Market Reaction to Earnings Surprise Warnings: The Incremental Effect of Shareholder Litigation Risk on the Warning Effect

Abstract

We examine the incremental effect of shareholder litigation risk on market reaction to earnings surprise warnings, that is, the warning effect. Prior research examines earnings warnings by firms reporting large earnings news (at least 1% of share price), and finds a negative warning effect for bad news firms but no warning effect for good news firms. We find similar results for a larger sample of firms. In addition, we find negative and positive warning effects, respectively, for firms reporting small bad and good earnings news, suggesting that the insignificant warning effect for good news firms is restricted to large earnings news. More importantly, we find that litigation risk magnifies the warning effect—for bad news firms, the warning effect is more negative for high-litigation-risk firms than for low-litigation-risk firms, but for good news firms, the warning effect is more positive for high-litigation-risk firms than for low-litigation-risk firms.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alexander

J. C.

1991. “Do the Merits Matter? A Study of Settlements in Securities Class Actions”. Stanford Law Review, 43 (February): 497–598.

Atiase

1985. “Predisclosure Information, Firm Capitalization, and Security Price Behavior Around Earnings Announcements”. Journal of Accounting Research, 23 (Spring): 21–36.

Francis

Philbrick

Schipper

. 1994. “Shareholder Litigation and Corporate Disclosures”. Journal of Accounting Research, 32 (Autumn): 137–164.

Frankel

McNichols

Wilson

. 1995. “Discretionary Disclosure and External Financing”. The Accounting Review, 70 (January): 135–150.

Freeman

Tse

. 1992. “A Nonlinear Model of Security Price Responses to Unexpected Earnings”. Journal of Accounting Research, 30 (Autumn): 185–209.

Grundfest

J. A.

Perino

M. A.

. 1997. “Ten Things We Know and Ten Things We Don't Know About the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995”. Joint Written Testimony before the Subcommittee on Securities of the Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs, United States Senate, on July 24, 1997. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.

Jennings

1987. “Unsystematic Securities Price Movements, Management Earnings Forecasts, and Revisions in Consensus Analyst Earnings Forecasts”. Journal of Accounting Research, 25 (Spring): 90–110.

Kasznik

Lev

. 1995. “To Warn or Not to Warn: Management Disclosure in the Face of an Earnings Surprise”. The Accounting Review, 70 (January): 113–134.

King

Pownall

Waymire

. 1990. “Expectations Adjustment via Timely Management Forecasts: Review, Synthesis and Suggestions for Future Research”. Journal of Accounting Literature, 9: 113–144.

10.

Lang

Lundholm

. 1993. “Cross-sectional Determinants of Analyst Ratings of Corporate Disclosures”. Journal of Accounting Research, 31 (Autumn): 246–271.

11.

Lev

1995. “Disclosure and Litigation”. California Management Review, 37: 8–28.

12.

Libby

Tan

. 1999. “Analysts' Reactions to Warnings of Negative Earnings Surprises”. Journal of Accounting Research, 37 (Autumn): 415–435.

13.

Matsumoto

2002. “Management's Incentive to Avoid Negative Earnings Surprises”. The Accounting Review, 77 (July): 483–515.

14.

Niehaus

Roth

. 1999. “Insider Trading, Equity Issues, and CEO Turnover in Firms Subject to Securities Class Action”. Financial Management, 28 (Winter): 52–72.

15.

Prentice

R. A.

Richardson

V. J.

Scholz

. 1999. “Corporate Web Site Disclosure and Rule 10b-5: An Empirical Evaluation”. American Business Law Journal, 36 (Summer): 531–578.

16.

Rogers

J. L.

Stocken

P. C.

. 2005. “Credibility of Management Forecasts”. The Accounting Review, 80 (October): 1233–1260.

17.

Skinner

1994. “Why Firms Voluntarily Disclose Bad News”. Journal of Accounting Research, 32 (Spring): 38–60.

18.

Skinner

1997. “Earnings Disclosures and Stockholder Lawsuits”. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 23: 249–282.

19.

Soffer

L. C.

Thiagarajan

S. R.

Walther

B. R.

. 2000. “Earnings Preannouncement Strategies”. Review of Accounting Studies, 5 (March): 5–26.

20.

Tucker

2004. “Does Disclosure Reputation Explain Earnings Warnings?” Working paper, University of Florida (August).