Antenatal Diagnosis of Renal Tract Anomalies: Has it Increased the Sum of Human Happiness?

Abstract

When used as a screening procedure, ultrasound examination of the fetal urinary tract seldom leads to beneficial interventions. There is also a cost in terms of parental anxiety and unnecessary investigation and treatment. A formal screening programme would therefore be unjustified. However, screening of women for obstetric purposes will continue to reveal fetal abnormalities, and a strategy for dealing with these is needed. Antenatal treatments remain experimental; for most of the common conditions postnatal treatment has no urgency; and, in cases of minor abnormality detected by ultrasound, the best course may be to do nothing.

Keywords

antenatal renal anomalies happiness

References

Robinson

D.E.

, Garrett

W.J.

, Kossoff

. Fetal anatomy displayed b) ultrasound. Invest Radiol 1968; 3: 508–12

Garrett

W.J.

, Grunwald

, Robinson

D.E.

. Prenatal diagnosis of fetal polycystic kidney by ultrasound. Aust NZ J Obstet Gynae 1970; 10: 7–9

Chitty

L.S.

, Pembrey

M.E.

, Chudleigh

P.M.

, Campbell

. Multicentre study of antenatal calyceal dilatation detected by ultrasound. Lancet 1990; 336: 875

Watson

A.R.

, Readett

, Nelson

C.S.

, Kapila

, Mayell

M.J.

. Dilemmas associated with antenatally detected urinary tract abnormalities. Arch Dis Child 1988; 63: 719–22

McKeown

. Validation of screening procedures. In: Screening and Medical Care. London: Nuffield Provincial Hospitals, 1968: 1

Lind

. Obstetric ultrasound: getting good vibrations. BMJ 1986; 293: 576

Thomas

D.F.M.

, Gordon

A.C.

. Management of prenatally diagnosed uropathies. Arch Dis Child 1989; 64: 58–63

Chamberlain

. Evaluation of screening procedures. In: Hobson

, ed. The Theory and Practice of Public Health, 5th edn. New York: Oxford University Press, 1979: 745–59

Brereton

R.J.

. Importance of surgical consultation after ultrasound diagnosis. BMJ 1984; 289: 1618–19

10.

Griffiths

D.M.

, Gough

M.H.

. Dilemmas after ultrasound diagnosis of fetal abnormality. Lancet 1985; i: 623–4

11.

Furness

M.E.

. Reporting obstetric ultrasound. Lancet 1987; i: 675–6

12.

Turnock

R.R.

, Shawis

. Management of fetal urinary tract anomalies detected by prenatal ultrasonography. Arch Dis Child 1984; 59: 962–5

13.

Ransley

P.G.

, Dhillon

H.K.

, Gordon

, Duffy

P.G.

, Dillon

M.J.

, Barratt

T.M.

. The postnatal management of hydronephrosis diagnosed by prenatal ultrasound. J Urol 1990; 144: 584–7

14.

Arnold

A.J.

, Rickwood

A.M.K.

. Natural history of pelviureteric obstruction detected by prenatal sonography. Br J Urol 1990; 65: 91–6

15.

Madden

N.P.

, Thomas

D.F.M.

, Gordon

A.C.

, Arthur

R.J.

, Irving

H.C.

, Smith

S.E.W.

. Antenatally detected pelviareteric junction obstruction. Is non-operation safe? Br J Urol 1991; 68: 305–10

16.

Dhillon

H.K.

, Gordon

, Duffy

P.G.

, Ransley

P.G.

. A randomised clinical trial in infants with prenatally diagnosed unilateral hydronephrosis [Abstract No. 5]. European Society of Paediatric Urology, Annual Meeting 1993; 23–24 April, Portugal. Portugal. ESPU, 1994

17.

Maizels

, Reisman

M.E.

, Flom

L.S.

Grading nephroureteral dilatation detected in the first year of life: correlation with obstruction.

J Urol 1992; 148: 609–14

18.

Thomas

D.F.M.

, Madden

N.P.

, Irving

H.C.

, Arthur

R.J.

, Smith

S.E.W.

. Mild dilatation of the fetal kidney: a follow-up study. Br J Urol 1994; 74: 236 9

19.

Rickwood

A.M.K.

, Jee

I.D.

, Williams

M.P.L.

, Anderson

P.A.M.

. Natural history of obstructed and pseudo-obstructed megaureters detected by prenatal ultrasonography. Br J Urol 1992; 70: 322–5

20.

Alexander Liu

H.Y.

, Dhillon

H.K.

, Yeung

C.K.

, Diamond

D.A.

, Duffy

P.G.

, Ransley

P.G.

. Clinical outcome and management of prenatally diagnosed primary megaureters. J Urol 1994; 152: 614–17

21.

Baskin

L.S.

, Zderic

S.A.

, Snyder

H.M.

, Duckett

J.W.

. Primary dilated megaureter: long-term, followup. J Urol 1994; 152: 618–21

22.

Rickwood

A.M.K.

, Anderson

P.A.M.

, Williams

P.M.L.

. Multicystic renal dysplasia detected by prenatal ultrasonography. Natural history and results of conservative management. Br J Urol 1992; 69: 538–40

23.

Kelleher

J.P.

, Dhillon

H.K.

, Duffy

P.G.

, Ransley

P.G.

. The antenatally diagnosed multicystic kidney: now you see it, now you don't [Abstract 128]. British Association of Urological Surgeons Annual Meeting 1993; 22 25 June, Harrogate. BAUS, 1994.

24.

Orejas

, Malaga

, Santos

, Rey

, Lopez

M.V.

, Merten

. Multicystic dysplastic kidney: Absence of complications in patients treated conservatively. Chld Nephrol Urol 1992; 12: 35–9

25.

Report of the International Fetal Surgery Registry.

Catheter shunts for fetal hydronephrosis and hydrocephalus.

N Engl J Med 1986; 315: 336–40

26.

Elder

J.S.

, Duckett

J.W.

, Snyder

H.M.

. Intervention for fetal obstructive uropathy: has it been effective? Lancet 1987; ii: 1007–10

27.

Harrison

M.R.

, Adzick

N.S.

. The fetus as a patient. Ann Surg 1991; 213: 279–91

28.

Estes

J.M.

, MacGillivray

T.E.

, Hedrick

M.H.

, Adzick

N.S.

, Harrison

M.R.

. Fetoscopic surgery for the treatment of congenital anomalies. J Pediatr Surg 1992; 27: 950–4

29.

O'Neill

J.A.

. The fetus as a patient. Ann Surg 1991; 213: 277–8

30.

Glick

P.L.

, Harrison

M.R.

, Golbus

M.S.

Management of the fetus with congenital hydronephrosis 11: prognostic criteria and selection for treatment.

J Pediatr Surg 1985; 20: 376–87

31.

Dinneen

M.D.

, Dhillon

H.M.

, Ward

H.C.

, Duffy

P.G.

, Ransley

P.G.

. Antenatal diagnosis of posterior urethral valves. Br J Urol 1993; 72: 364–9

32.

Reinberg

, Castano

Ide

, Gonzalez

. Prognosis for patients with prenatally diagnosed posterior urethral valves. J Urol 1992; 148: 125–6

33.

Jee

L.D.

, Rickwood

A.M.K.

, Turnock

. Posterior urethral valves. Docs prenatal diagnosis? Br J Urol 1993; 72: 830–3

34.

Mandell

, Lebowitz

R.L.

, Peters

C.A.

, Estroff

J.A.

, Retik

A.B.

, Benacerraf

B.R.

. Prenatal diagnosis of the megacystis-megaureter association. J Urol 1992; 148: 1487–9

35.

Avni

E.F.

, Dacher

J.N.

, Stallenberg

, Collier

, Hall

, Schulman

C.C.

. Renal duplications: The impact of perinatal ultrasound on diagnosis and management. Eur Urol 1991; 20: 43–8

36.

Donnai

, Charles

, Harris

. Attitudes of patients after “genetic” termination of pregnancy. BMJ 1981; 282: 621–2

37.

Leschot

N.J.

, Verjaal

, Treffers

P.E.

. Therapeutic abortion on genetic indications—A detailed follow-up study of 20 patients. J Psychosom Obstet Gynaecol 1982; 1–2: 47–56

38.

Dagg

P.K.B.

. The psychological sequelae of therapeutic abortion denied and completed. Am J Psychiat 1991; 148: 578–85

39.

Zolese

, Blacker

C.V.R.

. The psychological complications of therapeutic abortion. Br J Psychiat 1992; 160: 742–9

40.

Hutton

K.A.R.

. Posterior urethral valves. Br J Urol 1994; 74: 134

41.

Burge

D.M.

, Griffiths

M.D.

, Malone

P.S.

, Atwell

J.D.

. Fetal vesicoureteral reflux: Outcome following conservative postnatal management J Urol 1992; 148: 1743–5

42.

Smellie

J.M.

, Poulton

, Prescod

N.P.

. Retrospective study of children with renal scarring associated with reflux and urinary infection. BMJ 1994; 308: 1193–6

43.

Rickwood

A.M.K.

, Harney

J.V.

, Jones

M.O.

, Oak

. “Congenital” hydronephrosis: limitations of diagnosis by fetal ultrasonography. Br I Urol 1995; 75: 529–30

44.

Riccipetitoni

, Chierici

, Tamisari

Postnatal ultrasound screening of urinary malformations.

J Urol 1992; 148: 604–5

45.

Barakat

A.J.

, Drougas

J.G.

. Occurrence of congenital abnormalities of kidney and urinary tract in 13, 775 autopsies. Urology 1991; 38: 347–50