Does strong gender identity help or harm one’s well-being? Previous research suggests that acceptance of one’s social group and feelings of belongingness to the group are positively related to well-being, regardless of the group’s social status. However, there are inconsistent findings about the relation between well-being and how central the group is to one’s identity (centrality), especially among disadvantaged groups (e.g., women). In Studies 1 to 10 (total N = 5,955), we clarified these relations by controlling for shared variance between distinct gender identity aspects. Acceptance and belongingness were positively related to a range of well-being variables. Centrality was negatively related to well-being. These results were consistent across genders. Studies 11 to 14 (total N = 2,380) found that the negative relation between gender centrality and well-being might be mediated by perceived pressure to conform to the masculine role among men and perceived gender inequality among women. These results uncover a burden of strong gender identity.
AshmoreR. D.DeauxK.McLaughlin-VolpeT. (2004). An organizing framework for collective identity: Articulation and significance of multidimensionality. Psychological Bulletin, 130(1), 80–114.
2.
BaumeisterR. F.LearyM. R. (1995). The need to belong: Desire for interpersonal attachments as a fundamental human motivation. Psychological Bulletin, 117(3), 497–529.
3.
BeckA. T.SteerR. A.BrownG. (1996). Manual for the Beck Depression Inventory–II. Psychological Corporation.
4.
BoeckmannR. J.FeatherN. T. (2007). Gender, discrimination beliefs, group-based guilt, and responses to affirmative action for Australian women. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 31(3), 290–304.
5.
BourguignonD.SeronE.YzerbytV.HermanG. (2006). Perceived group and personal discrimination: Differential effects on personal self-esteem. European Journal of Social Psychology, 36(5), 773–789.
6.
BranscombeN. R.SchmittM. T.HarveyR. D. (1999). Perceiving pervasive discrimination among African Americans: Implications for group identification and well-being. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 77(1), 135–149.
7.
BusseriM. A.SadavaS. W. (2010). A review of the tripartite structure of subjective well-being: Implications for conceptualization, operationalization, analysis, and synthesis. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 15(3), 290–314.
8.
CameronJ. E. (2004). A three-factor model of social identity. Self and Identity, 3(3), 239–262.
9.
CasadB. J.HaleP.WachsF. L. (2017). Stereotype threat among girls: Differences by gender identity and math education context. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 41(4), 513–529.
10.
CaseK. A. (2007). Raising male privilege awareness and reducing sexism: An evaluation of diversity courses. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 31(4), 426–435.
11.
CrabtreeJ. W.HaslamS. A.PostmesT.HaslamC. (2010). Mental health support groups, stigma, and self-esteem: Positive and negative implications of group identification. Journal of Social Issues, 66(3), 553–569.
12.
CrockerJ.MajorB. (1989). Social stigma and self-esteem: The self-protective properties of stigma. Psychological Review, 96(4), 608–630.
13.
CruwysT.DingleG. A.HornseyM. J.JettenJ.OeiT. P. S.WalterZ. C. (2014). Social isolation schema responds to positive social experiences: Longitudinal evidence from vulnerable populations. British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 53(3), 265–280.
14.
CruwysT.GunaseelanS. (2016). “Depression is who I am”: Mental illness identity, stigma and wellbeing. Journal of Affective Disorders, 189, 36–42.
15.
DahlJ.VescioT.WeaverK. (2015). How threats to masculinity sequentially cause public discomfort, anger, and ideological dominance over women. Social Psychology, 46(4), 242–254.
16.
DienerE.EmmonsR. A.LarsenR. J.GriffinS. (1985). The satisfaction with life scale. Journal of Personality Assessment, 49(1), 71–75.
17.
EcclestonC. P.MajorB. N. (2006). Attributions to discrimination and self-esteem: The role of group identification and appraisals. Group Processes & Intergroup Relations, 9(2), 147–162.
18.
EganS. K.PerryD. G. (2001). Gender identity: A multidimensional analysis with implications for psychosocial adjustment. Developmental Psychology, 37(4), 451–463.
19.
EllemersN.KortekaasP.OuwerkerkJ. W. (1999). Self-categorisation, commitment to the group and group self-esteem as related but distinct aspects of social identity. European Journal of Social Psychology, 29(2–3), 371–389.
20.
EmersonR. M. (1976). Social exchange theory. Annual Review of Sociology, 2(1), 335–362.
21.
FairchildK.RudmanL. A. (2008). Everyday stranger harassment and women’s objectification. Social Justice Research, 21, 338–357.
22.
FazioR. H.EffreinE. A.FalenderV. J. (1981). Self-perceptions following social interaction. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 41(2), 232–242.
23.
GecasV.SchwalbeM. L. (1983). Beyond the looking-glass self: Social structure and efficacy-based self-esteem. Social Psychology Quarterly, 46(2), 77–88.
24.
GentileB.GrabeS.Dolan-PascoeB.TwengeJ. M.WellsB. E.MaitinoA. (2009). Gender differences in domain-specific self-esteem: A meta-analysis. Review of General Psychology, 13(1), 34–45.
25.
GlickP.GanglC.GibbS.KlumpnerS.WeinbergE. (2007). Defensive reactions to masculinity threat: More negative affect toward effeminate (but not masculine) gay men. Sex Roles, 57(1–2), 55–59.
26.
GreenawayK. H.CruwysT.HaslamS. A.JettenJ. (2016). Social identities promote well-being because they satisfy global psychological needs. European Journal of Social Psychology, 46(3), 294–307.
27.
HarderD. H.ZalmaA. (1990). Two promising shame and guilt scales: A construct validity comparison. Journal of Personality Assessment, 55(3–4), 729–745.
28.
HarrellZ. A.SettlesI. H.BuchananN. T.NnawuleziN. A.YapS. C. (2011). The role of multiple social groups and identities in women’s mental health. Women and Mental Disorders, 4, 1–31.
29.
HaslamS. A.JettenJ.PostmesT.HaslamC. (2009). Social identity, health and well-being: An emerging agenda for applied psychology. Applied Psychology, 58(1), 1–23.
30.
HoffmanR. M. (2006). How is gender self-confidence related to subjective well-being?The Journal of Humanistic Counseling, Education and Development, 45(2), 186–197.
31.
HoffmanR. M.BordersL. D.HattieJ. A. (2000). Reconceptualizing femininity and masculinity: From gender roles to gender self-confidence. Journal of Social Behavior and Personality, 15(4), 475–503.
32.
HughesM.KiecoltK. J.KeithV. M.DemoD. H. (2015). Racial identity and well-being among African Americans. Social Psychology Quarterly, 78(1), 25–48.
33.
JacksonJ. W. (2002). Intergroup attitudes as a function of different dimensions of group identification and perceived intergroup conflict. Self and Identity, 1(1), 11–33.
34.
JettenJ.BranscombeN. R.SchmittM. T.SpearsR. (2001). Rebels with a cause: Group identification as a response to perceived discrimination from the mainstream. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 27(9), 1204–1213.
35.
KhannaN. (2004). The role of reflected appraisals in racial identity: The case of multiracial Asians. Social Psychology Quarterly, 67(2), 115–131.
36.
KobrynowiczD.BranscombeN. R. (1997). Who considers themselves victims of discrimination? Individual difference predictors of perceived gender discrimination in women and men. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 21(3), 347–363.
37.
KroenkeK.SpitzerR. L.WilliamsJ. B. W. (2001). The PHQ-9: Validity of a brief depression severity measure. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 16(9), 606–613.
38.
LeachC. W.van ZomerenM.ZebelS.VliekM. L. W.PennekampS. F.DoosjeB.OuwerkerkJ. W.SpearsR. (2008). Group-level self-definition and self-investment: A hierarchical (multicomponent) model of in-group identification. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 95(1), 144–165.
39.
LevantR. F.HallR. J.RankinT. J. (2013). Male Role Norms Inventory–Short Form (MRNI-SF): Development, confirmatory factor analytic investigation of structure, and measurement invariance across gender. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 60(2), 228–238.
40.
LinleyP. A.MaltbyJ.WoodA. M.OsborneG.HurlingR. (2009). Measuring happiness: The higher order factor structure of subjective and psychological well-being measures. Personality and Individual Differences, 47(8), 878–884.
41.
LinvilleP. W. (1985). Self-complexity and affective extremity: Don’t put all of your eggs in one cognitive basket. Social Cognition, 3(1), 94–120.
42.
LinvilleP. W. (1987). Self-complexity as a cognitive buffer against stress-related illness and depression. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 52(4), 663–676.
43.
MahalikJ. R.MorrayE. B.Coonerty-FemianoA.LudlowL. H.SlatteryS. M.SmilerA. (2005). Development of the conformity to feminine norms inventory. Sex Roles: A Journal of Research, 52(7–8), 417–435.
44.
MajorB.QuintonW. J.McCoyS. K. (2002). Antecedents and consequences of attributions to discrimination: Theoretical and empirical advances. In M. P. Zanna (Ed.), Advances in experimental social psychology (Vol. 34, pp. 251–330). Academic Press.
45.
MajorB.QuintonW. J.SchmaderT. (2003). Attributions to discrimination and self-esteem: Impact of group identification and situational ambiguity. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 39(3), 220–231.
46.
McCoyS. K.MajorB. (2003). Group identification moderates emotional responses to perceived prejudice. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 29(8), 1005–1017.
47.
McKinleyN. M.HydeJ. S. (1996). The Objectified Body Consciousness Scale: Development and validation—Nita Mary McKinley, Janet Shibley Hyde, 1996. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 20, 181–215.
48.
MuehlenkampJ. J.Saris-BaglamaR. N. (2002). Self–objectification and its psychological outcomes for college women. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 26(4), 371–379.
49.
NosekB. A. (2005). Moderators of the relationship between implicit and explicit evaluation. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 134(4), 565–584.
50.
OysermanD. (2001). Self-concept and identity. In TesserA.SchwarzN. (Eds.), The Blackwell handbook of social psychology (pp. 499–517). Blackwell.
51.
PhinneyJ. S.CantuC. L.KurtzD. A. (1997). Ethnic and American identity as predictors of self-esteem among African American, Latino, and White adolescents. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 26(2), 165–185.
52.
RamosM. R.CassidyC.ReicherS.HaslamS. A. (2012). A longitudinal investigation of the rejection-identification hypothesis. British Journal of Social Psychology, 51(4), 642–660.
53.
RosenbergM. (1965). Society and the adolescent self-image. Princeton University Press.
54.
RosseelY. (2012). Lavaan: An R package for structural equation modeling. Journal of Statistical Software, 48(2), 1–36.
55.
RoszakJ. (2010). Culture as a factor influencing expression of one’s own identity: Measuring gender identity. In ChybickaA.SafdarS.KwiatkowskaA. (Eds.), Culture and gender: An intimate relation (pp. 117–138). GWP.
56.
RowleyS. J.SellersR. M.ChavousT. M.SmithM. A. (1998). The relationship between racial identity and self-esteem in African American college and high school students. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 74(3), 715–724.
57.
RubinM.StuartR. (2018). Kill or cure? Different types of social class identification amplify and buffer the relation between social class and mental health. The Journal of Social Psychology, 158(2), 236–251.
58.
RudmanL. A.GlickP. (2012). The social psychology of gender: How power and intimacy shape gender relations. Guilford Press.
59.
SaniF.HerreraM.WakefieldJ. R. H.BorochO.GulyasC. (2012). Comparing social contact and group identification as predictors of mental health. British Journal of Social Psychology, 51(4), 781–790.
60.
SchmaderT. (2002). Gender identification moderates stereotype threat effects on women’s math performance. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 38(2), 194–201.
61.
SchmaderT.BlockK. (2015). Engendering identity: Toward a clearer conceptualization of gender as a social identity. Sex Roles, 73(11), 474–480.
62.
SchmittM. T.BranscombeN. R.KobrynowiczD.OwenS. (2002). Perceiving discrimination against one’s gender group has different implications for well-being in women and men. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 28(2), 197–210.
63.
SettlesI. H.JellisonW. A.Pratt-HyattJ. S. (2009). Identification with multiple social groups: The moderating role of identity change over time among women-scientists. Journal of Research in Personality, 43(5), 856–867.
64.
ShapiroJ. R.NeubergS. L. (2007). From stereotype threat to stereotype threats: Implications of a multi-threat framework for causes, moderators, mediators, consequences, and interventions. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 11(2), 107–130.
65.
ShihM.PittinskyT. L.AmbadyN. (1999). Stereotype susceptibility: Identity salience and shifts in quantitative performance. Psychological Science, 10(1), 80–83.
66.
SimmonsJ. P.NelsonL. D.SimonsohnU. (2011). False-positive psychology: Undisclosed flexibility in data collection and analysis allows presenting anything as significant. Psychological Science, 22(11), 1359–1366.
67.
SipeS.JohnsonC. D.FisherD. K. (2009). University students’ perceptions of gender discrimination in the workplace: Reality versus fiction. Journal of Education for Business, 84(6), 339–349.
68.
SmithT. E.LeaperC. (2006). Self-perceived gender typicality and the peer context during adolescence. Journal of Research on Adolescence, 16(1), 91–104.
69.
SnellW. E.Jr.GodwinL. (2013). Beliefs About Women Scale (BAWS). Measurement Instrument Database for the Social Science. https://www.midss.org/
70.
SpenceJ. T. (1999). Thirty years of gender research: A personal chronicle. In Swann Jr.W. B.LangloisJ. H.GilbertL. A. (Eds.), Sexism and stereotypes in modern society: The gender science of Janet Taylor Spence (pp. 255–289). American Psychological Association.
71.
SteeleC. M.SpencerS. J.AronsonJ. (2002). Contending with group image: The psychology of stereotype and social identity threat. In ZannaM. P. (Ed.), Advances in experimental social psychology (Vol. 34, pp. 379–440). Academic Press.
72.
SwimJ. K.MillerD. L. (1999). White guilt: Its antecedents and consequences for attitudes toward affirmative action. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 25(4), 500–514.
73.
TajfelH. (1981). Human groups and social categories. Cambridge University Press.
74.
TajfelH.TurnerJ. C. (1979). An integrative theory of intergroup conflict. In AustinW. G.WorchelS. (Eds.), The social psychology of intergroup relations (pp. 33–47). Oxford University Press.
75.
TateC. C.BettergarciaJ. N.BrentL. M. (2015). Re-assessing the role of gender-related cognitions for self-esteem: The importance of gender typicality for cisgender adults. Sex Roles: A Journal of Research, 72(5–6), 221–236.
76.
TiggemannM.KuringJ. K. (2004). The role of body objectification in disordered eating and depressed mood. British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 43(3), 299–311.
77.
TwengeJ. M.CampbellW. K. (2002). Self-esteem and socioeconomic status: A meta-analytic review. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 6(1), 59–71.
78.
VandelloJ. A.BossonJ. K. (2013). Hard won and easily lost: A review and synthesis of theory and research on precarious manhood. Psychology of Men & Masculinity, 14(2), 101–113.
79.
Van DickR.KetturatC.HäusserJ. A.MojzischA. (2017). Two sides of the same coin and two routes for improvement: Integrating resilience and the social identity approach to well-being and ill-health. Health Psychology Open, 4(2), 1–6.
80.
VialA. C.NapierJ. L. (2017). High power mindsets reduce gender identification and benevolent sexism among women (but not men). Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 68, 162–170.
81.
WakefieldJ. R. H.SaniF.HerreraM. (2018). Greater university identification—but not greater contact—leads to more life satisfaction: Evidence from a Spanish longitudinal study. Applied Psychology: Health and Well-being, 10(2), 330–344.
82.
WangK.DovidioJ. F. (2017). Perceiving and confronting sexism: The causal role of gender identity salience. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 41(1), 65–76.
83.
YapS. C. Y.SettlesI. H.Pratt-HyattJ. S. (2011). Mediators of the relationship between racial identity and life satisfaction in a community sample of African American women and men. Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology, 17(1), 89–97.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
