Better to Own or to Regulate? The Case of Alcohol Distribution and Sales

Abstract

Alcohol-related income generation is compared across monopoly and license off-premise alcohol regulatory models in U.S. states, 1977-2010. An optimum organizational-ownership mix is found when states directly own alcohol wholesale and employ a network of state-owned retailers serving urban regions and private agents serving less-populated regions. Per capita alcohol-related income in US dollars for these optimal systems was $58.82 compared with $26.72 with license systems. This disparity held after controlling for alcohol sales and retail hours of operation. The findings challenge the wisdom of asset divestment as a response to fiscal stress and contradict a central tenet of New Public Management (NPM) Theory.

Keywords

alcohol regulation privatization new public management public ownership asset divestment

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Babor

Caetano

Casswell

Edwards

Giesbrecht

Graham

. . .Rossow

(2010). Alcohol: No ordinary commodity (2nd ed.). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.

Barzelay

(2001). The new public management: Improving research and policy dialogue. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Campbell

C. A.

Hahn

R. A.

Elder

Brewer

Chattopadhyay

Fielding

, . . . Task Force on Community Preventive Services. (2009). The effectiveness of limiting alcohol outlet density as a means of reducing excessive alcohol consumption and alcohol-related harms. American Journal of Preventative Medicine, 37, 556-569.

Cook

P. J.

(2007). Paying the tab: The economics of alcohol policy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Dannin

(2011). Crumbling infrastructure, crumbling democracy: Infrastructure privatization contracts and their effects on state and local governance. Northwestern Journal of Law and Social Policy, 6, 47-105.

Dense

(2009). Wither state lotteries? Gaming Law Review and Economics, 13, 404-414.

Gansler

J. S.

(2006). Moving toward market-based government: The changing role of government as a provider. In Kamensky

J. M.

Morales

(Eds.), Competition, choice and incentives in government programs (pp. 37-120). Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.

Gilmour

J. B.

(2012). The Indiana toll road lease as an intergenerational cash transfer. Public Administration Review, 72, 856-864.

Grubesic

T. H.

Murray

A. T.

Pridemore

W. A.

Tabb

L. P.

Liu

Wei

(2012). Alcohol beverage control, privatization, and the geographic distribution of alcohol outlets. BMC Public Health, 12, Article 1015, 1-10.

10.

Gruenewald

P. J.

Madden

Janes

(1992). Alcohol availability and the formal power and resources of state alcohol beverage control agencies. Alcoholism: Clinical & Experimental Research, 16, 591-597.

11.

Gyimah-Brempon

(2001). Alcohol availability and crime: Evidence from census tract data. Southern Economic Journal, 68, 2-21.

12.

Hahn

R. A.

Cook

J. M.

Elder

Brewer

Fielding

Naimi

T. S.

, . . . Community Preventive Services Task Force. (2012). Effects of alcohol retail privatization on excessive alcohol consumption and related harms: A community guide systematic review. American Journal of Preventative Medicine, 42, 418-427.

13.

Her

Giesbrecht

Room

Rehm

(1999). Privatizing alcohol sales and alcohol consumption: Evidence and implications. Addiction, 94, 1125-1139.

14.

Lane

(2000). New public management. London, England: Routledge.

15.

Livingston

(2008). A longitudinal analysis of alcohol outlet density and assault. Alcoholism: Clinical & Experimental Research, 32, 1074-1079.

16.

Lynn

L. E.

(2006). Public management: Old and new. New York, NY: Routledge.

17.

Mosher

J. F.

Beauchamp

D. E.

(1983). Justifying alcohol taxes to public officials. Journal of Public Health Policy, 4, 422-439.

18.

Norström

Miller

Holder

Österberg

Ramstedt

Rossow

Stockwell

(2010). Potential consequences of replacing a retail alcohol monopoly with a private license system: Results from Sweden. Addiction, 105, 2113-2119.

19.

Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development. (2005). Modernising government: The way forward. Paris, France: Author.

20.

Osborne

Gaebler

(1992). Reinventing government. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.

21.

Rabe-Hesketh

Skrondal

(2008). Multilevel and longitudinal modeling using Stata. College Station, TX: Stata Press.

22.

Room

(1987). Alcohol monopolies in the U.S.: Challenges and opportunities. Journal of Public Health Policy, 8, 509-530.

23.

Room

(1993). Evolution of alcohol monopolies and their relevance for public health. Contemporary Drug Problems, 20, 169-187.

24.

Seim

Waldfogel

(2013). Public monopoly and economic efficiency: Evidence from the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board’s entry decisions. American Economic Review, 103, 831-862.

25.

Siegel

DeJong

Albers

A. B.

Naimi

T. S.

Jernigan

D.H.

(2012). Differences in liquor prices between control state-operated and license-state retail outlets in the United States, Addiction, 108, 339–347.

26.

Siltala

(2013). New public management: The evidence-based worst practice? Administration & Society, 45, 468-493.

27.

Simon

J. L.

(1966). The economic effects of state monopoly of packaged-liquor retailing. Journal of Political Economy, 74, 188-194.

28.

Spellman

W. E.

Jorgenson

M. R.

(1982). The social and revenue effects of state alcoholic beverage control. American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 41, 77-83.

29.

Stockwell

Zhao

Macdonald

Pakula

Gruenewald

Holder

(2009). Changes in per capita alcohol sales during the partial privatization of British Columbia’s retail alcohol monopoly 2003–2008: A multi-level local area analysis. Addiction, 104, 1827-1836.

30.

Swidler

(1986). A reexamination of liquor price and consumption differences between public and private ownership states: Comment. Southern Economic Journal, 53, 259-264.

31.

Trolldal

Ponicki

(2005). Alcohol price elasticities in control and license states in the United States, 1982-99. Addiction, 100, 1158-1165.

32.

Wechsler

Lee

J. E.

Hall

Wagenaar

A. C.

Lee

(2002). Secondhand effects of student alcohol use reported by neighbors of colleges: The role of alcohol outlets. Social Science & Medicine, 55, 425-435.

33.

White

G. F.

Gainey

R. R.

Triplett

R. A.

(2012). Alcohol outlets and neighborhood crime: A longitudinal analysis. Crime & Delinquency. Advance online publication. doi: 10.1177/0011128712466386

34.

Zardkoohi

Sheer

(1984). Public versus private liquor retailing: An investigation into the behavior of the state governments. Southern Economic Journal, 50, 1058-1076.