The author investigates the implementation of labour policy reforms as part of the rescue programmes adopted in Greece and Portugal during the Great Recession. Both countries were strongly pressurized to reform their labour markets. However, while the content of policies was the same the changes then followed different pathways. Rather than considering path dependency and convergence as mutually exclusive, in this article the author contends that the concepts interact with each other and forge particular policy outcomes. Looking through the lens of a ‘contingent divergence’, it is argued that while the rescue programmes suggest a common policy trajectory of neoliberalism determining the content of policies, variation in the political ownership of the reform programmes and the subsequent disparity in reform implementation, government approaches to social dialogue, public policy choices and programme design faults have played their part in the diverse policy outcomes. Considering this, path dependence pressures account for divergence, while the common direction of the reforms defines the field within which the former takes place.
AchterbergPYerkesΜ (2009) One welfare state emerging? Convergence versus divergence in 16 western countries. Journal of Comparative Social Welfare25(3): 189–201.
2.
ArmingeonK (2012) The politics of austerity: What political parties can do and what markets want. In: 2012 Meeting of the American Political Science Association, New Orleans, USA, 30 August–2 September 2012.
3.
ArmingeonKBonoliG (eds) (2006) The Politics of Post-Industrial Welfare States: Adopting Post-War Social Policies to New Social Risks. Abingdon: Routledge.
4.
AttiaNBerengerV (2007) Social protection convergence in the European Union: Impact of Maastricht Treaty. Panoeconomicus54(4): 469–487.
5.
BonoliG (2001) Political institutions, veto points, and the process of welfare state adaptation. In: PiersonP (ed.) The New Politics of the Welfare State. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 238–264.
6.
BrooksCManzaJ (2006) Why do welfare states persist?The Journal of Politics68(4): 816–827.
7.
BusemeyerM (2009) From myth to reality: Globalisation and public spending in OECD countries revisited. European Journal of Political Research48(4): 455–482.
ChungHThewissenS (2011) Falling back on old habits? A comparison of the social and unemployment crisis reactive policy strategies in Germany, the UK and Sweden. Social Policy and Administration45(4): 354–370.
10.
ClauwaertSSchömannI (2012) The Crisis and National Labour Law Reforms: A Mapping Exercise. WP04. Brussels: European Trade Union Institute.
11.
De la PorteCPochetP (2012) Why and how (still) study the Open Method of Co-ordination (OMC)?Journal of European Social Policy22(3): 336–349.
12.
DimoulasC (2014) Exploring the impact of employment policy measures in the context of crisis: The case of Greece. International Social Security Review67(1): 49–65.
13.
DobbinFSimmonsBGarrettG (2007) The global diffusion of public policies: Social construction, coercion, competition, or learning?Annual Review of Sociology33: 449–472.
14.
DomnickCSchoenwaldS (2016) No pain, no gain? Economic adjustment programmes in Greece and Portugal. KfW Research Focus on Economics.
15.
DornelasAMinistroALopesFR, et al. (2011) Emprego, contratação colectiva de trabalho e protecção da mobilidade profissional em Portugal. Lisbon: Ministério do Trabalho e da Solidariedade Social (MTSS).
16.
EscariaV (2015) Portugal: Social Situation and Employment in a Post-Programme Country. Brussels: European Parliament, Directorate General for Internal Policies.
17.
Esping-AndersenG (1996) Occupational welfare in the social policy nexus. In: ShalevM (ed.) The Privatization of Social Policy?New York: Macmillan Press, pp. 327–338.
European Commission (2011) Portugal, Memorandum of Understanding on Specific Economic Policy Conditionality. Available at: https://resistir.info/portugal/memo_troika.pdf (accessed 10 March 2018).
FarnsworthKIrvingZ (eds) (2015) Social Policy in Times of Austerity. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
23.
GauthierAH (2002) Family policies in industrialized countries: Is there convergence?Population57(2): 447–474.
24.
GialisSHerodA (2014) Of steel and strawberries: Greek workers struggle against informal and flexible working arrangements during the crisis. Geoforum57: 138–149.
25.
HagforsR (2000) EMU convergence and the structure of social protection financing. In: International Research Conference on Social Security ‘Social Security in the Global Village’, Helsinki, Finland, 25–27 September 2000.
26.
HatfieldI (2015) Self-Employment in Europe. London: Institute for Public Policy Research.
27.
HayCWincottD (2012) The Political Economy of European Welfare Capitalism. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
28.
HermannC (2017) Crisis, structural reform and the dismantling of the European Social Model(s). Economic and Industrial Democracy38(1): 51–68.
29.
HinrichsK (2000) Elephants on the Move: Patterns of Public Pension Reform in OECD Countries. Bremen: Zentrum für Sozialpolitik, Universität Bremen.
30.
HolzingerKKnillC (2005) Causes and conditions of cross-national policy convergence. Journal of European Public Policy12(5): 775–796.
31.
IMF (2016a) The Portuguese Crisis and the IMF. IEO Background Paper. Washington, DC: International Monetary Fund.
32.
IMF (2016b) The IMF’s Role in Greece in the Context of the 2010 Stand-By Arrangement. IEO Background Paper. Washington, DC: International Monetary Fund.
33.
ImmergutEMAndersonKM (2008) Historical institutionalism and West European politics. West European Politics31(1–2): 345–369.
34.
InkelesA (1998) One World Emerging: Convergence and Divergence in Industrial Societies. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
35.
KaramessiniM (2007) The Southern European Social Model: Changes and Continuities in Recent Decades. Geneva: ILO.
36.
KaramessiniM (2008) Still a distinctive Southern European employment model?Industrial Relations Journal39(6): 510–531.
37.
KaramessiniMRubberyJ (eds) (2014) Women and Austerity: The Economic Crisis and the Future of Gender Equality. Abingdon: Routledge.
38.
KarantinosD (2014) An Evaluation of the Social and Employment Aspects and Challenges in Greece. Brussels: European Parliament, Directorate General for Internal Policies, EGSU.
39.
KauttoM (2002) Investing in services in West European welfare states. Journal of European Social Policy12(1): 53–65.
40.
KerrC (1983) The Future of Industrial Societies: Convergence or Continuing Diversity?Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
41.
KiessJNormanLTempleLUbaK (2017) Path dependency and convergence of three worlds of welfare policy during the Great Recession: UK, Germany and Sweden. Journal of International and Comparative Social Policy33(1): 1–17.
42.
KittelBObingerH (2003) Political parties, institutions, and the dynamics of social expenditure in times of austerity. Journal of European Public Policy10(1): 20–45.
43.
KnillC (2005) Introduction: Cross-national policy convergence: concepts, approaches and explanatory factors. Journal of European Public Policy (Special Issue) 12(5-S): 764–774.
44.
KorpiWPalmeJ (2003) New politics and class politics in the context of austerity and globalization: Welfare states regress in 18 countries, 1975–95. American Political Science Review97: 425–446.
KoukiadakiAGrimshawD (2016) Evaluating the Effects of the Structural Labour Market Reforms on Collective Bargaining in Greece. Geneva: ILO.
47.
KoukiadakiATávoraILucioM (2016) Continuity and change in joint regulation in Europe: Structural reforms and collective bargaining in manufacturing. European Journal of Industrial Relations22(3): 189–203.
48.
LadiS (2014) Austerity politics and administrative reform: The Eurozone crisis and its impact upon Greek public administration. Comparative European Politics12(2): 184–208.
49.
LallementM (2011) Europe and the economic crisis: Forms of labour market adjustment and varieties of capitalism. Work, Employment and Society25(4): 627–641.
50.
LeibfriedS (2005) Social policy. Left to courts and markets? In: WallaceHWallaceWPollackMA (eds) Policy-Making in the European Union. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
51.
LynchJRhodesM (2016) Historical institutionalism and the welfare state. In: FioretosOFalletiGSheingateA (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Historical Institutionalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
52.
MadsenPKMolinaOMøllerJLozanoM (2012) The inter-generational costs of flexicurity: Labour market transitions of young workers in Nordic and Southern European countries. Individual Pathways to Flexibility and Sustainability in Europe. Available at: https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/03e5/f0dccd4e7a00b2be009a80f2567903162bdd.pdf (accessed 12 December 2017).
53.
MartinsCD (2014) Labour law in Portugal between 2011 and 2014. In: Young Scholars Meeting of the XI European Regional Congress of 2014, Dublin, Ireland, 17–19 September 2014.
54.
MontanariI (2001) Modernization, globalization and the welfare state: A comparative analysis of old and new convergence of social insurance since 1930. British Journal of Sociology52(3): 469–494.
55.
NelsonK (2008) Minimum income protection and European integration: Trends and levels of minimum benefits in comparative perspective, 1990–2005. International Journal of Health Services38(1): 103–124.
56.
NorthDC (1990) Institutions, Institutional Change, and Economic Performance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
57.
OECD (2010) OECD Employment Outlook 2010. Paris: OECD Publishing.
58.
OECD (2012) Structural reforms in times of crisis. In: Going for Growth: Economic Policy Reforms. Paris: OECD Publishing.
PassasCPierrosC (2017) The failure of internal devaluation and the case of an investment-led strategy to foster competitiveness in Greece. Policy Brief 14, Labour Institute GSEE.
68.
PedrosoO (2014) Portugal and the global crisis: The impact of austerity on the economy, the social model and the performance of the state. Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung.
69.
PetmesidouM (1996) Social protection in Southern Europe: Trends and prospects. Journal of Area Studies9: 95–125.
70.
PiersonP (1994) Dismantling the Welfare State. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
71.
PiersonP (2004) Politics in Time: History, Institutions, and Social Analysis. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
72.
PiersonP (2011) The welfare state over the very long run. ZeSArbeitspapier, No. 02/2011, Zentrum für Sozialpolitik, Universität Bremen.
73.
PochetPDegryseCJespenM (2013) The Euro crisis and its impact on national and European social policies. ETUI WP05.
74.
PontussonJRaessD (2012) How (and why) is this time different? The politics of economic crisis in Western Europe and the United States. Annual Review of Political Science15: 13–33.
75.
PreunkertJ (2016) The European integration process and the social consequences of the crisis. In: HeidenreichM (ed.) Inequalities in Europe. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 220–235.
76.
RamalhoM (2013) Portuguese Labour law and Industrial Relations during the Crisis. WP 54. Geneva: ILO.
77.
SchmidtVAThatcherM (2013) Resilient Liberalism in Europe’s Political Economy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
78.
SchmittCStarkeP (2011) Explaining convergence of OECD welfare states: A conditional approach. Journal of European Social Policy21(2): 120–135.
79.
ShahidiFV (2015) Welfare capitalism in crisis: A qualitative comparative analysis of labour market policy responses to the great recession. Journal of Social Policy44(4): 659–686.
80.
StarkeP (2006) The politics of welfare state retrenchment: A literature review. Social Policy and Administration40(1): 104–120.
81.
StarkePKaaschAVan HoorenF (2013) The Welfare State as Crisis Manager: Explaining the Diversity of Policy Responses to Economic Crisis. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
82.
StarkePObingerHCastlesF (2008) Convergence towards where: In what ways, if any, are welfare states becoming more similar?Journal of European Public Policy15(7): 975–1000.
83.
SwankD (2010) Globalization. In: ObingerHCastlesFLiebfridSLewisJ (eds) Oxford Handbook on Comparative Welfare States. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 318–332.
84.
TávoraIGonzálezP (2016) Labour market regulation and collective bargaining in Portugal during the crisis: Continuity and change. European Journal of Industrial Relations22(3): 251–265.
85.
ThelenK (2012) Varieties of capitalism: Trajectories of liberalization and the new politics of social solidarity. Annual Review of Political Science15: 137–159.
86.
TheodoropoulouS (2016) Severe pain, very little gain: Internal devaluation and rising unemployment in Greece. In: MyantMTheodoropoulouSPiasnaA, Unemployment, Internal Devaluation and Labour Market Deregulation in Europe. Brussels: European Trade Union Institute.
87.
TimonenV (2003) Restructuring the Welfare State: Globalization and Social Policy Reform Finland and Sweden. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
88.
TiniosP (2015) Employment and Social Developments in Greece. Brussels: European Parliament, Directorate General for Internal Policies, Policy Department, ESP.
89.
ValenteAMarquesP. (2014) An Evaluation of the Social and Employment Aspects and Challenges in Portugal. Brussels: European Parliament, Directorate General for Internal Policies, EGSU.
90.
Van KersbergenKVisBHemerijckA (2014) The great recession and welfare state reform: Is retrenchment really the only game left in town?Social Policy and Administration48(7): 883–904.
91.
Vaughan-WhiteheadD (eds) (2015) The European Social Model in Crisis: Is Europe Losing its Soul?Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
92.
VennD (2009) Legislation, collective bargaining and enforcement: Updating the OECD employment protection indicators. OECD Social, Employment and Migration, WP 89.
