Differences in Text Comprehension Amongst 7-8-Year-Old Children

Abstract

The aim of this research was to compare the effectiveness of the three receptive language modes of oral reading, silent reading and listening, for comprehension of short pieces of text. Thirty-six children were used in the study, aged between 7:06 and 8:06 years old.

Three parallel passages at two levels of the Neale Analysis of Reading Ability (NARA) were used as texts. The order of presentation of each mode, and the particular text used for each mode, were both varied as part of the design. A complex Analysis of Variance design was used, incorporating the following independent variables:

(a) Reading Attainment of children;

(b) Sex of children;

(d) Mode of presentation of text;

(e) Form of text.

The dependent variable was NARA comprehension scores. Interaction effects were noted between certain combinations of the Independent Variables of Attainment, Sex, Form and Order. The Level 1 reading task did not discriminate effectively between the different attainment groups. As a consequence of this, the attitude of certain groups of children to the task seemed to affect their performance more than did their level of attainment. At both Levels 1 and 2 of the NARA the results demonstrated significant differences between the mode groups, with the silent reading group performing more poorly than either the oral reading or listening groups. This was thought to be because:

(a) The subjects were free to establish meaning whilst listening, and this assisted comprehension.

(b) The subjects' act of verbalization in the oral reading mode, helped to establish meaning.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Al-Dahiry, Saleem, A. (1981) 'A Comparison of Oral Reading, Silent Reading and Listening Comprehension Amongst 3rd Graders', unpublished doctorate dissertation, Kansas State University. Dissertation Abstracts International: 2031-A.

Bank, B.J. (1980) 'Sex Roles, Classroom Instruction and Reading Achievement', Journal of Educational Psychology 72(2):119-132.

Bormuth, J.R. (1970) 'Children's Comprehension of Between and Within Sentence Syntactic Structures', Journal of Educational Psychology 61(5):349-357.

Brown, D.A. (1984) Reading Diagnosis and Remediation. New Jersey: Prentice Hall.

Clark, M.L. (1973) The Hierarchical Structure of Comprehension Skills. Australian Council for Educational Research Series, No. 94.

Clay, M. (1982) Reading-the Patterning of Complex Behaviour. London: Heinemann Educational.

Curtis, M.E. (1980) 'Development of Components of Reading Skill', Journal of Educational Psychology 72(5):656-669.

Department of Education and Science (1981,1982) Assessment of Performance Unit Report. Language Performance in Schools: Primary Survey Report. London: HMSO.

Goodman, K.S. (1970) 'Behind the Eye: What Happens in Reading', in Reading: Process and Program. Urbana, IL: National Council for the Teaching of English.

10.

Guthrie, J.T. (1971) Cognition, Curriculum and Comprehension. Newark, Del: International Reading Association.

11.

Hunter-Grundin, E. and Grundin, H.U. (eds) (1978) Reading: Implementing the Bullock Report. London: WLE.

12.

Jenkinson, M. (1978) 'Ways of teaching', in L.J. Chapman and P. Czerniewska (eds) Reading: from Process to Practice. London and Henley: Routledge and Kegan Paul in association with The Open University Press.

13.

Kintsch, W. and Kozminsky, E. (1977) 'Summarising Stories After Reading and Listening', Journal of Educational Psychology 69(5):491-499.

14.

Kirkham, S. (1977) 'A Comparison of Silent Reading, Oral Reading, and Listening Comprehension of Students in Grades 3, 6, 9 and 12', Dissertation Abstracts International: p.4458-A, unpublished doctorate dissertation, University of Wisconsin.

15.

Lewis, D.G. (1968) Experimental Design in Education. London: University of London Press.

16.

Mosenthal, P. (1976) 'Psycholinguistic Properties of Aural and Visual Comprehension as Determined by Children's Abilities to Comprehend Syllogisms', Reading Research Quarterly xii:55-92.

17.

Neville, M.H. and Pugh, A.K. (1976) 'Context in Reading and Listening: Variations in Approach to Cloze Tasks', Reading Research Quarterly xii:13-31.

18.

Osgood, C.E. (1957) 'A Behavioristic Analysis', in C.E. Osgood (ed.) Contemporary Approaches to Cognition. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

19.

Pugh, A.J. (1978) Silent Reading. London: Heinemann Educational.

20.

Pumfrey, P.D. and Lee, J. (1982) 'Cultural Group, Reading Attainment and Dialect Interference', Journal of Research in Reading 5(2):133-146.

21.

Rosenshine, B.V. (1980) 'Skill Hierarchies in Reading Comprehension', in R.J. Spiro , B.C. Bruce and W.F. Bremer (eds) Theoretical Issues in Reading Comprehension. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.

22.

Rowell, E.M. (1976) 'Do Elementary Students Read Better Orally or Silently?' Reading Teacher 29(4):367-370.

23.

Ruddell, R.B. (1978) 'Language Acquisition and the Reading Process', in L.J. Chapman and P. Czerniewska (eds) Reading: from Process to Practice. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul in association with The Open University Press.

24.

Rude, R.T. and Oehlkers, W.J. (1984) Helping Students with Reading Problems. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

25.

Smiley, S.S. et al. (1977) 'Recall of Thematically Relevant Material by Adolescent and Poor Readers, as a Function of Oral Versus Written Presentation', Journal of Educational Psychology 69:381-387.

26.

Smith, W.L. (1974) 'Syntactic Recoding of Passages Written at Three Levels of Complexity', Journal of Experimental Education 43(2):66-72.

27.

Southgate-Booth, V. , Arnold, H. and Johnson, S. (1981) Extending Beginning Reading. London: Heinemann Educational.

28.

Wilkinson, A.C. (1980) 'Children's Understanding in Reading and Listening', Journal of Educational Psychology 72(4):561-561.

29.

Winer, B.J. (1962) Statistical Principles in Experimental Design. New York: McGraw Hill.