An Oncology Patient's Choice to Forgo Nonvolitional Nutrition Support: Ethical Considerations

Abstract

A 76-year-old patient with metastatic carcinoid tumor who had difficulty tolerating an oral diet and jejunostomy feedings became dehydrated and failed to thrive. His jejunostomy feeding regimen was manipulated to improve tolerance without success. Although his medical condition was untreatable, he was not considered terminally ill, and he was determined to be a reasonable candidate for home total parenteral nutrition (HTPN). However, he thought HTPN was an "excessive measure," and despite lengthy discussions with him by members of both the Hematology/Oncology and Nutrition Support services about the potential benefits of HTPN, he refused any further interventions involving nonvolitional nutrition support (jejunostomy feedings and HTPN). He was discharged to home receiving an oral diet as tolerated in the care of his family and hospice. This case illustrates the ethical considerations surrounding a patient's decision to forgo medical care that might prolong life.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Jonsen A. , Siefler M. , Winslade J. : Clinical ethics: A practical approach to ethical decisions in clinical medicine , 3rd ed. New York: McGraw Hill, 1992.

McCamish M. , Crocker N. : Enteral and parenteral nutrition support of terminally ill patients: practical and ethical perspectives. Hospice Journal 1993;9:107-29.

Kvols L. : Metastatic carcinoid tumors and the malignant carcinoid syndrome. Ann N Y Acad Sci 1994;733:464-70.

Marshall J. , Bodnarchuk G. : Carcinoid tumors of the gut. Our experience over three decades and review of the literature. J Clin Gastroenterol 1993 ;16:123-9.

Norton J. : Surgical management of carcinoid tumors: role of debulking and surgery for patients with advanced disease. Digestion 1994;55(Suppl):98-103.

Boisaubin E. : Legal decisions affecting the limitation of nutritional support. Hospice Journal 1993;9:131-47.

Goldstein M. , Fuller J. : Intensity of treatment in malnutrition: The ethical considerations. Prim Care 1994;21:191-206.

Silverman H. , Vinicky J. , Gasner M. : Advance directives: Implications for critical care. Crit Care Med 1992;20:1027-31.

The Layman's Guide to Death with Dignity. North Carolina Medical Society, North Carolina Hospital Association and the Duke Endowment. Durham, NC 1990.