This article argues that perspectives of migration as a matter of individual choice or structural coercion are limited in explaining Asian experiences in internal and international migration. Migration experiences in Asia range from early coerced and state-mediated migrations to migrations that are mostly demand-determined. A few exceptional cases, such as that of Malaysia, Indonesia's transmigration programs, and enforced migration on account of infrastructural projects, are noted. Also highlighted is migration in China before and after 1978. The Chinese path is distinct in that before market reforms, there was little rural to urban migration despite a high rate of industrialization. After 1978, rural to urban migration and urbanization increased, but was still lower compared to the rest of Asia. Whether China will go the same way as other Asian countries and how the state will respond to the challenges of increasing migration remain to be seen.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
CaiFang1999“Spatial Pattern of Migration in China's Reform Period,”Asian and Pacific Migration Journal, 8(3):313–327.
2.
CohenRobin, ed. 1996Theories of Migration. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
3.
CookS.1999“Surplus Labor and Productivity in Chinese Agriculture: Evidence from Household Survey Data,”Journal of Development Studies, 35(3):16–44.
4.
CrollE.PingHuang1997“Migration for and Against Agriculture in Eight Chinese Villages,”The China Quarterly, 149:128–146.
5.
Fernandez-StembridgeLeila1999“Labor Allocations of Rural Migrant Workers in Urban Areas: Job Election or Job Enforcement,”Asian and Pacific Migration Journal, 8(3):329–341.
6.
HareD.1999“‘Push versus ‘Pull’ Factors in Migration Outflows and Returns: Determinants of Migration Status and Spell Duration among China's Rural Population,”Journal of Development Studies, 35(3):45–72.
7.
HuangCen1999“Management and Education of Migrant Labor in Overseas Chinese Enterprises in South China,”Asian and Pacific Migration Journal, 8(3):361–379.
8.
HunterJ., ed. 1995Japanese Women Working. London: Routledge.
9.
JinyunP.ZhixiongD.XinhuaiW.1997“Programs for Poverty Alleviation in China,” SAAT Working Papers, ILO-SAAT, New Delhi.
10.
KhanA.R.1997“Economic Growth and the Poor in China,” SAAT Working Papers, ILO-SAAT, New Delhi.
11.
KnightJ.SongL.HuaibinJ.1999“Chinese Rural Migrants in Urban Enterprises: Three Perspectives,”Journal of Development Studies, 35(3):73–102.
12.
LewisW.A.1952“Economic Development with Unlimited Supplies of Labor,”The Manchester School, 22:139–191.
13.
MalleeH.1995“China's Household Registration System under Reform,”Development and Change, 26(1):1–19.
14.
NanshengBai1998“The Effect of Labor Migration on Agriculture: An Empirical Study.” Paper presented at the International Symposium on “Labor Mobility and Migration in China and Asia,” 17–18 April, Beijing, The Hague.
15.
OshimaK.1990“The Present Condition of Inter-regional Movements of the Labor Force in Rural Jiangsu Province, China,”The Developing Economies, 28(4):202–220.
16.
PerottiE.C.SunL.ZouL.1999“State-owned versus Township and Village Enterprises in China,”Comparative Economic Studies, 51(2–3):151–179.
17.
PhongpaichitPasuk1982From Peasant Girls to Bangkok Masseuses. Geneva: ILO.
18.
RavensteinE.G.1889“The Laws of Migration,”Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, 48(2):167–227.
19.
RavensteinE.G.1885“The Laws of Migration,”Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, 52:241–301.
20.
RobertsK.D.1997“China's Tidal Wave' of Migrant Labor: What can we Learn from Mexican Undocumented Migration to the United States,”International Migration Review, 31(2):249–293.
21.
SabinL.1999“The Development of Urban Labor Markets: China's Urban Wage Curve, 1980–92,”Journal of Development Studies, 35(3):134–152.
22.
SaithAshwani1997“Emigration Pressures and Structural Change: Case Study of the Philippines.” International Migration Papers, No. 19. Geneva: ILO.
23.
SaithAshwani1996a“Filipino Migration — The Billion Dollar Question: Rich Pickings or the Wages of Despair.”Research Monograph prepared for the Southeast Asian and Pacific Team, ILO, Manila. 1996b “Reflections on South Asian Reforms in East Asian Perspective.” Discussion Paper No. 2. Geneva: ILO.
24.
SaithAshwani1995a“Household Resource Allocation, Labor Mobility and Gender Disparities: Are Women Getting Left Behind? Some Survey Findings from Sichuan and Zhejiang.” Unpublished paper based on primary field research data. New Delhi: ILO-SAAT. 1995b “From Collectives to Markets: Restructured Agriculture-Industry Linkages in rural China — Some Micro-Level Evidence,”Journal of Peasant Studies, 22(2):206–260.
25.
SaithAshwani1994“The Impact of Gulf Crisis on Migration and Remittances Flows: A Review and Lessons of the South Asian Experience.” Research Paper, ARTEP-ILO, New Delhi. 1993 “Chinese rural Industrialization: Some Lessons for Reforming and Developing Economies,” ARTEP Working Papers, ILO-ARTEP, New Delhi.
26.
SaithAshwani1992a“Absorbing External Shocks: The Gulf Crisis, International Migration Linkages and the Indian Economy, 1990 (with special reference to Kerala),”Development and Change, 23(1).
27.
SaithAshwani1992b“Adding Insult to Injury: Estimating Losses of Returning Migrants in the Gulf Crisis.” Working Paper, Institute of Social Studies. 1990 “Location, Linkage and Leakage: Malaysian Rural Industrialization Strategies in National Perspective.” In Promotion of Small-scale Industries and Strategies for Rural Industrialization. Edited by EsdertsH.J.SallehI. Md., Kuala Lumpur: Friedrich Ebert Stiftung.
28.
SaithAshwani1989“Macro-Economic Issues in International Labor Migration: A Review.” In To the Gulf and Back: Studies on the Economic Impact of Asian Labor Migration. Edited by AmjadR., New Delhi: UNDP/ARTEP/ILO.
29.
SaithAshwani1987aThe Re-emergence of the Chinese Peasantry: Aspects of Decollectivization. London: Croom-Helm.
30.
SaithAshwani1987b“Contrasting Experiences of Rural Industrialization: Are the East Asian Successes Transferable.” In Rural Industrialization and Employment in Asia. Edited by IslamR., New Delhi: ILO/ARTEP.
31.
SaithAshwani1984“China's New Population Policies: Rationale and Some Implications,”Development and Change, 15(3).
32.
SaithAshwaniTankhaAjay1997“Longitudinal Analysis of Structural Change in a North Indian Village, 1970–87.” In The Village in Asia Revisited. Edited by BremanKloosSaithAshwani. Delhi: Oxford University Press.
33.
SaithAshwaniChadhaG.K.1996Rural Industrialization in Post-Reform China: Issues and Policy Perspectives, SAAT-ILO, New Delhi.
34.
SaxonhouseG.R.1976“Country Girls and Communication Among Competitors in the Japanese Cotton-Spinning Industry.” In Japanese Industrialization and Its Social Consequences. Edited by PatrickH., Berkeley: University of California Press.
35.
SieversS.L.1983Flowers in Salt: The Beginnings of Feminist Consciousness in Modern Japan. California: Stanford University Press.
36.
TodaroM.P.1969“A Model of Labor Migration and Urban Unemployment in Less Developed Countries,”American Economic Review, 59:138–148.
37.
TomokoYamazaki1996“On the History of Asian Women's Exchanges,”Review of Japanese Culture and Society, Vol. VIII, December. (Translated by YasukoWachiBalistrieriElizabeth).
38.
TruongT.D.1988“Sex, Money and Morality: The Political Economy of Prostitution and Tourism in South East Asia.” Unpublished Ph.D dissertation, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam.
39.
XiangBiao1999“Xi, Relations Cluster, and the Formation of a Migrant Community in Contemporary China,”Asian and Pacific Migration Journal, 8(3):343–359.
40.
WakabayashiK.1990“Migration from Rural to Urban Areas in China,”The Developing Economies, 28(4):503–523.
41.
YanShan-Ping1990“The Movement of Labor in Chinese Rural Areas: With a Focus on Developed Regions,”The Developing Economies, 28(4):524–543.
42.
YangD.T.ZhouH.1998“Rural-Urban Disparity and Sectoral Labor Allocation in China,”Journal of Development Studies, 35(3):105–133.
43.
ZhangJinfeng1999“How do Institutional Arrangements Influence the Process of Rural Labour Transfer: The Case of the Rural to Urban Floating Population in China.” Unpublished MA dissertation, Institute of Social Studies, The Hague.
