This article presents a critical discussion of Antonovsky's salutogenic model, focusing on its instrumentalisation in the Sense of Coherence questionnaire and implications for health care research. The critical discussion is related to three themes: a. The divorce between theory and method, b. The Sense of Coherence questionnaire: a «supra-cultural instrument»? and c. Numbers, normality and the social construction of reality. The author concludes that extreme cautiousness and further study is necessary before the Sense of Coherence questionnaire should be considered adequate for use in applied clinical research.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AntonovskyA.Health, Stress and Coping. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1979.
2.
AntonovskyA.Unraveling the Mystery of Health: How People manage Stress and Stay Well. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1987.
3.
AntonovskyA.Hälsans Mysterium. Stockholm: Natur och Kultur, 1991.
4.
TishelmanC.Making Sense of Sickness Experience. Cancer patients' perspectives on their sickness and care in urban Sweden. Aspects of relevance for nursing. Stockholm: Karolinska Institutet, 1993. Doctoral dissertation.
5.
LangiusABjörvellHAntonovskyA.The Sense of Coherence Concept and its Relation to Personality Traits in Swedish Samples. Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences1992, Vol.6, no3, p 165–171.
6.
AntonovskyA.The structure and properties of the Sense of Coherence scale. Social Science & Medicine1993, vol 36, no 6, p 725–733.
7.
BergerPLuckmannT.The Social Construction of Reality: A treatise in the sociology of experience. Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday and Co., 1966.
8.
AntonovskyA.Complexity, Conflict, Chaos, Coherence, Coercion and Civility. Soc Sci Med1993, vol 37, no 8, p 969–981.
9.
TishelmanCTaubeASachsL.Self-reported symptom distress in cancer patients: Reflections of disease, illness and sickness. Soc Sci Med1991, vol 33, no 11, p 1229–1240.
10.
BernsteinJCarmelS.Trait anxiety and the sense of coherence. Psychol Rep1987, no 60, p 1000.
11.
AntonovskyA.Salutogenesis: The Sense of Coherence Newsletter. 1993, October, no 8.
12.
KuritzenB.«Använd yxan inom sjukvården». Dagens Nyheter March 1, 1995, p A4.
13.
AntonovskyA.Salutogenesis: The Sense of Coherence Newsletter. 1994, January, no. 9.
14.
AntonovskyASagyS.Confronting developmental tasks in the retirement transition. The gerontologist1990, vol. 30, no. 3, p 362–368.
15.
AntonovskyA.Salutogenesis: The Sense of Coherence Newsletter. 1991, April, no. 2.
16.
PattersonJ.The Dread Disease: Cancer and Modern American Culture. Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 1987.
17.
Del Vecchio GoodMGoodBSchafferCLindS.American oncology and the discourse on hope. Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry1990, vol. 14, p. 59–79.
18.
GordonD.Embodying illness, embodying cancer. Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry1990, vol. 14, p. 275–297.
19.
SaillantF.Discourse, knowledge and experience of cancer: A life story. Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry1990, vol. 14, p. 81–104.
20.
GordonDR. Culture, Cancer and Communication in Italy. Anthropologies of Medicine, 1991, Vol. 7, p. 137–156.
21.
TishelmanC.Att Insjukna och att tillfriskna: Människors förklaringar till att ha insjuknat och tillfrisknat vid cancer. In: QvarsellR.RosénA-S, eds. Om nyttan av att vara sjuk: Forskningsrådsnämnden, 1995.
22.
TishelmanC.Kan Antonovsky's «salutogeniska» modell anvåndas inom vården? Vård: Utbildning, utveckling, forskning 1990, No.3–4, p. 43–48.
23.
SachsL.The Cultural Construction and Subtext of Prevention, submitted for publication.
GainesAD. Cultural Constructivism: Sickness Histories and the Understanding of Ethnomedicines beyond Critical Medical Anthropologies. In: PfleidererBBibeauG, eds. Anthropologies of Medicine: A Colloquium on West European and North American Perspectives. Germany: Vieweg, 1991, vol 7.
26.
GeertzC.The Interpretation of Cultures. London: Hutchinson & Co., 1973.
27.
AdelswärdVSachsL.The meaning of 6.8. submitted for publication.
28.
GilliganC.In a Different Voice. Psychological Theory and Women's Development. Cambridge Massachusetts: Harvård University Press, 1982.
