Theoretical expectations of participatory theorists (e.g. Pateman, Blumberg) are applied to labor management committees (LMCs) in an effort to predict the spillover effects of workers' participation in firm decision-making on their political and social participation. The two focal points are Jamestown, N.Y. and Buffalo, N.Y. Witte has argued that conditions may obstruct the hypothesized spillover effects from occurring: co-optation, structural impotence, and misrepresentation. In Jamestown and Buffalo, evidence that all three can be expected is found. The hypothesized spillover effects are not likely to emerge from the LMC experiments in the areas studied. It is suggested that structural impotence is perhaps the major obstruction to the spillover effect in these cases and in firms in capitalist economies.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Ahern, Robert W.
(1977) 'A Typology of Collective Bargaining Relationships'. Presented at Industrial Relations Association of Western New York meeting, Buffalo.
2.
Ahern, Robert W.
(1978a) 'The Buffalo-Erie County Labor-Management Council: The First Two Years'. Presented at Maryland Center for Productivity and Quality of Working Life Seminar, Baltimore.
3.
Ahern, Robert W.
(1978b) 'The Place of Area-wide Labor-Management Committees in Economic Development'. Report of Buffalo-Erie County Labor Management Council, Buffalo, September.
4.
Ahern, Robert W.
(1978c) Positive Labor Relations. Buffalo: Buffalo-Erie County Labor Management Council.
5.
Ahern, Robert W.
(1979) Interview, Buffalo, New York, April 1979.
6.
Bachrach, Peter
(1967) The Theory of Democratic Elitism. Boston: Little, Brown.
7.
Benello, C. George
and Dimitrious Roussopolous (1971) The Case for Participatory Democracy. New York: Grossman.
8.
Blumberg, Paul
(1968) Industrial Democracy. New York: Schocken.
9.
Braverman, Harry
(1974) Labor and Monopoly Capital. New York: Monthly Review Press.
10.
Cook, Terrence E.
and Patrick Morgan (eds.) (1971) Participatory Democracy. San Francisco: Canfield.
11.
Dahl, Robert
(1970) After the Revolution?New Haven: Yale University Press.
12.
Elden, J. Maxwell (1976) 'Democracy at Work for a More Participatory Politics'. PhD dissertation, UCLA.
13.
Eldred, John
(1979) Interview, Jamestown, New York, March 1979.
14.
Fletcher, Joseph F.
(1978) 'Community Through ParLicipation?' Presented at American Political Science Association meeting, New York.
15.
Gouldner, Alvin W.
(1954) Patterns of Industrial Bureaucracy. New York: The Free Press.
16.
Greenberg, Edward S.
(1975) 'Theories of Worker Participation: A Review Article'. Social Science QuarterlyNo. 56:191-209.
17.
Keidel, Robert W.
(1978) 'The Jamestown Area Labor-Management Committee: A Case Study in Community and Organizational Cooperation'. A paper presented at the Second Annual United States-Polish Conference on the Management of Large Scale Organizations, Tarrytown, New York.
18.
Kramer, David
(1972) Participatory Democracy. Cambridge, Mass.: Schenkman Publishing Co.
19.
Labor-Management Committee of the Jamestown Area
(1977) Commitment at Work: The Five-year Report. Jamestown: Labor-Management Committee of the Jamestown Area.
20.
Leitko, Thomas A. and Steven A. Peterson (1980) 'Worker Participation as the Nexus of Control'. Unpublished manuscript, Alfred University.
21.
Lundine, Stanley
(1977) 'Human Resources Development Act of 1977'. Speech published in Congressional Record123 (January 27).
22.
'Lundine Wins...' (1978) 'Lundine Wins Approval of Labor Groups Bill'. Olean Times Herald, 19 October: 21.
23.
McManus, Michael J.
(1978) 'Jamestown, N.Y.'s Northeast Manufacturing Hope'. Boston Herald American, 14 January: 5.
24.
Mason, Ronald M.
(1978) 'Participation in the Workplace and in Government'. Presented at Midwest Political Science Association meeting, Chicago.
25.
Milbrath, Lester
and M. L. Goel (1977) Political Participation. Chicago: Rand-McNally, 2nd edition.
26.
Morgan, Judith
, T. R. Durham, Barbara Larcom, and Christopher K. Chase-Dunn (1979) 'Control of the Work Process: The Workers' Viewpoint'. Presented at Society for the Study of Social Problems meeting, Boston.
27.
National Center for Productivity and Quality of Working Life
(1975) Labor-Management Productivity Committees in Amnerican Industry. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.
28.
National Center for Productivity and Quality of Working Life
(1978) Directory of Labor-Management Committees. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.
29.
National Council for Urban Economic Development
(1977) 'Area Labor-Management Committees'. National Council for Urban Economic Development Information Service. No. 12 (November): 1-8.
30.
Pateman, Carole
(1970) Participation and Democratic Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
31.
Raskin, A. H.
(1977a) 'Experiments in Cooperation of Workers and Management'. New York Times, 6 July.
32.
Raskin, A. H.
(1977b) 'A Move for Job Enrichment and Humanization of Work'. New York Times, 30 March.
33.
Reiter, Howard L.
(1977) 'The Trend Toward Presidential Non-voting'. Presented at American Political Science Association meeting, Washington, D.C.
34.
Sigel, Roberta S.
and Marilyn Brookes Hoskin (1977) 'Perspectives on Adult Political Socialization -Areas of Research'. In Stanley Renshon (ed.) Handbook of Political Socialization. New York: The Free Press.
35.
Verba, Sidney
(1961) Small Groups and Political Behavior. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
36.
Verba, Sidney
and Norman Nie (1972) Participation in America. New York: Harper and Row.
37.
Witte, John Frederick (1978) 'Democracy, Authority, and Alienation in Work'. PhD dissertation, Yale University. (To be published by University of Chicago Press.)
