In South Africa, post-apartheid, under the Mine Health and Safety Act No. 29 of 1996, workers elect health and safety representatives (HSRs). Descriptive case studies were conducted at four underground mine sites (gold, platinum and diamond) to explore the relationship between employer safety management and HSRs. A systems approach (socio-autopoiesis) is used as a metaphor for the circular/closed communication that ensured HSRs were dominated by employer interests and let down by the regulator. The stance of the employer to worker representation has not significantly changed since the managerial self-regulation prevalent in the demise of apartheid years. Given union membership is high, the capacity of HSRs to act without reference to management is uniquely compromised and presents as an anomaly in studies of worker representatives worldwide.
BachmanMLegerJMacunI, et al. (1989) The privatisation of working-class health care. In: South African Review 5. Johannesburg: Raven Press (Pty) Ltd, pp. 357–377.
4.
BhoratHNaidooKYuD (2014) Trade Unions in an Emerging Economy: The Case of South Africa. 201402, DPRU Working Paper, July. Development Policy Research Unit, University of Cape Town.
5.
BotiveauR (2017) Organise or Die?Johannesburg: Wits University Press.
6.
BuhlunguSBezuidenhoutA (2008) Union solidarity under stress: The case of the National Union of Mineworkers in South Africa. Labour Studies Journal33(3): 262–287.
CoulsonN (2018) The role of workplace health and safety representatives and the creeping responsibilisation of occupational health and safety on South African mines. Resources Policy 56 (June): 38–48.
10.
CoulsonNStewartPFSaeedS (2019) South African mine workers perspectives of the right to refuse dangerous work and the constraints to worker self-regulation. Journal of the Southern African Institute of Mining and Metallurgy119(1): 21–30.
11.
CoutrotT (2009) Health and safety committees in France: An empirical analysis. In: WaltersDNicholsT (eds) Workplace Health and Safety International Perspectives on Worker Representation. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 50–72.
12.
Department of Energy and Mineral Affairs, Republic of South Africa (1988) Amendment of Regulations Mines and Works Act No. 27 of 1956, G.N.R. 1889.
13.
Department of Mineral Resources (2017) Mine Health and Safety Inspectorate Annual Report 2016/2017. Pretoria: Department of Mineral Resources Republic of South Africa.
Duval SmithA (2013) South African platinum workers strike over job cut plans. The Guardian, 16January.
16.
ForrestK (2015) Rustenburg’s labour recruitment regime: Shifts and new meanings. Review of African Political Economy42(146): 508–525.
17.
FrickK (2013) Resilience within a weaker work environment system: The position and influence of Swedish safety representatives. In: NicholsTWaltersD (eds) Safety or Profit? International Studies in Governance, Change and the Work Environment. Work, Health and Environment Series. New York: Baywood Publishing.
18.
GarciaAMLopez-JacobMJDudzinskiI, et al. (2007) Factors associated with the activities of safety representatives in Spanish workplaces. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health61(9): 784–790.
19.
GunninghamN (2008) Occupational health and safety, worker participation and the mining industry in a changing world of work. Economic and Industrial Democracy29(3): 336–361.
20.
GunninghamNSinclairD (2009) Organizational trust and the limits of management-based regulation. Law and Society Review43(4): 865–900.
21.
HermanusMCoulsonNPillayN (2015) Mine Occupational Safety and Health Leading Practice Adoption System (MOSH) examined: The promise and pitfalls of this employer-led initiative to improve health and safety in South African Mines. Journal of the Southern African Institute of Mining and Metallurgy115(8): 717–727.
22.
HermanusMAPhakathiTSCoulsonN, et al. (2018) The achievements and limitations of statutory tripartism and non-statutory tripartism in South African mining. Journal of International Development Policy. Forthcoming.
23.
HovdenJLieTKarlsenJE, et al. (2008) The safety representative under pressure: A study of occupational health and safety management in the Norwegian oil and gas industry. Safety Science46: 493–509.
24.
IbsenCLTapiaM (2017) Trade union revitalisation: Where are we now? Where to next?Journal of Industrial Relations59(2): 170–191.
25.
ICMM (International Council on Mining and Metals) (2012) Mining’s contribution to sustainable development – an overview ICMM - 3716. Available at: www.icmm.com/document/3716 (accessed 31 March 2014).
JamesPWaltersD (2002) Worker representation in health and safety: Options for regulatory reform. Industrial Relations Journal33(2): 141–156.
28.
JohnstoneRQuinlanMWaltersD (2005) Statutory occupational health and safety workplace arrangements for the modern labour market. Journal of Industrial Relations47(1): 93–116.
29.
LegerJP (1985) Towards safer underground gold mining. An investigation commissioned by the National Union of Mine Workers. South Africa.
30.
LuhmannN (1995) Social Systems. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
MartinMESolomonH (2016) Understanding the phenomenon of ‘state capture’ in South Africa. Southern Africa Peace and Security Studies5(1): 21–34.
33.
MeleCPelsJPoleseF (2010) A brief review of systems theories and their management applications. Service Science 2(1–2): 126–135.
34.
MilgateNInnesEO’LoughlinK (2002) Examining the effectiveness of health and safety committees and representatives: A review. Work19(3): 281–290.
35.
MingersJ (2002) Can social systems be autopoietic? Assessing Luhmann’s social theory. The Sociological Review50(2): 278–299.
36.
MoodieDNdatsheV (1994) Going for Gold: Mines, Men and Migration. Berkeley: University of California Press.
37.
MoodieTD (2016) Making mincemeat out of mutton-eaters: Social origins of the NUM decline on platinum. Journal of Southern African Studies42(5): 841–856.
38.
NicholsTWaltersD (2009) Worker representation on health and safety in the UK: Problems with the preferred model and beyond. In: NicholsTWaltersD (eds) Workplace Health and Safety International Perspectives on Worker Representation. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 19–30.
39.
NicholsTWaltersDTasiranAC (2007) Trade unions, institutional mediation and industrial safety: Evidence from the UK. Journal of Industrial Relations49(2): 211–225.
40.
PhakathiST (2016) Safety: How good(or bad) are we really? In: Johannesburg Mining Indaba, Johannesburg, 5October2016.
41.
PhakathiST (2018) Production, Safety and Teamwork in a Deep-Level Mining Workplace: Perspectives from the Rock-Face. Bingley: Emerald Publishing.
42.
QuinlanM (2013) Precarity and workplace well-being: A general review. In: Safety or Profit? International Studies in Governance, Change and Work Environment. Work, Health and Environment Series. New York: Baywood Publishing, pp. 17–31.
43.
QuinlanM (2014) Ten Pathways to Death and Disaster: Learning from Fatal Incidents in Mines and Other High Hazard Workplaces. Sydney: The Federation Press.
SinwellL (2015) ‘AMCU by day, workers’ committee by night’: Insurgent trade unionism at Anglo Platinum (Amplats) mine, 2012–2014. Review of African Political Economy42(146): 591–605.
StewartPNiteDK (2017) From fatalism to mass action to incorporation to neo-liberal individualisation: Worker safety on South African mines, circa 1955–2016. Review of African Political Economy44(152): 252–271.
51.
VanderstraetenR (2012) Rewriting theory: From autopoiesis to communication: Autopoiesis, enaction and communication. Systems Research and Behavioral Science29(4): 377–386.
52.
WaltersD (1996) Trade unions and the effectiveness of worker representation in health and safety in Britain. International Journal of Health Services26(4): 625–641.
53.
WaltersD (2006) One step forward, two steps back: Worker representation and health and safety in the United Kingdom. International Journal of Health Services36(1): 87–111.
54.
WaltersDNicholsT (2007) Worker Representation and Workplace Health and Safety. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
55.
WaltersDQuinlanMJohnstoneR, et al. (2016) Representing miners in arrangements for health and safety in coalmines: A study of current practice. Economic and Industrial Democracy40(4): 976–996.
56.
WaltersDQuinlanMJohnstoneR, et al. (2017) Cooperation or resistance? Representing workers’ health and safety in a hazardous industry. Industrial Relations Journal48(6): 379–395.
57.
WebsterEBuhlunguS (2004) Between marginalisation and revitalisation? The state of trade unionism in South Africa. Review of African Political Economy31(100): 229–245.
58.
YinRK (2014) Case Study Research: Design and Methods, 5th edn.London: Sage. Available at: www.sagepub.com/textbooks/Book237921 (accessed 31 March 2014).
59.
ZwiAFonnSSteinbergM (1988) Occupational health and safety in South Africa: The perspectives of capital, state and unions. Social Science and Medicine27(7): 691–702.
