Marxist as well as classical and neo-liberal theories expect that the development of capitalist agriculture will be accompanied by the spread of an agricultural proletariat. That was what happened in eighteenth-century England; it is also what is happening in contemporary India. This article asks, first of all: just what is the size of China’s present agricultural proletariat? And how do we understand and explain those dimensions? Our finding is that, contrary to our own initial expectations, hired agricultural year-workers in China today total only 3 percent of all labor input in agriculture (and short-term workers another 0.4 percent), in sharp contrast to India’s 45 percent, this even while the past two decades have seen very substantial “capitalization” (i.e., increased capital input per unit of land) in agriculture. We term the phenomenon “capitalization without proletarianization,” perhaps the most distinctive characteristic of recent Chinese agricultural development.
ChayanovA. V. (1986 [1925]) The Theory of Peasant Economy. Madison: Univ. of Wisconsin Press.
2.
China Development Research Foundation (2005) China Human Development Report. United Nations Development Programme, China Country Office.
3.
DevS. Mahendra (2006) “Agricultural wages and labor since 1950.” Vol. 1, pp. 18–20 in WolpertStanley (ed.), Encyclopedia of India. Detroit: Thomson Gale.
4.
YangDu and 都阳MeiyanWang王美艳 (2010) “农村剩余劳动力的新估计及其含义.” (A new estimate of surplus labor in the countryside and its implications). 广州大学学报 (社会科学版)9, 4: 17–24.
5.
YuanGao高原 (n. d.) “小农农业的内生发展途径: 以山东省聊城市耿店村为例.” (The internally generated path of development of small peasant agriculture: with Gengdian village of Liaocheng city, Shandong province, as an example). 中国乡村研究, 第9辑. 福州: 福建教育出版社.
6.
YuanGao (2011) “Rural development in Chongqing: the ‘every peasant household’s income to grow by 10,000 yuan’ project.” Modern China 37, 6: 623–45.
7.
GulatiAshok (2006) “Agricultural growth and diversification since 1991.” Vol. 1, pp. 14–17 in WolpertStanley (ed.), Encyclopedia of India. Detroit: Thomson Gale.
8.
HanleySusan B.YamamuraKozo (1977) Economic and Demographic Change in Preindustrial Japan, 1600–1868. Princeton, N J: Princeton Univ. Press.
9.
HuangPhilip C. C. (1985) The Peasant Economy and Social Change in North China. Stanford, CA: Stanford Univ. Press.
10.
HuangPhilip C. C. (1990) The Peasant Family and Rural Development in the Yangzi Delta, 1350–1988. Stanford, CA: Stanford Univ. Press.
11.
HuangPhilip C. C. (1991) “The paradigmatic crisis in Chinese studies: paradoxes in social and economic history.” Modern China 17, 3: 299–341.
12.
HuangPhilip C. C. (2009) “China’s neglected informal economy: reality and theory.” Modern China 35, 4 (July): 405–38.
13.
HuangPhilip C. C. (2011a) “Chongqing: equitable development driven by a ‘third hand’?.” Modern China 37, 6 (Nov.): 569–622.
14.
HuangPhilip C. C. (2011b) “The modern Chinese family: in light of economic and legal history.” Modern China 37, 5 (Sept.): 450–97.
15.
HuangPhilip C. C. (2011c) “China’s new-age small farms and their vertical integration: agribusiness or co-ops?.” Modern China, 37, 2 (Mar.): 107–34.
16.
HuangPhilip C. C. (2011d) “The theoretical and practical implications of China’s development experience: the role of informal economic practices.” Modern China, 37, 1 (Jan.): 3–43.
17.
QifanHuang黄奇帆 (2011) “重庆共富的战略考虑与路径选择.” (Strategic considerations and choices of approach in Chongqing’s search for getting rich together). Pp. 30–67 in 重庆"缩差共富"参考资料 (Reference materials on Chongqing’s “reduce gaps and get rich together”), Aug.8. N.p.: 中国重庆广播电视集团.
ZongzhiHuangYushengPeng彭玉生 (2007) “三大历史性变迁的交汇与中国小规模农业的前景.” (The confluence of three historic tendencies and the future prospects of small-scale farming in China). 中国社会科学, 第4期: 74–88.
20.
LeninV. I. (1956 [1907]) The Development of Capitalism in Russia. Moscow: Foreign Languages Publishing House.
21.
KangLiu刘亢, HuoHuang黄豁YaoguoTang汤耀国 (2011) “重庆追寻'后来居上’的改革与发展逻辑.” (Chongqing searches for a “late starter comes out ahead” logic of reform and development). July16. 瞭望. http://news.hexun.com/2011-07-16/131497077.html.
22.
ShuchunMao毛树春 (2010) “我国棉花种植技术的现代化问题.” (The problem of modernizing our country’s cotton cultivation). http://gxs.ww.gov.cn.
23.
PerkinsDwightYusufShahid (1984) Rural Development in China. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Univ. Press.
24.
Quanguo nongchanpin chengben shouyi ziliao huibian全国农产品成本收益资料汇编 [Compendium of source materials from the national survey of costs-incomes of agricultural products] (2002) 北京: 中国物价出版社; (2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010) 北京: 中国统计出版社.
25.
RawalVikas (2008) “Ownership holdings in land in rural India: putting the record straight.” Economic and Political Weekly (Mar.8): 43–47.
26.
ShaninTeodor (1986) “Chayanov’s message: illuminations, miscomprehensions, and the contemporary ‘development theory.’.” Pp. 1–24 in Chayanov (1986 [1925]).
27.
SmithAdam (1976 [1776]) The Wealth of Nations. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.
28.
ShūzōTeruoka晖峻众三 (2011) 日本农业150年 (1850-2000) (150 years of Japanese agriculture, 1850–2000), trans. HaoHu. 胡浩等译 [from Nihon no nōgyō 150 nen (1850–2000), 2003, Tokyo: Yuhikaku Publishing Co.]. Beijing: 中国农业大学出版社.
29.
2010 Yantai diqu pingguo shengchan . . .2010年烟台地区苹果生产与销售情况 [Apple production and sale in the Yantai area in 2010] (2011) www.191bbs.com/simple/?t219223.html.
30.
MeiyanWang王美艳 (2011) “农民工还能返回农业吗？——来自全国农产品成本收益调查数据的分析.” (Can the peasant migrant workers return to agriculture? An analysis based on the data from the national surveys of costs-incomes of agricultural products).中国农村观察, 第1期: 20–30.
YulinZhang张玉林 (2011) “‘现代化’之后的东亚农业和农村社会——日本, 韩国和台湾地区的案例及其历史意蕴.” (East Asian agriculture and rural society after “modernization”: the cases of Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan and their historical implications). 南京农业大学学报 (社会科学版)11, 3: 1–8.
34.
XiaopingZhao赵小平 (2004) “在全国农产品成本调查二十周年纪念座谈会上的讲话.” (Talk at the seminar commemorating the twentieth anniversary of the national surveys costs of agricultural products). Nov.24. http://qzprice.gov.cn/5-xinxi/jgcbdc/lt/9.htm.
35.
Zhongguo di er ci quanguo nongye pucha ziliao zonghe tiyao中国第二次全国农业普查资料综合提要 [Compendium of materials from China’s second national comprehensive survey of agriculture, synthesized highlights] (2008) 北京: 中国统计出版社.
36.
Zhongguo di er ci quanguo nongye pucha ziliao huibian, nongye juan中国第二次全国农业普查资料汇编, 农业卷 [Compendium of materials from China’s second national comprehensive survey of agriculture, volume on agriculture] (2009) 北京:中国统计出版社.
37.
Zhongguo laodong tongji nianjian中国劳动统计年鉴 [Statistical yearbook of labor in China] (2007) 北京: 中国统计出版社.
Zhonghua renmin gongheguo guojia tongjiju中华人民共和国国家统计局 [National Bureau of Statistics of China] (2010) 2009 年农民工监测调查报告 (Investigative report on the monitoring of the nongmingong in 2009). www.stats.gov.cn/tjfx/fxbg/t20100319_402628281.htm.
