Everything and nothing changes: Fast-food employers and the threat to minimum wage regulation in Ireland

Abstract

Ireland’s selective system of collective agreed minimum wages has come under significant pressure in recent years. A new fast-food employer body took a constitutional challenge against the system of Joint Labour Committees (JLCs) and this was strengthened by the discourse on the negative effects of minimum wages as Ireland’s economic crisis worsened. Taking a historical institutional approach, the article examines the critical juncture for the JLC system and the factors which led to the subsequent government decision to retain but reform the system. The article argues that the improved enforcement of minimum wages was a key factor in the employers’ push for abolition of the system but that the legacy of a collapsed social partnership system prevented the system’s abolition.

Keywords

Economic change pay peak employer’s organisations trade unions

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barry

Wilkinson

(2011) Reconceptualising employer associations under evolving employment relations: Countervailing power revisited. Work, Employment and Society 25: 149–162.

Blackburn

(2009) Curse or cure? Why was the enactment of Britain’s 1909 Trade Boards Act so controversial? British Journal of Industrial Relations 47: 205–213.

Böckerman

Uusitalo

(2009) Minimum wages and youth employment: Evidence from the Finnish retail trade sector. British Journal of Industrial Relations 47: 388–405.

Braun

Clarke

(2008) Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology 2: 77–101.

Brown

Gilroy

Kohen

(1982) The effect of the minimum wage on employment and unemployment. Journal of Economic Literature 20: 487–528.

Busenberg

(2003) Agenda setting and policy evolution, theories and applications. In: Midwest Political Science Association Meeting.

Card

Krueger

(1995) Myth and Measurement: The New Economics of the Minimum Wage. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Clegg

(1970) The System of Industrial Relations. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.

Connacht Tribune (2009) Supermac’s takes the fast road. The Connacht Tribune, 17 December. Available at: www.galwaynews.ie/10232-supermacs-takes-fast-road.

10.

Council of Europe (1999) European Social Charter: European Committee of Social Rights/Committee of Independent Experts – Conclusions XIV-2. Strasbourg: Council of Europe.

11.

Deakin

Green

(2009) One hundred years of British minimum wage legislation. British Journal of Industrial Relations 47: 205–213.

12.

Deakin

Wilkinson

(2005) The Law of the Labour Market: Industrialisation, Employment, and Legal Evolution. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

13.

Deegan

(2009) Pretax profits quadruple for Supermac’s holding firm. The Irish Times, 16 December. Available at: www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/finance/2009/1216/1224260759868.html.

14.

Department of Enterprise, Trade and Innovation (2010) Address by Minister for Labour Affairs, Dara Calleary T.D., on the Second Stage debate on the Industrial Relations (Amendment) Bill 2009. Available at: www.deti.ie/press/2010/20100126.htm.

15.

Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation (2011) Bruton announces reforms to JLC/REA systems. Press release, 28 July. Available at: www.djei.ie/press/2011/20110728a.htm.

16.

Duffy

Walsh

(2011) Report of Independent Review of Employment Regulation Orders and Registered Employment Agreement Wage Setting Mechanisms. Dublin: Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation.

17.

Ebbinghaus

(2005) Can Path Dependence Explain Institutional Change? Two Approaches Applied to Welfare State Reform. MPIfG Discussion Paper 05/2. Cologne: Max Planck Institute for the Study of Societies.

18.

Erickson

Kuruvilla

(1998) Industrial relations system transformation. Industrial and Labor Relations Review 52: 3–21.

19.

Gersick

(1991) Revolutionary change theories: A multilevel exploration of the punctuated equilibrium. The Academy of Management Review 16: 10–36.

20.

Grote

Lang

Traxler

(2007) Germany. In: Traxler

Huemer

(eds) Handbook of Business Interest Associations, Firm Size and Governance. London and New York: Routledge, pp. 141–176.

21.

Higgins

(2009) Catering JLCs face High Court challenge, national terms to be proposed. Industrial Relations News 6. Available at: www.irn.ie/issues/article.asp?id=14317&issueType=2.

22.

Higgins

(2011) Bruton’s radical reform of wage-setting welcomed by EU. Industrial Relations News 33. Available at: www.irn.ie/issues/article.asp?id=17778&issueType=2.

23.

High Court (2008) John Grace Fried Chicken Limited, John Grace and Quick Service Food Alliance Limited and the Catering Joint Labour Committee, The Labour Court, Ireland and the Attorney General. Plenary Summons. No. 10663 P.

24.

International Monetary Fund (IMF) (2010) Ireland: Letter of Intent, Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies, and Technical Memorandum of Understanding. Washington, DC: IMF.

25.

Weil

(2009) Does ownership structure influence regulatory behavior? The impact of franchisee free-riding on labor standards compliance. Working Paper, Boston University.

26.

Kaufman

(2009) Promoting labour market efficiency and fairness through a legal minimum wage: The Webbs and the social cost of labour. British Journal of Industrial Relations 47: 306–326.

27.

Krasner

(1984) Approaches to the state: Alternative conceptions and historical dynamics. Comparative Politics 16(2): 223–246.

28.

Leidner

(2002) Fast-food work in the United States. In: Royle

Towers

(eds) Labour Relations in the Global Fast-food Industry. London: Routledge, pp. 8–29.

29.

Levi

(1997) A model, a method, and a map: Rational choice in comparative and historical analysis. In: Lichbach

Zuckerman

(eds) Comparative Politics: Rationality, Culture, and Structure. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 19–41.

30.

Lowndes

(1996) Varieties of new institutionalism: A critical appraisal. Public Administration 74: 181–197.

31.

McLaughlin

(2009) The productivity-enhancing impacts of the minimum wage: Lessons from Denmark and New Zealand. British Journal of Industrial Relations 47: 327–348.

32.

Mahoney

Thelen

(2010) A theory of gradual institutional change. In: Mahoney

Thelen

(eds) Explaining Institutional Change: Ambiguity, Agency, and Power. New York: Cambridge University Press.

33.

Metcalf

(2009) Nothing new under the sun: The prescience of W. S. Sanders’ 1906 Fabian Tract. British Journal of Industrial Relations 47: 289–305.

34.

NERA (2009) Review of 2008. Dublin: National Employment Rights Authority. Available at: www.employmentrights.ie/en/media/NERA%20Review%20of%202008.pdf.

35.

NERA (2010) Review of 2009. Dublin: National Employment Rights Authority. Available at: www.employmentrights.ie/en/aboutnera/publicationsdownloads/.

36.

Neumark

Wascher

(1992) Employment effects of minimum and subminimum wages: Panel data on state minimum wage laws. Industrial and Labor Relations Review 46: 55–81.

37.

O’Sullivan

Wallace

(2005) Review of the Joint Labour Committee system. Report to the Labour Relations Commission. Unpublished.

38.

O’Sullivan

Wallace

(2011) Minimum labour standards in a social partnership system: The persistence of the Irish variant of Wages Councils. Industrial Relations Journal 42: 18–35.

39.

Pierson

(2000) Increasing returns, path dependence, and the study of politics. The American Political Science Review 94: 251–267.

40.

Reiter

(2002) Fast-food work in Canada: Working conditions, labour law and unionization. In: Royle

Towers

(eds) Labour Relations in the Global Fast Food Industry. London: Routledge, pp. 30–47.

41.

Roche

(2007) Developments in industrial relations and human resource management in Ireland. Quarterly Economic Commentary Spring: 62–77.

42.

Royle

(2000) Working for McDonald’s in Europe. London and New York: Routledge.

43.

Royle

(2002) Multinational corporations, employer associations and trade union exclusion strategies in the German fast-food industry. Employee Relations 24: 437–460.

44.

Royle

(2004) Employment practices of multinationals in the Spanish and German quick food service sectors: Low road convergence? European Journal of Industrial Relations 10: 51–71.

45.

Royle

(2010) McDonald’s and the global ‘McJob’: A longitudinal study of work, pay and unionization in the international fast-food industry. Labor History 51: 249–269.

46.

Royle

(2012) Socially inclusive or exclusive? An analysis of European social policy, legislation and European case law. Bulletin of Comparative Labour Relations 80: 25–48.

47.

Rubery

(1997) Wages and the labour market. British Journal of Industrial Relations 35: 337–366.

48.

Sheehan

(2008) Employers and the traditional industrial relations system. In: Hastings

(ed.) The State of the Unions: Challenges Facing Organised Labour in Ireland. Dublin: The Liffey Press, pp. 105–126.

49.

Stewart

(1993) Rational choice theory, public policy and the liberal state. Policy Sciences 26: 317–330.

50.

Sweeney

O’Brien

(2011) Is the state’s wage-setting system necessary? The Irish Times, 18 June. Available at: www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/opinion/2011/0618/1224299152694.html.

51.

Thelen

(2009) Institutional change in advanced political economies. British Journal of Industrial Relations 3: 471–498.

52.

Thelen

(2010) Beyond comparative statics: Historical institutional approaches to stability and change in the political economy of labor. In: Richard

Kai

Crouch

. (eds) Oxford Handbook of Comparative Institutional Analysis. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 42–61.

53.

Thelen

Steinmo

(1992) Historical institutionalism in comparative politics. In: Steinmo

Thelen

Longstreth

(eds) Structuring Politics: Historical Institutionalism in Comparative Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 1–32.

54.

Turner

O’Sullivan

(2011) Economic crisis and the restructuring of wage setting mechanisms for vulnerable workers in Ireland. In: TASC Conference, Cork, 29 September.

55.

Wall

(2008) Pledge to protect minimum wage. Irish Times, 25 February. Available at: www.irishtimes.com.

56.

Wall

(2011) IBEC accuses government of prejudicing wage-rules review. The Irish Times, 15 March. Available at: www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/ireland/2011/0315/1224292162416.html.

57.

Weil

(2009) Rethinking the regulation of vulnerable work in the USA: A sector-based approach. Journal of Industrial Relations 51: 411–430.

58.

Weil

(2010) Improving Workplace Conditions Through Strategic Enforcement: A Report to the Wage and Hour Division. Boston, MA: Boston University.

59.

Wilkinson

(1983) Productive systems. Cambridge Journal of Economics 7: 413–429.

60.

Wood

(2012) McDonald’s says 2,500 new jobs a lifeline for young unemployed. The Guardian, 24 January. Available at: www.guardian.co.uk/business/2012/jan/24/mcdonalds-new-jobs-young-unemployed?newsfeed=true.