The Effects of a Brief Acceptance-Based Behavioral Treatment Versus Traditional Cognitive-Behavioral Treatment for Public Speaking Anxiety

Abstract

Individuals with public speaking anxiety (PSA) experience fear and avoidance that can cause extreme distress, impaired speaking performance, and associated problems in psychosocial functioning. Most extant interventions for PSA emphasize anxiety reduction rather than enhancing behavioral performance. We compared the efficacy of two brief cognitive-behavioral interventions, a traditional cognitive-behavior treatment (tCBT) and an acceptance-based behavior treatment (ABBT), on public speaking performance and anxiety in a clinical sample of persons with PSA. The effects of treatment on prefrontal brain activation were also examined. Participants (n = 21) were randomized to 90 min of an ABBT or a tCBT intervention. Assessments took place at pre- and post-treatment and included self-rated anxiety and observer-rated performance measures, a behavioral assessment, and prefrontal cortical activity measurements using functional near-infrared spectroscopy (fNIRS). Exploratory results indicated that participants in the ABBT condition experienced greater improvements in observer-rated performance relative to those in the tCBT condition, while those in the tCBT condition experienced greater reductions in subjective anxiety levels. Individuals in the ABBT condition also exhibited a trend toward greater treatment-related reductions in blood volume in the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex relative to those who received tCBT. Overall, these findings preliminarily suggest that acceptance-based treatments may free more cognitive resources in comparison with tCBT, possibly resulting in greater improvements in objectively rated behavioral performances for ABBT interventions.

Keywords

anxiety/anxiety disorders brain imaging/neuroimaging SAD/social anxiety disorder/social phobia ACT/acceptance and commitment therapy CBT/cognitive-behavior therapy

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abutalebi

Cappa

S. F.

Perani

(2001). The bilingual brain as revealed by functional neuroimaging. Bilingualism: Language and Cognition, 4, 179-190. doi:10.1017/S136672890100027X

Akiyoshi

Hieda

Aoki

Nagayama

(2003). Frontal brain hypoactivity as a biological substrate of anxiety in patients with panic disorders. Neuropsychobiology, 47, 165-170. doi:10.1159/000070587

American Psychiatric Association. (1994). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed.). Washington, DC: Author.

American Psychiatric Association. (2000). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed., text rev.). Washington, DC: Author.

American Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (5th ed.). Arlington, VA: American Psychiatric Publishing.

Anderson

Rothbaum

B. O.

Hodges

L. F.

(2003). Virtual reality exposure in the treatment of social anxiety. Cognitive and Behavioral Practice, 10, 240-247.

Banaji

Mallet

Elwell

C. E.

Nicholls

Cooper

C. E.

(2008). A model of brain circulation and metabolism: NIRS signal changes during physiological challenges. PLoS Computational Biology, 4(11), e1000212.

Barbey

A. K.

Koenigs

Grafman

(2013). Dorsolateral prefrontal contributions to human working memory. Cortex, 49, 1195-1205.

Block

J. A.

(2003). Acceptance or change of private experiences: A comparative analysis in college students with public speaking anxiety. Albany: The University at Albany, State University of New York.

10.

Brown

T. A.

Di Nardo

P. A.

Barlow

D. H.

(1994). Anxiety Disorders Interview Schedule for DSM-IV (ADIS-IV). Albany, NY: Graywind.

11.

Brown

T. A.

Di Nardo

P. A.

Lehman

C. L.

Campbell

L. A.

(2001). Reliability of DSM-IV anxiety and mood disorders: Implications for the classification of emotional disorders. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 110, 49-58.

12.

Carrell

L. J.

Willmington

S. C.

(1996). A comparison of self-report and performance data in assessing speaking and listening competence. Communication Reports, 9, 185-191.

13.

Clark

D. M.

Ehlers

McManus

Hackmann

Fennell

Campbell

Louis

(2003). Cognitive therapy versus fluoxetine in generalized social phobia: a randomized placebo-controlled trial. Journal of consulting and clinical psychology, 71(6), 1058.

14.

Clark

D. B.

Feske

Masia

C. L.

Spaulding

S. A.

Brown

Mammen

Shear

M. K.

(1997). Systematic assessment of social phobia in clinical practice. Depression and Anxiety, 6(2), 47-61. doi:10.1002/(sici)1520-6394(1997)6:2<47::aid-da1>3.0.co;2-2

15.

Clark

D. M.

Wells

(1995). A cognitive model of social phobia. In Heimberg

R. G.

Liebowitz

M. R.

Hope

D. A.

Schneier

F. R.

(Eds.), Social phobia: Diagnosis, assessment, and treatment (pp. 69-93). New York, NY: Guilford Press.

16.

Craske

M. G.

Niles

A. N.

Burklund

L. J.

Wolitzky-Taylor

K. B.

Vilardaga

J. C. P.

Arch

J. J.

. . .Lieberman

M. D.

(2014). Randomized controlled trial of cognitive behavioral therapy and acceptance and commitment therapy for social phobia: Outcomes and moderators. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 82, 1034-1048.

17.

Cui

Bray

Bryant

D. M.

Glover

G. H.

Reiss

A. L.

(2011). A quantitative comparison of NIRS and fMRI across multiple cognitive tasks. NeuroImage, 54, 2808-2821.

18.

Dalrymple

K. L.

Herbert

J. D.

(2007). Acceptance and commitment therapy for generalized social anxiety disorder: A pilot study. Behavior Modification, 31, 543-568. doi:10.1177/0145445507302037

19.

Daly

(1978). Behavioural correlates of social anxiety. British Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology, 17, 117-120. doi:10.1111/j.2044-8260.1978.tb00252.x

20.

Davidson

R. J.

(2002). Anxiety and affective style: Role of prefrontal cortex and amygdala. Biological Psychiatry, 51, 68-80.

21.

Davidson

R. J.

Marshall

J. R.

Tomarken

A. J.

Henriques

J. B.

(2000). While a phobic waits: Regional brain electrical and autonomic activity in social phobics during anticipation of public speaking. Biological Psychiatry, 47, 85-95. doi:10.1016/S0006-3223(99)00222-X

22.

Eng

Heimberg

R. G.

Coles

M. E.

Schneier

F. R.

Liebowitz

M. R.

(2000). An empirical approach to subtype identification in individuals with social phobia. Psychological Medicine, 30, 1345-1357. doi:10.1017/S0033291799002895

23.

England

E. L.

Herbert

J. D.

Forman

E. M.

Rabin

S. J.

Juarascio

A. S.

Goldstein

S. P.

(2012). Acceptance-based exposure therapy for public speaking anxiety. Journal of Contextual Behavioral Science, 1, 66-72.

24.

Etkin

Wager

(2007). Functional neuroimaging of anxiety: A meta-analysis of emotional processing in PTSD, social anxiety disorder, and specific phobia. American Journal of Psychiatry, 164, 1476-1488.

25.

First

M. B.

Spitzer

R. L.

Gibbon

Williams

J. B. W.

(1996). Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV Axis I Disorders, Clinician Version (SCID-CV). Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.

26.

Forman

E. M.

Shaw

J. A.

Goetter

E. M.

Herbert

J. D.

Park

J. A.

Yuen

E. K.

(2012). Long-term follow-up of a randomized controlled trial comparing acceptance and commitment therapy and standard cognitive behavior therapy for anxiety and depression. Behavior Therapy, 43, 801-811. doi:10.1016/j.beth.2012.04.004

27.

Freitas-Ferrari

M. C.

Hallak

J. E.

Trzesniak

Filho

A. S.

Machado-de-Sousa

J. P.

Chagas

M. H.

. . . Crippa

J. A.

(2010). Neuroimaging in social anxiety disorder: A systematic review of the literature. Progress in Neuro-Psychopharmacology & Biological Psychiatry, 34, 565-580. doi:10.1016/j.pnpbp.2010.02.028

28.

Furmark

Tillfors

Stattin

Ekselius

Fredrikson

(2000). Social phobia subtypes in the general population revealed by cluster analysis. Psychological Medicine, 30, 1335-1344.

29.

Glassman

L. H.

Herbert

J. D.

Forman

E. M.

Bradley

L. E.

Izzetoglu

Ruocco

A. C.

Goldstein

S. P.

(2014). Near-infrared spectroscopic assessment of in vivo prefrontal activation in public speaking anxiety: A preliminary study. Psychology of Consciousness: Theory, Research, and Practice, 1, 271-283. doi:10.1037/cns0000009

30.

Goldberg

(2009). The new executive brain: Frontal lobes in a complex world. New York: Oxford University Press.

31.

Goldin

P. R.

Manber

Hakimi

Canli

Gross

J. J.

(2009). Neural bases of social anxiety disorder: Emotional reactivity and cognitive regulation during social and physical threat. Archives of General Psychiatry, 66, 170-180.

32.

Grant

B. E.

Hasin

D. S.

Blanco

Stinson

F. S.

Chou

S. P.

Goldstein

R. B.

. . . Boji

(2005). The epidemiology of social anxiety disorder in the United States: Results from the national epidemiologic survey on alcohol and related conditions (Vol. 66). Memphis, TN: Physicians Postgraduate Press.

33.

Hayes

S. C.

Strosahl

K. D.

Wilson

K. G.

(1999). Acceptance and commitment therapy: An experiential approach to behavior change. New York, NY: Guilford Press.

34.

Hayes

S. C.

Strosahl

K. D.

Wilson

K. G.

(2011). Acceptance and commitment therapy: The process and practice of mindful change (2nd ed.). New York, NY: Guilford Press.

35.

Hayes

S. C.

Wilson

K. G.

Gifford

E. V.

Follette

V. M.

Strosahl

K. D.

(1996). Experiential avoidance and behavioral disorders: A functional dimensional approach to diagnosis and treatment. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 54, 1152-1163.

36.

Heimberg

R. G.

(1991). Cognitive-behavioral group therapy for social phobia: A treatment manual. Albany: The University at Albany, State University of New York.

37.

Heimberg

R. G.

Becker

R. E.

(2002). Cognitive-behavioral group therapy for social phobia: Basic mechanisms and clinical strategies. New York, NY: Guilford Press.

38.

Heimberg

R. G.

Hope

D. A.

Dodge

C. S.

Becker

R. E.

(1990). DSM-III-R subtypes of social phobia: Comparison of generalized social phobics and public speaking phobics. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 178, 172-179.

39.

Heimberg

R. G.

Liebowitz

M. R.

Hope

D. A.

Schneier

F. R.

Holt

C. S.

Welkowitz

L. A.

. . . Klein

D. F.

(1998). Cognitive-behavioral group therapy vs phenelzine therapy for social phobia: 12-week outcome. Archives of General Psychiatry, 55, 1133-1141. doi:10.1001/archpsyc.55.12.1133

40.

Heimberg

R. G.

Salzman

D. G.

Holt

C. S.

Blendell

K. A.

(1993). Cognitive-behavioral group treatment for social phobia: Effectiveness at five-year followup. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 17, 325-339. doi:10.1007/BF01177658

41.

Herbert

J. D.

Forman

E. M.

(Eds.). (2011). Acceptance and mindfulness in cognitive behavior therapy. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley.

42.

Herbert

J. D.

Forman

E. M.

Dalrymple

K. L.

(2009). Acceptance-based behavior therapy for social anxiety disorder (Unpublished therapy manual). Philadelphia, PA: Drexel University.

43.

Herbert

J. D.

Forman

E. M.

England

E. L.

(2009). Psychological acceptance. In O’Donohue

Fisher

J. E.

(Eds.), General principles and empirically supported techniques of cognitive behavior therapy (pp. 77-101). Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley.

44.

Herbert

J. D.

Gaudiano

B. A.

Rheingold

A. A.

Myers

V. H.

Dalrymple

Nolan

E. M.

(2005). Social skills training augments the effectiveness of cognitive-behavioral group therapy for social anxiety disorder. Behavior Therapy, 36, 125-138. doi:10.1016/s0005-7894(05)80061-9

45.

Hofmann

S. G.

(2004). Cognitive mediation of treatment change in social phobia. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 72, 392-399.

46.

Hofmann

S. G.

Gerlach

A. L.

Wender

Roth

W. T.

(1997). Speech disturbances and gaze behavior during public speaking in subtypes of social phobia. Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 11, 573-585.

47.

Hofmann

S. G.

Roth

W. T.

(1996). Issues related to social anxiety among controls in social phobia research. Behavior Therapy, 27, 79-91.

48.

Hyde

D. C.

Boas

D. A.

Blair

Carey

(2010). Near-infrared spectroscopy shows right parietal specialization for number in pre-verbal infants. NeuroImage, 53, 647-652.

49.

Izzetoglu

Bunce

Ayaz

Devaraj

Onaral

Pourrezaei

(2005). Functional near-infrared neuroimaging. IEEE Transactions on Neural Systems and Rehabilitation Engineering, 13, 153-159.

50.

Kennan

R. P.

Kim

Maki

Koizumi

Constable

R. T.

(2002). Non-invasive assessment of language lateralization by transcranial near infrared optical topography and functional MRI. Human Brain Mapping, 16, 183-189.

51.

Klinger

Bouchard

Légeron

Roy

Lauer

Chemin

Nugues

(2005). Virtual reality therapy versus cognitive behavior therapy for social phobia: A preliminary controlled study. CyberPsychology & Behavior, 8, 76-88. doi:10.1089/cpb.2005.8.76

52.

Kochel

Plichta

M. M.

Schafer

Schongassner

Fallgatter

A. J.

Schienle

(2011). Auditory symptom provocation in dental phobia: A near-infrared spectroscopy study. Neuroscience Letters, 503, 48-51. doi:10.1016/j.neulet.2011.07.058

53.

Kocovski

N. L.

Fleming

J. E.

Hawley

L. L.

Huta

Antony

M. M.

(2013). Mindfulness and acceptance-based group therapy versus traditional cognitive-behavioral group therapy for social anxiety disorder: A randomized controlled trial. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 51, 889-898.

54.

Leserman

Koch

(1993). Review of self-report depression and anxiety measures. Drug Information Journal, 27, 537-548.

55.

Lewin

M. R.

McNeil

D. W.

Lipson

J. M.

(1996). Enduring without avoiding: Pauses and verbal dysfluencies in public speaking fear. Journal of Psychopathology and Behavioral Assessment, 18, 387-402.

56.

Liebowitz

M. R.

Heimberg

R. G.

Schneier

F. R.

Hope

D. A.

Davies

Holt

C. S.

. . . Klein

D. F.

(1999). Cognitive-behavioral group therapy versus phenelzine in social phobia: Long-term outcome. Depression and Anxiety, 10(3), 89-98.

57.

Lorberbaum

J. P.

Kose

Johnson

M. R.

Arana

G. W.

Sullivan

L. K.

Hamner

M. B.

George

M. S.

(2004). Neural correlates of speech anticipatory anxiety in generalized social phobia. Neuroreport, 15(18), 2701-2705.

58.

Matsuo

Taneichi

Matsumoto

Ohtani

Yamasue

Sakano

. . . Kato

(2003). Hypoactivation of the prefrontal cortex during verbal fluency test in PTSD: A near-infrared spectroscopy study. Psychiatry Research: Neuroimaging, 124, 1-10.

59.

McCarthy

R. A.

Warrington

E. K.

(1990). Cognitive neuropsychology. San Diego, CA: Academic Press.

60.

Ogawa

Tank

D. W.

Menon

Ellermann

J. M.

Kim

S. G.

Merkle

Ugurbil

(1992). Intrinsic signal changes accompanying sensory stimulation: Functional brain mapping with magnetic resonance imaging. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 89, 5951-5955.

61.

Orsillo

S. M.

Batten

S. V.

(2005). Acceptance and commitment therapy in the treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder. Behavior Modification, 29, 95-129.

62.

Pallanti

Bernardi

(2009). Neurobiology of repeated transcranial magnetic stimulation in the treatment of anxiety: A critical review. International Clinical Psychopharmacology, 24, 163-173.

63.

Paquette

Lévesque

Mensour

Leroux

J. M.

Beaudoin

Bourgouin

Beauregard

(2003). “Change the mind and you change the brain”: Effects of cognitive-behavioral therapy on the neural correlates of spider phobia. NeuroImage, 18, 401-409.

64.

Powers

M. B.

Emmelkamp

P. M.

(2008). Virtual reality exposure therapy for anxiety disorders: A meta-analysis. Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 22, 561-569.

65.

Prasko

Horacek

Zalesky

Kopecek

Novak

Paskova

. . . Hoschl

(2004). The change of regional brain metabolism (18FDG PET) in panic disorder during the treatment with cognitive behavioral therapy or antidepressants. Neuroendocrinology Letters, 25, 340-348.

66.

Rapee

R. M.

Lim

(1992). Discrepancy between self-and observer ratings of performance in social phobics. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 101, 728-731.

67.

Roemer

Orsillo

S. M.

Salters-Pedneault

(2008). Efficacy of an acceptance-based behavior therapy for generalized anxiety disorder: Evaluation in a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 76, 1083-1089.

68.

Sachs

Anderer

Dantendorfer

Saletu

(2004). EEG mapping in patients with social phobia. Psychiatry Research: Neuroimaging, 131, 237-247.

69.

Salaberria

Echeburua

(1998). Long-term outcome of cognitive therapy’s contribution to self-exposure in vivo to the treatment of generalized social phobia. Behavior Modification, 22, 262-284.

70.

Scholing

Emmelkamp

P. M. G.

(1996). Treatment of generalized social phobia: Results at long-term follow-up. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 34, 447-452.

71.

Schwartz

J. M.

Stoessel

P. W.

Baxter

L. R.

Jr. Martin

K. M.

Phelps

M. E.

(1996). Systematic changes in cerebral glucose metabolic rate after successful behavior modification treatment of obsessive-compulsive disorder. Archives of General Psychiatry, 53, 109-113. doi:10.1001/archpsyc.1996.01830020023004

72.

Stangier

Heidenreich

Peitz

Lauterbach

Clark

D. M.

(2003). Cognitive therapy for social phobia: individual versus group treatment. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 41(9), 991-1007.

73.

Stein

M. B.

Torgrud

L. J.

Walker

J. R.

(2000). Social phobia symptoms, subtypes, and severity: Findings from a community survey. Archives of General Psychiatry, 57, 1046-1052.

74.

Stein

M. B.

Walker

J. R.

Forde

D. R.

(1996). Public-speaking fears in a community sample: Prevalence, impact on functioning, and diagnostic classification. Archives of General Psychiatry, 53, 169-174. doi:10.1001/archpsyc.1996.01830020087010

75.

Steinbeis

Bernhardt

B. C.

Singer

(2012). Impulse control and underlying functions of the left DLPFC mediate age-related and age-independent individual differences in strategic social behavior. Neuron, 73, 1040-1051.

76.

Tillfors

Furmark

Marteinsdottir

Fredrikson

(2002). Cerebral blood flow during anticipation of public speaking in social phobia: A PET study. Biological Psychiatry, 52, 1113-1119.

77.

Toronov

Webb

Choi

J. H.

Wolf

Michalos

Gratton

Hueber

(2001). Investigation of human brain hemodynamics by simultaneous near-infrared spectroscopy and functional magnetic resonance imaging. Medical Physics, 28, 521-527.

78.

Tuscan

L. A.

Herbert

J. D.

Forman

E. M.

Juarascio

A. S.

Izzetoglu

Schultheis

(2013). Exploring frontal asymmetry using functional near-infrared spectroscopy: A preliminary study of the effects of social anxiety during interaction and performance tasks. Brain Imaging and Behavior, 7, 140-153.

79.

Villringer

Chance

(1997). Non-invasive optical spectroscopy and imaging of human brain function. Trends in Neurosciences, 20, 435-442.

80.

Wijeakumar

Shahani

Simpson

W. A.

McCulloch

D. L.

(2012). Localization of hemodynamic responses to simple visual stimulation: An fNIRS study. Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science, 53, 2266-2273.

81.

Wolpe

Lazarus

A. A.

(1966). Behavior therapy techniques. New York, NY: Pergamon.

82.

Zanarini

M. C.

Skodol

A. E.

Bender

Dolan

Sanislow

Schaefer

. . . McGlashan

T. H.

(2000). The collaborative longitudinal personality disorders study: Reliability of axis I and II diagnoses. Journal of Personality Disorders, 14, 291-299.