The migration status of temporary migrant workers is often presented as a major determinant of labour rights and worker vulnerabilities. Using a sequential mixed method approach this article interrogates this proposition to examine the factors exacerbating temporary migrant worker exploitation within the Australian horticulture industry. The article finds that temporary migrants’ access to labour rights are shaped by their migration status. However, in contrast to prevalent assumptions, visa conditions play a preliminary, rather than a deterministic, role in this vulnerability. The article argues that notwithstanding the considerable links between vulnerability and migration status, changes in the political economy of Australian horticulture towards neoliberal or ‘pro-market governance’ arrangements have been central drivers of worker vulnerability. It focuses on three manifestations of these arrangements – the intensification of supply chain pressures, the emergence of labour market intermediaries, and the reduced presence of trade unions – as critical actors shaping temporary migrant worker agency.
ABARES (Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics and Sciences) (2018) Selected Physical and Financial Characteristics by State – Australian Vegetable Growing Farms: 2016–17 and 2017–18. Canberra: Australian Government.
2.
ABS (Australian Bureau of Statistics) (2012) Australian Social Trends, 4102.0. Canberra: Australian Government.
3.
ABS (2016) International Trade in Goods and Services, Australia: Merchandise Exports, Standard International Trade Classification (3 digit), Free On Board Value, 5368.0. Canberra: Australian Government.
4.
ABS (2017) Employee Earnings, Benefits and Trade Union Membership, Australia, 6310.0. Canberra: Australian Government.
5.
AndersonB (2010) Migration, immigration controls and the fashioning of precarious workers. Work, Employment and Society24(2): 300–317.
6.
AnnerM (2012) Corporate social responsibility and freedom of association rights: The precarious quest for legitimacy and control in global supply chains. Politics and Society40(4): 609–644.
7.
ArnholtzJHansenNW (2013) Labour market specific institutions and the working conditions of labour migrants: The case of Polish migrant labour in the Danish labour market. Economic and Industrial Democracy34(3): 401–422.
8.
AusVeg (2015) Summary of the Working Holiday Maker visa programme report (copy on file with author).
9.
BaccaroLHowellC (2017) Trajectories of Neoliberal Transformation: European Industrial Relations Since the 1970s. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
10.
BarrientosS (2013) ‘Labour chains’: Analysing the role of labour contractors in global production networks. Journal of Development Studies49(8): 1058–1071.
11.
BarrientosSKritzingerA (2004) Squaring the circle: Global production and the informalization of work in South African fruit exports. Journal of International Development16(1): 81–92.
12.
BauderH (2006) Labor Movement: How Migration Regulates Labor Markets. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
13.
BergL (2016) Migrant Rights at Work: Law’s Precariousness at the Intersection of Migration and Labour. Abingdon: Routledge.
14.
BergLFarbenblumB (2017) Wage Theft in Australia: Findings of the National Temporary Migrant Work Survey. Sydney: Migrant Worker Justice Initiative.
15.
BerntsenLLillieN (2016) Hyper-mobile migrant workers and Dutch trade union representation strategies at the Eemshaven construction sites. Economic and Industrial Democracy37(1): 171–187.
16.
BookerC (2016) Big supermarkets blamed for driving ‘ridiculous’ strawberry prices. Sydney Morning Herald, 20September.
17.
BrennanBMcNallyL (2015) Fruit picking industry operator investigated over claims of bullying, sexual harassment in Mildura. Australian Broadcasting Corporation News, 6January.
18.
BuchananK (2016) Fruit and veg growers call for licensing of labour contractors to crack down on backpacker exploitation. Australian Broadcasting Corporation News, 16June.
19.
CalvinLMartinP (2010) The US Produce Industry and Labor: Facing the Future in a Global Economy, Economic Research Report Number 106. Washington, DC: United States Department of Agriculture.
20.
ClibbornSWrightCF (2018) Employer theft of temporary migrant workers’ wages in Australia: Why has the state failed to act?The Economic and Labour Relations Review29(2): 207–227.
21.
CoeNMYeungHWC (2015) Global Production Networks: Theorizing Economic Development in an Interconnected World. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
22.
CollinsJKrivokapic-SkokoB (2016) New Immigrants Improving Productivity in Australian Agriculture. Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation Publication No 16/027. Canberra: Australian Government.
23.
CooperREllemB (2016) Cold climate: Australian unions, policy and the state. Comparative Labor Law and Policy Journal38(3): 415–435.
24.
CumminsMRodríguezF (2010) A rejoinder to Ruhs. Journal of Human Development and Capabilities11(2): 311–314.
25.
CurtainRDornanMHowesSSherrellH (2018) Pacific seasonal workers: Learning from the contrasting temporary migration outcomes in Australian and New Zealand horticulture. Asia and the Pacific Policy Studies5(3): 462–480.
26.
DaviesACL (2014) Migrant workers in agriculture. In: CostelloCFreedlandM (eds) Migrants at Work: Immigration and Vulnerability in Labour Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 79–97.
27.
Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry (2004) Price Determination in the Australian Food Industry. Canberra: Australian Government.
DickenP (2015) Global Shift, 7th edn.New York: Guilford Press.
31.
DundonTGonzález-PérezMAMcDonoughT (2007) Bitten by the Celtic Tiger: Immigrant workers and industrial relations in the new ‘glocalized’ Ireland. Economic and Industrial Democracy28(4): 501–522.
EmilssonHMagnussonKOsanami TörngrenSBevelanderP (2014) The World’s Most Open Country: Labour Migration to Sweden After the 2008 Law. Malmö: Malmö University, Malmö Institute for Studies of Migration, Diversity and Welfare.
34.
ForsythA (2016) Victorian Inquiry into the Labour Hire Industry and Insecure Work. Melbourne: Industrial Relations Victoria.
35.
FreemanGP (1995) Modes of immigration politics in liberal democratic states. International Migration Review29(4): 881–902.
36.
FudgeJ (2012) Precarious migrant status and precarious employment: The paradox of international rights for migrant workers. Comparative Labor Law and Policy Journal34(1): 95–132.
37.
FWO (Fair Work Ombudsman) (2010) Horticulture Industry Shared Compliance Program 2010: Final Report. Canberra: Australian Government.
38.
FWO (2016) Inquiry into Wages and Conditions of People Working under the 417 Working Holiday Visa Program. Canberra: Australian Government.
39.
Gammeltoft-HansenTNyberg SorensenN (2013) The Migration Industry and the Commercialization of International Migration. New York: Routledge.
40.
GautiéJSchmittJ (2010) Low-wage Work in the Wealthy World. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
41.
GereffiGLeeJ (2016) Economic and social upgrading in global value chains and industrial clusters: Why governance matters. Journal of Business Ethics133(1): 25–38.
42.
GordonJ (2016) Roles for workers and unions in regulating labour recruitment in Mexico. In: HoweJOwensR (eds) Temporary Labour Migration in the Global Era: The Regulatory Challenges. London: Hart, pp. 329–350.
43.
GroutsisDvan den BroekDHarveyWS (2015) Transformations in network governance: The case of migration intermediaries. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies41(10): 1558–1576.
44.
GuthmanJ (2004) Agrarian Dreams: The Paradox of Organic Farming in California. Oakland: University of California Press.
45.
HaakestadHFribergJH (2017) Deskilling revisited: Labour migration, neo-Taylorism and the degradation of craft work in the Norwegian construction industry. Economic and Industrial Democracy41(3): 630-651.
46.
HardyTHoweJ (2009) Partners in enforcement? The new balance between government and trade union enforcement of employment standards in Australia. Australian Journal of Labour Law22(3): 306–336.
47.
HayDHowesS (2012) Australia’s Pacific Seasonal Worker Pilot Scheme: Why has take-up been so low? Development Policy Centre Discussion Paper No. 17, Development Policy Centre, Australian National University.
48.
HeeryE (2009) Trade unions and contingent labour: Scale and method. Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society2(3): 429–442.
49.
Herzfeld OlssonP (2016) Temporary migrant workers in Sweden: A call for unequal treatment. In: HoweJOwensR (eds) Temporary Labour Migration in the Global Era: The Regulatory Challenges. London: Hart, pp. 203–222.
50.
HolgateJ (2015) Community organising in the UK: A ‘new’ approach for trade unions?Economic and Industrial Democracy36(3): 431–455.
51.
HoweJClibbornSReillyA, et al. (2018) Towards a Durable Future: Tackling Labour Challenges in the Australian Horticulture Industry. Adelaide: University of Adelaide.
52.
JamesPJohnstoneRQuinlanMWaltersD (2007) Regulating supply chains to improve health and safety. Industrial Law Journal36(2): 163–187.
53.
JohnstoneRMcCrystalSNossarI, et al. (2012) Beyond Employment: The Legal Regulation of Work Relationships. Sydney: Federation Press.
54.
KaplinskyR (2000) Globalisation and unequalisation: What can be learned from value chain analysis?Journal of Development Studies37(2): 117–146.
55.
KissaneK (2002) Families of Childers dead ‘unlikely ever to recover’. The Age, 19March.
56.
KringsTBobekAMoriartyE, et al. (2011) From boom to bust: Migrant labour and employers in the Irish construction sector. Economic and Industrial Democracy32(3): 459–476.
57.
LindquistJXiangBYeohBS (2012) Opening the black box of migration: Brokers, the organization of transnational mobility and the changing political economy in Asia. Pacific Affairs85(1): 7–19.
58.
McKenzieNToscanoN (2017) Seasonal workers program pickers told if they join a union they’ll get no work. Sydney Morning Herald, 12March.
59.
MarchingtonMGrimshawDRuberyJWillmottH (2005) Fragmenting Work: Blurring Organizational Boundaries and Disordering Hierarchies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
60.
MarinoSRoosbladJPenninxR (2017) Trade Unions, Immigration and Immigrants in Europe in the 21st Century: New Approaches under Changing Conditions. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
61.
MartinP (2002) Mexican workers and US agriculture: The revolving door. International Migration Review36(4): 1124–1142.
62.
MartinP (2003) Managing Labour Migration: Temporary Worker Programs for the 21st Century. Geneva: International Labour Organization.
63.
MartinP (2009) Importing Poverty: Immigration and the Changing Face of Rural America. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
64.
MeardiGMarginsonP (2014) Global labour governance: Potential and limits of an emerging perspective. Work, Employment and Society28(4): 651–662.
65.
Meldrum-HannaCRussellA (2015) Slaving away: The dirty secrets behind Australia’s fresh food. Australian Broadcast Corporation News, 4May.
66.
NowakP (2009) Building stronger unions: A review of organising in Britain. In: GallG (ed.) Union Revitalisation in Advanced Economies: Assessing the Contribution of Union Organising. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 131–153.
67.
Parliament of Australia (2016) A National Disgrace: The Exploitation of Temporary Work Visa Holders. Canberra: Senate Education and Employment References Committee.
68.
PearlmanJPalazzoC (2016) British man who tried to help backpacker stabbed in Australia dies. The Telegraph, 31August.
69.
PeckJ (2010) Constructions of Neoliberal Reason. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
70.
PeckJTheodoreNWardK (2005) Constructing markets for temporary labour: Employment liberalization and the internationalization of the staffing industry. Global Networks5(1): 3–26.
71.
PotterCTilzeyM (2005) Agricultural policy discourses in the European post-Fordist transition: Neoliberalism, neomercantilism and multifunctionality. Progress in Human Geography29(5): 581–600.
72.
PotterMHamiltonJ (2014) Picking on vulnerable migrants: Precarity and the mushroom industry in Northern Ireland. Work, Employment and Society28(3): 390–406.
73.
PreibischK (2010) Pick your own labor: Migrant workers and flexibility in Canadian agriculture. International Migration Review44(2): 404–441.
74.
PreibischK (2012) Migrant workers and changing work-place regimes in contemporary agricultural production in Canada. International Journal of Sociology of Agriculture and Food19(1): 62–82.
ReillyAHoweJvan den BroekDWrightCF (2018) Working holiday makers in Australian horticulture: Labour market effect, exploitation and avenues for reform. Griffith Law Review27(1): 99–130.
77.
RogalyB (2008) Intensification of workplace regimes in British horticulture: The role of migrant workers. Population, Space and Place14(6): 497–510.
78.
RuhsM (2008) Economic research and labour immigration policy. Oxford Review of Economic Policy24(3): 404–427.
79.
RuhsM (2013) The Price of Rights: Regulating International Labor Migration. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
80.
ScottS (2013) Migrant–local hiring queues in the UK food industry. Population, Space and Place19(5): 459–471.
81.
StoneKVWArthursH (eds) (2013) Rethinking Workplace Regulation: Beyond the Standard Contract of Employment. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
82.
TanYLesterLH (2012) Labour market and economic impacts of international working holiday temporary migrants to Australia. Population, Space and Place18(3): 359–383.
83.
TurnerTCrossCO’SullivanM (2014) Does union membership benefit immigrant workers in ‘hard times’?Journal of Industrial Relations56(5): 611–630.
84.
UnderhillERimmerM (2016) Layered vulnerability: Temporary migrants in Australian horticulture. Journal of Industrial Relations58(5): 608–626.
85.
ValleHMillistNGaleanoD (2017) Labour Force Survey: ABARES Report to the Department of Agriculture and Water Resources. Canberra: Australian Government.
86.
van den BroekDHarveyWGroutsisD (2016) Commercial migration intermediaries and the segmentation of skilled migrant employment. Work, Employment and Society30(3): 523–534.
87.
Vargas-SilvaC (2016) Potential Implications of Admission Requirements for EU Nationals Coming to the UK. Oxford: Migration Observatory.
88.
VogiazidesLHedbergC (2013) Trafficking for forced labour and labour exploitation in Sweden: Examples from the restaurant and the berry industries. In: OllusNJokinenAJoutsenM (eds) Exploitation of Migrant Workers in Finland, Sweden, Estonia and Lithuania. Helsinki: European Institute for Crime Prevention and Control, pp. 171–237.
89.
VorleyB (2003) Food, Inc: Corporate Concentration from Farm to Consumer. London: UK Food Group.
90.
VoskoLF (2006) Precarious Employment: Understanding Labour Market Insecurity in Canada. Quebec: McGill-Queen’s University Press.
91.
VoskoLF (2011) Precarious employment and the problem of SER-centrism in regulating for decent work. In: Regulating for Decent Work. London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 58–90.
92.
WalshJ (2014) From nations of immigrants to states of transience: Temporary migration in Canada and Australia. International Sociology29(6): 584–606
93.
WeilD (2014) The Fissured Workplace. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
94.
WoolfsonCFudgeJThörnqvistC (2014) Migrant precarity and future challenges to labour standards in Sweden. Economic and Industrial Democracy35(4): 695–715.
95.
WrightCFClibbornS (2017) Back door, side door, or front door: An emerging de-facto low-skilled immigration policy in Australia. Comparative Labor Law and Policy Journal39(1): 165–188.
96.
WrightCFKaineS (2015) Supply chains, production networks and the employment relationship. Journal of Industrial Relations57(4): 483–501.
