The condition of European economic democracy is generally recognised to be in a fragile state. Recent discussions have centred on pressures to converge towards an Anglo-American model of flexible and deregulated employment relations and systems, consonant with a broader neoliberal economic governance discourse. Existing approaches suggest an uneven experience between countries around a general trend of deterioration. In this article we offer two new contributions to these debates. First, we introduce findings from an Economic Democracy Index (EDI) we have developed. This goes beyond existing indices of employment and industrial democracy to allow us to examine the changing nature of individual employment rights as well as collective bargaining conditions between European countries. Second, we depart from existing studies of European employment relations, which tend to take a comparative national approach, by situating national employment relations and trajectories within a wider set of spatial and social relations. Qualitative analysis of three country cases (Denmark, Portugal and Slovenia) supplements our EDI analysis. Our evidence suggests the importance of multi-scalar relational and institutional dynamics between social actors at the national scale and those at higher scales such as the European Union in understanding variations in country performance on the EDI.
AccorneroGRamos PintoP (2015) ‘Mild mannered’? Protest and mobilisation in Portugal under austerity, 2010–2013. West European Politics38(3): 491–515.
2.
AmableB (2003) The Diversity of Modern Capitalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
3.
AminAThomasD (1996) The negotiated economy: State and civic institutions in Denmark. Economy and Society35(2): 255–281.
4.
BaccaroLHowellC (2011) A common neoliberal trajectory: The transformation of industrial relations in advanced capitalism. Politics & Society39(4): 521–563.
5.
BaccaroLHowellC (2017) Trajectories of Neoliberal Transformation: European Industrial Relations Since the 1970s. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
6.
BednarowiczB (2019) Delivering on the European Pillar of Social Rights: The new directive on transparent and predictable working conditions in the European Union. Industrial Law Journal48(4): 604–623.
7.
BekkerSMailandM (2019) The European flexicurity concept and the Dutch and Danish flexicurity models: How have they managed the Great Recession?Social Policy and Administration53(1): 142–155.
8.
BielerA (2013) The EU, global Europe and processes of uneven and combined development: The problem of transnational labour solidarity. Review of International Studies39(1): 161–183.
9.
BlankeTHoffmannJ (2008) Towards a European social model: Preconditions, difficulties and prospects of a European social policy. International Journal of Public Policy3(1–2): 20–38.
10.
BlythM (2013) Austerity: The History of a Dangerous Idea. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
11.
BoffeyD (2020) Nordic countries at odds with EU over minimum wage. The Guardian, 12January.
12.
BohleDGreskovitsB (2012) Capitalist Diversity on Europe’s Periphery. New York: Cornell University Press.
13.
BraunVClarkeV (2006) Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology3(2): 77–101.
14.
BrennerNPeckJTheodoreN (2010) Variegated neoliberalization: Geographies, modalities, pathways. Global Networks10(2): 1–41.
CaldasJC (2012) The Consequence of Austerity Policies in Portugal. Berlin: Friedrich Ebert Stiftung.
17.
CarvalhoTRamos PintoP (2019) From the ‘unfinished revolution’ to the ‘defence of the revolution’: Framing the transition in austerity-era Portugal. In: CavallaroMEKornetisK (eds) Rethinking Democratisation in Spain, Greece and Portugal. London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 199–227.
18.
CazesS (2009) Labour Market Policies in Times of Crisis. Geneva: ILO.
19.
ClaasenRGerbrandyAPrincenSSegersM (2019) Rethinking the European social market economy: Introduction to the special issue. Journal of Common Market Studies57(1): 3–12.
20.
CortiFVesanP (2020) Social democracy, social Europe, and the ‘post-Third way agenda’: From the European Pillar of Social Rights to the Covid-19 pandemic. Constellations27(4): 608–620.
21.
CostaCG (2018) Portuguese economy: How (not) to get away with financial crisis and economic adjustment programs. In: DavidI (ed.) Crisis, Austerity, and Transformation: How Disciplinary Neoliberalism is Changing Portugal. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books, pp. 3–24.
22.
CrouchC (2005) Capitalist Diversity and Change. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
23.
CumbersA (2015) Understanding labour’s agency under globalisation: Embedding GPNs within an Open Political Economy. In: NewsomeKTaylorPBairJRainnieA (eds) Putting Labour in its Place: Labour Process Analysis and Global Value Chains. London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 135–151.
24.
CumbersA (2018) The Danish low carbon transition and the prospects for the democratic economy. In: NorthPScott CatoM (eds) Towards Just and Sustainable Economies: The Social and Solidarity Economy North and South. Bristol: Policy, pp. 179–194.
25.
CumbersAFeatherstoneDMacKinnonD, et al. (2016) Intervening in globalization: The spatial possibilities and institutional barriers to labour’s collective agency. Journal of Economic Geography16(1): 93–208.
26.
CumbersAMcMasterRWhiteMJCabaçoS (2021) Income inequality and economic democracy. Economic Democracy Index Working Paper, University of Glasgow.
27.
DavidI (2018) Crisis, Austerity, and Transformation: How Disciplinary Neoliberalism is Changing Portugal. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.
28.
EldringLAlsosK (2015) Statutory Minimum Wage Regulation in Europe: A Necessary Evil?Oslo: Fafo.
29.
Eurofound (2016) Mapping Key Dimensions of Industrial Relations. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.
30.
European Commission (2007) Towards Common Principles of Flexicurity: More and Better Jobs through Flexibility and Security. Luxembourg: Commission of the European Communities.
European Commission (2021) Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council to strengthen the application of the principle of equal pay for equal work or work of equal value between men and women through pay transparency and enforcement mechanisms. COM(2021) 93. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=CELEX:52021PC0093 (accessed 10 June 2021).
34.
FarnhamD (2015) The Changing Face of Employment Relations: Global, Comparative, and Theoretical Perspectives. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
35.
FeldmannM (2007) The origins and varieties of capitalism: Lessons from post-socialist transition in Estonia and Slovenia. In: HanckéBRhodesMThatcherM (eds) Beyond Varieties of Capitalism: Conflicts, Contradictions, and Complementarities in the European Economy. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 328–350.
36.
FernandesT (2017) Late neoliberalism and its discontents: The case of Portugal. In: PortaDDAndrettaMFernandesT, et al (eds) Late Neoliberalism and its Discontents in the Economic Crisis. London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 169–200.
37.
FuråkerB (2020) The issue of statutory minimum wages: Views among Nordic trade unions. Economic and Industrial Democracy41(2): 419–435.
38.
GreenanNKaluginaEWalkowiakE (2013) Has the quality of working life improved in the EU-15 between 1995 and 2005?Industrial and Corporate Change23(2): 399–428.
39.
Gumbrell-McCormickR (2011) European trade unions and ‘atypical’ workers’. Industrial Relations Journal42(3): 293–310.
40.
HastingsTHayesJ (2018) Farewell to flexicurity? Austerity and labour policies in the European Union. Economic and Industrial Democracy39(3): 458–480.
41.
HeyesJ (2013) Flexicurity in crisis: European labour market policies in a time of austerity. European Journal of Industrial Relations19(1): 71–86.
42.
HeyesJLewisP (2014) Employment protection under fire: Labour market deregulation and employment in the European Union. Economic and Industrial Democracy35(4): 587–607.
43.
HeyesJLewisP (2015) Relied upon for the heavy lifting: Can employment protection legislation reforms lead the EU out of the jobs crisis?Industrial Relations Journal46(2): 81–99.
44.
HowellC (2016) Regulating class in the neoliberal era: The role of the state in the restructuring of work and employment relations. Work, Employment and Society30(4): 573–589.
45.
HymanR (2019) Editorial. European Journal of Industrial Relations25(4): 307–308.
46.
ILO (International Labour Organization) (2012) World of Work Report 2012: Better Jobs for a Better Economy. Geneva: ILO, International Institute for Labour Studies.
47.
JasieckiK (2018) The strength and weaknesses of the varieties of capitalism approach: The case of Central and Eastern Europe. International Journal of Management and Economics54(4): 328–342.
48.
JohannsenLKrašovecA (2017) Democratic critique and development: In search of responsiveness. Teorija in Praksa54: 45–59.
49.
JørgensenH (2009) Flexible labour markets, workers’ protection and ‘the security of the wings’: A Danish flexicurity solution to the unemployment and social problems in globalized economies? Cepal – Serie Macroeconomía del Desarrollo N° 76.
50.
KallebergA (2009) Precarious work, insecure workers: Employment relations in transition. American Sociological Review74(1): 1–22.
51.
KingLP (2007) Central European capitalism in comparative perspective. In: HanckéBRhodesMThatcherM (eds) Beyond Varieties of Capitalism: Conflicts, Contradictions, and Complementarities in the European Economy. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 307–327.
52.
LaneDMyantM (2007) Varieties of Capitalism in Post-Communist Countries. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
53.
López-AndreuM (2019) Neoliberal trends in collective bargaining and employment regulation in Spain, Italy and the UK: From institutional forms to institutional outcomes. European Journal of Industrial Relations25(4): 309–325.
54.
LörcherKSchömannI (2016) The European Pillar of Social Rights: Critical legal analysis and proposals. ETUI Report 139/2016. Brussels: ETUI.
55.
McMenaminI (2004) Varieties of capitalist democracy: What difference does East-Central Europe make?Journal of Public Policy24(3): 259–274.
56.
MairP (2013) Ruling the Void: The Hollowing of Western Democracy. London: Verso.
57.
MarginsonP (2017) European industrial relations: An increasingly fractured landscape? Warwick Papers in Industrial Relations 106.
58.
MasseyD (2004) Geographies of responsibility. Geografiska Annaler86(1): 5–18.
59.
MeardiG (2012) Social Failures of EU Enlargement: A Case of Workers Voting with their Feet. Abingdon: Routledge.
60.
MeardiG (2018) Economic integration and state responses: Change in European industrial relations since Maastricht. British Journal of Industrial Relations56(3): 631–655.
61.
MouryCFreireA (2013) Austerity policies and politics: The case of Portugal. Pôle Sud39(2): 35–56.
62.
MüllerTSchultenT (2020) The European minimum wage on the doorstep. ETUI Policy Brief No. 1/2020. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3532424 (accessed 10 June 2021).
63.
NielsenKPedersenO (1991) From the mixed economy to the negotiated economy: The Scandinavian countries. In: CoughlinR (ed.) Morality, Rationality and Efficiency: New Perspectives on Socio-Economics. New York: ME Sharpe, pp. 145–168.
64.
O’RourkeT (2012) The development of co-operatives in Slovenia. In: McDonnellDMacknightE (eds) The Co-operative Model in Practice: International Perspectives. Glasgow: Co-operative Education Trust, pp. 31–40.
OECD/JRC (2008) Handbook on Constructing Composite Indicators: Methodology and User Guide. OECD/Joint Research Centre.
67.
OlsenM (2020) Danes still sceptical on EU minimum wage. EU Observer, 21January. Available at: https://euobserver.com/social/147188 (accessed 17 June 2021).
68.
PeckJ (2010) Constructions of Neoliberal Reason. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
PeckJTheodoreN (2007) Variegated capitalism. Progress in Human Geography31(6): 731–772.
71.
PerkovićAJUčakarT (2017) Economic crisis and the crisis of national identity in Slovenia: Toward a new notion of social order. Nationalities Papers: The Journal of Nationalism and Ethnicity45(2): 292–306.
72.
PlehweDWalpenBNeunhöfferG (2006) Neoliberal Hegemony: A Global Critique. London: Routledge.
73.
ProsserT (2014) Financialization and the reform of European industrial relations systems. European Journal of Industrial Relations20(4): 351–365.
74.
ProsserT (2016) Dualization or liberalization? Investigating precarious work in eight European countries. Work, Employment and Society30(6): 949–965.
75.
QuinlanMMayhewCBohleP (2001) The global expansion of precarious employment, work disorganization, and consequences for occupational health: Placing the debate in a comparative historical context. International Journal of Health Services31(3): 507–536.
76.
RasnačaZ (2017) Bridging the gaps or falling short? The European Pillar of Social Rights and what it can bring to EU-level policymaking. ETUI Working Paper 2017.5, Brussels.
77.
RasnačaZTheodoropoulouS (2020) EMU and the European Pillar of Social Rights: Do (shall) the twain ever meet?Social Policies2: 331–354.
78.
RathgebP (2018) Strong Governments, Precarious Workers: Labor Market Policy in the Era of Liberalization. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
79.
RochaFStoleroffA (2014) The challenges of the crisis and the external intervention in Portugal. In: RochaF (ed.) The New EU Economic Governance and its Impact on the National Collective Bargaining Systems. Madrid: Fundación 1° de Mayo, pp. 150–174.
80.
Sanz de MiguelPWelzCCaprileMContrerasRR (2020) Industrial democracy in Europe: A quantitative approach. Labour & Industry: A Journal of the Social and Economic Relations of Work30(2): 101–132.
81.
SchoukensPBarrioAMonteboviS (2018) The EU social pillar: An answer to the challenge of social protection of platform workers?European Journal of Social Security20(3): 219–241.
82.
SchultenT (2008) Towards a European minimum wage policy? Fair wages and social Europe. European Journal of Industrial Relations14(4): 421–439.
83.
SchultenTMüllerT (2015) European economic governance and its intervention in national wage development and collective bargaining. In: LehndorffS (ed.) Divisive Integration: The Triumph of Failed Ideas in Europe – Revisited. Brussels: ETUI, pp. 331–364.
84.
SoeiroJ (2020) The precariat strikes back? Political alternatives to labour degradation. In: CarmoRMSimõesJAV (eds) Protest, Youth and Precariousness: The Unfinished Fight Against Austerity in Portugal. New York: Berghahn Books, pp. 94–114.
85.
StandingG (2009) Work After Globalization: Building Occupational Citizenship. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
86.
StanojevićMKrašovicA (2011) Slovenia: Social pacts and political exchange. In: AvdagicSRhodesMVisserJ (eds) Social Pacts in Europe: Emergence, Evolution and Institutionalization. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 232–256.
87.
StiglitzJ (2016) Inequality and economic growth. In: JacobsMMazzucatoM (eds) Rethinking Capitalism: Economics and Policy for Sustainable and Inclusive Growth. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell, pp. 134–155.
88.
StreeckW (2013) Gekaufte Zeit: Die vertagte Krise des demokratischen Kapitalismus. Berlin: Suhrkamp.
89.
TávoraIGonzálezP (2016) Labour market regulation and collective bargaining in Portugal during the crisis: Continuity and change. European Journal of Industrial Relations22(3): 251–265.
90.
ThelenK (2014) Varieties of Liberalization and the New Politics of Social Solidarity. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
