Scoundrel or Scapegoat? A Reassessment of the Office of Thrift Supervision’s Performance Before the 2008 Financial Crisis

Abstract

This research attempts to determine whether Congress was justified in shutting down the Office of Thrift Supervision (OTS) in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis. I do so by comparing its performance with that of the other federal banking regulators: the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC), and the Federal Reserve. Results show that the OTS is not consistently the worst performer across a variety of measures. This finding suggests it was unfairly scapegoated and that many of the problems attributed to the OTS still remain at the other agencies, despite financial reforms in 2010.

Keywords

financial crisis banking regulation regulatory effectiveness regulatory capture Office of Thrift Supervision Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adler

(2009, October 26). Frank: Zero odds of single regulator. The American Banker, 174(194), 12.

Agarwal

Lucca

Seru

Trebbi

(2014). Inconsistent regulators: Evidence from banking. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 129, 889-938.

Angelides

Born

Georgiou

Graham

Murren

H. H.

Thompson

J. W.

(2011). The financial crisis inquiry report. The Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission. Available from http://www.fcic.gov/

Appelbaum

Nakashima

(2008, November 23). Banking regulator played advocate over enforcer. The Washington Post. Retrieved from http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/11/22/AR2008112202213.html

Bair

(2012). Bull by the horns: Fighting to save main street from Wall Street and Wall Street from itself. New York, NY: Free Press.

Bar-Gill

Warren

(2008). Making credit safer. University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 157, 101-201.

Barkow

R. E.

(2010). Insulating agencies: Avoiding capture through institutional design. Texas Law Review, 89, 15-79.

Bernstein

M. H.

(1955). Regulating business by independent commission. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Blair

Kushmeider

R. M.

(2006). Challenges to the dual banking system: The funding of bank supervision. FDIC Banking Review Series, 18(1), 1-22.

10.

Bowman

(2009). Testimony on federal regulator perspectives on financial regulatory reform proposals before the Committee on Financial Services United States House of Representatives. Retrieved from http://archives.financialservices.house.gov/media/file/hearings/111/bowman_-_ots.pdf

11.

Cyran

(2009, April 9). Downfall of a regulator. The New York Times, p. 2.

12.

Department of the Treasury. (2009). Financial regulatory reform: A new foundation. Retrieved from http://www.treasury.gov/initiatives/Documents/FinalReport_web.pdf

13.

Ding

Quercia

R. G

Reid

C. K

White

A. M.

(2012). The impact of federal preemption of state antipredatory lending laws on the foreclosure crisis. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 31, 367-387.

14.

Dodd

C. J.

(2009). Opening Statement of Chairman Christopher J. Dodd: Modernizing Bank Supervision and Regulation. Retrieved from http://www.banking.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=Files.View&;FileStore_id=a5455409-f62c-624.e34-9279-eb035a92a353

15.

Eisinger

(2012, June). Incoming regulator promises no more coddling of banks. Pro Publica. Retrieved from http://www.propublica.org/thetrade/item/incoming-regulator-promises-no-more-coddling-of-banks

16.

Eisner

M. A.

Worsham

Ringquist

E. J.

(2000). Contemporary regulatory policy. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers.

17.

Engel

K. C.

McCoy

P. A.

(2010). The subprime virus: Reckless credit, regulatory failure, and next steps. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

18.

FBI warns of mortgage fraud “epidemic”: Seeks to head off “next S&L crisis.” (2004, September). Retrieved from http://www.cnn.com/2004/LAW/09/17/mortgage.fraud/

19.

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. (2013). Quarterly banking profile. Retrieved from http://www2.fdic.gov/qbp/qbpSelect.asp?menuItem=QBP

20.

The Federal Reserve System. (2013). The National Information Center: Institution search. Retrieved from http://www.ffiec.gov/nicpubweb/nicweb/SearchForm.aspx

21.

Garsson

R. M.

(1990, January 22). Twilight of OTS? Lawmakers light flame; thrifts add fuel. The American Banker, p. 17.

22.

Glaser

B. G.

Strauss

A. L.

(1967). The discovery of grounded theory: Strategies for qualitative research. Chicago, IL: Aldine.

23.

Gormley

W. T.

Jr. (1982). Alternative models of the regulatory process: Public utility regulation in the states. The Western Political Quarterly, 35, 297-317.

24.

Gormley

W. T.

Jr. (1986). Regulatory issue networks in a federal system. Polity, 18, 595-620.

25.

Green

R. T.

(2012). Plutocracy, bureaucracy, and the end of public trust. Administration & Society, 44, 109-143.

26.

Hopkins

(2009, August 5). Lawmakers push for single bank regulator. The American Banker, 174(149), 1.

27.

Hopkins

(2010, May 24). Bill misses opportunity to overhaul agencies. The American Banker, 175(79), 1.

28.

Isaac

W. M.

(1991, March 7). Treasury’s plan falls short in streamlining regulation. The American Banker, p. 4.

29.

Johnson

Kwak

(2010). 13 bankers. New York, NY: Pantheon.

30.

Kaper

(2009, November 11). Dodd goes for broke with tough reform bill. The American Banker, 174(204), 1.

31.

Kaper

(2010a, March 16). Dodd tactic: Down the middle on reg reform. The American Banker, 175(40), 1.

32.

Kaper

(2010b, February 25). New details, progress on Dodd Reg Reform Bill. The American Banker, 175(30), 1.

33.

Khademian

A. M.

(1996). Checking on banks: Autonomy and accountability in three federal agencies. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.

34.

Kingdon

J. W.

(2003). Agendas, alternatives, and public policies (2nd ed.). New York, NY: Longman Classic in Political Science.

35.

Lewis

D. E.

(2002). The politics of agency termination: Confronting the myth of agency immortality. The Journal of Politics, 64, 89-107.

36.

McDonnell

Schwarcz

(2011). Regulatory contrarians. North Carolina Law Review, 89, 1629-1679.

37.

Meier

K. J.

(1985). Regulation: Politics, bureaucracy, and economics. New York City, NY: St. Martin’s Press.

38.

Meier

K. J.

Bohte

(2007). Politics and the bureaucracy: Policymaking in the Fourth Branch of Government. Belmont, CA: Thomson-Wadsworth.

39.

Meredith

(1994, April 19). OTS team preparing a “plan B” in case super regulator idea fails. The American Banker, p. 4.

40.

Morgenson

(2013). Surprise, surprise: The banks win. The New York Times. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2013/01/06/business/bank-settlement-may-leave-tiny-slices-of-a-smaller-pie.html?ref=gretchenmorgenson

41.

Offices of Inspector General. (2010). Evaluation of federal regulatory oversight of Washington Mutual Bank. Department of the Treasury, The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. Retrieved from http://fdicoig.gov/reports10%5C10-002EV.pdf

42.

Offices of Inspector General. (2011). Review of the joint implementation plan for the transfer of Office of Thrift Supervision functions. Department of the Treasury, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. Retrieved from http://www.fdicig.gov/reports12/12-015AUD.pdf

43.

Peterson

C. L.

(2005). Federalism and predatory lending: Unmasking the deregulatory agenda. Temple Law Review, 78, 1-98.

44.

Potter

(2012). Still learning to speak and still not being heard Public administration and the latest financial crisis. Administration & Society, 44, 367-373.

45.

Potter

(2013a). Considering public interest regulatory theory: Investigating the links between regulatory emphasis and effectiveness. Public Administration Research, 2(2), 37-48.

46.

Potter

(2013b). An exploration of effectiveness in the regulation of federal depository institutions, 1989-2008: Striving for balance. Plymouth, UK: Lexington Books.

47.

ProPublica. (2013). The bailout: Initiatives and programs. Retrieved from http://projects.propublica.org/bailout/programs

48.

Rainey

H. G.

Steinbauer

(1999). Galloping elephants: Developing elements of a theory of effective government organizations. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 9, 1-32.

49.

Ramirez

S. A.

(2000). Depoliticizing financial regulation. William & Mary Law Review, 41, 503.

50.

Ryan

(1992, November 12). Ryan’s advice to a factious industry. The American Banker, p. 4.

51.

Singleton

Straits

B. C.

(2005). Approaches to social research (4th ed.). New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

52.

Son

Chadbourn

(2009). OTS “fell short” regulating AIG credit swaps, Polakoff says. Retrieved from http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=21070001&;sid=aDm4OdFvcWUw

53.

Spitzer

(2008, February 14). Predatory lenders’ partner in crime. The Washington Post. Retrieved from http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/02/13/AR2008021302783.html

54.

Swann

Cox

(2011, March 21). A badge of honor for a regulator. The New York Times, p. 2.

55.

Treasury Office of Inspector General. (2009). Safety and soundness: OTS involvement with backdated capital contributions by thrifts. Retrieved from http://www.treasury.gov/about/organizational-structure/ig/Documents/oig09037.pdf

56.

U.S. Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, & Urban Affairs. (2009). American international group: Examining what went wrong, government intervention, and implications for future regulation. Retrieved from http://www.banking.senate.gov/public/index.cfm?FuseAction=Hearings.Hearing&;Hearing_ID=1655fd01-154e-48de-9fd8-2832a68f04d6

57.

U.S. Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations. (2011). Wall Street and the financial crisis: Anatomy of a collapse. Retrieved from http://hsgac.senate.gov/public/_files/Financial_Crisis/FinancialCrisisReport.pdf

58.

Worsham

(1997). Other people’s money: Policy change, congress, and bank regulation. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.