Cognitive-structural models of moral reasoning have been criticized for ignoring contextual determinants of moral reasoning and, therefore, failing to enhance understanding of real-life moral reasoning. Three studies are reported: (a) Participants completed the Defining Issues Test (DIT; Rest, 1988) and the Personal Moral Dilemma Inventory (PMDI), created to assess real-life moral reasoning; (b) the DIT and PMDI were completed using moral role-plays; (c) participants described the response sets resulting from these role-plays. High- and low-principled reasoners' responses to real-life moral dilemmas were not significantly different. Also, it was harder to distinguish moral from immoral responses to DIT dilemmas than similar responses to real-life dilemmas. Findings support the argument that cognitive-structural models of moral reasoning fail to address everyday moral concerns.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Baumrind, D. (1978). A dialectical materialist's perspective on knowing social reality. In W. Damon (Ed.), New directions for child development: Moral development (Vol. 2. pp. 61-82). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
2.
Bebeau, M. J. (1994). Influencing the moral dimensions of dental practice. In J. R. Rest & D. Narvaez (Eds.), Moral development in the professions: Psychology and applied ethics (pp. 121-146). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
3.
Blasi, A. (1990). How should psychologists define morality? Or, the negative side effects of philosophy's influence on psychology. In T. Wren (Ed.), The moral domain: Essays in the ongoing discussion between philosophy and the social sciences (pp. 38-70). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
4.
Bollerud, K., Christopherson, S., & Frank, E. (1990). Girls' sexual choices: Looking for what is right: The intersection of sexual and moral development. In C. Gilligan, N. Lyons, & T. Hanmer (Eds.), Making connections: The relational worlds of adolescent girls at Emma Willard School (pp. 274-285). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
5.
Boyes, M. C., & Walker, L. J. (1988). Implications of cultural diversity for the universality claims of Kohlberg's theory of moral reasoning. Human Development, 31, 44-59.
6.
Burton, R. V. (1984). A paradox in theories and research in moral development. In W. M. Kurtines & J. L. Gewirtz (Eds.), Morality, moral behavior and moral development. New York: John Wiley.
7.
Chang, F. (1993). The development of a teacher's test of moral reasoning. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis.
8.
Chang, F. (1994). School teachers' moral reasoning. In J. R. Rest & D. Narvaez (Eds.), Moral development in the professions: Psychology and applied ethics (pp. 71-84). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
9.
Colby, A., & Kohlberg, L. (1987). The measurement of moral judgment: Vol. 1. Theoretical foundations and research validation. Cambridge, UKCambridge University Press.
10.
Dien, D. S. (1982). A Chinese perspective on Kohlberg's theory of moral development. Developmental Review, 2, 331-341.
11.
Duckett, L. J., & Ryden, M. B. (1994). Education for ethical nursing practice. In J. R. Rest & D. Narvaez (Eds.), Moral development in the professions: Psychology and applied ethics (pp. 51-70). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
12.
Emler, N., Renwick, S., & Malone, B. (1983). The relationship between moral reasoning and political orientation. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 45(5), 1073-1080.
13.
Gergen, K. (1992). Social construction and moral action. In D. Robinson (Ed.), Social discourse and moral judgment (pp. 9-27). San Diego, CA: Academic Press.
14.
Gilligan, C. (1982). In a different voice: Psychological theory and women's development. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
15.
Gilligan, C., & Belenky, M. (1980). A naturalistic study of abortion decision. In R. L. Selman & R. Yando (Eds.), New directions for child development: Clinical-developmental psychology (No. 7, pp. 69-90).
16.
Harre, R. (1984). Personal being: A theory for individual psychology. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
17.
Higgins, A., Power, C., & Kohlberg, L. (1984). The relationship of moral atmosphere to judgments of responsibility. In W. M. Kurtines & J. L. Gewirtz (Eds.), Morality, moral behavior and moral development (pp. 74-106). New York: John Wiley.
18.
Kohlberg, L. (1981). Essays on moral development: Vol. 1. The philosophy of moral development. Cambridge: Harper & Row.
19.
Kohlberg, L. (1984). Essays on moral development: Vol. 2. The psychology of moral development. Cambridge: Harper & Row.
20.
Kohlberg, L., Levine, C., & Hewer, A. (1983). Moral stages: A current formulation and a response to critics. Basel, Switzerland: Karger.
21.
Kohlberg, L., Scharf, P., & Hickey, J. (1971). The justice structure of the prison: A theory and an intervention. Prison Journal, 51(2), 3-14.
22.
Kurtines, W. M., & Gewirtz, J. L. (Eds.). (1984). Morality, moral behavior and moral development. New York: John Wiley.
23.
Kurtines, W. M., & Grief, E. B. (1974). The development of moral thought: Review and evaluation of Kohlberg's research. Psychological Bulletin, 81, 453-470.
24.
Langford, P. E., & D'Cruz, J. V. (1989). A new way of scoring moral judgment interviews. Journal of Moral Education18(2), 118-150.
25.
Lewin, K. (1951). Problems of research in social psychology. In D. Cartwright (Ed.), Field theory in social science (pp. 155-169). New York: Harper & Row.
26.
Lickona, T. (1991). Moral development in the elementary school classroom. In W. M. Kurtines & J. L. Gewirtz (Eds.), Handbook of moral behavior and development (Vol. 3, pp. 143-162). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
27.
MacIntyre, A. (1984). After virtue. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.
28.
Manicas, P. T., & Secord, P. F. (1983). Implications for psychology of the new philosophy of science. American Psychologist, 38, 399-413.
29.
Modgil, S., & Modgil, C. (Eds.). (1986). Lawrence Kohlberg Consensus and controversy. Philadelphia: Falmer.
30.
Moran, J. J., & Joniac, A. J. (1979). Effect of language preference for responses to a moral dilemma. Developmental Psychology, 15(3), 337-338.
31.
Napier, J. D. (1979). Effects of knowledge of cognitive-moral development and request to fake on Defining Issues Test P-scores. Journal of Psychology, 101, 45-52.
32.
Packer, M. (1992). Toward a postmodern psychology of moral action and moral development. In W. Kurtines, M. Azmitia, & J. Gewirtz (Eds.), The role of values in psychology and human development (pp. 31-59). New York: John Wiley.
33.
Packer, M., & Addison, R. (Eds.). (1989). Entering the circle: Hermeneutic investigation in psychology. New York: State University of New York Press.
34.
Polanyi, M. (1962). Personal knowledge.: Towards a post-critical philosophy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
35.
Rawls, J. (1971). A theory of justice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
36.
Rest, J. R. (1984). The major components of morality. In W. M. Kurtines & J. L. Gewirtz (Eds.), Morality, moral behavior and moral development (pp. 24-38). New York: John Wiley.
37.
Rest, J. R. (1986). Moral development: Advances in research and theory. New York: Praeger.
38.
Rest, J. R. (1988). Manual for the Defining Issues Test (3rd ed. rev.). Minneapolis: Center for the Study of Ethical Development, University of Minnesota.
39.
Rest, J. R. (1994). Background: Theory and research. In J. R. Rest & D. Narvaez (Eds.), Moral development in the professions: Psychology and applied ethics (pp. 1-26). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
40.
Rest, J., Cooper, D., Coder, R., Masanz, J., & Anderson, D. (1974). Judging the important issues in moral dilemmas—An objective measure of development. Developmental Psychology, 10(4), 491-501.
41.
Rest, J. R., & Narvaez, D. (Eds.). (1994). Moral development in the professions: Psychology and applied ethics. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
42.
Rest, J. R., & Thoma, S. J. (1985). Relation of moral judgment development to formal education. Developmental Psychology, 21(4), 709-714.
43.
Schweder, R. (1982). Liberalism as destiny. [Review of the book Essays on moral development: Vol. 1. The philosophy of moral development]. Contemporary Psychology, 27(6), 421-424.
44.
Simpson, E. L. (1974). Moral development research: A case study of scientific cultural bias. Human Development17, 81-106.
45.
Snarey, J. R. (1985). Cross-cultural universality of social-moral development: A critical review of Kohlbergian research. Psychological Bulletin, 97(2), 202-232.
46.
Tappan, M., & Brown, L. M. (1992). Hermeneutics and developmental psychology: Toward an ethic of interpretation. In W. Kurtines, M. Azmitia, & J. Gewirtz (Eds.), The role of values in psychology and human development (pp. 105-130). New York: John Wiley.
47.
Trevethan, S. D., & Walker, L. J. (1989). Hypothetical versus real-life moral reasoning among psychopathic and delinquent youth. Development and Psychopathology, 1, 91-103.
48.
Vasudev, J., & Hummel, R. C. (1987). Moral stage sequence and principled reasoning in an Indian sample. Human Development30, 105-118.
49.
Walker, L. J., de Vries, B., & Trevethan, S. (1987). Moral stages and moral orientations in real-life and hypothetical dilemmas. Child Development, 58, 842-858.
50.
Walker, L. J., & Moran, T. J. (1991). Moral reasoning in a communist Chinese society. Journal of Moral Education, 20(2), 139-155.
51.
Walker, L. J., Pitts, R. C., Hennig, K. H., & Matsuba, M. K. (1995). Reasoning about morality and real-life moral problems. In M. Killen & D. Hart (Eds.), Morality in everyday life: Developmental perspectives (pp. 371-407). New York: Cambridge University Press.
52.
Wygant, S. A., & Williams, R. N. (1995). Perceptions of a principled personality: An interpretive examination of the Defining Issues Test. Journal of Social Behavior and Personality, 10(1), 53-66.
