Advantages of and developments in dual bluff-body vortex flowmeters

Abstract

The paper begins by reviewing the main performance characteristics of vortex flowmeters - eg, signal stength, signal-to-noise ratio, frequency, repeatability, meter factor and blockage ratio. It then develops a performance equation which calculates the total time required to capture sufficient cycles to achieve a given overall repeatability. From this equation we see that for a typical single bluff-body vortex meter the time required to achieve an overall repeatability of 0.02% is 387min. This underlines the point that single bluff-body meters are in general not very useful for fiscal metering or custody-transfer applications.

The paper then reviews the general principles of vortex shedding from two bluff bodies in tandem, explaining that there are two distinct flow regimes, depending on whether the bluff-body separation is less than, or greater than, a critical value. A summary of results is presented for initial tests on 15 combinations of two rectangular bluff bodies in tandem, together with three single bluff bodies for comparison. These initial tests were carried out in a 300 mm diameter wind tunnel at a free-stream velocity of 6.5 mls and a turbulence intensity of 0.5%.

Seven combinations with optimum separations were then tested over a free-stream velocity range between 0.6 and 13.0 mls and at three turbulence levels. Detailed results showing the variation in RMS vortex velocity, signal-to-noise ratio, meter factor and percentage frequency standard deviation with free-stream velocity are presented. Certain of these combinations give a far more regular and repeatable vortex signal than single bluff bodies; the time required to achieve an overall repeatability of 0.02% is as low as 33 min.

All of the above dual combinations have a small separation, so that vortex shedding takes place behind the downstream bluff body only. Detailed maps of the vortex field around certain dual combinations are presented which show that, in certain cases, the oscillations of boundary layers in the gap are strongly correlated with the oscillations of boundary layers moving around the bluff bodies. Thus the vortex shedding from the downstream bluff body is reinforced by oscillating boundary layers moving through the gap.

Keywords

Vortex flowmeter single bluff body dual bluff body performance equation performance data

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Cousins, T. 1975. 'The performance and design of vortex meters'. Proc Int Conf on Flow Measurement in the mid-1970s, National Engineering Laboratory.

Cousins, T. Foster, S.A. and Johnson, P.A. 1973. 'A linear and accurate flowmeter using vortex shedding ', (Kent Instruments), Symposium on Power Fluidics for Process Control, Guildford .

Dewey, Jr et al. 1982. Vortex shedding flowmeter having two bluff bodies, US Patent 4,350,047, September.

Hayward, A.T.J. and Jelffs, P.A.M. 1986. 'The potential of the vortex-shedding meter as a custody-transfer meter for liquids', Flow measurement in the mid-'80s , East Kilbride.

Herzl et al. 1984. Dual-body vortex-shedding flowmeter, US Patent 4,445,388, May.

Igarishi, T. 1981. 'Characteristics of the flow around two circular cylinders arranged in tandem', Bulletin of the JSME, 24, 323-331.

Igarishi, T. 1985. 'Fluid flow around a bluff body used for a Karman vortex flowmeter', First Int Conf on fluid control and measurement, Tokyo.

Institute of Petroleum. 1987. Petroleum Measurement Paper No 1.

Nichols, A.R. 1988. Vortex shedding from two rectangular bluff bodies in tandem . PhD thesis, Teesside Polytechnic (unpublished).

10.

Nichols, A.R. and Bentley, J.P. 1987a. 'A performance evaluation of a dual cylinder vortex flowmeter ', Test and Transducer Conference, Wembley.

11.

Nichols, A.R. and Bentley, J.P. 1987b. 'A performance evaluation of an experimental dual bluff body vortex flowmeter', Industrial Flow Measurement Onshore and Offshore, London.

12.

Nichols, A.R. , Bentley, J.P. et al. 1986. 'Experimental investigation of vortex shedding from two rectangular bluff bodies in tandem', Industrial Flow Measurements in the mid-'80s, East Kilbride .

13.

Noor-E-Alan, A. 1984. 'The development of a flow meter using the vortex shedding principle' (Kent Industrial Measurements Ltd), I Chem E symposium on the selection and use of modern measuring instruments, Manchester.

14.

Robinson, E.R. 1985. 'Simulation studies of pulse interpolation methods', Proc Int Conf on the metering of petroleum and its products, London.

15.

Zdravkovich, M.M. 1977. 'Review of flow interference between two circular cylinders in various arrangements', Trans ASME Fluids Engng , December, 618-633.