Reality or pretense? Renouncing nationality and organized hypocrisy of the sovereignty of Taiwan

Abstract

Adopting Krasner’s thesis of organized hypocrisy, this research examined the institution of sovereignty in regard to the naturalization of migrant spouses in Taiwan. Using migrant spouses as a case study, this article argues that the hypocrisy of Taiwan’s sovereignty lies in demanding migrants to renounce their native nationality or cancel their household registration. This demand not only fails to prevent statelessness but also prompts the origin state to recognize or reject Taiwan’s sovereignty. The interactions between Taiwan and the origin states of migrant spouses from Japan, Vietnam and China underline the hypocrisy of Taiwan’s sovereignty. The more Taiwan insists on migrant spouses renouncing their original nationality, the more this destabilizes Taiwan’s sovereignty because of its lack of international recognition.

Keywords

sovereignty organized hypocrisy nationality statelessness household registration Taiwan

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Augustine-Adams

(2002) “She consents implicitly”: Women’s citizenship, marriage, and liberal political theory in late-nineteenth- and early-twentieth-century Argentina. Journal of Women’s History 13(4): 8–30.

Central News Agency (CNA) (2008) Vietnamese spouses become stateless after divorce? NIA: Impossible (越南籍配偶離婚無國籍移民署: 不可能發生). 11 March. Available at: http://www.epochtimes.com/b5/8/3/11/n2040864.htm.

Chamberlain

(2015) On autonomy and migration: The politics of statelessness. At the Interface/Probing the Boundaries 89: 3–28.

Chang

J-LJ

(2010) Taiwan’s participation in the World Health Organization: The U.S. “facilitator” role. American Foreign Policy Interests 32(3): 131–146.

Chao

(2004) Imagined modernities, transnational marriage and border control: A case study of Taiwan’s “mainland brides” [現代性想像與國界管理的衝突：以中國婚姻移民女性為研究案例]. Taiwanese Journal of Sociology [台灣社會學刊] 32(June): 59–102. [In Chinese].

Chao

(2005) Household registration, social welfare distribution and border control: A case study of regulating mainland spouses in Taiwan [社福資源分配的戶籍邏輯與國境管理的限制：由大陸配偶的入出境管控機制談起]. Taiwanese: A Radical Quarterly in Social Studies [台灣社會研究季刊] 59(September): 43–90. [In Chinese].

Chen

(2009) Gendered borders: The historical formation of women’s nationality under law in Taiwan. Positions 17(2): 289–314.

Chen

C-YJ

T-L

(2005) Public attitudes toward Taiwan’s immigration policies [台灣民眾對外來配偶移民政策的態度]. Taiwanese Sociology [台灣社會學] 10(1): 48–95. [In Chinese].

Chen

LT-S

(2012) Stateless or belonging to Taiwan or PRC: Nationality and passport of overseas Chinese. In: Tan

C-B

(ed.) Routledge Handbook of the Chinese Diaspora, London, UK: Routledge, pp. 310–322.

10.

Chen

M-H

(2010) Sexualized border control: The investigation of ‘phony marriages’ and the exclusion of Chinese migrants/sex workers [性化的國境管理：「假結婚」查察與中國移民／性工作者的排除]. Taiwanese Sociology [台灣社會學] 19(June): 55–105. [In Chinese].

11.

Cheng

(2013) Making foreign women the mother of our nation: The excluding and assimilating immigrant wives from outside. Asian Ethnicity 14(2): 157–179.

12.

Cheng

(2016) Cross-strait marriages and immigration policies. In: Shubert

(ed.) Handbook of Modern Taiwan Politics and Society, London, UK: Routledge, pp. 447–463.

13.

Cheng

(2017) She cares because she is a mother: The intersection of citizenship and motherhood of Southeast Asian immigrant women in Taiwan. In: Fresnoza-Flot

Ricordeau

(eds) Gender, Migration and Citizenship: Revisiting Southeast Asian International Marriages, London, UK: Routledge, pp. 158–175.

14.

Deans

(2001) A democracy craving for recognition: A pessimistic view of the impact of democratisation on Taiwan’s international status. China Perspectives 34(March–April): 35–47.

15.

De Hart

(2006a) The unity of the family? Legal perspectives on nationally mixed marriage in postwar Europe. In: Waldis

Byron

(eds) Migration and Marriage: Heterogamy and Homogamy in A Changing World, Zurich, Switzerland: LIT Verlag, GmbH and Co. KG Wien, pp. 179–199.

16.

De Hart

(2006b) The morality of Maria Toet: Gender, citizenship and the construction of the nation-state. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 32(1): 49–68.

17.

Epstein

(1978) Ethos and Identity: Three Studies in Ethnicity, London, UK: Tavistock Publications.

18.

Executive Yuan (EY) (1990) The Draft Bill of the Act Governing Relations between People of the Taiwan Area and the Mainland Area Submitted to the Legislative Yuan. The Legislative Yuan General No. 1554, Initiative of Government No. 3933. [立法院議案關係文書院總第一五五四號，政府提案第三九三三號，中華民國七十九年十二月五日印發，案由：行政院函請審議「台灣地區與大陸地區人民關係條例草案」案]. 5 December 1990 [In Chinese].

19.

Executive Yuan (EY) (2002) The Draft Bill of the Act Governing Relations between People of the Taiwan Area and the Mainland Area Submitted to the Legislative Yuan. The Legislative Yuan General No. 1554, Initiative of Government No. 8786. [立法院議案關係文書院總第一五五四號，政府提案第八七八六號，中華民國九十一年十月十六日印發，案由：行政院函 [In Chinese].

20.

Feinberg

(2006) Elusive Equality: Gender, Citizenship, and the Limits of Democracy in Czechoslovakia, 1918–1950, Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.

21.

Friedman

(2015) Exceptional States: Chinese Immigrants and Taiwanese Sovereignty, Oakland, CA: University of California Press.

22.

Grossman

(2001) Nationality and the unrecognised state. International & Comparative Law Quarterly 50(4): 849–876.

23.

(1995) Conflicts of Divided Nations: The Cases of China and Korea, Westport, CT: Praeger.

24.

Hayden

(2008) From exclusion to containment: Arendt, sovereign power, and statelessness. Societies Without Borders 3(2): 248–269.

25.

PSC

(2006) The impact of the U.N. fish stocks agreement on Taiwan’s participation in international fisheries fora. Ocean Development and International Law 37(2): 133–148.

26.

Hsiao H-P (2010) The negotiation and performance of cultural citizenship by female Japanese spouses in Taiwan [文化公民權協商與展演：以在台日籍女性配偶的生活為例]. Master’s Degree dissertation. National Sun Yat-Sen University, Kaohsiung [In Chinese].

27.

Hsiao

MH-H

(2003) Taiwan and Southeast Asia: Go South Policy and Vietnamese Brides, Taipei, China: Center for Asia-Pacific Area Studies, Academia Sinica.

28.

Huang

L-L

(2006) A world without strangers? Taiwan’s new households in the nexus of China and Southeast Asia relations. International Development Planning Review 28(4): 447–474.

29.

Huang

Y-H

Liaw

(2012) Taiwan’s economic diplomacy in Vietnam from the 1990s to the early twenty-first century. East Asia: An International Quarterly 29(4): 355–376.

30.

Huang

Wang

(2013) Chinese question in the Olympic movement: From the perspective of Taiwan. International Journal of the History of Sport 30(17): 2052–2068.

31.

Hughes

(1999) Taiwan and Chinese Nationalism: National Identity and Status in International Society, London, UK: Routledge.

32.

Jacobs

(2005) ‘Taiwanisation’ in Taiwan’s politics. In: Makeham

Hsiau

A-C

(eds) Cultural, Ethnic, and Political Nationalism in Contemporary Taiwan, New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 7–54.

33.

Kawaguchi D and Lee S (2012) Brides for Sale: Cross-Border Marriages and Female Immigration. Discussion Paper Series. Forschungsinstitut zur Zukunft der Arbeit [Institute for the Study of Labor], No. 6458. Available at: http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:101:1-201208065409.

34.

Kingston

(2013) “A forgotten human rights crisis”: Statelessness and issue (non) emergence. Human Rights Review 14(2): 73–87.

35.

Krasner

(1999) Sovereignty: Organized Hypocrisy, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

36.

Kuo

Y-H

(2011) Subversions of the social hierarchy: Social closure as adaptation strategy by the female marriage migrants of Taiwan. Journal of Comparative Research in Anthropology and Sociology 2(1): 85–101.

37.

Lan

P-C

(2008) Migrant women’s bodies as boundary markers: Reproductive crisis and sexual control in the ethnic frontiers of Taiwan. Signs 33(4): 833–861.

38.

Lee

T-H

(1999) Understanding Taiwan: Bridging the perception gap. Foreign Affairs 78(6): 9–14.

39.

Legislative Yuan (LY) (1992a) Record of Floor Meeting. 26 June 1992. (院會紀錄). The Official Gazette of the Legislative Yuan (立法院公報第八十一卷五十二期) 81(52): 47–77. [In Chinese].

40.

Legislative Yuan (LY) (1992b) Record of the Sixth Joint Deliberation Meeting of the Draft Bill of the Act Governing the Relations between the People of Taiwan Area and Mainland Area by the Committees of Home Affairs, Judiciary, and Organic Laws and Statutes (Eighty-Ninth Session of the First Legislative Yuan). 23 June 1992. The Official Gazette of the Legislative Yuan [立法院公報第八十一卷二十六期] 81(26): 607–653. [In Chinese].

41.

Legislative Yuan (LY) (1992c) Record of Floor Meeting [院會紀錄]. 9 January 1992. The Official Gazette of the Legislative Yuan [立法院公報第八十一卷第五期] 81(5): 26–63. [In Chinese].

42.

Legislative Yuan (LY) (1992d) Record of Floor Meeting[院會紀錄]. 14 January 1992. The Official Gazette of the Legislative Yuan [立法院公報第八十一卷第六期] 81(6): 6–25. [In Chinese].

43.

Legislative Yuan (LY) (1998a) Minutes of the First Joint Deliberation Meeting of the Draft Bill of the Immigration Act by the Committees of Home and Frontier Affairs, Foreign and Overseas Chinese Affairs, Transport and Communication, and Judicial Affairs, the Sixth Session of the Third Legislative Yuan. 2 November 1998. The Legislative Yuan Gazette [立法院公報第八十七卷第四十五期] 87(45): 183–232. [In Chinese].

44.

Legislative Yuan (LY) (1998b) Minutes of the Second Joint Deliberation Meeting of the Draft Bill of the Immigration Act of the Committees of Home and Frontier Affairs, Foreign and Overseas Chinese Affairs, Transport and Communication, and Judicial Affairs (Sixth Session of the Third Legislative Yuan). 16 December 1998. The Legislative Yuan Gazette [立法院公報第八十七卷第五十期] 87(50): 249–305. [In Chinese].

45.

Legislative Yuan (LY) (2003) Record of Floor Meeting [院會紀錄]. 9 October 2003. The Official Gazette of the Legislative Yuan [立法院公報第九十二卷第四十一期] 92(41): 284–327. [In Chinese].

46.

Legislative Yuan (LY) (2016) Minutes of the 9th Plenary Meeting of the Committee of Home Affairs, the 1st Session of the 9th Legislative Yuan. 18 April 2016. The Legislative Yuan Gazette [立法院公報第105 卷第29 期委員會紀錄] 105(29): 1–80. [In Chinese].

47.

Liberty Times (2007) Cambodian brides may become stateless. 4 March 2007. Available at: news.ltn.com.tw/news/politics/paper/118474 [In Chinese].

48.

C-Y

(2000) Politics of foreign labor policy in Taiwan. Journal of Asian and African Studies 35(1): 113–131.

49.

McKinsey

(2007) Divorce leaves some Vietnamese women broken-hearted and stateless. UNHCR. 14 February 2007. Available at: http://www.unhcr.org/45d324428.html.

50.

McKinsey K (2009) Viet Nam sets the pace for Asia with new law to prevent statelessness. UNHCR. 1 July 2009. Available at: http://www.unhcr.org/news/latest/2009/7/4a4b809d9/viet-nam-sets-pace-asia-new-law-prevent-statelessness.html.

51.

McKinsey K (2010) Preventing statelessness: Southeast Asian countries share lessons. UNHCR. 29 October 2010. Available at: http://www.unhcr.org/news/latest/2010/10/4ccae1009/preventing-statelessness-southeast-asian-countries-share-lessons.html.

52.

Ministry of the Interior (MoI) (2015) Statistical Yearbook of Interior (Numbers of the Acquisition of ROC Nationality). Available at: http://sowf.moi.gov.tw/stat/year/list.htm [In Chinese].

53.

Morello

(1966) The International Legal Status of Formosa, The Hague, The Netherlands: Martinus Nijhoff.

54.

National Immigration Agency (NIA) (2017) Numbers of foreign spouses and Mainland spouses (including spouses from Hong Kong and Macao). 18 January 2017. Available at http://www.immigration.gov.tw/ct.asp?xItem=1325434&ctNode=29699&mp=1 [In Chinese].

55.

National Security Council (NSC) (2006) National Security Report, Taipei, China: National Security Council. [In Chinese].

56.

Peng

S-Y

(1997) Economic relations between Taiwan and Southeast Asia: A review of Taiwan’s Go South policy. Wisconsin International Law Journal 16(3): 639–660.

57.

Rigger

(2002) Nationalism versus citizenship in the Republic of China on Taiwan. In: Goldman

Perry

(eds) Changing Meanings of Citizenship in Modern China, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, pp. 353–372.

58.

Roy

(2003) Taiwan: A Political History, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

59.

Scott

(1929) Problems of nationality: International status of married women. Advocate of Peace through Justice 91(3): 137–140.

60.

Sheu

Y-H

(2007) Full responsibility with partial citizenship: Immigrant wives in Taiwan. Social Policy and Administration 41(2): 179–196.

61.

Studer

(2001) Citizenship as contingent national belonging: Married women and foreigners in twentieth-century Switzerland. Gender & History 13(3): 622–654.

62.

The China Post (2011) Taiwan recalls envoy to Philippines. 11 February 2011. Available at: http://www.chinapost.com.tw/asia/philippines/2011/02/08/290282/Taiwan-recalls.htm.

63.

Tsai C-C (2012) An analysis on the equality of naturalisation regulations for foreign spouses and mainland spouses and a critique on the protection of their rights and lives in Taiwan [論外籍及大陸配偶在臺入籍規範之權益衡平性－兼論兩者在臺生活權益保障之現況及檢討]. Paper presented at the Conference on Population Movement and Law Enforcement, 13 November 2012, Taipei [In Chinese].

64.

Tsai C-J (2008) An Analysis on Basic Family Rights of Foreign Spouses and Expulsion: A Case Study of the Verdict of Su 20581 by Taipei High Administrative Court in 2006 [自外籍配偶家庭基本權之保障論驅逐出國處分 - 評臺北高等行政法院95年度訴字第02581號判決]. Paper presented at the Conference on Border Security and Population Movement, 8 December 2008, Taipei [In Chinese].

65.

Tsai

M-C

(2011) ‘Foreign brides’ meet ethnic politics in Taiwan. International Migration Review 45(3): 243–268.

66.

Tseng

W-C

(1999) An Analysis on the Immigration Act [入出國移民法釋論], Taipei, China: Cheng Chung. [In Chinese].

67.

Tseng

Y-F

Komiya

(2011) Classism in immigration control and migrant integration. In: Ngo

T-W

Wang

H-Z

(eds) Politics of Difference in Taiwan, London, NY: Routledge, pp. 98–115.

68.

Tseng

Y-C

Cheng

Fell

(2014) The politics of the mainland spouses’ rights’ movement in Taiwan. In: Fell

Chiu

K-F

Lin

(eds) Migration to and from Taiwan, London, UK: Routledge, pp. 205–226.

69.

Tucker

(2011) Strait Talk: United States–Taiwan Relations and the Crisis with China, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

70.

United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) (2010) Good practices: Addressing statelessness in South East Asia. Report of the Regional Expert Roundtable on Good Practices for the Identification, Prevention and Reduction of Statelessness and the Protection of Stateless Persons in South East Asia, Bangkok, 28 to 29 October 2010. Available at: http://www.unhcr.org/protection/statelessness/4d7de47f9/good-practices-addressing-statelessness-south-east-asia-report-regional.html.

71.

Van Waas

(2012) Fighting statelessness and discriminatory nationality laws in Europe. European Journal of Migration and Law 14(3): 243–260.

72.

Wachspress

(2009) Rethinking sovereignty with reference to history and anthropology. International Journal of Law in Context 5(3): 315–330.

73.

Wang

H-Z

(2008) Taiwanizing female immigrant spouses and materializing differential citizenship. Citizenship Studies 12(1): 91–106.

74.

Wang

H-Z

(2011) Immigration trends and policy changes in Taiwan. Asian and Pacific Migration Journal 20(2): 169–194.

75.

Y-T

(2008) Taiwan international family in a difficult situation of the legislation. Taiwan International Law Quarterly 5(1): 51–82.

76.

Xinhua News Agency (2002) Indonesian consulate general in HK reiterates One-China policy. Available at: http://www.china.org.cn/english/international/39718.htm.

77.

Xinhua News Agency (2017) Vietnam reaffirms adherence to one-China policy. 13 November. Available at: http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2017-11/13/c_136748651.htm.

78.

Yang

C-J

Chien

H-C

(2010) Could Taiwan be included in UNFCCC negotiations? Climate Policy (Earthscan) 10(3): 317–321.

79.

Yang

W-Y

Lee

P-R

(2009) The citizenship dilemma of mainlander spouses in Taiwan: The conspiracy of nationalism and patriarchy [大陸配偶的公民權困境一國族與父權的共謀]. Taiwan Democracy Quarterly [臺灣民主季刊] 6(3): 47–86. [In Chinese].

80.

Yeh

C-H

(2014) The legal status of foreign spouse - from the aspects of entry, permanent stay, and naturalization [論外籍配偶的法律地位－以入境、居留與歸化為中心]. Taiwan International Law Quarterly [台灣國際法季刊] 11(3): 7–26. [In Chinese].

81.

Yuval-Davis

Anthias

(1989) Woman–Nation–State, London, UK: Macmillan.