In 2004 Steve Friesen proposed a `poverty scale' for Graeco-Roman urbanism as a backdrop against which to assess features of the earliest urban Christian communities. This article offers an assessment of the strengths and weaknesses of Friesen's scale, not least in relation to binary taxonomies of Graeco-Roman economic stratification, rhetorical conventions of the ancient world, and the `middling groups' of Graeco-Roman urbanism. It proposes adjustments to the scale (renamed as the `economic scale') and gives consideration to the significance of those adjustments for the reconstruction of early Christianity relative to ancient poverty.
Abramenko, A.1993Die munizipale Mittelschichte im kaiserzeitlichen Italien: Zu einem neuen Verständnis von Sevirat und Augustalität ( Frankfurt: Peter Lang).
2.
Adams, E. and D.G. Horrell (eds.) 2004Christianity in Corinth: The Quest for the Pauline Church (Louisville, KY: Westminster/ John Knox Press).
3.
Alcock, S.E.2007`The Eastern Mediterrannean', in Scheidel, Morris and Saller2007: 671-97.
4.
Alföldy, G.1986Die römische Sozialgeschichte (3rd edn; Wiesbaden: Steiner Franz Verlag).
5.
Andreau, J.2002`Twenty Years after Moses I. Finley's The Ancient Economy' , in Scheidel and von Reden2002: 33-49. (Originally: `Vingt ans après L'économie antique de Moses I. Finley', in Annales ESC 50 [1995]: 947-60.)
6.
Atkins, M. and R. Osborne (eds.) 2006Poverty in the Roman World (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
7.
Bagnall, R.S.1992`Landholding in Late Roman Egypt: The Distribution of Wealth' , JRS82: 128-49.
8.
Bang, P.F., M. Ikeguchi and H.G. Ziche (eds.) 2006Ancient Economies, Modern Methodologies: Archaeology, Comparative History, Models and Institutions (Bari: Edipuglia).
9.
Barclay, J.2004`Poverty in Pauline Studies: A Response to Steven Friesen' , JSNT26: 363-66.
10.
Brunt, P.A.1971Italian Manpower, 225 BC-AD 14 ( London : Oxford University Press).
11.
Carandini, A.1989`Italian Wine and African Oil: Commerce in a World Empire' , in K. Randsborg (ed.), The Birth of Europe: Archaeology and Social Development in the First Millenium AD (Rome: L'Erma di Bretschneider ): 16-24.
12.
Carney, T.F.1975The Shape of the Past: Models and Antiquity ( Lawrence, KS: Coronado Press).
13.
Christ, K.1980`Grundfragen der römischen Sozialstruktur', in W. Eck, H. Galsterer and H. Wolff (eds.), Studien zur antiken Sozialgeschichte ( Cologne: Böhlau).
14.
Crossan, J.D. and J. Reed2004 In Search of Paul (San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco).
15.
D'Arms, J.H.1977`M.I. Rostovtzeff and M.I. Finley: The Status of Traders in the Roman World', in J.H. D'Arms and J.W. Eadie (eds.), Ancient and Modern: Essays in Honor of Gerald F. Else ( Ann Arbor : University of Michigan Press): 157-79.
16.
2000 `Memory, Money, and Status at Misenum: Three New Inscriptions and the Collegium of the Augustales', JRS90: 126-44.
17.
Descat, R.1995`L'économie antique et la cité grecque', Annales50 (1995): 961-89.
18.
Drinkwater, J.F.2001`The Gallo-Roman Woollen Industry and the Great Debate: The Igel Column Revisited' , in Mattingly and Salmon2001a: 297-308.
19.
Duncan-Jones, R.1964`Human Numbers in Towns and Town-Organisations of the Roman Empire: The Evidence of Gifts', Historia13: 199-208.
20.
1976 `Some Configurations of Landholding in the Roman Empire', in M.I. Finley (ed.), Studies in Roman Property (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press): 7-33.
21.
1990Structure and Scale in the Roman Economy ( Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
22.
Duthoy, R.1974`La fonction sociale de l'augustalité', Epigraphica36: 134-54.
23.
Edmondson, J.2006`Cities and Urban Life in the Western Provinces of the Roman Empire, 30 BCE-250 CE', in D.S. Potter (ed.), A Companion to the Roman Empire ( Oxford: Blackwell Publishing): 250-80.
24.
Finley, M.I.1965`Technical Innovation and Economic Progress in the Ancient World', Economic History Review18: 29-45.
25.
1975The Ancient Economy (London: Chatto & Windus).
26.
Fredriksen, M.W.1975`Theory, Evidence and the Ancient Economy', JRS65, 164-71.
27.
Friesen, S.2004`Poverty in Pauline Studies: Beyond the So-called New Consensus' , JSNT26: 323-61.
28.
2005`Injustice or God's Will: Explanations of Poverty in Proto-Christian Communities', in Richard A. Horsley (ed.), Christian Origins (A People's History of Christianity, 1; Minneapolis: Fortress Press): 240-60.
29.
Garnsey, P.D.A., K. Hopkins and C.R. Whittaker, 1983Trade in the Ancient Economy ( London : Chatto & Windus).
30.
Garnsey, P.D.A. and R.P. Saller1987The Roman Empire: Economy, Society and Culture (London: Duckworth).
31.
Gill, D.W.J.1994`Acts and the Urban Élites', in David W.J. Gill and Conrad Gempf (eds.), The Book of Acts in its First Century Setting. II. The Book of Acts in its Graeco-Roman Setting ( Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans): 105-118.
32.
Greene, K.1986The Archaeology of the Roman Economy ( London: Batsford; Berkeley: University of California Press).
33.
2000 a `Industry and Technology', in A.K. Bowman, P. Garnsey and D. Rathbone (eds.), The Cambridge Ancient History. XI. The High Empire, A.D. 70-192 (Cambridge: CambridgeUniversity Press): 741-68.
34.
2000b `Technological Innovation and Economic Progress in the Ancient World', Economic History Review53: 29-59.
35.
2006 `Archaeological Data and Economic Interpretation', in Bang, Ikeguchi and Ziche 2006: 109-36.
36.
Grey, C.2006`Salvian and the Poor in Fifth-Century Gaul', in Atkins and Osborne 2006: 162-82.
37.
Hellerman, J.H.2005Reconstructing Honor in Roman Philippi: Carmen Christi as cursus pudorum (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
38.
Hitchner, R.B.1993`Olive Production and the Roman Economy: The Case for Intensive Growth in the Roman Empire', in M.-C. Amouretti and J.-P. Brun (eds.), La production du vin et de l'huile en Méditerranée (Athens: École francaise d'Athènes): 499-508.
39.
2005``The advantages of wealth and luxury': The Case for Economic Growth in the Roman Empire', in J. Manning and I. Morris (eds.), The Ancient Economy: Evidence and Models (Stanford: Stanford University Press): 207-22.
40.
Holmberg, B.2004`Methods of Historical Reconstruction', in Adams and Horrell 2004: 255-72.
41.
Hopkins, K.1978`Economic Growth and Towns in Classical Antiquity' , in P. Abrams and E.A. Wrigley (eds.), Towns in Societies: Essays in Economic History and Historical Sociology (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press): 35-79.
42.
1980`Taxes and Trade in the Roman Empire, 200 BC-AD 400', JRS70: 101-25.
43.
1983 `Introduction', in Garnsey, Hopkins, and Whittaker 1983: ix-xxv.
44.
1995/6 `Rome, Taxes, Rents and Trade', Kodai: Journal of Ancient History6/7: 41-75.
45.
Hopwood, K.1989`Bandits, Elites and Rural Order', in Andrew Wallace-Hadrill (ed.), Patronage in Ancient Society (London: Routledge ): 171-88.
46.
Humfress, C.2006`Poverty and Roman Law', in Atkins and Osborne 2006: 183-203.
47.
Jongkind, D.2001`Corinth in the First Century AD: The Search for Another Class', TynBul52: 139-48.
48.
Jongman, W.M.2007`The Early Roman Empire: Consumption', in Scheidel, Morris and Saller 2007: 592-618.
49.
Kehoe, D.P.2007`The Early Roman Empire: Production', in Scheidel, Morris and Saller 2007: 543-69.
50.
de Ligt, L.1990`Demand, Supply, Distribution: The Roman Peasantry between Town and Countryside: Rural Monetization and Peasant Demand', Münstersche Beiträge zur antiken Handelsgeschichte9.2: 24-56.
51.
Longenecker, B.W. forthcoming `Socio-Economic Profiling of the First Urban Christians' , in Still and Horrell forthcoming.
52.
Longenecker, B.W. and K. Liebengood (eds.) forthcoming Engaging Economics: New Testament Scenarios and Early Christian Reception (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans).
53.
Louw, J.P. and E.A. Nida1988/89 Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament Based on Semantic Domains (New York: United Bible Societies).
54.
Mattingly, D.J. and J. Salmon2001a Economies beyond Agriculture in the Classical World (London : Routledge).
55.
2001 b `The Productive Past: Economies beyond Agriculture', in Mattingly and Salmon 2001a: 3-14.
56.
Mattingley, E.2006`The Imperial Economy', in David S. Potter (ed.), A Companion to the Roman Empire ( Oxford: Blackwell Publishing ); 283-96.
57.
Meeks, W.A.1983The First Urban Christians: The Social World of the Apostle Paul (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press).
58.
Meggitt, J.J.1998Paul, Poverty and Survival ( Edinburgh : T&T Clark).
59.
2004 `Sources: Use, Abuse, Neglect: The Importance of Ancient Popular Culture', in Adams and Horrell2004: 241-54.
60.
Morley, N.2006a `The Poor in the City of Rome', in Atkins and Osborne 2006: 21-39.
61.
2006 b `Narrative Economy', in Bang, Ikeguchi and Ziche 2006: 27-47.
62.
Oakes, P.2001Philippians: From People to Letter ( Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
63.
2004 `Constructing Poverty Scales for Graeco-Roman Society: A Response to Steven Friesen's `Poverty in Pauline Studies'', JSNT26: 367-71.
64.
forthcoming `Methodological Issues in Using Economic Evidence in Interpretation of Early Christian Texts', in Longenecker and Liebengood forthcoming .
65.
Oliver, J.H.1958`Gerusiae and Augustales', Historia7: 472-96.
66.
Osborne, R.2006`Roman Poverty in Context', in Atkins and Osborne 2006: 1-20.
67.
Parkin, A.2006``You do him no service': An Exploration of Pagan Almsgiving' , in Atkins and Osborne 2006: 60-82.
68.
Paterson, J.J.1997`Production and Consumption', in P. Jones and K. Sidwell (eds.), The World of Rome: An Introduction to Roman Culture (Cambridge : Cambridge University Press): 181-207.
69.
Patterson, J.R.2006Landscapes and Cities: Rural Settlement and Civic Transformation in Early Imperial Italy (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
70.
Pleket, H.W.1990`Wirtschaft', in F. Vittinghoff (ed.), Europäische Wirtschafts- und Sozialgeschichte in der römischen Kaiserzeit (Stuttgart: Ernst Klett Verlag): 25-160.
71.
Purcell, N.1983`The apparitores: A Study in Social Mobility', PBSR51: 125-73.
72.
Rathbone, D.W.1993`The Census Qualifications of the assidui and the prima classis', in H. Sancisi-Weerdenburg and H.C. Teitler (eds.), De Agricultura: In Memoriam Pieter Willem de Neeve (1945-1990) (Amsterdam : J.C. Gieben): 121-52.
73.
2006`Poverty and Population in Roman Egypt', in Atkins and Osborne 2006: 100-15.
74.
Saller, R.2002`Framing the Debate over Growth in the Ancient Economy' , in Scheidel and von Reden 2002: 251-69.
75.
Scheidel, W.2006`Stratification, Deprivation and Quality of Life' , in Atkins and Osborne 2006: 40-59.
76.
Scheidel, W. and S. von Reden (eds.) 2002The Ancient Economy ( Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press).
77.
Scheidel, W., I. Morris and R. Saller (eds.) 2007The Cambridge Economic History of the Graeco-Roman World ( Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
78.
Silver, M.2003 Review of Walter Scheidel and Sitta von Reden (eds.), The Ancient Economy. EH.Net Economic History Services, 3 January 2003. URL: http.//eh.net/bookreviews/library/0570 ; accessed 11 March 2008.
79.
Smith, M.G.1966 `Pre-Industrian Social Stratification Systems', in N.J. Smelser and S.M. Lipset (eds.), Social Structure and Mobility in Economic Development (Chicago: Aldine Press , 1966): 141-76.
80.
Stegemann, E.W. and W. Stegemann1999The Jesus Movement: A Social History of its First Century (ET: Minneapolis: Fortress Press , 1999).
81.
Still, T. and D.G. Horrell (eds.) forthcoming After the First Urban Christians: The Socio-Historical Study of Pauline Christianity Twenty-Five Years Later (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic).
82.
Tchalenko, G.1953Villages antiques de la Syrie du nord, I ( Paris: P. Geuthner, 1953).
83.
Theissen, G.2001`The Social Structure of Pauline Communities: Some Critical Comments on J.J. Meggitt, Paul, Poverty and Survival', JSNT84: 65-84.
84.
Toner, J.P.2002Rethinking Roman History (Cambridge, MA: Polity Press).
85.
Vittinghoff, F.1980`Soziale Struktur und politisches System in der hohen römischen Kaiserzeit', Historische Zeitschrift230: 31-55.
86.
Wallace-Hadrill, A.1994Houses and Society in Pompeii and Herculaneum (Princeton : Princeton University Press ).
87.
Whittaker, C.R.1993`The Poor in the City of Rome', in Land, City and Trade in the Roman Empire (Aldershot: Variorum Ashgate, 1993), article 7.
88.
Wilson, A.2002`Machines, Power and the Ancient Economy', JRS92: 1-32.
89.
2004 `Cyrenaica and the Late Antique Economy', in Ancient West and East 3: 143-54.
90.
2006 `The Economic Impact of Technological Advances in the Roman Construction Industry', in Elio Lo Cascio (ed.), Innovazione tecnica e progresso economico (Bari: Edipuglia): 225-36.
91.
Woolf, G.1992`Imperialism, Empire and the Integration of the Roman Economy' , World Archaeology23: 283-93.
92.
2006 `Writing Poverty in Rome', in Atkins and Osborne 2006: 83-99.
