Seasonal input–output efficiencies of two heating plants with condensing boilers in cold climate institutional buildings (3300 m2 school and 12,000 m2 university building) were evaluated. Plant efficiency remained about the same or declined with load, contrary to typical lab boiler ratings, which show efficiency increasing at lower loads. These results occurred when the boilers were operated with return water temperatures largely in the condensing range. Heating plant load was often 25% or less of the rated load of a single boiler, resulting in heating plant input–output efficiencies well below rated boiler efficiencies.
Practical application: In-situ boiler plant input–output efficiencies can differ widely from manufacturer's boiler efficiency curves. For applications such as simulation for energy-efficient design, effective decision-making depends on accurately estimating real-world performance.
HewettMJBixbyDCNelsonRM. New software for calculating seasonal efficiency for boilers. ASHRAE J2009; 46: 55–56.
2.
NRCan. Commercial and Institutional Building Energy Use Survey 2000 – Detailed statistical report 2002, Cat. No. M144-4/2000E, . Ottawa: Natural Resources Canada, 2002.
3.
ASHRAE. ASHRAE 90.1-2010 Energy standard for buildings except low-rise residential buildings, . Atlanta: ASHRAE, 2010.
4.
BelisoAHuestisED'AlboraM. Boiler research project – ASHRAE Standard 155P – Phase II, ET Project Number ET11PGE5272, . San Ramon, CA: Pacific Gas and Electric, 2012.
5.
LandryRWMaddoxDEBohacDL. Seasonal efficiency and off-cycle flue loss measurements of two boilers. ASHRAE Trans1993; 99: 440–454.
6.
LobensteinMSLandryRWBohacDL. Application of short-term diagnostic methods for measuring commercial boiler losses, 1994. ASHRAE Trans1994; 100: 876–890.
7.
TorcelliniPADeruMGriffithB. Lessons learned from field evaluation of six high-performance buildings, Golden, CO: National Renewable Energy Laboratory, 2006. . NREL Technical Report TP-550-37542.
8.
BordassBCohenRStandevenM. Assessing building performance in use 3: energy performance of the Probe buildings. Building Res Inform2001; 29: 114–128.
9.
UnderwoodCP. Evaluation of condensing boiler performance and space heating in a sheltered housing scheme. Building Services Engg Res Technol1992; 13: 155–161.
10.
HallerMYPaavilainenJKonersmannL. A unified model for the simulation of oil, gas and biomass space heating boilers for energy estimating purposes. Part II: Parameterization and comparison with measurements. J Build Performance Simul2011; 4: 19–36.
11.
ButcherTA. Performance of integrated hydronic systems, Upton, NY: Brookhaven National Laboratory, 2007. . BNL Report BNL-79814-IR.
12.
Orr G, Lelyveld T and Burton S. Final report: in-situ monitoring of efficiencies of condensing boilers and use of secondary heating. Contract number GaC3563. London, UK: Energy Saving Trust.
13.
UyttenbroeckJ. Seasonal efficiency of a heating plant. In: New energy conservation technologies and their commercialization: proceedings of an international conference1981; Vol. 1Berlin: Springer-Verlag, pp. 329–334.
14.
Jensen B and Sorensen BR. Energy flexible heating systems - integration of heating stations in buildings. In: proc. 6th International symposium on heating, ventilation and airconditioning, Nanjing, China, 2009.
15.
JensenBSorensenBRProsjekttittel. Energifleksible varmesystemer - Integrering av varmesentraler (Energy flexible heating systems - integration of heating stations), Narvik, Norway: Narvik University College, 2004. . Report for NT-programmet (in Norwegian).
16.
KennaEBannisterP. Simple, fully featured boiler loop modelling. In: Bsim 2009: proceedings of the 2009 international building performance simulation association conference, Glasgow: Springer-Verlag, 2009, pp. 428–433. http://www.ibpsa.org/proceedings/BS2009/BS09_0428_433.pdf (accessed 2 February 2014).
17.
Ratkovich B, Martin T, Sawatzky R, et al. Measurement and verification of hot water boiler plant thermal efficiency in real operating conditions, In: Proc. 19th national conference on building commissioning, 10–12 August 2011, Cincinnati, USA, Building Commissioning Association, Beaverton, OR, USA.
18.
CholewaTSiuta-OlchaASkwarczyńskiMA. Experimental evaluation of three heating systems commonly used in the residential sector. Energy Building2011; 43: 2140–2144.
19.
GillZMTierneyMJPeggIM. Measured energy and water performance of an aspiring low energy/carbon affordable housing site in the UK. Energy Building2011; 43: 117–125.
20.
ArenaLBButcherTAZoellerWA. In-field performance of condensing boilers. ASHRAE Trans2012; 118: 359–366.
21.
LazzarinRM. Condensing boilers in buildings and plants refurbishment. Energy Building2012; 47: 61–67.
22.
Parker SA and Blanchard J. Condensing boiler assessment: Peachtree Summit Federal Building Atlanta, Georgia, 2012, www.gsa.gov/portal/getMediaData?mediaId=163539 (accessed 15 July 2013).
23.
FracasteroGVLybergMB. International Energy Agency – Energy Conservation in Buildings and Community Systems Programme Annex III. Guiding principles concerning design of experiments, instrumentation and measuring techniques – section f, Stockholm, Sweden: Swedish Council for Building Research, 1983. . Report D1.
CIBSE. Metering energy use in new non-domestic buildings. General Information Leaflet 65. London, UK: Chartered Institute of Building Services Engineers, undated.
27.
PeetersLVan der VekenJHensH. Control of heating systems in residential buildings: Current practice. Energy Building2008; 40: 1446–1455.
28.
BoyensACornetMEppeJP. Audit and monitoring of a large residential building in Liège. In: Proceedings of Lausanne ICEBEM1987; Vol. 87: 427–434.
FiskWJMendellMJDaviesM. Demand controlled ventilation and classroom ventilation, LBNL-6258E, Oakland, CA: Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, 2012.
31.
NewshamGRManciniSBirtBJ. Do LEED-certified buildings save energy? Yes, but…. Energy Building2009; 41: 897–905.
32.
ASHRAE. HVAC systems and equipment, Atlanta, USA: ASHRAE, 2012.
33.
ASME. ASME PTC 4-2008 fired steam generators performance test codes, . New York, NY: American Society of Mecanical Engineers, 2008.
34.
Code of Federal Regulations, Title 10 Part 430 – energy conservation program for consumer products Subpart B – Test Procedures, . Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office, 2013.
35.
Code of Federal Regulations, Title 10, Part 431 – energy efficiency program for certain commercial and industrial equipment, Subpart E – Commercial Packaged Boilers, . Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office, 2013.
36.
De PaepeMT'JoenCHuisseuneH. Comparison of different testing methods for gas fired domestic boiler efficiency determination. Appl Thermal Engg2012; 50: 275–281.
37.
Hydronics Institute Division. BTS-2000 testing standard method to determine efficiency of commercial. Heating boilers, 2nd edn. Arlington, VA: Air-Conditioning, Heating, and Refrigeration Institute, 2007.
38.
HM Government. Non-domestic building services compliance guide, London: UK RIBA Bookshop, 2010. . Stock Code 72348.
