Exemplifying a rather widespread attitude among Pauline scholars, it has recently
been argued on the basis of Rom. 12 that Paul differed sharply from the Stoics in
his moral teaching. The present article aims to show that such a claim does not hold
if and when the sources of Roman Stoicism are taken into consideration. A comparison
of Paul’s moral teaching in Rom. 12 and contemporary Stoic ethics reveals
that, whereas the two differ somewhat in scope (particular vs. universal), the
differences are clearly outweighed by the many, striking similarities.
Behm, Johannes1965‘(see pdf for character)’
, TDNT, III:
180-190
.
3.
Betz, Hans Dieter1991‘Christianity as Religion: Paul’s Attempt at Definition
in Romans’
, JR71:
315-344
.
4.
Black, David A.1989‘The Pauline Love Command: Structure, Style, and Ethics in Romans 12.9-21’
, FilNeot2:
3-22
.
5.
Brennan, Tad1998‘The Old Stoic Theory of Emotions’, in
J. Sihvola
and
T. Engberg-Pedersen
(eds.), The Emotions in Hellenistic Philosophy (The New Synthese
Historical Library, 46;
Dordrecht: Kluwer
): 21-70.
6.
Colish, Marcia L.1992‘Stoicism and the New Testament: An Essay in Historiography’
, ANRW2.26.1:
334-379
.
7.
Dunn, James D. G.1988Romans 9-16 (WBC, 38B;
Dallas: Word)
.
8.
Engberg-Pedersen, Troels2005‘The Relationship with Others: Similarities and Differences
Between Paul and Stoicism’
, ZNW96:
35-60
.
9.
Esler, Philip F.2004‘Paul and Stoicism: Romans 12 as a Test Case’
, NTS50:
106-124
.
10.
Fitzmyer, Joseph A.1993Romans: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary (AB, 33;
New York: Doubleday)
.
11.
Furnish, Victor P.1972The Love Command in the New Testament (
Nashville: Abingdon Press)
.
12.
Johnson, Luke Timothy2003‘Transformation of the Mind and Moral Discernment in
Paul’, in
J. T. Fitzgerald
,
T. H. Olbricht
and
L. M. White
(eds.), Early Christianity and Classical Culture: Comparative Studies in
Honor of Abraham J. Malherbe (NovTSup, 110;
Leiden: Brill
): 215-236.
Long, A. A.2002Epictetus: A Stoic and Socratic Guide to Life (
Oxford: Clarendon Press)
.
15.
Lutz, Cora E.1947‘Musonius Rufus: “The Roman Socrates”’
, YCS10:
3-147
.
16.
Malherbe, Abraham J.1992‘Hellenistic Moralists and the New Testament’
, ANRW2.26.1:
267-333
.
17.
Moxnes, Halvor1994‘The Quest for Honor and the Unity of the Community in Romans 12
and in the Orations of Dio Chrysostom’, in
T. Engberg-Pedersen
(ed.), Paul in his Hellenistic Context (
Edinburgh: T&T Clark
): 203-230.
18.
Pohlenz, Max 1964 Die Stoa: Geschichte einer geistigen Bewegung
(Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 3rd edn).
19.
Pomeroy, Arthur J.
(ed.) 1999Arius Didymus: Epitome of Stoic Ethics (
Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature)
.
20.
Reiser, Marius2001‘Love of Enemies in the Context of Antiquity’
, NTS47:
411-427
.
21.
Rist, J. M.1969Stoic Philosophy (
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
.
22.
Russell, Bertrand1979A History of Western Philosophy (
London: Unwin
, 2nd edn).
23.
Sandbach, F. H.1989The Stoics (
London: Duckworth)
.
24.
Söding, Thomas 1995 Das Liebesgebot bei Paulus: Die Mahnung zur
Agape im Rahmen der paulinischen Ethik (NTAbh, 26; Münster: Aschendorff).
25.
Thorsteinsson, Runar M.2003Paul’s Interlocutor in Romans 2: Function and Identity in the Context
of Ancient Epistolography (ConBNT, 40;
Stockholm: Almqvist & Wiksell)
.
26.
Whittaker, John1979‘Christianity and Morality in the Roman Empire’
, VC33:
209-225
.
27.
Wilson, Walter T.1991Love without Pretense: Romans 12.9-21 and Hellenistic-Jewish Wisdom
Literature (WUNT, 2.46;
Tübingen: Mohr [Siebeck])
.
