Comparison of Weighted vs Unweighted Enteral Feeding Tubes for Efficacy of Transpyloric Intubation

Abstract

Routine transpyloric placement of feeding tubes reduces aspiration in intensive care unit patients. Spontaneous passage eliminates the need for radiologic or endoscopic intervention. It is unclear whether the addition of a weight to the end of the tube or the use of the prokinetic agent metoclopramide in the conventional dose (10 mg) improves spontaneous transpyloric placement. In a randomized, prospective trial, 39 intensive care unit patients (age >2 years) had a total of 50 nasoenteral tubes placed after intravenous metoclopramide (20 mg in adults, 0.2 mg/kg in children). The tubes were 8 French in diameter with either a weighted end or an unweighted bullet tip. Tip position was confirmed radiographically within 4 hours after blinded placement and at 1 and 2 days if spontaneous passage had not occurred. At 4 hours, 36% of the weighted tubes and 84% of the unweighted tubes (p < .002) had passed through the pylorus. At 1 day, 48% of the weighted tubes and 86% of the unweighted tubes (p < .007) had achieved transpyloric position. At 2 days, 56% and 92% of the weighted and unweighted tubes, respectively, had passed through the pylorus (p < .009, χ²). The occurrence of transpyloric passage and the rapidity at which it occurred was significantly greater for the unweighted tube during all time periods. A poststudy trial was conducted to evaluate the effect of the normal dose of metoclopramide (10 mg in adults and 0.1 mg/kg in children) and the transpyloric passage of the unweighted feeding tube. Twenty-five patients received 10 mg of metoclopramide before the insertion of the unweighted tube. Within a 4-hour period, 22 (88%) of 25 tubes passed through the pylorus spontaneously. There was no statistical difference between the use of 10 and 20 mg of metoclopramide. The combination of preinsertion metoclopramide and a tapered, unweighted feeding tube achieved transpyloric position in a vast majority of intensive care unit patients, obviating the need for additional intervention. ( Journal of Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition 17:271-273, 1993)