The analysis of supranational union organization has been a neglected area for many years. However, the construction of trading blocs and the accelerating internationalization of capital has increased the motivation for labour movements to cooperate, and provided some new opportunities for such efforts. In order to assess the prospects for success, five different approaches to analysis of international unionism are distilled from a fragmented literature, evaluated critically, and the subsequent insights are applied to the prospects for the future. The assessment concentrates on the European scene, where the pace of change and the efforts to construct a continental industrial relations area have been most in evidence. Conclusions are mixed: while there are some real advances and areas of improved outlook for international unions, there are growing challenges from management and a double-edged shift to an enterprise focus in many areas of activity.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alexander, J.
(1989) 'Divergent European Community Unionism: A Threat to Single Market Unification?', paper presented at International Industrial Relations Association, 8th World Congress, Brussels, 31 August-September.
2.
Baldry, C.
, N. Haworth, S. Henderson & H. Ramsay (1983) 'Fighting Multinational Power: Possibilities, Limitations and Contradictions', Capital & Class20 (Summer): 157-166.
3.
Baun, M.
(1990) 'Europe 1992 and Trade Union Politics: Towards a European "Industrial Relations Space"?', paper presented at 7th International Conference of Europeanists, Washington DC, 23-25March.
4.
Beynon, H.
(1984) Working For Ford, 2nd edn.Harmondsworth: Penguin.
5.
Blake, D.H.
(1973) 'Cross-National Cooperative Strategies: Union Response to the MNCs', pp. 223-248 in P. Tudyka (ed.) Multinational Corporations and Labour Unions, selection from a symposium, Nijmegen, 17-19 May (mimeo).
6.
Blanpain, R.
(1972) 'Efforts to Bring About Community-level Collective Bargaining in the Coal and Steel Community and the EEC', pp.275-308 in H. Gunter (ed.) Transnational Industrial Relations. London: Macmillan.
7.
Bomers, G.B.J.
& R.B. Peterson (1977) 'Multinational Companies and Industrial Relations: The Case of West Germany and the Netherlands', British Journal of Industrial Relations15(1): 45-62.
8.
Carley, M.
(1993) 'Social Dialogue', in M. Gold (ed.) The Social Dimension: Employment Policy in the European Community, London: Macmillan.
9.
Davies, I.
(1966) African Trade Unions. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
10.
Deakin, S.
& F. Wilkinson (1994) 'Rights vs Efficiency? The Economic Case for Transnational Labour Standards', Industrial Law Joumal23(4): 289-310.
11.
Dolvik, J.E.
, D. Olberg & D. Stokland (1990) 'European Integration Changing the Preconditions for Solidaristic Union Strategies', paper presented at Work Employment & Society/ European Centre for the Development of Vocational Training conference on 'Work and Employment in European Society Convergence and Integration', Bath, 6-8September.
12.
Enderwick, P.
(1985) Multinational Business & Labour. London: Croom Helm.
13.
Fieldhouse, D.K.
(1986) 'The Multinational: A Critique of a Concept', in A. Teichova, M. Levy-Leboyer and H. Nussbaum (eds) Multinational Enterprise in Historical Perspective. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
14.
Flanagan, R.J.
& A.R. Weber (eds) (1974) Bargaining without Boundaries: The Multinational Corporation and Intemational Labor Relations, Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
15.
Gaffikin, F.
& A. Nickson (1984) The Jobs Crisis and the Multinationals: The Case of the West Midlands. Nottingham: Spokesman Press.
16.
Gennard, J.
(1976) 'Multinationals: Industrial Relations and the Trade Union Response', Occasional Paper Series No. 1, Universities of Leeds & Nottingham.
17.
Goetschy, J.
(1994) 'A Further Comment on Wolfgang Streeck's "European Social Policy after Maastricht" ', Economic & Industrial Democracy15(4): 477-485.
18.
Gold, M.
& M. Hall (1992) Report on European-Level Information & Consultation in Multinational Companies An Evaluation of Practice. Luxembourg: European Commission.
19.
Gunter, H.
(ed.) (1972) Transnational Industrial Relations. London: Macmillan.
20.
Hamill, J.
(1984) 'Labour Relations Decision-Making within Multinational Corporations', Industrial Relations Journal15(2): 304-304.
21.
Harrod, J.
(1972) 'Multinational Corporations, Trade Unions and Industrial Relations: A Case Study of Jamaica', in H. Gunter (ed.) Transnational Industrial Relations. London: Macmillan.
22.
Hartmann, H.
& A.I. Marsh (1983) 'Information as a Trade Union Strategy: Research on a Systematic Approach to Comparative Data', Labour & Society8: 209-224.
23.
Haworth, N.
& H. Ramsay (1986) 'Workers of the World Untied: A Critical Analysis of the Labour Response to the Internationalisation of Capital', International Law of Sociology and Social Policy6(2): 55-82.
24.
Haworth, N.
& H. Ramsay (1987) 'Labour and Management Strategies in the World Market: The Plot Thickens', pp. 141-164 in T. Dickson & D. Judge (eds) The Politics of Industrial Closure. London: Macmillan.
25.
Hecker, S.
(1993) 'US Unions, Trade and International Solidarity: Emerging Issues and Tactics', Economic & Industrial Democracy, 14(3): 355-367.
26.
Helfgott, R.B.
(1983) 'American Unions and Multinational Companies: A Case of Misplaced Emphasis', Columbia Journal of World BusinessXVIII(2): 81-86.
27.
Hyman, R.
(1990) 'The Representativeness of National Trade Union Confederations: Challenges from Above and Below', paper presented at ISA Congress, Madrid, 12 July (mimeo).
28.
Hyman, R.
(1991) 'European Unions: Towards 2000', Work, Employment and Society5(4): 621-639.
29.
Industrial Relations Services (IRS)
(1993a) 'The Hoover Affair and Social Dumping', European Industrial Relations Review 230.
30.
Industrial Relations Services (IRS)
(1993b) 'Information and Consultation in European Multinationals', European Industrial Relations Review228: 13-19 & 229: 14-20.
31.
Industrial Relations Services (IRS)
(1994a) 'European Works Councils The Action Begins', European Industrial Relations Review 250.
32.
Industrial Relations Services (IRS)
(1994b) 'The First UK European Works Councils', European Industrial Relations Review251: 20-22.
33.
Industrial Relations Services (IRS)
(1997) 'Commission Sets Out Options for the Future of the Social Dialogue', European Industrial Relations Review276: 24-29.
34.
Jensen, C.S.
, J.S. Madsen and J. Due (1995) 'A Role for a Pan-European Trade Union Movement? Possibilities in European IR Regulation', Industrial Relations Journal26(1): 4-18.
35.
Krieger, H.
& P. Bonneton (1995) 'Analysis of Existing Voluntary Agreements on Information and Consultation in European Multinationals', Transfer1(2): 188-206.
36.
Kujawa, D.
(1975) 'Transnational Industrial Relations: A Collective Bargaining Prospect?', in D. Kujawa (ed.) International Labour and the Multinational Enterprise. New York: Praeger.
37.
Labour Research Department
(1987) 'Multinationals Reduce UK Investment', Labour Research July.
38.
Labour Research DepartmentTrades Union Congress
(1997) European Works Councils: Negotiating the Way Forward. London: LRD/TUC.
39.
Lambert, J.
(1991) 'Europe: The Nation-State Dies Hard', Capital & Class43: 9-24.
40.
Lane, T.
(1986) 'Economic Democracy: Are the Trade Unions Equipped?', Industrial Relations Journal17(4): 321-328.
41.
Levinson, C.
(1972) International Trade Unionism. London: Allen and Unwin.
42.
Levinson, C.
(ed.) (1974) Industry's Democratic Revolution. London: Allen & Unwin.
43.
Litvak, I.A.
& C.J. Maule (1972) 'The Union Response to International Corporations', Industrial Relations11: 62-71.
44.
MacShane, D.
(1991) 'France The Missing Link in European Labour?', European Labour Forum4: 17-21.
45.
Marginson, P.
(1992) 'European Integration and Transnational Management-Union Relations in the Enterprise', British Journal of Industrial Relations30(4): 529-546.
46.
Marginson, P.
, P.K. Edwards, R. Martin, J. Purcell & K. Sisson (1988) Beyond the Workplace: Managing Industrial Relations in the Multi-Establishment Enterprise. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
47.
Marginson, P.
, A. Buitendam, C. Deutschmann & P. Perulli (1993) 'The Emergence of the Euro-Company: Towards a European Industrial Relations?', Industrial Relations Journal24(3): 182-190.
48.
Martinez Lucio, M.
& S. Weston (1995) 'Trade Unions and Networking in the Context of Change: Evaluating the Outcomes of Decentralization in Industrial Relations', Economic & Industrial Democracy16(2): 233-251.
49.
Northrup, H.R.
& R.L. Rowan (1979) Multinational Collective Bargaining Attempts. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
50.
Northrup, H.R.
, D. Campbell & B. Slowinski (1988) 'Multinationals UnionManagement Consultation in Europe: Resurgence in the 1980s', International Labour Review127(5): 323-543.
51.
Olle, W.
& W. Schoeller (1977) 'World Market Competition and Restrictions Upon International Trade Union Policies', Capital and Class2: 56-75.
Press, M.
(1984) 'The Lost Vision: Trade Unions and Internationalism', pp. 88-105 in P. Waterman (ed.) For a New Labour Internationalism. The Hague: ILERI.
54.
Press, M.
(1989) 'A Critique of Trade Union Internationalism', in M. Press and D. Thomson (eds) Solidarity for Survival: The Don Thomson Reader. Nottingham: Spokesman Press.
55.
Ramsay, H.E.
(1986) Transnational Corporations in Austrialia: Issues for Industrial Democracy. Canberra: AGPS.
56.
Ramsay, H.E.
(1992) 'Whose Champions? Multinationals, Labour and Industry Policy in the European Community after 1992', Capital and Class48: 17-39.
57.
Ramsay, H.E.
(1995a) 'Euro-Unionism and the Great Auction: An Assessment of the Prospects for Organised Labour Post-Maastricht', Industry & Labour6(2): 13-44.
58.
Ramsay, H.E.
(1995b) 'Le d6fi Europ6en: Multinational Restructuring, Labour and EU Policy', in A. Amin & J. Tomaney (eds) Behind the Myth of European Union. London: Routledge.
59.
Ramsay, H.E.
& N. Haworth (1990) 'Managing the Multinationals: The Emerging Theory of the Multi-National Enterprise and its Implications for Labour Resistance', in S. Clegg (ed.) Organisation Theory and Class Analysis: New Approaches and New Issues. Berlin: de Gruyter.
60.
Roberts, B.C.
(1972) 'Factors Influencing the Organisation and Style of Management and their Effect on the Pattern of Industrial Relations in Multinational Corporations', in H. Gunter (ed.) Transnational Industrial Relations. London: Macmillan.
61.
Roberts, B.C.
(1973) 'Multinational Collective Bargaining: A European Prospect?', British Journal of Industrial Relations11(l): 1-19.
62.
Ross, G.
(1994) 'On Half-Full Glasses, Europe and the Left: Comments on Wolfgang Streecks' "European Social Policy after Maastricht"', Economic & Industrial Democracy15(4): 486-496.
63.
Silvia, S.J.
(1991) 'The Social Charter of the European Community: A Defeat for European Labour', Industrial and Labor Relations Review44(4): 626-645.
64.
Spalding, H.J., Jr
(1977) 'US and Latin American Labor: The Dynamics of Imperialist Control', in J. Nash (ed.) Ideology and Social Change in Latin America. New York: Gordon & Breach.
65.
Streeck, W.
(1991) 'More Uncertainties: German Unions Facing 1992', Industrial Relations30(3): 317-349.
66.
Streeck, W.
(1994) 'European Social Policy after Maastricht: The "Social Dialogue" and "Subsidiarity" ', Economic & Industrial Democracy15(2): 151-177.
67.
Streeck, W.
& S. Vitols (1993) 'European Works Councils: Between Statutory Enactment and Voluntary Adoption', Wissenschaftscentrum Berlin Discussion Paper FSI93 312. Berlin: WZB.
68.
Teichova, A.
, M. Levy-Leboyer and H. Nussbaum (eds) (1986) Multinational Enterprise in Historical Perspective. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
69.
Thomson, D.
& R. Larson (1978) Where Were You Brother? An Account of Trade Union Imperialism. London: War on Want.
70.
Tudyka, P.
(ed.) (1973) Multinational Corporations and Labour Unions, selection from a symposium, Nijmegen, 17-19 May (mimeo).
71.
Turner, L.
(1993) 'Beyond National Unionism? Cross-National Labor Collaboration', paper presented at conference on 'Rethinking the Boundaries of Labor Politics: New Directions for Comparative Research and Theory', Minda de Gunzberg Center for European Studies, Harvard University, March12-14.
72.
Turner, L.
(1996) 'The Europeanization of Labor Structure Before Action', January (mimeo).
73.
Ulman, L.
(1975) 'Multinational Unionism: Incentives, Barriers and Alternatives', Industrial Relations14(1): 1-31.
74.
UN
(1994) World Investment Report 1994: Transnational Corporations, Employment and the Workplace. New York: UN.
75.
UN
(1996) World Investment Report 1996: Investment, Trade and International Policy Arrangements. New York: UN.
76.
Veersma, U.
(1995) 'Multinational Corporations and Industrial Relations: Policy and Practice', pp. 318-336 in A.-W. Harzing & J.V. Ruysseveldt (eds) International Human Resource Management. London: Sage.
77.
Visser, J.
(1994) 'European Trade Unions: The Transition Years', in R. Hyman & A. Femer (eds) New Frontiers in European Industrial Relations. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
78.
von Beyme, K.
(1984) 'Unions and Multinational Companies', pp. 115-136 in B. Wilpert & A. Sorge (eds) International Yearbook of Organizational Democracy Vol. II: International Perspectives on Organizational Democracy. Chichester: John Wiley.
79.
Woolfson, C.
& J. Foster (1988) Track Record. The Story of the Caterpillar Occupation. London: Verso.
