Collective action and labour militancy interrupted: Back-to-work legislation and the state of permanent exceptionalism at Air Canada

Abstract

Using data collected from survey responses and interviews conducted in 2014, this study examines the consequences of back-to-work legislation from the perspective of customer service workers at Air Canada represented by Unifor Local 2002. By examining union attitudes, opinions of strikes, wildcat actions and back-to-work legislation deployed in 2011 and 2012, the study concludes that this type of legislation functioned to protect the interests of the employer in an ongoing process of corporate restructuring. Such ad hoc legislative measures, defined by political economists as ‘permanent exceptionalism’, further undermines the industrial pluralist regime that is the foundation of Canadian labour relations.

Keywords

Air Canada back-to-work legislation industrial pluralism union attitudes wildcat action

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Badigannavar

Kelly

(2005) Why are some union organizing campaigns more successful than others. British Journal of Industrial Relations 43(3): 515–535.

Barling

Milligan

(1987) Some psychological consequences of striking: A six month longitudinal study. Journal of Occupational Behaviour 8(2): 127–137.

Bray

Underhill

(2009) Industry differences in the neoliberal transformations of Australian industrial relations. Industrial Relations Journal 40(5): 372–392.

Brinkmann

(2015) Interviewing and the production of the conversational self. In: Denzin

Giardina

(eds) Qualitative Inquiry: Past, Present, and Future. Walnut Creek, CA: Left Coast Press, pp. 223–241.

Briskin

(2007) From person-days lost to labour militancy: A new look at the Canadian work stoppage data. Industrial Relations Journal 61(1): 31–62.

Burawoy

(1983) Factory regimes under advanced capitalism. American Sociological Review 48(3): 587–605.

Burawoy

(1985) The Politics of Production: Factory Regimes Under Capitalism and Socialism. London: Verso.

Bush

(2015) Airport workers say no to contracting out. Available at: http://rankandfile.ca/2015/04/10/airport-workers-say-no-to-contracting-out

Buttigieg

Deery

Iverson

(2008) Union mobilization: A consideration of the factors affecting the willingness of union members to take industrial action. British Journal of Industrial Relations 46(2): 248–267.

10.

Campbell

Larry

(2011) Struggles on the frontier of professional control: Leading cases from Canada. Economic and Industrial Democracy 33(4): 669–689.

11.

Canadian Labour Reporter (2016) Air Canada, CALDA sign collective agreement. Available at: www.labour-reporter.com/articleview/26684-air-canada-calda-sign-collective-agreement

12.

Canadian Press (2012) Air Canada wildcat strike: Disruptions predictable outcome of Harper government labour intervention say experts. Available at: www.huffingtonpost.ca/2012/03/23/air-canada-strike-harper-labour_n_1375427.html#s807184

13.

CAW (2011) CAW-Canada / Air Canada bargaining report. Available at: www.unifor2002.org/resources/1/pdf2/11-06-19_ac_barg_en.pdf

14.

CBC News (2011) Air Canada union cancels strike. Available at: www.cbc.ca/news/canada/air-canada-union-cancels-strike-1.1085123

15.

Chaulk

Brown

(2008) An assessment of worker reaction to their union and employer post-strike: A Canadian experience. Industrial Relations 63(2): 223–245.

16.

Denzin

Giardina

(2015) Qualitative Inquiry: Past, Present, and Future. Walnut Creek, CA: Left Coast Press.

17.

Deveau

(2012) Air Canada moves to prevent further illegal sick-outs, flight cancellations. Available at: http://business.financialpost.com/2012/04/13/air-canada-moves-to-prevent-further-illegal-sick-outs-flight-cancellations

18.

Dixon

Roscigno

Hodson

(2004) Unions, solidarity, and striking. Social Forces 83(1): 3–33.

19.

Eaton

(1993) Air France’s strategic plan: Benevolent ‘new despotism’. Work, Employment and Society 7(4): 585–602.

20.

Edwards

(2015) Stranded passengers frustrated by escalating wildcat job action at Pearson Airport. Available at: www.thestar.com/news/gta/2015/07/03/jet-fuel-dispute-delays-cancels-pearson-flights-friday.html

21.

Fantasia

(1988) Cultures of Solidarity: Consciousness, Action, and Contemporary American Workers. Berkeley: University of California Press.

22.

Fowler

Gudmundsson

Whicker

(2009) The psychological impact of industrial strikes: Does involvement in union activity during strikes make a difference? Journal of Industrial Relations 51(2): 227–243.

23.

Fryer

(2000) Identifying the Issues: Final Report. Advisory Committee on Labour Management Relations in the Federal Public Service. Ottawa: Treasury Board of Canada.

24.

Fudge

Tucker

(1996) Forging responsible unions: Metal workers and the rise of the labour injunction in Canada. Labour/Le Travail 37(1): 81–120.

25.

Fudge

Tucker

(2001) Labour Before the Law: The Regulation of Workers’ Collective Action in Canada, 1900–1948. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

26.

Gall

Fiorito

(2016) Union effectiveness: In search of the Holy Grail. Economic and Industrial Democracy 37(1): 189–211.

27.

Godard

(1992) Strikes as collective voice: A behavioral analysis of strike activity. Industrial and Labor Relations Review 46(1): 161–175.

28.

Godard

(2011) What has happened to strikes? British Journal of Industrial Relations 49(2): 282–305.

29.

Harris

Rausch

Ryan

(1982) Ineffectiveness in teacher bargaining: The anatomy of a first strike. Relations Industrielles/Industrial Relations 37(4): 905–926.

30.

Harvey

(2005) A Brief History of Neoliberalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

31.

Hebdon

(1998) Behavioural determinants of public sector illegal strikes: Cases from Canada and the U.S. Relations Industrielles/Industrial Relations 53(4): 667–690.

32.

Hodder

Williams

Kelly

, et al. (2016) Does strike action stimulate trade union membership growth? British Journal of Industrial Relations. Epub ahead of print.

33.

Howard

Smith

(2012) Stuck in the terminal with the gates firmly shut: Suspension and termination of industrial action after Qantas. Victoria Law School Journal 41(1): 41–55.

34.

IAMAW (2015) Air Canada dismantles fuel consortium hundreds of airport fuelers lose jobs. Available at: www.iamaw.ca/node/2031

35.

International Labour Organization (2013) Reports of the Committee on Freedom of Association. 319th session. Geneva: ILO.

36.

Jacques

Kepos

(eds) (2011) Air Canada. International Directory of Company Histories 125. Detroit: St. James Press.

37.

Jain

Singh

Zinni

(2005) The effects of the use of striker replacement workers in Canada: An analysis of four cases. Labor Studies Journal 30(2): 61–86.

38.

Jansen

Akkerman

Vandaele

(2014) Undermining mobilization? The effect of job flexibility and job instability on the willingness to strike. Economic and Industrial Democracy. Epub ahead of print 17 December 2014. doi:10.1177/0143831X14559782

39.

Keenan

(2015) Unifor approves new five-year contract with Air Canada. Globe and Mail. Available at: www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/unifor-approves-new-five-year-contract-with-air-canada/article25137268

40.

Kelly

(1994) Who gets involved in collective action: Social psychological determinants of individual participation in trade unions. Human Relations 47(1): 63–83.

41.

Kelly

(1998) Rethinking Industrial Relations: Mobilization, Collectivism, and Long Waves. London: Routledge.

42.

Kelly

(2015) Conflict: Trends and forms of collective action. Employee Relations 37(6): 720–732.

43.

Klandermans

(1997) The Social Psychology of Protest. Oxford: Blackwell.

44.

Langford

(1996) Effects of strike participation on the political consciousness of Canadian postal workers. Relations Industrielles/Industrial Relations 51(3): 563–585.

45.

Lansbury

Oxenbridge

Tiernan

, et al. (2010) A comparative analysis of restructuring employment relationships in Qantas and Aer Lingus: Different routes, similar destinations. International Journal of Human Resource Management 21(2): 180–196.

46.

Larsen

Navrbjerg

(2015) The economic crisis: Testing employee relations. Economic and Industrial Democracy 36(2): 331–353.

47.

Lee

Sack

(1989) The role of the state in Canadian labour relations. Relations Industrielles/Industrial Relations 44(1): 195–223.

48.

(2015) Air Canada flight attendants approve 10-year deal. Toronto Star. Available at: www.thestar.com/business/2015/11/18/air-canada-flight-attendants-approve-10-year-deal.html

49.

Macbride

Lancee

Freeman

(1981) The psychosocial impact of a labour dispute. Journal of Occupational Psychology 54(1): 125–133.

50.

McClendon

Klaas

(1993) Determinants of strike-related militancy: An analysis of a university faculty strike. Industrial and Labor Relations Review 46(3): 560–573.

51.

McShane

(1985) Sources of attitudinal union militancy. Relations Industrielles/Industrial Relations 40(1): 285-301.

52.

McShane

(1986) General union attitude: A construct validation. Journal of Labour Research 12(4): 403–417.

53.

Marowits

(2014) Air Canada pilots ratify 10-year contract with 20% wage increase. Available at: www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/air-canada-pilots-ratify-10-year-contract/article21401537

54.

(1993) Strike activities and post-strike perceptions among university faculty. Relations Industrielles/Industrial Relations 48(1): 231–249.

55.

Nicholson

Kelly

(1980) The psychology of strikes. Journal of Occupational Behavior 1(4): 275–284.

56.

Panitch

Swartz

(2009) From Consent to Coercion: The Assault on Trade Union Freedoms, 3rd edn. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

57.

Panitch

Swartz

(2013) The continuing assault on public sector unions. In: Ross

Savage

(eds) Public Sector Unions in the Age of Austerity. Halifax: Fernwood, pp. 31–45.

58.

Rose

(2004) Public sector bargaining: From retrenchment to consolidation. Relation Industrielles/Industrial Relations 59(2): 271–294.

59.

Savage

(2008) Workers’ rights as human rights: Organized labor rights discourse in Canada. Labor Studies Journal 34(1): 8–20.

60.

Schutt

(1982) Models of militancy: Support for strikes and work actions among public employees. Industrial and Labor Relations Review 35(1): 406–422.

61.

Shirom

(1977) Union militancy: Structural and personal determinants. Industrial Relations 16(1): 152–162.

62.

Simms

Dean

(2015) Mobilising contingent workers: An analysis of two successful cases. Economic and Industrial Democracy 36(1): 173–190.

63.

Smith

Howard

(2012) Stuck in the terminal with the gates firmly shut: Suspension and termination of industrial action after Qantas. Victoria Law School Journal 41: 41–55.

64.

Stevens

Nesbitt

(2014) Era of wildcats and sick-outs in Canada? The continued decline of industrial pluralism and the case of Air Canada. Labour Studies Journal 39(2): 118–139.

65.

Tabachnick

Fidell

(2001) Using Multivariate Statistics, 4th edn. Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon.

66.

Taylor

Moore

(2015) Cabin crew collectivism: Labour process and the roots of mobilization. Work, Employment and Society 29(1): 79–98.

67.

Thomas

Tufts

(2016) Austerity, right populism, and the crisis of labour in Canada. Antipode 48(1): 212–230.

68.

Thommes

Akkerman

Torenvlied

, et al. (2014) The dark side of solidarity: Social norms and social relations in the aftermath of strikes. Industrial Relations Journal 45(4): 348–367.

69.

Tucker

(2014) Shall Wagnerism have no dominion? Just Labour: A Canadian Journal of Work and Society 21(1): 1–27.

70.

Warskett

(2013) Federal public sector unions in times of austerity: Linking structure and strategic choice. In: Ross

Savage

(eds) Public Sector Unions in the Age of Austerity. Halifax and Winnipeg: Fernwood, pp. 126–138.

71.

YouTube (2015) May Day ice cream YYZ. Available at: www.youtube.com/watch?v=ujxLiZkRYBs