While much of the literature on teamworking has become focused on employer-driven
design of work teams, this article casts a critical eye on employee-driven
workgroups through the examination of a selfselected and autonomous employee group.
The evidence from this case study suggests that groupworking can result in a quest
for homogenization, and in strong informal controls on members’
behaviours, where these controls operate through covert confiict expressions,
mediated by the work environment. The evidence to emerge indicates that some of the
suggested positive impacts on employees of groupworking may be simply surface
constructs, while covert, suppressed confiicts persist. The unique contribution of
this study is the modelling of a lexicon of confiict under concertive control
conditions and the integration of social identity theory into a groupwork framework.
Bacon, N.
and
P. Blyton
(2000)
‘High Road and Low Road Teamworking: Perceptions of Management
Rationales and Organisational and Human Resource Outcomes’
, Human Relations53(11):
1425–1458
.
2.
Barker, J.R.
(1993)
‘Tightening the Iron Cage: Concertive Control in Self-Managing Teams’
, Administrative Science Quarterly38(3):
408–437
.
3.
Barker, J.R.
and
P.K. Tompkins
(1994)
‘Identification in the Self-Managing Organization:
Characteristics of Targets and Tenure’
, Human Communication Research21:
223–240
.
Blasi, J.
,
M. Conte
and
D. Kruse
(1996)
‘Employee Stock Ownership and Corporate Performance among Public Companies’
, Industrial and Labour Relations Review50(1):
60–79
.
6.
Bradley, K.
and
A. Gelb
(1983) Worker Capitalism: The New Industrial Relations.
London. Heinemann
.
7.
Cornforth, C.
,
A. Thomas
,
J. Lewis
and
R. Spear
(1988) Developing Successful Worker Cooperatives.
London: Sage
.
8.
Cressey, P.
and
R. Williams
(1990) Participation in Change: New Technology and the Role
of Employee Involvement.
Dublin: European Foundation for the Improvement
in Living and Working Conditions
.
9.
Findlay, P.
,
A. McKinlay
,
A. Marks
and
P. Thompson
(2000)
‘In Search of Perfect People: Teamwork and Team Players in the
Scottish Spirits Industry’
, Human Relations53(12):
1549–1574
.
10.
Forsyth, D.R.
(1990) Group Dynamics.
Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole
.
11.
Gamson, Z.
and
H. Levine
(1984) ‘Obstacles to the Survival of Democratic
Workplaces’, in
M. Mellor
,
J. Hannah
and
J. Stirling
(eds) Worker Cooperatives in Theory and Practice.
Milton Keynes: Open University Press
.
12.
Garavan, T.
and
M. Morley
(1992) ‘Organisational Change and Development:
Introducing Flexible Working Groups in a High Technology
Environment’, in
D. Winstanley
and
J. Woodhall
(eds) Case Studies in Personnel.
IPM
, pp. 162–185.
13.
Giddens, A.
(1993) New Rules of Sociological Method: A Positive Critique
of Interpretative Sociologies.
Oxford: Polity Press
.
14.
Knights, D.
and
D. McCabe
(2000)
‘Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered: The Meaning and Experience
of Teamworking for Employees in an Automobile Company’
, Human Relations53(11):
1481–1517
.
15.
Levine, D.I.
(1995) Reinventing the Workplace: How Business and Employees
Can Both Win.
Washington, DC: Brookings Institution
.
16.
McNabb, R.
and
K. Whitfield
(1998)
‘The Impact of Financial Participation and Employee Involvement
on Financial Performance’
, Scottish Journal of Political Economy45(2):
171–187
.
17.
Marques, J.M.
,
V.Y. Yzerbyt
and
J.P. Leyens
(1988)
‘The Black Sheep Effect: Extremity of Judgements towards Ingroup
Members as a Function of Group Identification’
, European Journal of Social Psychology18(1):
1–16
.
18.
Mellor, M.
,
J. Hannah
and
J. Stirling
(1988) Worker Cooperatives in Theory and Practice.
Milton Keynes: Open University Press
.
19.
Mitchell, J.C.
, ed. (1969) Social Networks in Urban Situations: Analysis of
Personal Relationships in Central African Towns.
Manchester: Manchester University Press
.
20.
Mueller, F.
,
S. Procter
and
D. Buchanan
(2000)
‘Teamworking in its Context(s): Antecedents, Nature and Dimensions’
, Human Relations53(11):
1387–1424
.
21.
Oakland, J.C.
(1996) Total Quality Management: A Practical Approach.
Bradford: European Centre For Total Quality
Management, University of Bradford Management Centre
.
22.
Paton, R.
(1978) ‘Some Problems of Co-operative
Organisation’, Cooperatives Research Unit Monograph No. 3.
Milton Keynes: Open University Press
.
23.
Paton, R.
(1989) Reluctant Entrepreneurs.
Milton Keynes: Open University Press
.
24.
Peters, T.J.
and
R.H. Waterman
(1982) In Search of Excellence.
New York: Harper and Row
.
25.
Ramsay, H.
,
S. Parry
,
A. Paton
and
J. Hyman
(1998)
‘The Big Sell: Employee Participation and Gender in Retail’
, paper presented for the 14th World Congress of
Sociology, 26 July–1 August.
26.
Scott, J.
(1991) Social Network Analysis: A Handbook.
London: Sage
.
27.
Sewell, G.
(1998)
‘The Discipline of Teams: The Control of Team-Based Industrial
Work through Electronic and Peer Surveillance’
, Administrative Science Quarterly43(2):
397–428
.
28.
Sharpe, D.R.
(2002)
‘Teamworking and Managerial Control within a Japanese
Manufacturing Subsidiary in the UK’
, Personnel Review31(3):
267–282
.
29.
Sinclair, A.
(1992)
‘The Tyranny of a Team Ideology’
, Organization Studies13(4):
611–626
.
30.
Sprigg, C.
,
P. Jackson
and
S. Parker
(2000)
‘Production Teamworking: The Importance of Interdependence and
Autonomy for Employee Strain and Satisfaction’
, Human Relations53(11):
1519–1543
.
31.
Tajfel, H.
(1982)
‘Social Psychology of Intergroup Relations’
, Annual Review of Psychology33:
1–39
.
32.
Thompson, P.
and
T. Wallace
(1996)
‘Redesigning Production through Teamworking: Case Studies from
the Volvo Truck Corporation’
, International Journal of Operations and Production Management16(2):
103–116
.
33.
Thornley, J.
(1981) Workers Co-operatives: Jobs and Dreams.
London: Heinemann
.
34.
Tynan, E.
(1980) Sunderlandia: Cooperative Research Unit Case Study
No.3.
Milton Keynes: Open University Press
.
