Clinical Efficacy and Design Changes of "Fine Bore" Nasogastric Feeding Tubes: A Seven-Year Experience Involving 809 Intubations in 403 Patients

Abstract

We report here our clinical experiences of "fine bore" nasogastric feeding tubes. Data have been collated over a 7-year period (1978-1985). A total of 403 patients were intubated on 809 occasions. In the first retrospective study, the clinical use of 491 unweighted tubes was compared with that of fifty 3.5-g weighted tubes. No advantage was found in the use of the weighted tubes. In the second prospective controlled clinical trial, these results were confirmed. Forty-six patients were intubated on 76 occasions with an 85-cm open-ended, unweighted nasogastric feeding tube (Prima, Portex UK), and 57 patients were intubated on 79 occasions with a 91-cm 3.0-g weighted tube (Entriflex, Biosearch, Raritan, NJ). Mean duration of placement was similar in each case, and 62% of both types of tubes were inadvertently removed. Without exception, all the tubes remained in the stomach throughout. Disappointed with the similar and overall performance of both types of tubes, we initiated a design program which resulted in the development of two new nasogastric tubes, one weighted and one unweighted. The tubes were manufactured with polyurethane, rather than polyvinychloride (PVC), which permitted an increase in diameter of the internal lumen which, in turn, was coated with water-activated lubricant to ease removal of the introducer wire. A specially modeled outflow port was incorporated into the tips of both tubes. The performance of the two new polyurethane nasogastric feeding tubes was assessed under controlled trial conditions; as a reference, a widely used PVC unweighted open-ended tube was used. Although intubation times were similar in patients without concurrent endotracheal intubation, it took a significantly shorter time to intubate patients with concurrent endotracheal intubation with the new weighted tube. After tube intubation, it was possible to aspirate gastric contents significantly more often through the new polyurethane tubes ( p < 0.001) than through the PVC tube, and the unweighted polyurethane tube stayed in situ longer (p < 0.05) than the PVC tube. The newly designed polyurethane nasogastric feeding tubes are the first tubes that have been shown to have advantages over the simpler type of open-ended, unweighted PVC nasogastric feeding tubes. (Journal of Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition 11:378-383, 1987)