Abstract
In Ancient Greek medicine the heart instead of the brain was sometimes thought to be the organ co-ordinating sensory and motor activity. The history of the origin of this erroneous idea is outlined. The relative importance of observations and theory in early medical investigations is discussed, and the anatomical dissections leading to the establishment of the brain as the centre of sensory and motor function are described.
References
1.
Popper
K
. In:
Miller
D
, ed. A pocket Popper . London : Fontana Paperbacks , 1987 : 102 –8 , 134
2.
Popper
K
. Conjectures and refutations . London : Routledge & Kegan Paul , 1963 : 47
3.
Himsworth
H
. Scientific knowledge and philosophic Thought . Baltimore : The Johns Hopkins University Press , 1986
4.
Breasted
JH
. New York Hist Soc Q Bull 1922 ; vi : 1 –31
5.Theophrastus . In:
Stratton
GM
, transl. On the Senses 26 . George Allen & Unwin. 1917 : 89 –90
6.Theophrastus . In:
Stratton
GM
, transl. On the Senses 26 . On the Senses 10 . 1917 : 75
7.Empedocles . In:
Wright
MR
, ed. The Extant Fragments . New Haven : Yale University Press , 1981 : 130 , 250
8.Theophrastus . On the senses 39–40 . 1917 : 101
9.Theophrastus . On the senses 45 and 46 . 1917 : 105 –7
10.Hippocrates . The Sacred Disease Sect. 10 . In:
Chadwick
J
Mann
WN
, transl.
Lloyd
GER
, ed. Hippocratic Writings Harmondsworth, England : Penguin Books , 1978 : 243 –4
11.Hippocrates . The Sacred Disease . Sect. 17 and 19. 1978 : 248 –50
12.Plato . Timaeus 69–73 . In: Lee D, transl. Timaeus and Critias Harmondsworth, England : Penguin Books , 1965 : 96 –101
13.Plato . Timaeus 67 and 77 . 1965 : 93 –4 , 106
14.Aristotle . History of Animals 494b. 25–32, In:
Barnes
J
, ed. Complete works of Aristotle . Princeton : Princeton University Press , 1984 ; 1 : 788
15.Aristotle . On the Soul . 412b. 10–414a. 29. 1984;1:657–9
16.Aristotle . On the Soul 429a. 22–429b.5 & 430a.14–26. 1981 : 682 , 684
17.Aristotle . Generation of Animals 736b.27. 1981 : 1143
18.Aristotle . On Youth, Old Age . 469a.3–23 & 469b. 3–20. 1981 : 747 –8
19.Aristotle . Parts of Animals . 640a.1–17. 1981 : 995 –6
20.Aristotle . History of Animals . 561a.8–11. 1981 : 883
21.Aristotle . On Youth, Old Age . 478b.32–479a.2. 1981 : 760
22.Aristotle . Parts of Animals . 666a.13–14. 1981 : 1038
23.Aristotle . Parts of Animals . 656a.24–25. 1981 : 1022
24.Aristotle . On Youth, Old Age . 478a.28–31. 1981 : 759
25.Aristotle . Parts of Animals . 652a.28–653a. 10. 1981 : 1015 –17
26.Aristotle . On Dreams . 461a.4–30 & 461b.11–14. 1981 : 733 –4
27.Aristotle . Parts of Animals . 666a.17–19. 1981 : 1038
28.
Solmsen
F
. Greek Philosophy and the Discovery of the Nerves . Museum Helveticum. 1961 : 174 –8
29.Aristotle . Generation of Animals . 743b.35–744a.5 & 781a.21–781b.1. 1981 : 1154 , 1208
30.Aristotle . Movements of Animals . 703a.9–28. 1981 : 1094 –5
31.Galen . In:
May
MT
, transl. On the Usefulness of the Parts of the Body . 8 :11 . New York : Cornell University Press , 1968 : 413 –15
32.Rufus Ephesius. De anatomia partium hominis 71–75 . In: Von Staden H. Herophilus. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press , 1989 : 200 –1
33.Galen . In:
Duckworth
WLH
, transl.
Lyons
MC
Towers
B
, eds. On Anatomical Procedures. The Later Books . Cambridge : Cambridge University Press , 1962 : 9 –10
34.
Longrigg
J
. Superlative achievement and comparative neglect: Alexandrian medical science and modern historical researach . Hist Sci 1981 : 182
35.
Wilson
LG
. Erasistratus Galen and the Pneuma . Bull Hist Med 1959 ; 33 : 310 –14
36.Galen . On the Usefulness of the Parts of the Body . 7 :14 . 1968 : 363
37.Galen . On Anatomical Procedures. The Later Books . 1962 : 19 –20
38.Galen . On Anatomical Procedures. The Later Books . 1962 : 22 –6
39.Galen . On Anatomical Procedures. The Later Books . 1962 : 203 –8
40.
Walsh
J
. Galen's writings and influences inspiring them . Ann Med Hist 1937 : ns 9:52
41.
Harvey
W
. In: Willis R, transl . The motion of the heart and blood in animals. 1628 . London : JM Dent , 1906 : 141
42.
Himsworth
H
. Scientific knowledge and philosophic thought . Baltimore : The Johns Hopkins University Press , 1986 : 20 –7
43.
Ayer
AJ
. Philosophy in the twentieth century . London : Counterpoint. Unwin Paperbacks , 1982 : 131 –4