This article argues that restrictive laws against migrants in Beijing, China have some unexpected consequences which turn out to be conducive to the survival and development of migrant businesses. First, restrictive and discriminatory legislation compels migrants to cooperate with locals, illegally or semi-legally, in order to get into the market. Locals are willing to provide migrants with protection in exchange for monetary interests. The cooperative relationship between migrants and locals renders the state and its agents unable or unwilling to strictly enforce the restrictive laws. Second, in response to discriminatory and restrictive regulations, migrants turn to informal rules and communal solidarity. Third, given the hostile legal environment, migrants tend to be ambivalent about settling down in big cities. As a result, they work harder and spend less. These factors enable migrants to survive the hostile legal environment and achieve considerable economic success. In turn, their economic success gives them more bargaining power to consolidate their cooperation with locals and gain a de facto existence in the city.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BaumgartnerM.P.1984“Social Control from Below.” In Toward a General Theory of Social Control, Vol. 1. Edited by BlackDonald. London: Academic Press.
2.
Beijing Labor Bureau1995Waidi laijing renyuan guanli shiyong shouche (Management Manual for Migrants in Beijing). Beijing: Beijing Labor Bureau.
3.
Beijing Statistic Bureau2002“2001 nian Beijing wailai renkou xingshi he bianhua moshi” (Current Situation and Changing Pattern of Migrants in Beijing in 2001). Available at http://chall.bjstats.gov.cn:77/tjbgpc/htm/zl2002–04.htm, accessed on 6 March 2002.
4.
BejaJean PhilippeBonninMichel1995“The Destruction of the “Village,””China Perspective, 2 Nov./Dec.:21–25.
5.
BonacichEdna1973“A Theory of Middleman Minorities,”American Sociological Review, 39:583–594.
6.
DavinDelia1998Internal Migration in Contemporary China. New York: St. Martin's Press.
7.
HareDenise1999“‘Push’ versus ‘Pull’ Factors in Migration Outflows and Returns: Determinants of Migration Status and Spell Duration Among China's Rural Population,”The Journal of Development Review, 18(3):46.
8.
HeXin F.2003a“Legal Evasion Among the Advancement of Rule of Law,”Canadian Journal of Law and Society, 17(2). Forthcoming.
9.
HeXin F.2003b“Why Do They not Obey the Law.” Unpublished manuscript.
10.
HeXin F.2001“Regulating Rural-Urban Migrants in Beijing: Insitutional Conflict and Ineffective Campaigns,”Stanford Journal of International Law, 39(2): 177–206.
11.
HuXiaobo2002“Political Economy of the Floating Chinese Population,”Journal of Contemporary Asia, 32(3):536–552.
12.
Jong-HoJeong2000Renegotiating with the State: The Challenge of Floating Population and the Emergence of New Urban Space in Contemporary China. PhD diss., Yale University.
13.
LandaJanet1994Trust, Ethnicity and Identity: Beyond the New Institutional Ethnic Trading Networks, Contract Law, and Gift-Exchange. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
14.
LomnitzLarissa Adler1988“Informal Exchange Networks in Formal Systems: A Theoretical Model,”Anthropologist, 90(1):42–55.
15.
MaLaurence J.C.XiangBiao1998“Native Place, Migration and the Emergence of Peasant Enclaves in Beijing,”The China Quarterly, 155:546–581.
16.
PortesAlejandroSensenbrennerJulia1993“Embeddedness and Immigration: Notes on the Social Determinants of Economic Action,”American Journal of Sociology, 98(6):1320–1350.
17.
PortesAlejandroGuarnizoLuis E.1991“Tropical Capitalists: US Bound Immigration and Small Enterprise Development in the Dominican Republic.” In Migration, Remittances and Small Business Development, Mexico and Caribbean Basin Countries. Edited by Diaz-BriquetsS.WeintraubS., Boulder: Westview Press.
18.
SchwartzRichard D.1954“Social Factors in the Development of Legal Control: A Case Study of Two Israeli Settlements,”Yale Law Journal, 63:471.
19.
SiuPaul1952“The Sojourner,”American Journal of Sociology, 58:34–44.
20.
SmartJosephine1989The Political Economy of Street Hawkers in Hong Kong. Hong Kong: Centre of Asian Studies, University of Hong Kong.
21.
SolingerDorothy1999Contesting Citizenship in Urban China: Peasant Migrants, the State and the Logic of the Market. Berkeley: University of California Press.
22.
SteinPeter1984Legal Institutions: The Development of Dispute Settlement. London: Butterworths.
23.
WangChun-Guang1995Shehui Liudong he Shehui Chonggou: Jingchen Zhejiang Cun Yanjiu (Social Mobilization and Social Reconstruction: A Research on “Zhejiang Village” in Capital Beijing). Hangzhou: Zhejiang ren min chu ban she (Zhejiang People's Press).
24.
WinnJane K.1994“Relational Practices and the Marginalization of Law: Informal Financial Practices of Small Businesses in Taiwan,”Law and Society Review, 28:193.
25.
WongSimon1998Migrants in China: Leaving the Communes, Entering the Market, Still Under the State. J.S.M. diss., Stanford University.
26.
WoonYuen-Fong1999“Labor Migration in the 1990s: Homeward Orientation of Migrants in the Pearl River Delta Region and Its Implications for Interior China,”Modern China, 25(4):475–512.
27.
XiangBiao2000A Community Beyond Boundaries. Beijing: Sanlian Shudian.
28.
XiangBiao1999“The Networking Logic of Power: Big Men in a Migrant Community in Contemporary China.” Paper presented at the British Association for Chinese Studies conference on Social Marginalization, 6 September, School of Oriental and African Studies, London.
29.
XiangBiao1998“Taobi, Lianhe yu Biaoda: Zhejiangcun de Guzhi” (Escape, Ally and Express), Zhongguo Shehui Kexue Jikan (China's Social Science Quarterly), 1(22)91:112.
30.
XiangBiao1996“How to Create A Visible ‘Non-State Space’ through Migration and Marketized Traditional Networks: An Account of A Migrant Community in China.” Paper presented at the international conference on Chinese Rural Labor Force Mobility, 25–27 June, Beijing.
31.
XiangBiao1994Beijing You Ge “Zhejiang Cun” (There is a “Zhejiang Village” in Beijing), Chengshi Jingji Quyu Jingji (Urban Economy and Regional Economy)1:33–50.
32.
XiongDaxin1995“The Explanation Regarding the Draft of “Beijing Management Regulation on Migrant Laborers and Entrepreneurs.” In Manual Book on Migrant Laborers and Entrepreneurs Management. Beijing Labor Bureau.
33.
ZhaoYaoyui2001“Rural-to-Urban Migration in China: The Past and the Present.” In Rural Labor Flows in China. Edited by WestLoraine A.ZhaoYaohui. Berkeley: University of California Press.
34.
ZhangLi2001Strangers in the City: Reconfigurations of Space, Power and Identity in China's Floating Population. Palo Alto: Stanford University Press.
