There has been little research in Britain into the experiences of doctors who are ill. We conducted in-depth interviews with 64 doctors of all grades with a recent illness lasting one month or more. Whether the illness was physical or psychiatric, many expressed the idea that illness is inappropriate for doctors. This idea is a cultural value among doctors which is reinforced by the organization of medical work. It discourages doctors from seeking and obtaining appropriate help when they are ill.
References
1.
MurrayRM. Psychiatric illness in doctors.Lancet1974; i: 1211–13.
2.
MurrayRM. Alcoholism amongst male doctors in Scotland.Lancet1975; ii: 729–31.
3.
BrookeD, EdwardsG, TaylorC.Addiction as an occupational hazard: 144 doctors with drug and alcohol problems.Br J Addict1991; 86: 1011–16.
4.
FirthJ.Levels and sources of stress in medical students.BMJ1986; 292: 1177–80.
5.
Firth-CozensJ.Emotional distress in junior house officers.BMJ1987; 295: 533–6.
6.
WinefieldHR, AnsteyTJ. Job stress in general practice: practitioner age, sex and attitudes as predictors.Fam Tract1991; 8: 140–4.
7.
CaplanR.Stress, anxiety and depression in hospital consultants, general practitioners and senior health service managers.BMJ1994; 309: 1261–3.
8.
RamirezAJ, GrahamJ, RichardsMA, CullA, GregoryWM. Mental health of hospital consultants: the effects of stress and satisfaction at work.Lancet1996; 347: 724–8.
9.
AlliboneA, OakesD, ShannonHS. The health and health care of doctors.J R Coll Gen Tract1981; 31: 728–34.
10.
ChambersR, BelcherJ.Self-reported health care over the past 10 years: a survey of general practitioners.Br J Gen Tract1992; 42: 153–6.
11.
PullenD, LonieCE, LyleDM, CamDE, DoughtyMV. Medical care of doctors.Med J Aust1995; 162: 481–4.
12.
RichardsC.The Health of Doctors.London: King's Fund,1989.
13.
McKevittCJ, MorganM, SimpsonJ, HollandWW. Doctors' Health and Needs for Services.London: Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust,1996.
14.
PopeC, MaysN.Qualitative methods in health and health services research. In: MaysN, PopeC eds. Qualitative Research in Health Care.London: BMJ Publishing,1996.
15.
MaysN, PopeC.Rigour and qualitative research. In: MaysN, PopeC eds. Qualitative Research in Health Care.London: BMJ Publishing,1996.
16.
ParsonsT.Illness and the role of physicians: a sociological perspective. In: StoeckleJ ed. Encounters Between Doctors and Tatients.Cambridge: MIT Press,1987.
17.
KingM, CockroftA, GoochC.Emotional distress in doctors: sources, effects and help sought.J R Soc Med1992; 85: 605–8.
18.
SilvesterS, AllenH, MorganM, WitheyC, HollandWW. The Trovision of Medical Services to Sick Doctors.London: Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust,1994.
19.
MacDonaldEB, McCloyE.Existing services need to be coordinated.BMJ1994; 309: 1235.
McBrideM, MetcalfeD.General practitioners' low morale: reasons and solutions.Br J Gen Tract1995; 45: 227–9.
22.
DonaldsonL.Sick doctors: a responsibility to act.BMJ1994; 309: 557–8.
23.
RoutU, RoutJK. Job satisfaction, mental health and job stress among general practitioners before and after the new contract: a comparative study.Fam Tract1994; 11: 300–6.
24.
McKevittC, MorganM, HollandWW. Protecting and Promoting Doctors' Health: the Work Environment and Counselling Services in Three Sites.London: Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust,1996.
25.
StylesW.Stress in undergraduate medicine: the mask of relaxed brilliance.Br J Gen Tract1993; 43: 47–7.
26.
HiggsR.Doctors in crisis.J R Coll Thysicians Lond1994; 28: 538–40.
27.
Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust.Taking Care of Donors' Health: Reducing Doctors' Avoidable Stress and Improving Service for Doctors' Health.London: Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust, 1996.
28.
McKevittC, MorganM, DundasR, HollandWW. Sickness absence and working through illness: a comparison of two professional groups.J Puhl Health Med (in press).
29.
RutleO.Physician and patient at the same time: experiences from participants of a health service trial for physicians.T Nor Laegeforen1993; 113: 964–6.
