Dynamic model development and control of an existing operating industrial continuous bulk free radical styrene polymerization process are carried out to evaluate the performance of auto-refrigerated CSTRs (continuous stirred tank reactors). One of the most difficult tasks in polymerization processes is to control the high viscosity reactor contents and heat removal. In this study, temperature control of an auto-refrigerated CSTR is carried out using an alternative control scheme which makes use of a vacuum system connected to the condenser and has not been addressed in the literature (i.e. to the best of our knowledge). The developed model is then verified using some experimental data of the real operating plant. To show the heat removal potential of this control scheme, a common control strategy used in some previous studies is also simulated. Simulation results show a faster dynamics and superior performance of the first control scheme which is already implemented in our operating plant. Besides, a nonlinear model predictive control (NMPC) is developed for the polymerization process under study to provide a better temperature control while satisfying the input/output and the heat exchanger capacity constraints on the heat removal. Then, a comparison has been also made with the conventional proportional-integral (PI) controller utilizing some common tuning rules. Some robustness and stability analyses of the control schemes investigated are also provided through some simulations. Simulation results clearly show the superiority of the NMPC strategy from all aspects.
AbbasiMShamiriAHussainM (2019) A review on modeling and control of olefin polymerization in fluidized-bed reactors. Reviews in Chemical Engineering35(3): 311–333.
2.
AlipoorMZeinaliMYazdiHS (2009) Fuzzy temperature control in a batch polymerization reactor using anfis method. International Journal of Engineering and Technology1(1): 1793–8236.
3.
AlmeidaAWadaKSecchiA (2008) Simulation of styrene polymerization reactors: Kinetic and thermodynamic modeling. Brazilian Journal of Chemical Engineering25(2): 337–349.
4.
AltıntenAKetevanlioğluFErdoğanS, et al. (2008) Self-tuning PID control of jacketed batch polystyrene reactor using genetic algorithm. Chemical Engineering Journal138(1–3): 490–497.
5.
AroraSGesthuisenREngellS (2007) Model based operation of emulsion polymerization reactors with evaporative cooling: Application to vinyl acetate homopolymerization. Computers & Chemical Engineering31(5–6): 552–564.
6.
AströmKHägglundT (2006) Advanced PID Control. Research Triangle Park, NC: ISA-The Instrumentation, Systems and Automation Society.
7.
BartonJNolanP (1989) Incidents in the chemical industry due to thermal runaway chemical reactions. Hazards X: Process Safety in Fine and Speciality Chemical Plants115: 3–18.
8.
BeckmanJ (1973) Design of large polymerization reactors. PlatzerNorbert A. J. (Eds.), polymerization kinetics and technology. Chap 3, pp. 37–50. Advances in Chemistry Series: 128.
9.
BradfordEImslandL (2019) Economic stochastic nonlinear model predictive control of a semi-batch polymerization reaction. IFAC-PapersOnLine52(1): 667–672.
10.
BradfordERebleMImslandL (2019) Output feedback stochastic nonlinear model predictive control of a polymerization batch process. In: 2019 18th European Control Conference (ECC), June 25–28. pp. 3144–3151. Naples, Italy, IEEE, New York, U.S.
11.
ByrdRHHribarMENocedalJ (1999) An interior point algorithm for large-scale nonlinear programming. SIAM Journal on Optimization9(4): 877–900.
12.
CamachoEFAlbaCB (2013) Model Predictive Control. Springer Science & Business Media, Springer, Verlag London.
13.
ChenC (1994) A continuous bulk polymerization process for crystal polystyrene. Polymer-Plastics Technology and Engineering33(9): 55–81.
14.
CherbańskiRAleksandraMEugeniuszM (2007) Safety aspects in batch reactors for styrene suspension polymerization. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research46(18): 5898–5906.
15.
ChoWEdgarTFLeeJ (2008) Iterative learning dual-mode control of exothermic batch reactors. Control Engineering Practice16(10): 1244–1249.
16.
CokerA (2014) Ludwig’s applied process design for chemical and petrochemical plants. In: Ludwig’s (Ed) Appendix C: Physical Properties of Liquids and Gases. 4th ed, 2007. Gulf Professional Publishing. Elsevier, pp. 827–862.
17.
CopelliSBarozziMPetrucciNMorenoV (2019) Modeling and process optimization of a full-scale emulsion polymerization reactor. Chemical Engineering Journal358: 1410–1420.
18.
CottBJMacchiettoS (1989) Temperature control of exothermic batch reactors using generic model control. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research28(8): 1177–1184.
19.
DahlinE (1968) Designing and tuning digital controllers. Instruments and Control Systems41(6): 77–83.
20.
de ToledoEMartiniRMaciel FilhoR (2000) Development of high performance operational strategies for polymerization reactor. Computers & Chemical Engineering24(2–7): 481–486.
21.
de ToledoECVMartiniRFMacielMRWMaciel FilhoR (2005) Process intensification for high operational performance target: Autorefrigerated CSTR polymerization reactor. Computers & Chemical Engineering29(6): 1447–1455.
22.
de ToledoEMartiniRMaria Regina WolfMFilhoR (2006) Influence of non-condensable gases on the dynamic behaviour of an auto-refrigerated CSTR polymerization reactor. The Canadian Journal of Chemical Engineering84(4): 469–479.
23.
EkpoEEMujtabaIM (2007) Performance analysis of three controllers for the polymerisation of styrene in a batch reactor. Chemical Product and Process Modeling2(1). pp. 1–29.
24.
FiletiAMFAntunesAJB.SilvaFV, et al. (2007) Experimental investigations on fuzzy logic for process control. Control Engineering Practice15(9): 1149–1160.
25.
Fisher (2001) Control valve selection. In: Control Valve HandBook. 3rd ed, Chap 5. Emerson Process Management. Fisher Control International Inc., U.S. pp. 73–145.
26.
GarrigaJLSoroushM (2010) Model predictive control tuning methods: A review. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research49(8): 3505–3515.
27.
GharaghaniMAbediniHParvaziniaM (2012) Dynamic simulation and control of auto-refrigerated CSTR and tubular reactor for bulk styrene polymerization. Chemical Engineering Research and Design90(10): 1540–1552.
28.
GhasemNMSataSAHussainMA (2007) Temperature control of a bench-scale batch polymerization reactor for polystyrene production. Chemical Engineering & Technology: Industrial Chemistry-Plant Equipment-Process Engineering-Biotechnology30(9): 1193–1202.
29.
HägglundT (2019) The one-third rule for PI controller tuning. Computers & Chemical Engineering127: 25–30.
30.
HallB (2018) Nonlinear model predictive control and dynamic real-time optimization of semi-batch reactors-a case study of expandable polystyrene production. Master’s thesis, NTNU.
31.
HendersonIII LCornejoR (1989) Temperature control of continuous, bulk styrene polymerization reactors and the influence of viscosity: an analytical study. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research28(11): 1644–1653.
32.
HidalgoPBrosilowC (1990) Nonlinear model predictive control of styrene polymerization at unstable operating points. Computers & Chemical Engineering14(4–5): 481–494.
33.
HosenMHussainMMjalliF (2011) Control of polystyrene batch reactors using neural network based model predictive control (NNMPC): An experimental investigation. Control Engineering Practice19(5): 454–467.
34.
HosenMAHussainMAMjalliFS, et al. (2014) Performance analysis of three advanced controllers for polymerization batch reactor: An experimental investigation. Chemical Engineering Research and Design92(5): 903–916.
35.
HuiAHamielecA (1972) Thermal polymerization of styrene at high conversions and temperatures. An experimental study. Journal of Applied Polymer Science16(3): 749–769.
36.
HvalaNAllerFMitevaTKukanjaD (2011) Modelling, simulation and control of an industrial, semi-batch, emulsion-polymerization reactor. Computers & Chemical Engineering35(10): 2066–2080.
37.
LiangXMJiangHCFangJL, et al. (2019) Thermal analysis of the styrene bulk polymerization and characterization of polystyrene initiated by two methods. Chemical Engineering Communications206(4): 432–443.
38.
LuybenW (1972) Effect of inert venting on the stability of autorefrigerated batch reactors. AIChE Journal18(1): 58–61.
39.
LuybenW (1999) Temperature control of autorefrigerated reactors. Journal of Process Control9(4): 301–312.
40.
LuybenWL (2004) Quantitative comparison of temperature control of reactors with jacket cooling or internal cooling coils. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research43(11): 2691–2703.
41.
MastanEZhuS (2015) Method of moments: A versatile tool for deterministic modeling of polymerization kinetics. European Polymer Journal68: 139–160.
42.
MaulJFrushourBKontofJ, et al. (2000) Polystyrene and styrene copolymers. In: Wiley-VCH (Ed) Ullmann’s Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry 2007. 29: pp. 475–522.
43.
NovákJChalupaP (2013) Multiple model predictive control of a styrene polymerization process. In: ZelinkaIRösslerO.ESnáselVAbrahamACorchadoE.S., (Eds.), Nostradamus: Modern Methods of Prediction, Modeling and Analysis of Nonlinear Systems Chap 17. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer, pp. 143–152.
44.
NguyenSHoangNHussainM (2017) Analysis of the steady-state multiplicity behavior for polystyrene production in the CSTR. Chemical Product and Process Modeling12(4): 1–12.
45.
NogueiraIFontesRRibeiroA, et al. (2020) A robustly model predictive control strategy applied in the control of a simulated industrial polyethylene polymerization process. Computers & Chemical Engineering133: 106664.
46.
ÖzkanGHapogluHAlpbazM (1998) Generalized predictive control of optimal temperature profiles in a polystyrene polymerization reactor. Chemical Engineering and processing: Process Intensification37(2): 125–139.
47.
ÖzkanGHapogluHAlpbazM (2006) Non-linear generalised predictive control of a jacketed well mixed tank as applied to a batch process—A polymerisation reaction. Applied Thermal Engineering26(7): 720–726.
48.
PrasadVSchleyMRussoLBequetteB (2002) Product property and production rate control of styrene polymerization. Journal of Process Control12(3): 353–372.
49.
SkogestadS (2003) Simple analytic rules for model reduction and PID controller tuning. Journal of Process Control13(4): 291–309.
50.
SolórzanoMZRayWH (2008) Multiplicity and stability of chemical reactors with evaporative cooling. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research47(23): 9025–9039.
51.
TakashiUSurianarayananMWakakuraMTomiokaH (1998) Hazards of radical polymerizations: Thermokinetic investigation of styrene polymerization methods. Journal of Chemical Engineering of Japan31(6): 960–968.
52.
VafamandNNaghaviSVSafaviAA, et al. (2018) TS-based sampled-data model predictive controller for continuous-time nonlinear systems. International Journal of Systems Science49(16): 3284–3295.
53.
VillaCVan HornBRayW (1999) Dynamics of polymerization reactors with evaporative cooling and wall heat transfer. Polymer Reaction Engineering7(2): 151–194.
54.
WaltzRAMoralesJLNocedalJOrbanD (2006) An interior algorithm for nonlinear optimization that combines line search and trust region steps. Mathematical Programming107(3): 391–408.
55.
ZarbilMSSaeidiMVahediAMoghaddamHA (2019) Continuous control set model predictive control (CCS-MPC) of a three-phase rectifier. Zanco Journal of Pure and Applied Sciences31(s3): 342–350.
