When Professionalism Is Not Enough: On Public Discourse Regarding Women’s Combat Service in Israel

Abstract

This article examines public discourse regarding women’s combat service in Israel following the October 7, 2023, Hamas attack and subsequent war, analyzing how demonstrated combat effectiveness impacts policy and social attitudes. Drawing on content analysis of mainstream and sectarian media, official statements, and survey data through January 2025, the study finds that despite women’s proven battlefield success, public discourse and policy have not significantly shifted in favor of expanded combat roles. Comparing the Israeli case to historical precedents (World War II, Israel’s 1948 War), the paper demonstrates that professional competence alone does not drive institutional change. The paper argues that social and political considerations, rather than combat performance, continue to dominate policy decisions regarding women’s military integration. This suggests that even conclusive evidence of women’s combat capabilities may not accelerate their integration into combat roles beyond the current incremental pace.

Keywords

civil military relations women prisoners of war female combat soldiers Israel Iron Swords October 7th

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bagno

(2024, March). A new poll reveals: How did the war affect the perception of women in the IDF? Maariv Online. https://www.maariv.co.il/news/military/Article-1081776 (in Hebrew).

Bamishpacha

(2023). Twitter. https://x.com/mishpach/status/1716849358392500619 (in Hebrew).

Ben-Shalom

Lewin

Engel

(2019). Organizational processes and gender integration in operational military units: An Israel Defense Forces case study. Gender, Work & Organization, 26(9), 1289–1303.

Ben-Shalom

Turgeman

(2018). On the borders—Collective action in gender mixed operational units on the Israeli Southern Frontline. Maarachot, 478, 30–37 (in Hebrew)

Carreiras

(2006). Gender and the military: Women in the armed forces of western democracies. Routledge.

Caspit

(2023, November 27). One of the greatest arguments of war is over. The proof waits in hell. Walla. https://news.walla.co.il/item/3624714 (Hebrew).

Cohn

(2000). “How can she claim equal rights when she doesn’t have to do as many push-ups as I do?” The framing of men’s opposition to women’s equality in the military. Men and Masculinities, 3(2), 131–151.

Coughlin

K. M.

(2000). Women, war and the veil: Muslim women in resistance and combat. In DeGroot

G. J.

Peniston-Bird

(Eds.), A Soldier and A Woman: Sexual Integration in the Military, pp. 223–239). Longman.

Elbaz-Alush

(2024, September). The first casualty in Gaza and women’s courage in the war. YNET. https://www.ynet.co.il/news/article/ryttcmuar (in Hebrew).

10.

Epstein

Heled

(2014). Integrating women in combat: The physiological aspect. Maarchot, 460(2014), 44–49 (in Hebrew).

11.

Erlich

(2024, March 14). Three female combat soldiers, three branches–and the message for those dreaming of going far. Israel Defense Forces. https://www.idf.il/185690 (in Hebrew).

12.

Fagge

(2023, October 25). All-female Israeli “lionesses” combat unit of just 13 soldiers killed nearly 100 Hamas gunmen as they helped liberate Kibbutz. Mail Online. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12669623/israeli-lionesses-kill-hamas-gunmen.html

13.

Falk

(1994). The making of policy: Media discourse conversations. Discourse, 15(2), 1–12.

14.

Forum Dvorah. (2023–2024). Women in combat–a story of their heroism. https://www.womenwarriors.co.il/womenwarriors/ (in Hebrew).

15.

Gez

(2023). Cpt. Gez’s testimony before the Knesset. Knesset channel, Twitter. https://x.com/KnessetT/status/1734959604583330149 (Hebrew).

16.

Glazer

(2023, October 20). They attacked. They knew they were the last stand before an awful massacre. Haaretz Weekend Supplement, pp. 14–19 (in Hebrew).

17.

Greenburg

(2023, May 22). Women’s secret war. The Conversation. https://theconversation.com/womens-secret-war-the-inside-story-of-how-the-us-military-sent-female-soldiers-on-covert-combat-missions-to-afghanistan-205669

18.

Halutz

(2023, October 30). After October 7, there are no more doubts about women combatants, they did everything required. YNET. https://www.ynet.co.il/laisha/article/b1scedsmt (in Hebrew).

19.

Harel-Shalev

Daphna-Tekoah

(2019). Breaking the binaries in security studies: A gendered analysis of women in combat. Oxford University Press.

20.

Holm

(1992). Women in the military: An unfinished revolution. Gower Publishing Company, Limited.

21.

King

A. C.

(2013). The female soldier. Parameters, 43(2), 13.

22.

Kushmaro

(2023, November 25). Just running over the terrorists and moving on. N12. https://www.mako.co.il/news-military/6361323ddea5a810/Article-a0389683a720c81027.htm (in Hebrew).

23.

Levy

(2023, October 19). The Battalion Commander who fought for 14 hours. N12. https://www.mako.co.il/news-military/6361323ddea5a810/Article-afaaceb10944b81026.htm (in Hebrew).

24.

Livni-Ben Yehuda

. (2024, May 13). I understood this is the end, I won’t see my kids again. Mako. https://www.mako.co.il/culture-books-and-theatre/first-chapters-short-stories/Article-be519b258ad4f81027.htm (in Hebrew).

25.

Lomsky-Feder

Sasson-Levy

(2018). Women soldiers and citizenship in Israel: Gendered encounters with the state. Routledge.

26.

MacKenzie

(2015). Beyond the band of brothers: The US military and the myth that women can’t fight. Cambridge University Press.

27.

McCombs

M. E.

Shaw

D. L.

(1972). The agenda-setting function of mass media. Public Opinion Quarterly, 36(2), 176–187.

28.

McCombs

M. E.

Shaw

D. L.

Weaver

D. H.

(2018). New directions in agenda-setting theory and research. In Advances in foundational mass communication theories (pp. 131–152). Routledge.

29.

Morgan

(2019). Female militarization and women’s rights: A case study of the Peshmerga and YPJ.

30.

Navo

(16 August, 2024, August 16). “The Barrier” Makor Rishon - MOTASH, p.10 [Hebew].

31.

Peri

(2023, December 7). Their voice is not heard. Mako. https://www.mako.co.il/men-weekend/Article-7c5867b0be44c81026.htm (in Hebrew).

32.

Peylan

(2023, December 19). A commander from the mixed gender battalion said: From now on there will only be men here. N12. https://www.mako.co.il/news-military/6361323ddea5a810/Article-f5b56333d8e7c81026.htm (in Hebrew).

33.

Quinn-Judge

(2001). Women in the early Vietnamese communist movement: Sex, lies, and liberation. South East Asia Research, 9(3), 245–269.

34.

Re’em

(2010). Women prisoners of war during the Israeli Independence war. HaMidrasha HaLeumit LeLimudei HaMachtarot veHaTziyonut (in Hebrew).

35.

Rickover

Ben-Ishai

Keissar-Sugarman

(2021). Hi-tech-oriented national service: The free choice of religious women recruits and the de-monopolization of the Israeli military. Religions, 12(11), 921.

36.

Rones

(2017). Gender-mixed army dorm rooms, 50% women and all-female special forces training: How does Norway’s radical attempt to integrate women in the military work? Res Militaris, 7(2). http://18.195.19.6/bitstream/handle/20.500.12242/858/1534457.pdf?sequence=2&isAllowed=y

37.

Rosenberg-Friedman

(2004). Religious women fighters in Israel’s war of independence: A new gender perception or a passing episode? Nashim: A Journal of Jewish Women’s Studies & Gender Issues, 6(1), 119–147.

38.

Rosenberg-Friedman

(2005). Revolutionaries despite themselves: Women and gender in religious Zionism in the Yishuv period. Yad Ben-Zvi Press (in Hebrew).

39.

Rosenberg-Friedman

(2018). Captivity and gender: The experience of female prisoners of war during Israel’s war of independence. Nashim: A Journal of Jewish Women’s Studies & Gender Issues, 33, 64–89.

40.

Rosman-Stollman

(2009). Women of valor: The Garin program and the Israel defense forces. Israel Studies, 14, 158–177.

41.

Rosman-Stollman

(2014). For god and country? Religious student-soldiers in the Israel defense forces. University of Texas Press.

42.

Rosman-Stollman

(2018). (Not) becoming the norm: Military service by religious Israeli women as a process of social legitimation. Israel Studies Review, 33(1), 42–60.

43.

Rosman-Stollman

(2020). The pink tank in the room: The role of religious considerations in the discussion of women’s combat service—The case of the Israel Defense Forces. Religions, 11(11), 557.

44.

Saban

(2023, November 29). There is no dispute over women’s capabilities in war. Mako. https://www.mako.co.il/news-military/6361323ddea5a810/Article-5009edde4b91c81026.htm (in Hebrew).

45.

Scollon

(2008). Analyzing public discourse: Discourse analysis in the making of public policy. Routledge.

46.

Shafran-Gittleman

(2020). Integrating women in combat: Statement to the Strick committee. Israel Democracy Center. https://www.idi.org.il/media/15848/havad3.pdf (in Hebrew).

47.

Shalev

(2023, December 15). The first female combat soldiers making history. Walla. https://news.walla.co.il/item/3628795 (in Hebrew).

48.

Shields

P. M.

(1988). Sex roles in the military. In Moskos

C. C.

Wood

F. R.

(Eds.), The Military: More Than Just a Job? (pp. 99–111). Pergamon-Brassey.

49.

Solaro

(2006). Women in the line of fire: What you should know about women in the military. Seal Press.

50.

Spijkers

A. S.

Snoek

Molewijk

van Baarle

(2024). Complexities and possibilities of strengthening the social inclusion of military women in the Netherlands Armed Forces: Findings from an action research project. Armed Forces & Society. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1177/0095327X241279184

51.

Tzemach-Lemmon

Curry

(2015). Noted journalist tells story of the women soldiers of the Afghanistan war. https://laist.com/shows/airtalk/noted-journalist-tells-story-of-the-women-soldiers-of-the-afghanistan-war

52.

Tzuri

(2024). Deceived. Olam Katan, 976, 18–19 (in Hebrew).

53.

White

M. D.

Marsh

E. E.

(2006). Content analysis: A flexible methodology. Library Trends, 55(1), 22–23, 27–34, 36.

54.

Zamir

(2023, June 23) “The War ahs lowered the opposition of the Religious and Haredi sectors to women’s combat service,” Zman Yisrael. https://www.zman.co.il/595640/ (in Hebrew).

55.

Zeitoun

(2023a, November 23). The Chief of Staff met the female tank crews: We received an answer without words. YNET. https://www.ynet.co.il/news/article/rkgzqmqbp (in Hebrew).

56.

Zeitoun

(2023b, December). I promise my kids I will return with victory. YNET. https://www.ynet.co.il/news/article/yokra13723890#autoplay (in Hebrew).

57.

Zeitoun

(2024, April 11). More than 100 female recruits refuse to serve as lookouts. YNET. https://www.ynet.co.il/news/article/yokra13881191 (in Hebrew).

When Professionalism Is Not Enough: On Public Discourse Regarding Women’s Combat Service in Israel—the Case of Iron Swords (2023–2025)

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References