This article seeks to establish the factors and circumstances in China's rural and urban sectors that have prompted communitybased enterprises in the former and state-owned firms in the latter to undertake privatization through partial employee buyouts. Emergent employee ownership systems are briefly examined, and their unique features are analyzed in the context of local conditions. High and intermediate level official interventions are discussed. Research needs are considered.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Bannister, J.
(1984) 'Population Policy and Trends in China, 1978-83'. The China Quarterly100: 717-741.
2.
Barnathan, J.
, P. Engardio, L. Curry and B. Einhorn (1993) 'China: The Making of an Economic Giant', Business Week17 May: 54-60, 64-64, 68-68.
3.
Beijing Review
(1988) 'Farmers like Economic Reform', an article from the overseas edition of the People's Daily appearing in the 'From the Chinese Press' section Beijing Review30: 13-13, 39-39.
4.
Beijing Review (1993) '1st Enterprise-run Bank Opens to Business', 36: 3-4, 9-9.
5.
Blasi, J.
(1993) 'Privatization in Russia', Employee Ownership Report13(2): 11-11.
6.
Blasi, J.
and A. Shleifer (1996) 'Corporate Governance in Russia: An Initial Look', in R. Frydman, C. Gray and A. Rapaczynski (eds) Corporate Governance in Central Europe and Russia, Volume 2: Insiders and the State. New York and Oxford: Central European University Press and Oxford University Press.
7.
Bohai Steel Construction Materials Corporate Group
(1994) 'Travelling the Stock Share System Road, Building a Modern Enterprise Model', paper presented at the Sino-American Conference to Promote Employee Ownership, Yantai, Shandong, 30 May-4 June.
8.
Bowles, P.
and G. White (1989) 'Contradictions in China's Financial Reforms: The Relationship between Banks and Enterprises', Cambridge Journal of Economics13: 481-495.
9.
Buck, J.L.
(1937) Land Utilization in China, Vol. 3: Statistics. Nanking: University of Nanking.
10.
Byrd, W.A.
and Lin Qongsong (eds) (1990) China's Rural Industry: Structure, Development and Reform. Now York: Oxford University Press.
11.
Cable, J. R.
(1988) 'Is Profit-sharing Participation? Evidence on Alternative Firm Types from West Germany', International Journal of Industrial Organization6(1): 121-137.
12.
Cao Feng Qi
(1994) 'Modern Enterprise Systems and Employee Stock Ownership', paper presented at the Sino-American Conference to Promote Employee Ownership, Yantai, Shandong, 30 May-4 June.
13.
Chai, J.C.H.
(1992) 'Consumption and Living Standards in China', The China Quarterly131: 721-749.
14.
Chamberlain, H.B.
(1987) 'Party-management Relations in Chinese Industries: Some Political Dimensions of Economic Reform', The China Quarterly112: 631-661.
15.
Changes and Development in China (1949-1989) (1989) Beijing: Beijing Review Press.
16.
Chen, K.
, G.H. Jefferson, T. Rawski, H. Wang and Y. Zheng (1988) 'Productivity Change in Chinese Industry: 1953-1985', Journal of Comparative Economics12(4): 570-591.
17.
Chen, K.
, G.H. Jefferson and I. Singh (1992) 'Productivity Change in Chinese Industry', Journal of Comparative Economics12: 570-591.
18.
Chen Qiuping
(1992) 'Foreign Banks Branch out in China', Beijing Review35(47): 17-22.
19.
China Agricultural Yearbook 1985 (1985) Beijing: Agricultural Publishing House.
20.
China Agricultural Yearbook 1993 (1993) Beijing: Agricultural Publishing House.
21.
China Market Economy Research Centre
(1995) 'A Successful Model for the Reform of Medium and Small State-owned Enterprises: Shandong Province, Zhu Chen City State-owned Enterprises Reform Investigation Report', China National Conditions and Strengths6: 29-30.
22.
China Social Statistics (W. T. Lin, ed.) (1986) New York: Praeger.
23.
China Statistical Yearbooks 1990-1993. Compiled by the State Statistical Bureau of the People's Republic of China. Copyright by the China Statistical Information and Consultancy Service Center and the University of Illinois at Chicago.
24.
Conte, M.A.
and J. Svejnar (1988) 'Productivity Effects of Worker Participation, Profit-sharing, Worker Ownership of Assets and Unionization in US Firms', International Journal of Industrial Organization6: 139-151.
25.
Csillag, I. (1993) 'Management and Employee Buy-outs in Hungary', pp. 131-43 in D.P. Ellerman (ed.), Management and Employee Buy-outs as a Technique of Privatization. Ljubljana, Slovenia: Central and Eastern European Privatization Network.
26.
Dai Yannian
(1986) 'Beefing up the Rural Co-operative System', Beijing Review29(25): 4-4.
27.
Defourney, J.
, S. Estrin and D.C. Jones (1985) 'The Effects of Workers' Participation on Enterprise Performance', International Journal of Industrial Organisation3:197-217.
28.
Ellerman, D.P. (1993a) 'Management and Employee Buy-outs in Central and Eastern Europe: Introduction', pp. 13-30 in D.P. Ellerman (ed.), Management Tseo: Employee Ownership in China and Employee Buy-outs as a Technique of Privatization. Ljubljana, Slovenia: Central and Eastern European Privatization Network.
29.
Ellerman, D.P.
(1993b) 'Management and Employee Buy-outs as a Technique of Privatization: Overview', pp. 31-71 in D.P. Ellerman (ed.), Management and Employee Buy-outs as a Technique of Privatization. Ljubljana, Slovenia: Central and Eastern European Privatization Network.
30.
Estrin S.
, D.C. Jones and J. Svejnar (1987) 'The Productivity Effects of Worker Participation: Producer Cooperatives in Western Economies., Journal of Comparative Economics11: 40-61.
31.
Fujimoto, A.
(1990) 'Business Management in China', China Newsletter90: 8-12.
32.
Gates, J.R.
(1994) 'Capitalist Tools for Chinese Workers', Financial Times 17 February: 19-19.
33.
Gibney, F.
(1993) 'Prepare to Crash'Newsweek (Pacific Edition) 12 July: 30-30, 31-31.
34.
Goldstein, L.
, L. Kaye and A. Blass (1993) 'Get Off Our Backs, Far Eastern Economic Review 15 July: 68-70.
35.
Gong Yusong
(1990) 'A Study on the Urbanization of Population in Modern China', Chinese Journal of Population Science2(2): 125-137.
36.
Groves, T.
, Y. Hong, J. McMillan and B. Naughton (in press) 'Productivity Growth in Chinese State-run Industry', in F. Dong, C. Lin and B. Naughton (eds), Reform of China's State-owned Enterprises. London: Macmillan.
Jackson, S.
and C.R. Littler (1991) 'Wage Trends and Policies in (China: Dynamics and Contradictions', Industrial Relations Journal22(1): 5-19.
39.
Jefferson, G.H.
, T.G. Rawsk and Zheng Yuxin (1992) 'Growth, Efficiency, and Convergence in China's State and Collective Industry, Economlic Developnment and Cultural Change40(2): 239-266.
40.
Jensen, M.C.
(1989) 'Eclipse of the Public Corporation', IHarvard Business Review5: 61-74.
41.
Jensen, M.C.
and W.H. Meckling (1979) 'Rights and Production Functions: An Introduction to Labor-managed Firms and Codetermination. Jolurnal of Business52(4): 469-506.
42.
Jia Heting
(1994) 'What We Learn from US Employee Stock Ownership Plans', paper presented at the Sino-American Conference to Promote Employee Ownership, Yantai, Shandong, 30 May-4 June.
43.
Jiang Wandi
(1993) 'Is Privatization "Threat" Looming Large?'Beijing Review36(7): 30-30.
44.
Jianzhong Tang
and L.J.C. Ma (1985) 'Evolution of Urban Collective Enterprises. The China Quarterly104: 614-639.
45.
Kotova, E., A. Vasiliev and A. Abramov (1993) 'Management and Employee Buyouts in Russia', pp. 144-50 in D.P. Ellerman (ed.), Management and Employee Buy-outs as a Technique of Privatization. Ljubljana, Slovenia: Central and Eastern European Privatization Network.
46.
Lau, K.
and J.C. Brada (1990) 'Technological Progress and Technical Efficiency in Chinese Industrial Growth: A Frontier Production Function Approach'. China Economic Review1(2): 113-124.
47.
Lee, P.N.
(1986) 'Enterprise Autonomy Policy in Post-Mao China: A Case Study of Policy-making, 1978-83', The China Quarterly105: 45-71.
48.
Li Ning
(1994a) 'From State Treasury to Real Bank', Beijing Review37(18): 8-12.
49.
Li Ning
(1994b) 'China Adopts New Taxation System', Beijing Review37(11): 11-15.
50.
Li Ping
(1992) 'Price Reform the Progressive Way', Beijing Review35(18): 18-21.
51.
Li Qinbiao
(1987) 'Survey of Forty Individual Businesses', Chinese Economic Studies21(2): 25-27.
52.
Lin Qongsong (1987) 'The Reports of the China United Investigation Team on TVE', Zhongguo xiangzhen qiye de jingji fazhan yu jingji tizhi (The Economic Development and Economic Institution of China's TVE). Beijing: China Economics Press.
53.
Liu Hongru
(1988) 'Developments in the Reform of China's Banking and Financial Systems', Journal of Chinese Law2(fall): 324-358.
54.
Liu Hongru
(1993) 'Stock Market Standardization', Beijing Review30(20): 13-16.
55.
Lockett, M.
(1981) 'Self-management in China?', Economic Analysis and Workers' Management1(15): 85-114.
56.
Lockett, M.
and C.R. Littler (1984) 'Trends in Chinese Enterprise Management', in N. Maxwell and D. McFarlane (eds), China's Changed Road to Development. Oxford: Pergamon Press.
57.
Lu Da-jing
(1992) 'The Supply and Marketing Co-operatives in China', Review of International Cooperation85(1): 61-64.
58.
Luo Xiaopeng
(1989) 'The Hierarchical Structure and the System of Ownership in China's Rural Enterprises', Chinese Economic Studies23(1): 89-99.
59.
Mahatoo, W.H.
(1990) 'Marketing in China', Journal of General Management15(3): 63-79.
60.
Ma Zhiping
(1993) 'Most Grain Prices now Determined by Market', China Daily 8 July: 3-3.
61.
Naughton, B.
(1994) 'What is Distinctive about China's Economic Transition? State Enterprise Reform and Overall System Transformation', Journal of Comparative Economics18: 470-490.
62.
NCEO
(1990) International Developments in Employee Ownership. Oakland, CA: National Center for Employee Ownership.
63.
NCEO
(1992a) Employee Ownership Fact Sheet. Oakland, CA: National Center for Employee Ownership.
64.
NCEO
(1992b) '35 Developing and Reforming Countries Now Have Employee Ownership Programs', Employee Ownership Report12(5): 9-9.
65.
NCEO
(1993a) 'New Research Evaluates Management Ownership' (a summary of findings by Joseph Blasi and Shane Williams of Rutgers University), Employee Ownership Report13(1): 1-1, 3-3.
66.
NCEO
(1993b) The Employee Ownership 100, a fact sheet. Oakland, CA: National Center for Employee Ownership.
NCEO
(1993d) 'Privatization in Eastern Europe', Employee Ownership Report13(6): 6-6.
69.
Nee, V.
(1992) 'Organizational Dynamics of Market Transition: Hybrid Forms, Property Rights and Mixed Economy in China', Administrative Science Quarterly37(1): 1-27.
70.
Oi, J.
(1992) 'Fiscal Reform and the Economic Foundations of Local State Corporatism in China', World Politics45(1): 99-126.
71.
Oksenberg, M.
and J. Tong (1991) 'The Evolution of Central-Provincial Fiscal Relations in China, 1971-1989: The Formal System', The China Quiarterly125: 1-32.
72.
Pan Qiangren
(n.d.) 'Deng Xiao Peng's Theory and Wan Feng Village's Experience', Wan Feng Industrial Village.
73.
Pitt, M.M. and L. Putterman (1992) 'Employment and Wages in Township, Village and other Rural Enterprises', mimeo, Brown University.
74.
The PRC (People's Republic of China) Regulations of Rural Collectively-owned Enterprises (zhonghua renmin gongheguo xiangcuin jiti suoyou zhi qiye tiaoli) (1990) Beijing: People's Press.
75.
Report on Agriculture (1934) National Institute of Agriculture of the Nationalist Party, 12 and 5.
76.
Reynolds, B.L.
(ed.) (1987) Reform in China: Challenges and Choices. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe.
77.
Riskin, C.
(1988) China's Political Economy: The Quest for Development Since 1949. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
78.
Rosen, C.
and M. Quarrey (1987) 'How Well is Employee Ownership Working?', Harvard Butsiness Review65(5): 126-128, 132-132.
79.
Schran, P.
(1969) The Development of Chinese Agricultuire 1950-1959. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
80.
Seminar in Modern Chinese History, 5. (1978) Tokyo: Tokyo University Press.
81.
Sender, H.
(1993) 'Money Machines: China's Banks are Forced to Act as Government Cashiers', Far Eastern Economic Review15 July: 74-74, 75-75.
82.
Simmons, J.
(in press) Making Employee Ownership Work. New York: Greenwood Publishers.
83.
Simmons, J.
and W. Mares (1985) Working Together: Employee Participation in Action. New York: New York University Press.
84.
Sivan, N.
(ed.) (1988) The Contemporary Atlas of China. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin.
85.
Stettner, N.
and B. Oram (1987) Changes in China: The Role of Co-operatives in the New Socialism. Manchester: Holyoake Books.
86.
Sun Hua Chu
(1994) 'Employee Stock Ownership System and its Consideration. paper presented at the Sino-American Conference to Promote Employee Ownership, Yantai, Shandong, 30 May-A June.
87.
Svejnar, J.
(1990) 'Productive Efficiency and Employment', in W.A. Byrd and Q. Lin (eds), China's Rural Industry: Structure, Development and Reform. New York: Oxford University Press.
88.
Tam, O.
(1988) 'Rural Finance in China', The China Quarterly13: 60-76.
89.
Tam, O.
(1992) 'A Private Bank in China: Hui Tong Urban Cooperative Bank', The China Quarterly131: 766-777.
90.
Taubman, W.
(1992) 'Socio-economic Development and Rural-Urban Migration in the People's Republic of China since the Beginning of the 1980s', paper presented at the 27th International Geographical Congress, Washington, DC, 9-14 August.
91.
Tennant, D.
(1991) 'Beijing Stone Looks to the West', Computer World25(22): 118-118.
92.
Thomas, H.
anid C. Logan (1982) Mondragon: An Economic Analysis. London: George Allen and Unwin.
93.
Tian Xueyuan
(1990) 'The Third Population Boom and Corresponding Macropolicies', Chinese Journal of Population Science2(2): 115-124.
94.
Tseo, G.K.Y.
(1990) 'Political Economy of Northern Chinese Arid Lands Development', paper presnted at the Third International Conference on Desert Development, Beijing, 23-28 July.
95.
Tseo, G.K.Y.
(1992) 'The Greening of China', Earthwatch May/June: 20-26.
96.
Tyson, J.L.
and A.S. Tyson (1992a) 'Chinese Reforms Widen Gap between Coast and Hinterland', The Christian Science Monitor22 July: 9-9, 12-12.
97.
Tyson, J.L.
and A.S. Tyson (1992b) 'China's Remotest Regions Slip Deeper into Poverty', The Christian Science Monitor22 July: 10-10, 1-1.
98.
Tyson, J.L.
and A.S. Tyson (1992c) 'Rural Engine Powers Market Reform', The Christian Science Monitor29 July: 9-9, 12-12.
99.
Tyson, J.L.
and A.S. Tyson (1992d) 'China's Richest Capitalist Draws Conservative Critics', The Christian Science Monitor29 July: 10-10, 11-11.
100.
Tyson, J.L.
and A.S. Tyson (1992e) 'Two Roads to Rural Development', The Christian Science Monitor 29 July: 11-11.
101.
Tyson, J.L.
and A.S. Tyson (1992f) 'Beijing and Local Officials Vie for Control of Private Factory', The Christian Science Monitor 29 July: 12-12.
102.
Tyson, J.L.
and A.S. Tyson (1992g) 'Restless Migrants Stream to Cities', The Christian Science Monitor5 August: 9-9, 12-12.
103.
Tyson, J.L.
and A.S. Tyson (1992h) 'Long Days, Hard Labor for Women Left on the Farm', The Christian Science Monitor5 August: 10-10, 11-11.
104.
Tyson, J.L.
and A.S. Tyson, (1992i) 'As Party Declines, Who is in Charge?', The Christian Science Monitor12 August: 9-9, 12-12.
105.
Walder, A.G.
(1987) 'Wage Reform and the Web of Factory Interests', The China Quarterly109: 22-41.
106.
Walder, A.G.
(1989) 'Factory and Manager in an Era of Reform', The China Quarterly118: 242-263.
107.
Walker, K.R.
(1988) 'Trends in Crop Production, 19781986', The China Quarterly116: 592-632.
108.
Wang Xiaoqiang
(1989) 'Transcending the Logic of Private Ownership', Chinese Economic Studies23(1): 43-56.
109.
Watson, A.
(1984) 'Agriculture Looks for "Shoes that Fit": The Production Responsibility System and its Implications', in N. Maxwell and B. McFarlane (eds), China's Changed Road to Development. Oxford: Pergamon Press.
110.
Weitzman, M.L.
and C. Xu (1994) 'Chinese Township-village Enterprises as Vaguely Defined Cooperatives', Journal of Comparative Economics18: 121-145.
111.
White, G.
(1987) 'The Politics of Economic Reform in Chinese Industry: The Introduction of the Labour Contract System', The China Quarterly111: 365-389.
112.
Wong, C.P.W.
(1991) 'Central-Local Relations in an Era of Fiscal Decline: The Paradox of Fiscal Decentralization in Post-Mao China', The China Quarterly128: 691-715.
113.
Woo, W., W. Hai, Y. Jin and G. Fan (1993) 'How Successful has Enterprise Reform Been?', mimeo, University of California at Davis.
114.
Woo, W.
, W. Hai, Y. Jin and G. Fan (1994) 'How Successful has Chinese Enterprise Reform Been? Pitfalls in Opposite Biases and Focus', Journal of Comparative Economics18: 410-437.
115.
World
(1993) 'China: Charting New Courses', 27(2): 33-43.
116.
Wright, M.
, R.S. Thompson and K. Robbie (1989) 'Privatization via Management and Employee Buyouts: Analysis and UK Experience', Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics60(4): 399-429.
117.
Xia Xiaoxun
and Li Jun (1987) 'Consumption Expansion: A Grave Challenge to Reform and Development', pp. 89-107 in B.L. Reynolds (ed.), Reform in China: Challenges and Choices. Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe.
118.
Xi Mi
(1993) 'Who Really Owns the Township Enterprises?', China Daily 6 June: 4-4.
119.
Xu, C. (1991) 'Productivity and Behavior of Chinese Rural Industrial Enterprises. Innovation, Productivity and Labor Mobility in Socialist Economies', PhD thesis. Harvard University.
120.
Zhang Shaojie
and Zhang Amei (1987) 'The Present Management Environment in China's Industrial Enterprises', pp. 47-58 in B.L. Reynolds (ed.), Reform in China: Challenges and Choices. Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe.
121.
Zhang Zhensheng
, Feng Ai and Wang Yulu (1987) 'Why Can a Large City like Qinhuangdao not Accommodate a Small Individual Venture'?, Chinese Economic Studies21(2): 28-33.
122.
Zhu Qingfang
(1987) 'On the Evolution and Changes of Individual Economy and Countermeasures', Chinese Economic Studies21(2): 100-114.
123.
Zweig, D.
(1991) 'Internationalizing China's Countryside: The Political Economy of Exports from Rural Industry', The China Quarterly128: 716-741.
124.
Zweig, D.
(1992) 'Reaping Rural Rewards', The China Butsiness Review19 (November-December): 12-17.
125.
Blasi, J. Professor, Rutgers University, School of Management and Labor Relations. Levin Building, Room 200C, New Brunswick, NJ 08903, USA.
Du Ying, Acting Director, Executing Office for Rural Reform Experimental Areas, Ministry of Agriculture, No. 9, Xihuangchenggen, Nanjie, Beijing 100032. People's Republic of China.
128.
Hu Zhuangjun, Division Director, Department for Rural Development, Development Research Centre, The State Council, No. 9, Xihuangchenggen. Nanjie Beijing 100032, People's Republic of China.
129.
Jia Heting, Deputy Department Chief, State Commission for Restructuring Economic Systems, 22 Xi An Men Street, Beijing 100017, People's Republic of China.
130.
Simmons, John Participation Associates, 2555 North Clark Street, Suite 1903. Chicago, IL 60614-1758, USA.
131.
Sun Hua Chu, Economist, All-China Federation of Trade Unions. 10 Fuxingmenwai Street, Beijing 100865, People's Republic of China.
132.
Sun Yuyan, Assistant Director, China Research Centre for Management Science, China Association of Science and Technology, 54 Sanlihe Road, Beijing 100863. People's Republic of China.
133.
Yuan Zhenguan, Professor of Ownership, China Lecture Society of Science and Technology, China Association of Science and Technology, 54 Sanlihe Road, Beijing 100863, People's Republic of China.
134.
Andy Veje, Vice President, The Ralph Parsons Corp., 100 W. Walnust Street, Pasadena, CA 91124, USA.
135.
Wu Jianhong, Vice Division Chief, Enterprise Management Research Division, Economic and Planning Research Institute, Ministry of Railways, No. 8 (Jia) Yangfangdian Road, Haidan District, Beijing 100038, People's Republic of China.
