In studies of China’s economic rise and political system, multiyear comprehensive and sectoral plans issued by the national government tend to be played down as futile efforts at reigning in a political economy increasingly driven by market incentives and decentralized decisions. Contrary to this, we provide evidence that China’s planning system has been transformed alongside the economic transition, yet remains central to almost all domains of public policy making and the political institutions that have fostered China’s high-speed growth and economic stability. The incorporation of experimental programs into macro-plans, a tiered hierarchy of policy oversight, newly introduced mid-course plan evaluations, and systematic top-level policy review have allowed Chinese planners to play a central role in economic policy making without succumbing to the rigidity traps that debased traditional planned economies. By better understanding how the planning cycle influences incentives and resources of successive layers of bureaucracies and jurisdictions, and how it updates itself and adapts to new challenges, it is possible to explain a greater proportion of the Chinese policy-making process, including many of its successes and pathologies.
Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection, and Quarantine (2006) 关于贯彻落实“千家企业节能行动实施方案”的通知 (Notice on the implementation of the “Implementation plan for the Thousand Enterprise energy conservation program”). 国质检量函 174 号 (AQSIQ document 174) http://jls.aqsiq.gov.cn/gcjlxxzh/200610/t20061021_1501.htm.
2.
AMR [Academy of Macroeconomic Research of the NDRC] (2007) Task Force of the Research Institute for State Land and Regional Economy, “我国主体功能区” (China’s development priority zones). 宏观经济管理4: 3–10.
3.
BramallChris (2009) Chinese Economic Development. London: Routledge.
4.
BrandtLorenRawskiThomas G. [eds.] (2008) China’s Great Economic Transformation. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.
5.
CCP Central Committee (1993) “Decision of the CCP Central Committee on Some Issues Concerning the Establishment of a Socialist Market Economic Structure” (official translation). Xinhua News Agency News Bulletin 16388, Nov. 17.
6.
CCP Central Committee (2003) 党的十六届三中全会《关于完善社会主义市场经济体制若干问题的决定》(Decision of the 3rd plenum of the 16th CCP Central Committee on some issues concerning the improvement of the structure of the socialist market economy). Nov. www.people.com.cn/GB/shizheng/1024/2145119.html.
7.
ChaiJoseph C. H. [ed.] (1998) China: Transition to a Market Economy. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press.
8.
ChangXin常欣 (2006) “第九个五年计划的制定和实施” (Formulation and implementation of the ninth five-year plan). Pp. 603–60 in Liu Guoguang, 2006.
9.
ChenJinhua陈锦华 (2005) 国事忆述 (Recollections on state affairs). Beijing: Zhonggong dangshi chubanshe.
ChengSiwei成思危 (2004) “论中国社会主义市场经济制度下的发展计划” (On development plans under China’s socialist market economy). 公共管理学报 11, 2 (May): 5.
12.
ChowGregory C. (2007) China’s Economic Transformation. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
13.
ChungJae HoLaiHongyiJooJang-Hwan (2009) “Assessing the ‘revive the northeast’ programme: origins, policies and implementation.” China Q. 197: 108–25.
14.
COD [CCP Central Organization Department) [ed.] (2009) 建立促进科学发展的干部考核评价机制十二讲 (Twelve statements on creating a cadre appraisal mechanism to promote scientific development). Beijing: Zhongguo fangzheng.
15.
DuPing杜平 (2010) “区域规划的演变与展望” (Evolution and prospects of macro-regional planning). Pp. 79–97 in Yang Weimin, 2010.
16.
EvansPeter (1995) Embedded Autonomy: States and Industrial Transformation. Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press.
17.
Guangdong Province Development and Reform Commission (2008) 关于广东省“十一五”规划纲要中期评估及部分目标调整草案的报告 (Report on mid-term evaluation of Guangdong province’s eleventh five-year plan outline and draft target adjustments). Report presented by Commission Chairman Li Miaojun 李妙娟 to the 7th plenary meeting of the Standing Committee of the 11th People’s Congress of Guangdong Province. www.gddpc.gov.cn/fgzl/fzgh/zqpg/200812/t20081208_27052.htm.
18.
Guangdong Province Economic and Trade Commission (2006) 关于印发广东省重点耗能企业“双千节能行动”实施方案的通知 (粤经贸环资 [2006] 814号) (Notice on the distribution of Guangdong province’s key energy consuming enterprises “dual thousand enterprise energy conservation initiative” implementation plan [Guangdong Economic and Trade Commission document 814, 2006]). www.gdei.gov.cn/zwgk/tzgg/2006/200612/t20061205_54132.html.
19.
Guangdong Province Economic and Trade Commission (2008) 关于调整广东省千家企业节能行动企业名单及进一步加强节能监管的通知 (粤经贸环资 [2008] 643号) (Notice on adjusting Guangdong province’s thousand enterprise energy conservation initiative enterprise list and progressively strengthening energy conservation supervision [Guangdong Economic and Trade Commission document 643, 2008]). www.gddpc.gov.cn/fgzl/nygzn/nyzc/200812/t20081210_27156.htm.
20.
Guangdong Province People’s Government (2006a) 广东省国民经济和社会发展十一五规划纲要 (Guangdong province’s eleventh five-year plan for economic and social development). Mar. 10. www.gd.gov.cn/govpub/fzgh/sywgy/0200607260010.htm.
21.
Guangdong Province People’s Government (2006b) 关于进一步加强广东省节能工作的意见 (粤府 [2006] 120号) (Opinions on the progressive strengthening of Guangdong province’s energy conservation work [Guangdong government document 120, 2006]). http://search.gd.gov.cn/detail?record=251&channelid=8907.
22.
Guangdong Province People’s Government (2006c) 关于印发广东省“十一五”期间单位生产总值能源消耗降低指标计划分解方案的通知 (粤府 [2006] 125号) (Notice on the dissemination of the target allocation plan for Guangdong province’s unit-GDP energy conservation plan during the eleventh five-year plan [Guangdong government document 125, 2006]). No longer available online.
23.
Guangdong Province People’s Government (2007) 印发广东省节能减排综合性工作方案的通知 (粤府 [2007] 66号) (Notice of the publication of a comprehensive work plan for Guangdong province’s energy conservation and emissions reduction [Guangdong government document 66, 2007]). http://search.gd.gov.cn/detail?record=164&channelid=8907.
24.
Guangdong Province People’s Government Office (2008) 印发广东省单位GDP能耗考核体系实施方案的通知 (粤府办 [2008] 20 号) (Notice of the dissemination of the implementation plan for methods to implement Guangdong province’s unit-GDP energy conservation evaluation system [Guangdong government office document 20, 2006]). http://search.gd.gov.cn/detail?record=66&channelid=8907.
HamrinCarol LeeZhaoSuisheng [eds.] (1995) Decision-Making in Deng’s China: Perspectives from Insiders. Armonk, NY: M.E. Sharpe.
27.
HeilmannSebastian (2008) “Policy experimentation in China’s economic rise.” Studies in Comparative International Development 43, 1: 1–26.
28.
HeilmannSebastian (2010) “Economic governance: authoritarian upgrading and innovative potential.” Pp. 109–26 in FewsmithJoseph (ed.), China Today, China Tomorrow: Domestic Politics, Economy, and Society. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
29.
HeilmannSebastian (2011) “Making plans for markets: policies for the long term in China.” Harvard Asia Q. 13, 2: 33–40.
30.
HeilmannSebastian (2012) “China’s core executive in economic policy.” Paper presented at the conference “Power in the Making: Governing and Being Governed in Contemporary China,”Oxford Univ., Mar. 2012.
31.
HeilmannSebastianHofemAndreasShihLea (2013) “National planning and local technology zones: experimental governance in China’s torch program.” China Q. (forthcoming).
32.
HeilmannSebastianPerryElizabeth J.(2011) “Embracing uncertainty: guerrilla policy style and adaptive governance.” Pp. 1–29 in HeilmannPerry (eds.), Mao’s Invisible Hand: The Political Foundations of Adaptive Governance in China. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univ. Press.
33.
HowlettMichaelRameshM.PerlAnthony (2009) Studying Public Policy: Policy Cycles and Policy Subsystems. 3rd ed.Toronto: Oxford Univ. Press.
34.
HsüRobert C. (1986) “The political economy of guidance planning in post-Mao China.” Rev. of World Economics 122, 2: 382–94.
HuAngang胡鞍钢WangYahua王亚华YanYilong鄢一龙 (2008) “国家 ‘十一五’ 规划纲要实施进展评估报告” (Evaluation report on the implementation and progress of China’s eleventh five-year plan outline). 宏观经济管理10: 13–17.
37.
HuangYasheng(2008) Capitalism with Chinese Characteristics. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.
38.
KostkaGeniaHobbsWilliam (2012) “Local energy efficiency policy implementation in China: bridging the gap between national priorities and local interests.” China Q. 211: 765–85.
39.
LaiRui赖睿 (2010) “更加开放自信的中国:‘十二五’规划向全球取经” (A more open self-confident China: twelfth five-year plan looking to the world for ideas). People’s Daily overseas ed., Feb3. http://cppcc.people.com.cn/GB/34952/10916092.html.
40.
LevineMarkPriceLynnNanZhouFridleyDavidAdenNathanielHongyouLuMcneilMichaelZhengNinaYiningQin (2010) “Assessment of China’s energy-saving and emission-reduction accomplishments and opportunities during the 11th five-year plan.” Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. http://china.lbl.gov/publications/the-ace-study.
LiPeng李鹏 (2007) 市场与调控: 李鹏经济日记 (Markets and [government] controls: Li Peng’s economic diaries). Beijing: Xinhua chubanshe.
43.
LiPumin李朴民BingLi李冰 (2001) “‘九五’ 时期我国计划体制改革回顾” (A retrospective on planning system reform in China during the ninth five-year plan period). 宏观经济研究2: 24–26.
44.
LiewLong H. (1997) The Chinese Economy in Transition: From Plan to Market. London: Edward Elgar.
45.
LiuGuoguang刘国光 [ed.] (2006) 中国十个五年计划研究报告 (Research report on ten Chinese five-year plans). Beijing: Renmin chubanshe.
46.
LiuRixin刘日新 (2006) 新中国经济建设简史 (A brief history of economic construction in new China). Beijing: Zhongyang wenxian chubanshe.
47.
MaKai马凯 (2006) “‘十一五规划纲要’ 的编制过程和定位” (Drafting process and orientation of the eleventh five-year plan outline). 经济日报, April18.
48.
McgregorRichard (2010) The Party: The Secret World of China’s Communist Rulers. New York: HarperCollins.
49.
MeltonOliver (2010) “Understanding China’s five-year plan: planned economy or coordinated chaos?” China Insight Economics (GaveKalDragonomics), Nov9: 1–19.
50.
MohanRakeshAggarwalVandana (1990) “Commands and controls: planning for Indian industrial development, 1951–1990.” J. of Comparative Economics14: 681–712.
51.
NaughtonBarry (1990) “China’s experience with guidance planning.” J. of Comparative Economics14: 743–67.
52.
NaughtonBarry (1995) Growing Out of the Plan: Chinese Economic Reform, 1978–1993. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.
53.
NaughtonBarry (2006) “The new common economic program: China’s eleventh five-year plan and what it means.” China Leadership Monitor16.
54.
NaughtonBarry (2007) The Chinese Economy: Transitions and Growth. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
NDRC (2006a) 关于印发千家企业节能行动实施方案的通知 (发改环资 [2006] 571号) (Notice on the issuance of the implementation plan for the Thousand Enterprise energy conservation initiative [Department of Resource Conservation and Environmental Protection document 71, 2006]). http://hzs.ndrc.gov.cn/newzwxx/t20060413_66111.htm.
57.
NDRC (2006b) 关于加强固定资产投资项目节能评估和审查工作的通知 (发改投资 [2006] 2787号) (Notice on strengthening evaluation and inspections of fixed asset investment programs’ energy conservation [NDRC Investment Office document 2787, 2006]). www.gzqdc.com/detail1.asp?id=20070125165157594723.
NDRC (2007) 关于印发固定资产投资项目节能评估和审查指南 [2006] 的通知 (发改环资 [2007] 21号) (Notice on the dissemination of the 2006 Handbook on evaluation and inspection of fixed asset investment programs’ energy conservation). www.ndrc.gov.cn/zcfb/zcfbtz/2007tongzhi/t20070112_110694.htm.
60.
NDRC (2010) 关于印发促进中部地区崛起规划实施意见的通知 (Circular on disseminating the implementation instructions on the plan for promoting the rise of the central regions). 发改地区 (NDRC Division on Regional Development) 1827号. Aug. 12. www.ndrc.gov.cn/zcfb/zcfbtz/2010tz/t20100825_367456.htm.
ShiQingqiXiaobingYangTianhuaHuang (1993) “Changing patterns of development planning in China.” Pp. 91–114 in TambunlertchaiSomsakGuptaS. P. (eds.), Development Planning in Asia. Kuala Lumpur: Asian and Pacific Development Centre.
63.
ShirkSusan L. (1993) The Political Logic of Economic Reform in China. Berkeley: Univ. of California Press.
64.
Southern Media Group 南方网 (2006) 粤21地市签订节能“军令状” 降耗目标将纳入政绩考核 (Guangdong’s 21 prefecture cities signed “military order” consumption targets for energy conservation that will enter government performance evaluations). Dec15. www.southcn.com/news/gdnews/nanyuedadi/200612150699.htm.
65.
State Council (2005) 国务院关于加强国民经济和社会发展规划编制工作的若干意见 (国发 [2005] 33 号) (State Council opinions on strengthening drafting work for the national economic and social development plan [State Council document 33, 2005]). www.gov.cn/zwgk/2005-10/26/content_84417.htm.
State Council (2006b) 国务院关于“十一五”期间各地区单位生产总值能源消耗降低指标计划的批复 (国函 [2006] 94号) (State Council on the approval of the plan for the eleventh five-year plan period regional unit-GDP energy consumption reduction standards [State Council document 94, 2006]). www.gov.cn/gongbao/content/2006/content_443285.htm.
68.
State Council (2006c) 国务院关于加强节能工作的决定 (国发 [2006] 28号) (State Council decision on strengthening energy conservation work [State Council document 28, 2006]). www.gov.cn/zwgk/2006-08/23/content_368136.htm.
69.
State Council (2006d) 国务院关于落实《中华人民共和国国民经济和社会发展第十一个五年规划纲要》主要目标和任务工作分工的通知 (国发 [2006] 29号) (State Council notice on the division of major targets and responsibilities for the implementation of the “China’s eleventh five-year plan for national economic and social development” [State Council document 29, 2006]). www.gov.cn/gongbao/content/2006/content_413969.htm.
70.
State Council (2007a) 国务院批转节能减排统计监测及考核实施方案和办法的通知 (国发 [2007] 36号) (State Council notice on the approval of methods for implementing energy conservation and emissions reduction statistical monitoring and evaluation [State Council document 36, 2007]). www.gov.cn/zwgk/2007-11/23/content_813617.htm.
71.
State Council (2007b) 国务院关于印发节能减排综合性工作方案的通知 (国发 [2007]15号) (State Council notice on a comprehensive work plan to implement energy conservation and emissions reduction [State Council document 15, 2007]). www.5izixun.com/fagui/show.asp?id=2155.
72.
State Council (2009) 国务院关于推进重庆市统筹城乡改革和发展的意见 (Opin-ions of the State Council on furthering urban-rural integrated reform in Chongqing municipality). State Council document13, Jan. www.gov.cn/zwgk/2009-02/05/content_1222355.htm.
TianJinjian田锦尖 (2010) “规划指标的设计与测算” (Designing and calculating plan targets). Pp. 145–61 in Yang Weimin, 2010.
75.
TodaroMichael P.SmithStephen C. (2006) Economic Development. London: Pearson.
76.
WangLixinFewsmithJoseph (1995) “Bulwark of the planned economy: the structure and role of the State Planning Commission.” Pp. 51–65 in Hamrin and Zhao, 1995.
77.
WangYahua王亚华YanYilong鄢一龙 (2007) “十个五年计划的制定过程与决策机制” (Drafting processes and decision mechanisms for ten five-year plans). 宏观经济管理5: 67–70.
78.
WuHongying吴红缨 (2009) “综改成重庆‘两会’重中之重” (Comprehensive reform becomes top priority of Chongqing’s “two sessions”). 21世纪经济报道, Jan. 10.
79.
WuLi武力 (2006) “中华人民共和国实施计划管理的基础和条件” (Foundations and conditions of implementing plan administration in the PRC). Pp. 1–51 in Liu Guogang, 2006.
80.
XiangWei相伟 (2009) “对十二五规划 编制的思考” (Reflections on drafting the twelfth five-year plan). 宏观经济管理1: 38–40.
81.
Xinhua News (2008) “‘十一五’规划实施总体进展良好: 经济社会发展主要指标大多达到预期进度要求” (Implementation of the ‘eleventh five-year plan’ is progressing well: the majority of major economic and social development targets are on schedule). Dec24. http://news.xinhuanet.com/newscenter/2008-12/24/content_10554035.htm.
82.
XuLin徐林 (2010) “规划编制程序和评估制度” (Plan drafting procedures and evaluation institutions). Pp. 163–79 in WeiminYang, 2010.
83.
YabukiSusumu (1995) China’s New Political Economy. Boulder, CO: Westview.
84.
YangDali (1997) Beyond Beijing: Liberalization and the Regions in China. London: Routledge.
85.
YangWeimin杨伟民 (2003) “我国规划体制改革的任务及方向” (Mission and direction of reforming China’s planning system). 宏观经济管理4: 4–8.
86.
YangWeimin [ed.] (2010) 发展规划的理论和实践 (The theory and practice of development planning). Beijing: Qinghua daxue chubanshe.
YuDonghui余东晖 (2001) 两会前奏:“十五”计划是怎样制定出来的?(Prelude to the National People’s Congress and Chinese People’s Political Consultative Congress: how is the tenth five-year plan formulated?). China News Service, Feb26. www.chinanews.com/2001-02-27/26/73800.html.
89.
ZhangZhuoyuan张卓元YaoLu路遥 (2006) “第十个五年计划的制定与实施” (Formulation and implementation of the tenth five-year plan). Pp. 661–703 in Liu Guogang, 2006.
ZhongQifu钟契夫 (2007) 钟契夫自选集 (Selected works of Zhong Qifu). Beijing: Zhongguo renmin daxue chubanshe.
92.
ZhuBaozhi朱宝芝 (2010) “国家专项规划的编制与管理” (Drafting and administering national special plans). Pp. 99–109 in Yang Weimin, 2010.
93.
ZhuZhixin朱之鑫 [ed.] (2009) ‘十一五’规划实施中期评估报告 (Mid-term evaluation reports on the implementation of the eleventh five-year plan). Beijing: Zhongguo renkou chubanshe.
