Does Consolidation of Variable Interest Entities Improve the Pricing of Financial Reporting in Bank Holding Companies? Evidence From FAS 166/167

Abstract

The study examines whether consolidating qualified special-purpose entities (QSPEs) under Statement of Financial Accounting Standards Nos. 166 and 167 (FAS 166/167) improves the market reaction to earnings disclosures. We use a difference-in-difference design to compare the change sample, which is defined as banks that consolidate QSPEs after FAS 166/167, with the no-effect sample, which is defined as financial institutions with no QSPEs or banks that do not consolidate QSPEs after FAS 166/167. The results show that, during a short window around earnings announcements, the change sample experiences higher market reaction to earnings surprises than the no-effect sample after the implementation of FAS 166/167. We also find that the effect is more pronounced in banks that engage in securitization and in financial institutions whose securitized loans originate primarily from consumer loans rather than mortgages. Additional analysis also finds that adopting FAS 166/167 enhances the ability of earnings to predict future earnings and future cash flows in banks. The important implication of the study for regulators is that FAS 166/167 improves bank transparency.

Keywords

FAS 166/167 QSPE consolidation securitization earnings predictability

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abad

Laffarga

Garcia-Borbolla

Larrdn

Piñero

J. M.

Garrod

(2000). An evaluation of the value relevance of consolidated versus unconsolidated accounting information: Evidence from quoted Spanish Firms. Journal of International Financial Management and Accounting, 11(3), 156-177.

Altamuro

Beatty

(2010). How does internal control regulation affect financial reporting? Journal of Accounting and Economics, 49(1), 58-74.

Ayotte

Gaon

(2011). Asset backed securities: Costs and benefits of bankruptcy remoteness. The Review of Financial Studies, 24(4), 1299-1335.

Ball

Brown

(1968). An empirical evaluation of accounting income numbers. Journal of Accounting Research, 6(2), 159-178.

Barth

M. E.

Landsman

W. R.

(2010). How did financial reporting contribute to the financial crisis? European Accounting Review, 19(3), 399-423.

Barth

M. E.

Ormazabal

Taylor

D. J.

(2012). Asset securitizations and credit risk. The Accounting Review, 87(2), 423-448.

Bens

D. A.

Monahan

S. J.

(2008). Altering investment decisions to manage financial reporting outcomes: Asset-backed commercial paper conduits and FIN 46. Journal of Accounting Research, 46(5), 1017-1055.

Callahan

C. M.

Smith

R. E.

Spencer

A. W.

(2012, July). An examination of the cost of capital implications of Financial Interpretation 46. The Accounting Review, 87(4), 1105-1134.

Chen

Liu

C. C.

Ryan

S. G.

(2008). Characteristics of securitizations that determine issuers’ retention of the risks of the securitized assets. The Accounting Review, 83(5), 1181-1215.

10.

Cheng

Dhaliwal

D. S.

Neamtiu

(2011). Asset securitization, securitization resource, and information uncertainty. The Accounting Review, 86(2), 541-568.

11.

Coallier

(2002). Buyer beware of off-the-books funding. Mergers and Acquisitions, 37(10), 29-34.

12.

DeAngelo

L. E.

(1981). Auditor independence, “low balling,” and disclosure regulation. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 3(2), 113-127.

13.

Dechow

P. M.

Myers

L. A. S.

Shakespeare

(2010). Fair value accounting and gains from asset securitizations: A convenient earnings management tool with compensation side-benefits. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 49(1-–2), 2-25.

14.

Dechow

P. M.

Richardson

S. A.

Sloan

R. G.

(2008). The persistence and pricing of the cash component of earnings. Journal of Accounting Research, 46(3), 537-566.

15.

Dechow

P. M.

Shakespeare

(2009). Do managers time securitizations for their accounting benefits? The Accounting Review, 84(1), 99-132.

16.

Dharan

B. G.

(2002). Financial engineering with special purpose entities. In Brazelton

J. K.

Ammons

J. L.

(Eds.), Enron and beyond: Technical analysis of accounting, corporate governance and securities (pp. 301-325). CCH.

17.

Dionne

Harchaoui

T. M.

(2008). Banks’ capital, securitization and credit risk: Empirical evidence for Canada. Insurance and Risk Management, 75(4), 459-485.

18.

Dou

Ryan

Xie

(2018). The real effects of FAS 166/167 on banks’ mortgage approval and sale decisions. Journal of Accounting Research, 56(3), 843-882.

19.

Feng

Gramlich

J. D.

Gupta

(2009). Special purpose vehicles: Empirical evidence on determinants and earnings management. The Accounting Review, 84(6), 1833-1876.

20.

Financial Accounting Standards Board. (1959). Consolidated financial statements: Accounting Research Bulletin No. 51 (ARB No. 51). Accounting Principles Board.

21.

Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2000). Accounting for transfers and servicing of financial assets and extinguishments of liabilities: A replacement of FASB Statement 125 (Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 140).

22.

Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2003a). Consolidation of variable interest entities—An interpretation of ARB No.51 (Statement of Financial Accounting Standards Interpretation No. 46).

23.

Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2003b). Consolidation of variable interest entities (revised December 2003)—An interpretation of ARB No. 51 (FIN 46R).

24.

Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2009a). Accounting for transfers of financial assets: An amendment of FASB statement No. 140 (Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 166).

25.

Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2009b). Amendments to FASB interpretation No. 46(R). (Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 167).

26.

Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2009c). News release 06/12/09, FASB issues statements 166 and 167 Pertaining to securitizations and special purpose entities. http://www.fasb.org/cs/ContentServer?pagename=FASB/FASBContent_C/NewsPage&cid=1176156240834

27.

Ghosh

Moon

(2005). Auditor tenure and perceptions of audit quality. The Accounting Review, 80(2), 585-612.

28.

Gurun

U. G.

Lerman

Ronen

(2012). Anticipatory and implementation effects of FIN 46 on the behavior of different market participants. Asia-pacific Journal of Accounting & Economics, 19(1), 30-55.

29.

Hanlon

Maydew

E. L.

Shevlin

(2008). An unintended consequence of book-tax conformity: A loss of earnings informativeness. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 46(2), 294-311.

30.

Harris

T. S.

Lang

Möller

H. P.

(1994). The value relevance of German accounting measures: An empirical analysis. Journal of Accounting Research, 32(2), 187-209.

31.

Hartgraves

A. L.

Benston

G. J.

(2002). The evolving accounting standards for special purpose entities and consolidations. Accounting Horizons, 16(3), 245-258.

32.

Henry

Holzmann

O. J.

(2009). FASB, IASB respond to financial crisis. Journal of Corporate Accounting & Finance, 20(3), 71-75.

33.

Henry

Holzmann

O. J.

Yang

Y. W.

(2008). The recent credit crunch and GAAP. Journal of Corporate Accounting & Finance, 19(5), 89-94.

34.

Herz

(2008). Speech on “Lessons learned, relearned, and relearned again from the credit crisis—Accounting and beyond.”http://www.fasb.org/news/09-18-08_herz_speech.pdf

35.

Hoyle

J. B.

Schaefer

T. F.

Doupnik

T. S.

(2011). Advanced accounting (11th ed.). McGraw-Hill.

36.

Hsu

A. W. H.

Duh

R. R.

Cheng

(2012). Does the control-based approach to consolidated statements better reflect market value than the ownership-based approach ? The International Journal of Accounting, 47(2), 198-225.

37.

Hsu

A. W. H.

Pourjalali

(2016). The impact of IAS No.27 on the market’s ability to anticipate future earnings. Contemporary Accounting Research, 32(2), 789-813.

38.

International Accounting Standards Board. (2003). Consolidated and separate financial statements (IAS 27).

39.

International Accounting Standards Board. (2004). Consolidation-special purpose entities (SIC 12).

40.

Johnson

(2007, August 29). Accounting consequences of subprime loan modifications: Senator Schumer urges wider understanding. Deloitte “Heads Up,”14(17). https://www.iasplus.com/en/binary/usa/headsup/headsup0708subprime.pdf

41.

Karaoglu

(2005). Regulatory capital and earnings management in banks: The case of loan sales and securitizations [Working Paper]. University of Southern California.

42.

Lander

G. H.

Barker

Zabelina

Williams

T. A.

(2009). Subprime mortgage tremors: An international issue. International Advances in Economic Research, 15(1), 1-16.

43.

Landsman

W. R.

Peasnell

K. V.

Shakespeare

(2008). Are asset securitizations sales or loans? The Accounting Review, 83(5), 1251-1272.

44.

Leland

H. E.

(2007). Financial synergies and the optimal scope of the firm: Implications for mergers, spinoffs, and structured finance. The Journal of Finance, 62(2), 765-807.

45.

Lemmon

Liu

L. X.

Mao

M. Q.

(2010). Asset-backed securitization in industrial firms: An empirical investigation [Working Paper]. Hong Kong University of Science and Technology.

46.

Lim

Tan

(2008). Non-audit service fees and audit quality: The impact of auditor specialization. Journal of Accounting Research, 46(1), 199-246.

47.

Niu

F. F.

Richardson

G. D.

(2006). Are securitizations in-substance sales or secured borrowings: Capital market evidence. Contemporary Accounting Research, 23(4), 1105-1133.

48.

(2013). Did FAS 166 and FAS 167 improve the transparency of securitizing banks? [Working Paper]. Stern School of Business, New York University.

49.

Petersen

(2009). Estimating standard errors in finance panel data sets: Comparing approaches. Review of Financial Studies, 2(1), 435-480.

50.

Pourjalali

Wilde

L. T. F.

Clarke

R. F.

(2009). The effect of Financial Interpretation Number 46 on electric utility companies. Journal of Accounting, Auditing & Finance, 24(2), 263-293.

51.

Sidel

Reilly

Enrich

(2007). Citigroup alters course, bails out affiliated funds. The Wall Street Journal. https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB119759010104328237.

52.

Teoh

S. H.

Wong

T. J.

(1993). Perceived auditor quality and the earnings response coefficient. The Accounting Review, 24(2), 263-293.

53.

Tian

Zhang

(2017). Impact of FAS 166 and FAS 167 on the securitization of credit card loans [Working Paper]. Fisher College of Business, The Ohio State University.

54.

Tucker

(2010). Selection bias and econometric remedies in accounting and finance research. Journal of Accounting Literature, 29, 31-57.