Internal long-wave radiation exchange in buildings: Comparison of calculation methods: I Review of algorithms

Abstract

The pair of papers of which this is the first presents some of the commonest methods for calculating long-wave radiation heat exchange in a room. Paper I covers the theory behind the various methods. These vary in complexity from accurate calculation of view factors with multiple inter-reflections between surfaces to simple, non-geometric methods using fixed heat transfer coefficients. Paper II presents a set of tests which were developed to allow a comparison of the performance of these algorithms with an analytically exact method. The results of these tests are shown, the main conclusion being that in many cases it is possible to use a non-geometric model without significant loss of accuracy. A more accurate method is required in cases of low surface emissivity or large temperature differences between surfaces. The importance of internal long-wave radiation to the overall energy balance of typical houses was tested, and the results presented in Paper II. If no account is taken of long-wave exchange (disabling exchanges by setting all internal emissivities to zero), predicted energy requirements changed by up to -11% in the type of house and heating system tested: greater changes could arise in different house types or in those with a larger radiant output from the heating system. The results also showed the importance of modelling long-wave exchange to and from windows explicitly.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bloomfield D.

Appraisal techniques for methods of calculating thermal performance of buildings Building

Serv. Eng. Res. Technol. 6(1) 13-20 (1985)

Hottel H.C. Radiant Heat Transmission in Heat Transmission (ed. W H McAdams ) 3rd edn ch 4, ( New York: McGraw-Hill) (1954)

Buchberg H. Sensitivity of room thermal response to inside radiation exchange and surface conductance Building Sci. 6 133-149 (1971)

Oppenheim A.K.

Radiation analysis by the network method

Trans. Amer. Soc. Mech. Eng. 78(5) 725-735 (1956)

Hottel H.C. and Sarofim A.F. Radiative Transfer (New York:McGraw-Hill ) (1967)

Ozisik M.N. Radiative Transfer (New York: John Wiley & Sons) (1973)

Siegel R. and Howell J.R. Thermal Radiation Heat Transfer (New York: McGraw-Hill) (1981)

Eckert E R G and Drake R.M. Heat and Mass Transfer ( New York: McGraw-Hill) (1959)

Clarke J.A. ESP System Documentation Set ABACUS Publication, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow (1982)

10.

Clarke J.A. and McLean D. ESP, A Building and Plant Energy Simulation System, Version 6 Release 2 ABACUS Publication, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow (1987)

11.

Clarke J.A. Energy Simulation in Building Design (Bristol/ Boston: Adam Hilger) (1985)

12.

Kusuda T. NBSLD, The Computer Program for Heating and Cooling Loads in Buildings NBS Building Science Series 69 National Bureau of Standards, USA ( 1976)

13.

Arumi-Noe F. The DEROB System: Volume II Explanatory Notes and Theory Numerical Simulation Laboratory, School of Architecture, University of Texas , Austin (1979)

14.

Numan M.Y. and Moore G.R. Form Factors: The problem of partial obstruction Working Paper, Martin Centre for Architectural and Urban Studies, Cambridge, UK (1982)

15.

Walton G.N.

A new algorithm for radiant interchange in room loads calculations

ASHRAE Trans. 86(2) 190-208 (1980)

16.

Davies M.G.

Optimal designs for star circuits for radiant exchange in a room

Building Environment 18(1/2) 19-37 (1983)

17.

Stefanizzi P. , Wilson A. and Pinney A.

Internal long-wave radiation in buildings: Comparison of calculation methods: II Testing of algorithms

Building Serv. Eng. Res. Technol. 11(3) 87-96 (1990)

18.

CIBSE Guide Section A5 Thermal Response of Buildings (London Chartered Institution of Building Services Engineers) (1986)