This article examines why employer opposition is stimulated by the introduction of statutory union recognition provisions in Britain, Ireland and the US. It examines the impact of the provisions for encouraging union organizing, which in turn stimulates employer anti-unionism, which then negates the intention of the provisions.
Abelow, R. ( 1958) ‘Management Experience under the Taft-Hartley Act’ , Industrial and Labor Relations Review11(3): 360-70.
2.
Adams, R. ( 1999) ‘Why Statutory Union Recognition is Bad Labour Policy: The NorthAmerican Experience’, Industrial Relations Journal30(2): 96-100.
3.
American Rights at Work (2006) ‘Every 23 Minutes/About this Statistic’, American Rights at Work leaflet and website; at: www.americanrightsatwork.org
4.
Batstone, E. ( 1988) ‘The Frontier of Control’, pp. 218-47 in D. Gallie (ed.) Employment in Britain. Oxford: Blackwell.
5.
Bendix, R. ( 1956) Work and Authority in Industry: Ideologies of Management in the Course of Industrialization. New York: John Wiley.
6.
Bernstein, I. ( 1960) The Lean Years: A History of the American Worker, 1920-1933 . Boston, MA: Houghton-Mifflin .
7.
Bernstein, I. ( 1970) The Turbulent Years: A History of the American Worker, 1933-1941. Boston, MA: Houghton-Mifflin .
8.
Bronfenbrenner, K. and T. Juravich ( 1998) ‘It Takes More than House Calls: Organizing to Win with a Comprehensive Union-Building Strategy’, pp. 19-36 in K. Bronfenbrenner, S. Friedman, R. Hurd, R. Oswald and R. Seeber (eds) Organizing to Win: New Research on Union Strategies. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
9.
Clawson, D. ( 2003) The Next Upsurge: Labor and the New Social Movements . Ithaca, NY: ILR Press.
10.
Clawson, D. and M. Clawson ( 1999) ‘What Has Happened to the US Labor Movement? Union Decline and Renewal’, Annual Review of Sociology25: 95-199.
11.
Cohen, J. and L. Cohen ( 1948) ‘The National Labor Relations Board in Retrospect’ , Industrial and Labor Relations Review1(4): 648-56.
12.
Cooke, W. ( 1983) ‘Determinants of the Outcomes of Union Certification Elections’, Industrial and Labor Relations Review36(3): 402-14.
13.
Cooke, W. ( 1985a) ‘The Failure to Negotiate First Contracts: Determinants and Policy Implications’, Industrial and Labor Relations Review38(2): 163-78.
14.
Cooke, W. ( 1985b) ‘The Rising Toll of Discrimination against Union Activists’, Industrial Relations24(3): 421-42.
15.
Cully, M., S. Woodland, A. O’Reilly and G. Dix ( 1999) Britain at Work - As Depicted by the 1998 Workplace Employee Relations Survey. London: Routledge .
16.
D’Art, D. and T. Turner ( 1999) ‘An Attitudinal Revolution in Irish Industrial Relations: The End of "Them" And "Us" ’, British Journal of Industrial Relations37(1): 101-16.
17.
D’Art, D. and T. Turner ( 2003) ‘Union Recognition in Ireland: One Step Forward or Two Steps Back?’, Industrial Relations Journal34(3): 226-40.
18.
D’Art, D. and T. Turner ( 2005) ‘Union Recognition and Partnership at Work: A New Legitimacy for Irish Labour Unions’, Industrial Relations Journal36(2): 121-39.
19.
Dickens, W. ( 1983) ‘The Effect of Company Campaigns on Certification Elections: Law and Reality Once Again’, Industrial and Labor Relations Review36(4): 560-75.
20.
Dubofsky, M. ( 1994) The State and Labour in Modern America. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
21.
EIRO (European Industrial Relations Observatory) ( 2002) ‘Ireland: Effectiveness of "Right to Bargain" Law Questioned’, Eironline, Dublin.
22.
EIRO (European Industrial Relations Observatory) ( 2005) ‘Ireland: Union Density Declines to Around a Third’ , Eironline, Dublin.
23.
Ewing, K., S. Moore and S. Wood ( 2003) Unfair Labour Practices: Labour Union Recognition and Employer Resistance. London: Institute of Employment Rights.
24.
Farber, H. and A. Krueger ( 1993) ‘Union Membership in the United States: The Decline Continues’, pp. 105-34 in B. Kaufamn and M. Kleiner (eds) Employee Representation: Alternatives and Future Direction. Madison, WI: Industrial Relations Research Association.
25.
Fiorito, J. ( 2001) ‘Human Resource Management Practices and Worker Desires For Union Representation’, Journal of Labor Research22(2): 335-54.
26.
Fiorito, J. ( 2002) ‘Human Resource Management Practices and Desires for Union Representation’, pp. 28-58 in J. Bennett and B. Kaufman (eds) The Future of Private Sector Unionism in the United States. Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharp.
27.
Fiorito, J. ( 2003) ‘Union Organizing in the United States’ , pp. 191-210 in G. Gall (ed.) Union Organising: Campaigning for Trade Union Recognition. New York and London: Routledge.
28.
Flanagan, R. ( 2005) ‘Has Management Strangled US Unions?’ , Journal of Labor Research26(1): 33-63.
29.
Flood, P. and B. Toner ( 1997) ‘Large Non-Union Companies: How Do They Avoid a Catch 22?’, British Journal of Industrial Relations35(2): 257-77.
30.
Freeman, R. ( 1986) ‘Why Are Union Faring Poorly in NLRB Representation Elections?’, pp. 45-64 in T. Kochan (ed.) Challenges and Choices Facing American Labor. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
31.
Freeman, R. and M. Kleiner ( 1990) ‘Employer Behavior in the Face of Union Organizing Drives’, Industrial and Labor Relations Review43(4): 351-65.
32.
Freeman, R. and H. Medoff ( 1984) What Do Unions Do?New York : Basic Books.
33.
Fulmer, W. ( 1982) Union Organizing: Management and Labor Conflict . New York: Praeger.
34.
Gall, G. ( 1993) ‘Trade Union Strikes for Union Recognition, 1980-1990’, unpublished paper, University of Stirling .
35.
Gall, G. ( 2003) ‘Introduction’, pp. 1-18 in G. Gall (ed.) Union Organising: Campaigning for Labour Union Recognition. London: Routledge.
36.
Gall, G. ( 2004a) ‘Trade Union Recognition in Britain, 1995-2002: Turning a Corner?’, Industrial Relations Journal35(3): 249-70.
37.
Gall, G. ( 2004b) ‘British Employer Resistance to Trade Union Recognition’ , Human Resource Management Journal14(2): 36-53.
38.
Gall, G. ( 2007) ‘Trade Union Recognition in Britain: A Crisis of Union Capacity?’, Economic and Industrial Democracy28(1): 83-114.
39.
Gall, G. and S. McKay ( 1994) ‘Trade Union Derecognition in Britain 1988-1994’ , British Journal of Industrial Relations32(3): 433-48.
40.
Gould, W. ( 1994) Agenda for Reform: The Future of Employment Relationships and the Law. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
41.
Gross, J. ( 1974) The Making of the National Labor Relations Board: A Study in Economics, Politics, and the Law (Volume 1, 1933-1937). Albany: State University of New York Press .
42.
Gross, J. ( 1981) The Reshaping of the National Labor Relations Board: National Labor Policy in Transition, 1937-1947. Albany : State University of New York Press.
43.
Gross, J. ( 1985) ‘Conflicting Statutory Purposes: Another Look at Fifty Years of NLRB Law Making’, Industrial and Labor Relations Review39(1): 7-18.
44.
Gross, J. ( 1995) Broken Promise: The Subversion of US Labor Relations Policy, 1947-1994. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
45.
Gunnigle, P., S. MacCurtain and M. Morley ( 2001) ‘Dismantling Pluralism; Industrial Relations in Irish Greenfield Sites’, Personnel Review30(3): 263-29.
46.
Gunnigle, P., M. O’Sullivan and M. Kinsella ( 2002) ‘Organised Labour in the New Economy; Labour Unions and Public Policy in the Republic of Ireland’, pp. 222-58 in T. Turner and D. D’Art (eds) Irish Employment Relations and the New Economy . Dublin : Blackhall.
47.
Gunnigle, P., D. Collings and M.J. Morley ( 2006) ‘Accommodating Global Capitalism? State Policy and Industrial Relations in American MNCs in Ireland’, pp. 86-108 in A. Ferner, J. Quintanilla and C. Sanchez-Runde (eds) Multinationals and the Construction of Transnational Practices: Convergence and Diversity in the Global Economy. Basingstoke: Palgrave.
48.
Heery, E. ( 2000) ‘New Unionism Research Project’, Bulletin No. 8, Cardiff University .
49.
Heery, E. and M. Simms ( 2003) Bargain or Bust? Employer Responses to Union Organising . London: TUC.
50.
Heery, E. and M. Simms ( 2006) ‘Union Organising under Certification Law in Britain’ , pp. 44-63 in G. Gall (ed.) Union Recognition: Organising and Bargaining Outcomes. London: Routledge.
51.
Heery, E., M. Simms, D. Simpson, R. Delbridge and J. Salmon ( 2000a). ‘Organising Unionism Comes to Britain’ , Employee Relations22(1): 38-57.
52.
Jordan, L. and B. Bruno ( 2006) ‘Does the Organising Means Determine the Bargaining Ends?’, pp. 181-97 in G. Gall (ed.) Union Recognition: Organising and Bargaining Outcomes. London: Routledge.
53.
Keoller, C. ( 1992) ‘Employer Unfair Labor Practices and Union Organizing Activity: A Simultaneous Equation Model’, Journal of Labor Research13(2): 173-87.
54.
Kersley, B., C. Alpin, J. Forth, A. Bryson, H. Bewley, G. Dix and S. Oxenbridge ( 2006) Inside the Workplace: Findings from the 2004 Workplace Employment Relations Survey. London: Routledge.
55.
Klein, J. and E. Wanger ( 1986) ‘The Legal Setting for the Emergence of the Union Avoidance Strategy’, pp. 75-88 in T. Kochan (ed.) Challenges and Choices Facing American Labor. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press .
56.
Kleiner, M. ( 1984) ‘Unionism and Employer Discrimination: Analysis of 8(a)(3) Violations’, Industrial Relations23(2): 234-43.
57.
Kleiner, M. ( 2001) ‘Intensity of Management Resistance: Understanding the Decline of Unionization in the Private Sector’, Journal of Labor Research22(3): 519-40.
58.
Kochan, T. ( 1980) Collective Bargaining and Industrial Relations . Homewood, IL: Richard Irwin .
59.
Kochan, T., H. Katz and T. McKersie ( 1984) The Transformation of American Industrial Relations . New York: Basic Books.
60.
Labour Court (1992-2007) Annual Reports. Dublin: Labour Court ; at: www.labourcourt.ie
61.
Lipset, S. and I. Katchanovski ( 2001) ‘The Future of Private Sector Unions in the US’ , Journal of Labor Research22(2): 229-44.
62.
Logan, J. ( 2001) ‘Is Statutory Recognition Bad News for British Unions? Evidence for the History of North American Industrial Relations’ , Historical Studies in Industrial Relations11: 63-107.
63.
Logan, J. ( 2002) ‘Consultants, Lawyers and the "Union Free" Movement in the USA since the 1970s’, Industrial Relations Journal33(3): 197-214.
64.
McCammon, H. ( 2001) ‘Labor’s Legal Mobilization: Why and When Do Worker File Unfair Labor Practices?’, Work and Occupations28(2): 143-75.
65.
McDonald, C. ( 1986) ‘Discussion Part 1’, pp. 45-64 in T. Kochan (ed.) Challenges and Choices Facing American Labor . Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
66.
McGovern, P. ( 1989) ‘Union Recognition and Union Avoidance in the 1980s’ , pp. 61-72 in T. Murphy (ed.) Industrial Relations in Ireland: Contemporary Trends and Developments. Dublin: University College Dublin.
67.
Mercer, S. and R. Notley ( 2008) Trade Union Membership 2007. London : Department of Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform/National Statistics.
68.
Meyer, D. and W. Cooke ( 1993) ‘US Labour Relations in Transition: Emerging Strategies and Company Performance’, British Journal of Industrial Relations31(4): 531-52.
69.
Millward, N., A. Bryson and J. Forth ( 2000) All Change at Work? British Employment Relations 1980-1998, as Portrayed by the Workplace Industrial Relations Survey Series. London: Routledge.
70.
Moody, K. ( 1986) An Injury to All: The Decline of American Unionism . London: Verso.
71.
Moody, K. ( 2007) US Labor in Trouble and Transition: The Failure of Reform from Above, the Promise of Revival from Below. London: Verso.
72.
Moore, S. ( 2004) ‘Union Mobilization and Employer Counter-Mobilization in the Statutory Recognition Process’, pp. 7-31 in J. Kelly and P. Willman (eds) Union Organization and Activity. London: Routledge.
73.
Pavy, G. ( 1994) ‘Winning NLRB Elections and Establishing Collective Bargaining Relationships’, pp. 110-21 in S. Friedman, R. Hurd, R. Oswald and R. Seeber (eds) Restoring the Promise of American Labor Law. Ithaca, NY : ILR Press.
74.
Renshaw, P. ( 1991) American Labour and Consensus Capitalism 1935-1990 . Basingstoke: Macmillan.
75.
Roche, W. ( 1998) ‘The Problem of Trade Union Recognition: Endangering Social Consensus in Ireland?’, European Industrial Relations Observatory (EIRO), Eironline (IE9803114F) , Dublin.
76.
Roche, W. ( 2001) ‘Accounting for the Trend in Labour Union Recognition in Ireland’, Industrial Relations Journal32(1): 37-54.
77.
Roomkin, M. ( 1981) ‘A Quantitative Study of Unfair Labour Practice Cases’, Industrial and Labor Relations Review34(2): 245-56.
78.
Seeber, R. and W. Cooke ( 1983) ‘The Decline in Union Success in NLRB Representation Elections’, Industrial Relations22(1): 34-44.
79.
Smith, P. and G. Morton ( 2001) ‘New Labour’s Reform of Britain’s Employment Law: The Devil is Not Only in the Detail But in the Values and Policy Too’ , British Journal of Industrial Relations39(1): 119-38.
80.
Snape, E. ( 1994) ‘Union Organizing in Britain: The Views of Local Full-Time Officials’Employee Relations16(8): 48-62.
81.
Swenson, P. ( 2002) Capitalists against Markets: The Making of Labor Markets and Welfare States in the United States and Sweden. New York: Oxford University Press.
82.
Swenson, P. ( 2004) ‘Varieties of Capitalist Interests: Power, Institutions, and the Regulatory Welfare State in the United States and Sweden’ , Studies in American Political Development18(1): 1-29.
83.
Towers, B. ( 1999) ‘. . . The Most Lightly Regulated Labour Market . . . Britain’s Third Statutory Union Recognition Procedure’, Industrial Relations Journal30(2): 82-95.
84.
Turner, T., D. D’Art and P. Gunnigle ( 1997) ‘Pluralism in Retreat? A Comparison of Irish and Multinational Manufacturing Companies’, International Journal of Human Resource Management8(6): 835-40.
85.
Zeiger, R. ( 1997) The CIO, 1935-1955. Chapel Hill : University of North Carolina Press.
