Trade Union Responses to the Contemporary Economic Problems in Western Europe: The Context of Current Debates and Policies in the Federal Republic of Germany
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online February, 1981
Trade Union Responses to the Contemporary Economic Problems in Western Europe: The Context of Current Debates and Policies in the Federal Republic of Germany
Unions in most advanced capitalist societies have faced new challenges as a consequence of the lasting economic crisis since the mid-1970s. This rather unsettling situation has called for a strategic and conceptual reorientation on the part of most organized labor movements, including the West German. Although still very much in the stage of general formulation, the unions are in the process of rethinking their priorities in the area of collective bargaining, their relationship to the state and political parties, and their view of technology and economic growth; in short, we are witnessing a period of the reevaluation of previously-held positions. In specific, our paper focuses on this formative period in connection with economic policy in West Germany and analyzes the strident debates which have transpired in the daily formulation of actual strategies. Concretely, we delineate the unions' conceptions in opposition to the dominant theories in the West German political economy and highlight additional important intra-union debates. As evident in our brief description of the 'Memorandum' debates, these processes are far from being merely 'academic' and have decisive immediate implications upon the politics of West German unions and their role in German society.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Agartz, Victor (1971) werkschaft und Arbeiterklasse. Munich: C. Trikont Verlag.
2.
Altvater, Elmar and Jurgen Hoffmann (1980). Unpublished Letter to Rudolf Hickel and Axel Zerdick. (April 30) Berlin.
3.
Altvater, Elmar, Jurgen Hoffmann, and Carlos Maya (1980). 'Konzentration als Ursache von Profitratendifferenzen? — Eine Auseinandersetzung mit der These vom positiven Zusammenhang zwischen Konzentration und Profitraten im "Memorandum".' WSI Mitteilungen, No. 4 (April): 196-206.
4.
Anderson, Douglas D.
(1980). 'Germany (B): The Uncertain Stride of a Reluctant Giant'. Harvard Business School.
5.
Berliner Handels-und Frankfurter Bank (1978). 'Is Investing Abroad Bad for Employment at Home?' No. 719 (8 June).
6.
Blick durch die Wirtschaft (1979), 20 April: 5.
7.
Boccara, Paul (197Z). Der Staatsmonopolistische Kapitalismus. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.
8.
Brosius, Gerhard, Jorg Huffschmid, and Herbert Schui (1980). 'Theoretische und empirische Aspekte des Zusammenhangs von Monopolisierung und Verlauf der Krise seit 1973'. WSI Mitteilungen No. 4 (April): 174-186.
9.
Bundesministerium fur Arbeit und Sozialordnung (1978). Statistiches Taschenbuch: Arbeits-und Sozialstatistik. Bonn.
10.
Buschmann, Karl (1978). 'Probleme der internationalen Arbeitsteilung in der Textil-und Bekleidungsindustrie.' Gewerkschaftliche Monatshefte, No. 6 (June): 355-367.
11.
Deppe, Frank (1979). Autonomie und Integration. Materialien zur Gewerkschafts-analyse. Marburg: Verlag Arbeiterbewegung und Gesellschaftswissenschaft.
12.
Deppe, F., G. Fulberth, H.-J. Harrer, et al. (1977). Geschichte der deutschen Gewerkschaftsbewegung. Cologne: Pahl-Rugenstein.
13.
Die Neue (1980). 9-21 June.
14.
DGB (1977). Vorschlage des DGB zur Wiederherstellung der Vollbeschaftigung, Dusseldorf.
15.
DGB (1978). 'Offentliche Haushalte im Zeichen des Steuerpakets'. Abteilung Wirtschaftspolitik (3 November).
DGB(1980). 'Dokumentation: Das Grundsatzprogramm des DGB von 1963 und der Entwurf von 1979 im Vergleich'. Gewerkschaftliche Monatshefte, No. I (January): 28-82.'
18.
Die Zeit (1979a). 'Die deutsche Herausforderung.' March 28:25-27.
19.
Die Zeit (1979b). 4 May: 23.
20.
Europaisches Gewerkschaftsinstitut (1978). 'Uber Keynes hinaus-Gestaltung der Wirtschaftspolitik durch Alternativen'. Brussels.
Frobel, Volker, Jurgen Heinrichs
, and Otto Kreye, (1978). 'The New International Division of Labour'. Social Science Information, Vol. 17, No. 1:123-142.
29.
The German Tribune (1978). 25 June: 7-7.
30.
Handelsblatt (1979). 11 June: 3-3.
31.
Henschel, Rudolf (1979). 'Eine Problemskizze aus gewerkschaftlicher Sicht'. Unpublished manuscript (4 May).
Kopke, Gunter (1980). 'Europa-Studie der Gewerkschaften zur Mikroelektronik'. Die Quelle, No. 2 (February): 84-87.
38.
Kreye, Otto (1978). 'Western Europe's Economic and Social Development and the Rationality and Reality of a New International Economic Order'. Unpublished manuscript (December).
Kuhnl, Reinhard (ed.) (1972). Der Burgerliche Staat der Gegenwart. Reinbeck: Rowolt.
41.
Lecher, Wolfgang (1979). 'Unternehmensmitbestimtnung und Tarifpolitik-die europaische Perspektive'. WSI-Mitteilungen, No. 4 (April): 178-187.
42.
Markovits, Andrei S.
and Christopher S. Allen (1979a). 'The Human Experience of Labor in a Changing Market Economy'. Paper presented at the XI World Congress of the International Political Science Association, Moscow (12-18 August).
43.
Markovits, Andrei S.
and Christopher S. Allen(1979b). 'The West German Trade Unions' Role in Democratization and Participation: Social Partnership or Class Conflict?' Paper presented at the XI World Congress of the International Political Science Association, Moscow (12-18 August).
44.
Markovits, Andrei S.
and Christopher S. Allen (1979c). 'Strike Divides German Labor'. Democratic Left, Vol. 7, No. 5 (May): 9-11.
45.
Markovits, Andrei S.
and Christopher S. Allen(1979d). 'Social Democracy, Communism and the West German Trade Unions: An Old Debate Reopened'. Paper presented at the Conference on Socialist Theory, Practice and Transformation in Western Europe, New York.
46.
Markovits, Andrei S.
and Christopher S. Allen(1980a). 'Power and Dissent: The Trade Unions in the Federal Republic of Germany Re-Examined'. West European Politics, Vol. 3, No. 1 (January): 68-86.
47.
Markovits, Andrei S.
and Christopher S. Allen (1980b). 'Structural Change and Union Response in the Chemical Industry: The German Economy in Microcosm'. Paper presented at the New York State Political Science Association, Syracuse.
48.
Markovits, Andrei S.
and Christopher S. Allen (1980c). 'Capital, Labor and the State: The German Construction Industry and Regulatory Relationships in the 1970s'. Paper presented at the American Political Science Association, Washington, D.C.
49.
Markovits, Andrei S.
and Christopher S. Allen (1980d). 'The Automobile Industry and the Metal Workers Union in the Federal Republic of Germany: Changing Relationships in Crisis Conditions'. Paper presented at the Conference of Europeanists, Washington, D.C.
50.
Markovits, Andrei S.
and Christopher S. Allen and Kenneth Gibbs (1980). 'Class Power and Industrial Policy in Advanced Capitalism: The Interaction of Business, Labor and the State in the post-WWII West German Steel Industry'. Paper presented at the American Political Science Association, Washington, D.C.
51.
Martin, Andrew
and George Ross (1980). 'European Trade Unions and the Economic Crisis: Perceptions and Strategies'. West European Politics, Vol. 3, No. 1 (January): 33-67.
52.
Memorandum '79 (1979). 'Vorrang fur Vollbeschaftigung-Alternativen der Wirtschaftspolitik'. Blatter fur deutsche und internationale Politik, No. 5 (May): 614-633.
53.
Memorandum '80 (1980). 'Gegen konservative Formierung-Alternativen der Wirtschaftspolitik'. Blatterfur deutsche und internationale Politik, No. 5 (May): 608-629.
54.
Metall (1979) 14. 'Der Kandidat des groBen Geldes'. 18 July: 10-13.
55.
Minnerup, Gunter
(1976). 'The Bundersrepublik Today'. New Left Review, No. 99 (September-October): 3-47.
56.
Muller, Gernot (1980). 'Die Rolle der staatlichen Konjunkturpolitik bei Entstehung und Verlauf der Krise seit 1973'. WSI Mitteilung, No. 4 (April): 174-186.
57.
New York Times (1979a). 8 May: D1-D1.
58.
New York Times(1979b). 13 May: D5-D5.
59.
New York Times(1979c). 16 May: D1-D1.
60.
New York Times(1979d). 17 June.
61.
Odhner, Clas-Erik (1978). Participatory Economics or Keynes Plus. Stockholm.
62.
OECD
(1979a). Germany-1979. Paris.
63.
OECD
(1979b) Investing in Developing Countries, Fourth Revised Edition. (January).
64.
Pehl, Guinter (1978). 'Eine neue internationale Arbeitsteilung setzt sich durch'. Die Quelle, No. 5 (May): 276-277.
65.
Pirker, Theo (1960). Die Blinde Macht, Vol. I. Munich: Mercator Verlag.
66.
Riemer, Jeremiah M.
(1979). 'West German Economic Policy'. Paper presented at the Northeast Political Science Association Conference, Newark (8-10 November).
67.
Rudzio, Wolfgang (1979). 'Politische Perspektiven der 'STAMOKAP'-Theorie'. nGewerkschaftliche Monatshefte, No. 4 (April): 228-241.
68.
Sachverstindigenrat (1978). Wachstum und Wahrung. Stuttgart and Mainz: Verlag W. Kohlhammer GmbH.
69.
Suddeutsche Zeitung (1979). 29 June: 4.
70.
Vetter, Heinz Oskar (1979). Brief an die DGB-Landesbezirke und DGB-Kreise dem DGB-Bundesvorstand z.K. (29 May).
71.
WSI Mitteilungen (1979). 'Zum Memorandum '79'. No. 6 (June): 294-297.
72.
Zeuner, Bodo (1976). ' "Solidaritat" mit der SPD oder Solidaritat der Klasse? Zur SPD-Bindung der Gewerkschaften.' Prokla, No. 26 (January): 22-35.
