The article explores the claim that Scandinavian countries have been able to support forms of work organization which afford employees higher levels of autonomy and control, compared with liberal market economies, such as the UK. Focusing upon the experience of vocational teachers in England, Wales and Norway, the article compares levels of autonomy, discretion and decision-making influence. The research finds evidence that Norway is indeed distinctive, and that both the institutional and policy context, alongside the actions of trade unions, are crucial in explaining the differences found.
AckroydSKirkpatrickIWalkerR (2007) Public management reform in the UK and its consequences for professional organization: A comparative analysis. Public Administration85(1): 9–26.
2.
ArmstrongRBéduwéCGermeJ-FLeneyTPlanasJPoumayM (2008) New and emerging issues in vocational education and training research beyond 2010. In: CEDEFOP (ed.) Modernising Vocational Education and Training. Luxembourg: EC.
3.
AvisJ (2003) Re-thinking trust in a performative culture: The case of education. Journal of Education Policy18(3): 315–332.
4.
BallS (2003) The teacher’s soul and the terrors of performativity. Journal of Education Policy18(2): 215–228.
5.
BealeD (2004) The impact of restructuring in further education colleges. Employee Relations26(5): 465–479.
6.
BoschGLehndorffS (eds) (2005) Working in the Service Sector: A Tale from Different Worlds. Abingdon: Routledge.
7.
BrownPGreenALauderH (2001) High Skills: Globalisation, Competitiveness, and Skill Formation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
8.
ChristensenTLieALǽgreidP (2008) Beyond new public management: Agencification and regulatory reform in Norway. Financial Accountability and Management24(1): 15–30.
9.
CoffieldF (2008) Just Suppose Teaching and Learning Became the First Priority…London: Learning and Skills Network.
10.
CoffieldFEdwardSFinlayIHodgsonASteerRSpoursK (2008) Improving Learning, Skills and Inclusion: The Impact of Policy. London: Routledge/Falmer.
11.
CribbAGewirtzS (2007) Unpacking autonomy and control in education: Some conceptual and normative groundwork for a comparative analysis. European Educational Research Journal6(3): 203–213.
12.
DobbinFBoychukT (1999) National employment systems and job autonomy: Why autonomy is high in Nordic countries and low in the United States, Canada and Australia. Organization Studies20(2): 257–291.
13.
DWP (Department of Work and Pensions), DIUS (Department for Innovation, Universities and Skills) and Cabinet Office. (2008) Life chances: Supporting people to get on in the labour market. An analytical discussion paper. Cabinet Office, London.
14.
Eurydice. (2008a) Levels of Autonomy and Responsibilities of Teachers in Europe. Brussels: European Unit.
15.
Eurydice. (2008b) National Summary Sheets on Education Systems in Europe and Ongoing Reforms – Norway (December 2008). Available at: www.eurydice.org
16.
FerlieEGeraghtyK (2005) Professionals in public services organizations: Implications for public sector ‘reforming’. In: FerlieELynnLPollittC (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Public Management. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 422–445.
17.
FinegoldDWagnerKMasonG (2000) National skill-creation systems and career paths for service workers: Hotels in the United States, Germany and the United Kingdom. International Journal of Human Resource Management11(3): 497–516.
18.
FlynnR (1999) Managerialism, professionalism and quasi markets. In: ExworthyMHalfordS (eds) Professionals and the New Managerialism in the Public Sector. Buckingham: Open University Press.
19.
FriedmanA (1977) Industry and Labour. London: Macmillan.
20.
GallieD (2003) The quality of working life: Is Scandinavia different?European Sociological Review19(1): 61–79.
21.
GallieD (2007) Production regimes and the quality of employment in Europe. Annual Review of Sociology33: 85–104.
22.
GautiéJSchmittJ (eds) (2010) Low-Wage Work in the Wealthy World. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
23.
GreenF (2006) Demanding Work: The Paradox of Job Quality in the Affluent Economy. Princeton, NJ and Oxford: Princeton University Press.
24.
HallPSoskiceD (2001) An introduction to varieties of capitalism. In: HallPSoskiceD (eds) Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1–68.
25.
HelgøyIHommeA (2006) Policy tools and institutional change: Comparing education policies in Norway, Sweden and England. Journal of Public Policy26(2): 141–165.
26.
HelgøyIHommeA (2007) Towards a new professionalism in school? A comparative study of teacher autonomy in Norway and Sweden. European Educational Research Journal6(3): 232–249.
27.
HelgøyIHommeAGewirtzS (2007) Introduction to special issue local autonomy or state control? Exploring the effects of new forms of regulation in education. European Educational Research Journal6(3): 198–202.
28.
HodkinsonP (2008) Scientific research, education policy, and educational practice in the United Kingdom: The impact of the audit culture on further education. Cultural Studies-Critical Methodologies8(3): 302–324.
29.
HolmJLorenzELundvallBValeyreA (2008) Work organisation and systems of labour market regulation in Europe. Paper presented at the EAEPE Conference, Rome, 6–8 November.
30.
JamesDDimentK (2003) Going underground? Learning and assessment in an ambiguous space. Journal of Vocational Education and Training55(4): 407–422.
31.
JephcoteMSalisburyJReesG (2008) Being a teacher in further education in changing times. Research in Post-Compulsory Education13(2): 163–172.
32.
KeepE (2006) State control of the English education and training system – playing with the biggest train set in the world. Journal of Vocational Education and Training58(1): 47–64.
33.
KellyJ (1996) Union militancy and social partnership. In: AckersPSmithCSmithP (eds) The New Workplace and Trade Unionism. London: Routledge.
34.
KletteK (1998) Working time blues: On how Norwegian teachers experience restructuring in education. Change: Transformations in Education1(1): 48–61.
35.
KletteK (2002) Reform policy and teacher professionalism in four Nordic countries. Journal of Educational Change3–4: 265–282.
36.
LawtonK (2009) Nice Work if You Can Get it: Achieving a Sustainable Solution to Low Pay and In-work Poverty. London: IPPR (Institute for Public Policy Research).
37.
Lifelong Learning UK. (2009) SIR 2004/2005 terms of employment breakdown. London.
38.
LloydCPayneJ (forthcoming) Raising the quality of vocational teachers: Continuing professional development in England, Wales and Norway. Research Papers in Education.
39.
LyngSBlichfeldtJ (2003) Norwegian Country Background Report for the OECD Project ‘Attracting, Developing and Retaining Effective Teachers’. Oslo: Work Research Institute.
40.
McCabeD (2009) Enterprise contested: Betwixt and between the discourses of career and enterprise in a UK bank. Human Relations62(10): 1551–1579.
41.
MauriceMSellierFSilvestreJ (1986) The Social Foundations of Industrial Power: A Comparison of France and Germany. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
42.
MøllerJEggenAFuglestadOLangfeldtGPresthusA-MSkrøvsetS. (2005) Successful school leadership: The Norwegian case. Journal of Educational Administration43(6): 584–594.
43.
PayneJ (2002) A tale of two curriculums: Putting the English and Norwegian curriculum models to the test of the high skills vision. Journal of Education and Work15(2): 117–143.
44.
PayneJKeepE (2003) Re-visiting the Nordic approaches to work organization and job redesign: Lessons for UK skills policy. Policy Studies24(4): 205–225.
45.
PollittC (1993) Managerialism and the Public Services: Cuts or Cultural Change in the 1990s?Oxford: Blackwell.
46.
QuackSO’ReillyJHildebrandtS (1995) Structural change: Training and recruitment in retail banking in Germany, Britain and France. International Journal of Human Resource Management6(4): 759–794.
47.
ReedM (2002) New managerialism, professional power and organisational governance in UK universities: A review and assessment. In: AmaralAJonesGKarsethB (eds) Governing Higher Education: National Perspectives on Institutional Governance. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic.
48.
ReesG (2007) The impacts of parliamentary devolution on education policy in Wales. Welsh Journal of Education14(1): 8–20.
49.
SimmonsRThompsonR (2008) Creativity and performativity: The case of further education. British Educational Research Journal34(5): 601–618.
50.
SkuleSStuartMNyenT (2002) Training and development in Norway. International Journal of Training and Development6(4): 263–276.
51.
SolhaugT (2008) New public management in educational reform in Norway. Paper presented at the International Political Science Association Conference, Concordia University, Montreal, 30 April–2 May.
52.
Statistics for Wales. (2009) Staff at Further Education Institutions in Wales, 2007/08. SDR 121/2009. Cardiff: Welsh Assembly Government.
53.
SteedmanHWagnerK (1989) Productivity, machinery and skills: Clothing manufacture in Britain and Germany. National Institute Economic Review128: 40–57.
54.
StreeckW (1992) Social Institutions and Economic Performance: Studies of Industrial Relations in Advanced Capitalist Economies. London: Sage.
55.
TaylorIKellyJ (2006) Professionals, discretion and public sector reform in the UK: Re-visiting Lipsky. International Journal of Public Sector Management19(7): 629–642.
56.
WallisJ (2009) Conclusion: Is there a common thread? In: WallisJGoldfinchS (eds) International Handbook of Public Management Reform. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 351–370.
57.
WarhurstCThompsonP (1998) Hands, hearts and minds: Changing work and workers at the end of the century. In: ThompsonPWarhurstC (eds) Workplaces of the Future. London: Macmillan, 1–24.
