Kemper M. , Elwyn D. , et al: The energy expenditure of the mechanically ventilated critically ill patient-an analysis. Chest 89:254-259, 1986

19.

Liggett SB , St John RE , Lefrak SS : Determination of resting energy expenditure utilizing the thermodilution pulmonary artery catheter. Chest 91:562-566. 1987

20.

Long CI , Schaeffel N. , Geiger JW , et al: Metabolic response to injury and illness: Estimation of energy and protein needs from indirect calorimetry and nitrogen balance. JPEN 3:452-456, 1979

21.

Laaban JP , Lemaire F. , Baron JF , et al: Influence of caloric intake on the respiratory mode during mandatory minute volume ventilation. Chest 87:67-72, 1985

22.

Nordenstrom J. , Askanazi J. , Elwyn DH , et al: Nitrogen balance during parenteral nutrition. Ann Surg 197:27-33, 1983

23.

Cortes V. , Nelson LD : Errors in estimating energy expenditure in critically ill surgical patients . Arch Surg 124:287-290, 1989

24.

Head CA , McManus CB , Seitz S. , et al: A simple and accurate indirect calorimetry system for assessment of resting energy expenditure. JPEN 8:45-48, 1984

25.

Damask MC , Askanazi J. , Elwyn DH , et al: Artifacts in measurement of resting energy expenditure. Crit Care Med 11:750-752, 1983

26.

Askanazi J. , Rosenbaum SH , Hyman AI , et al: Respiratory changes induced by the large glucose loads of total parenteral nutrition. JAMA 243:1444-1447, 1980

27.

Van Lanschot J. , Feenstra B. , Vermeij C. , et al: Accuracy of intermittent metabolic gas exchange recordings extrapolated for diurnal variation . Crit Care Med 16:737-742, 1988

28.

Swinamer D. , Phang P. , Jones R. , et al: Twenty four hour energy expenditure in critically ill patients. Crit Care Med 15:637-643, 1987

29.

Weissman C. , Kemper M. , Hyman AI : Variation in the resting metabolic rate of mechanically ventilated critically ill patients. Anesth Analg 68:457-461, 1989