Various polities have imported soldiers to compensate for a lack of manpower, to reduce costs, or to avoid the risk of arming potentially disloyal citizenry. However, importing soldiery is not without dangers. Foreign soldiers may carry with them subversive ideas, continue homegrown conflicts in their employer’s territory, be unreliable, or, worse, revolt. How importers of foreign soldiers might mitigate these risks is little studied. This case study reveals the repertoire of measures Britain used to mitigate the risks posed by one group of imported soldiers—the Dhofaris from Oman’s restive southern province who served from the late 1950s to 1973 in the British protected Trucial States, which became the United Arab Emirates in 1971. It concludes that intelligence collection measures were hampered by an inability to penetrate the Dhofaris’s linguistic and sociocultural world, and that threat analysis failed to accurately consider the impact of the conflict in their homeland.
AgarC. J. S. (UK Defence Attaché). (1974). Annual report for 1973 by Defence Attaché United Arab Emirates (FCO 8/2371). TNA.
2.
ArielliN. I. R. (2018). From Byron to bin Laden—A history of foreign war volunteers. Harvard University Press.
3.
BakkeK. M. (2014). Help wanted? The mixed record of foreign fighters in domestic insurgencies. International Security, 38(4), 150–187.
4.
BarnesC. (ca. 1976). A short history of the Trucial Oman Levies, Trucial Oman Scouts and the Union Defence Force of the Trucial States (later United Arab Emirates) of the Arabian Gulf, 1951 to 1972. Royal Society for Asian Affairs.
5.
BeasantJ. (2011). Oman: The true-life drama and intrigue of an Arab state. Mainstream.
6.
BelgraveS. C. (n.d). Belgrave diaries. In Personal papers of Sir Charles Belgrave (1894-1969), advisor to the rulers of Bahrain, 1926-57. Arab World Document Unit, Exeter University.
7.
BradshawT. (2017). The hand of Glubb: The origins of the Trucial Oman Scouts, 1948-1956. Middle Eastern Studies, 53(4), 656–672.
8.
BrownR. J. F. (1968). Report by major R. J. F. Brown (DIO Salalah) on Dhofar—March 1968 (FCO 8/5728572). TNA.
9.
BuddM. T. (1969). Trucial Oman Scouts bi-annual security report (WO 337/13). TNA.
10.
BurrowsB. A. B. (1949). To captain H. E. Butler Bowden, chiefs of Staff Committee (untitled letter ed.) (FO 371/75018). TNA.
11.
ButlerM. (2017). ADDF 1968 & special branch Al Ain, 1968-70 (interview ed.).
12.
ButlerM. (2021). ADDF 1968 & special branch Al Ain, 1968-70 (email ed.).
13.
CaferroW. (2006). John Hawkwood: An English mercenary in fourteenth-century Italy. Johns Hopkins University Press.
14.
CawstonA.CurtisM. (2010). Arabian days: Memoirs of two Trucial Oman Scouts. Privately Published.
15.
ClarkT. J. (1969). Trucial States intelligence report number 22 of 20 October 1969 (FCO 8/1255). TNA.
16.
ClaytonP. (1999). Two Alpha Lima: The first ten years of the Trucial Oman Levies and Trucial Oman Scouts (1950 to 1960). Janus.
17.
ColesA. J. (1970a). My Telno 192 of 17 July: Sharjah assassination attempt (FCO 8/1511). TNA.
18.
ColesA. J. (1970b). Operational against NDFLOAG (FCO 8/1511). TNA.
19.
CrawfordR. S. (1969). Dhofaris in the T.O.S (FCO 8/983). TNA.
20.
CurtisC. J. M. (2021). A Squadron, TOS, 1966-68 (email ed.).
21.
de ButtsC. F. M. (1967). Report on TOS covering period of command, March 1964 to Feb. 1967 (Commander TOS to PRPG Sir Stewart Crawford). Collection of J. E. Peterson.
22.
DeVoreM. R. (2012). A more complex and conventional victory: Revisiting the Dhofar counterinsurgency, 1963–1975. Small Wars & Insurgencies, 23(1), 144–173.
23.
DicksonH. R. P. (1949). The Arab of the desert: A glimpse into Badawin life in Kuwait and Saudi Arabia. George Allen and Unwin.
24.
DunP. (1971). Situation in Dhofar (FCO 8/1667). TNA.
25.
FM Muscat. (1971a). SAF SITREP as at 6 Nov 1971 (FCO 8/1668). TNA.
26.
FM Muscat. (1971b). SITREP No. 2 as at 14 November (FCO 8/1668). TNA.
27.
Foreign Office. (1949). Record of foreign office meeting with Arab Legion representatives (FO 371/82172). TNA.
28.
FowleT. C. (1930). Policy for Muscat Levy Corps (IOR/L/PS/12/2956). Levy Corps: Policy in regard to: Functions etc: Qatar Digital Library.
29.
FuccaroN. (2009). Histories of city and state in the Persian Gulf: Manama since 1800. Cambridge University Press.
30.
GrasmederE. M. F. (2021). Leaning on Legionnaires: Why modern states recruit foreign soldiers. International Security, 46(1), 147–195.
31.
GreenP. A. D. (1970). Telno.206 on 23 July (FCO 8/1511). TNA.
32.
Grove-WhiteL. C. N. F. (1969). Trucial Oman Scouts security report (WO 337/13). TNA.
33.
HallidayF. (2002). Arabia without sultans. Saqi.
34.
HawleyD. F. (1970). The Trucial States. Allen & Unwin.
35.
Heard-BeyF. (1982). From Trucial States to United Arab Emirates: A society in transition. Longman.
36.
HQ British Forces Gulf. (1971). Dhofar incidents (FCO 8/1667). TNA.
37.
HQ TOS. (1962). Trucial Oman Scouts security report period Dec 61—Jul 62 (WO 337/13). TNA.
38.
HQ TOS. (1963). Trucial Oman Scouts security report period 1 Jan 63 - 1 Jun 63 (WO 337/13). TNA.
39.
HQ TOS. (1964). Trucial Oman Scouts security report: 1 Jan 64 to 1 Jun 64 (WO 337/13). TNA.
40.
HQ TOS. (1965a). Trucial Oman Scouts security report for the period 1 June to 31 December 1964 (WO 337/13). TNA.
41.
HQ TOS. (1965b). Trucial Oman Scouts security report period June to December 1965 (WO 337/13). TNA.
42.
HQ TOS. (1966). Trucial Oman Scouts security report for the period January to June 1966 (WO 337/13). TNA.
43.
HQ TOS. (1967a). Trucial Oman Scouts security report for the period July to December 1966 (WO 337/13). TNA.
HQ TOS. (1968). Trucial Oman Scouts security report for the period Jan to May 1968 (WO 337/13). TNA.
46.
HQ TOS. (1969). Trucial Oman Scouts security report for period June-December 1969 (WO 337/13). TNA.
47.
HQ TOS. (1971a). COMTOS report for June and July, 1971 (FCO 8/1779). TNA.
48.
HQ TOS. (1971b). Trucial Oman Scouts security report Jul 70 to Dec 70 (WO 337/13). TNA.
49.
HughesG. (2009). A “model campaign” reappraised: The counter-insurgency war in Dhofar, Oman, 1965–1975. Journal of Strategic Studies, 32(2), 271–305.
50.
HughesG. (2015). Demythologising Dhofar: British policy, military strategy, and counter-insurgency in Oman, 1963–1976. The Journal of Military History, 79(2 April), 423–456.
51.
IveK. C. P. (1968). Trucial Oman Scouts security report, July-Dec 1967 (WO 337/13). TNA.
52.
JanzenJ. (1986). Nomads in the Sultanate of Oman: Tradition and development in Dhofar. Avalon.
53.
JonesC. (2014). Military intelligence and the war in Dhofar: An Appraisal. Small Wars & Insurgencies, 25(3), 628–646.
54.
LuntJ. D. (1981). Imperial sunset: Frontier soldiering in the 20th century. Macdonald Futura.
55.
McCarthyD. J. (1969). Dhofaris in the TOS (FCO 8/983). TNA.
56.
MachiavelliN. (1920). The prince (MarriottW. K., Trans.). J. M. Dent and Sons. (Original work published 1532)
57.
MaletD. (2013). Foreign fighters: Transnational identity in civic conflicts. Oxford University Press.
58.
MannM. (1994). The Trucial Oman Scouts: The story of a Bedouin force. Michael Russell.
59.
MartinW. J. (ca. 1986). Just a British soldier [unpublished autobiography] (Documents 4105). Private Papers of Lieutenant Colonel W. J. Martin: Imperial War Museum.
60.
MetcalfT. R. (2007). Imperial connections: India in the Indian Ocean Arena, 1860-1920. University of California Press.
61.
Military Co-ordination Committee (Persian Gulf). (1957). The organisation and deployment of land forces in the Persian Gulf, Muscat and Oman (FO 371/126951). TNA.
62.
OnleyJ. (2007). The Arabian frontier of the British Raj: Merchants, rulers, and the British in the nineteenth-century Gulf. Oxford University Press.
63.
PellyC. J. (1949). Political agent Bahrain, to Sir Rupert Hay [Untitled Letter] (FO 371/82172). TNA.
64.
PetersonJ. E. (1978). Oman in the twentieth century: Political foundations of an emerging state. Croom Helm.
65.
PetersonJ. E. (1986). Defending Arabia. Croom Helm.
66.
PetersonJ. E. (2004). Oman: The 1966 assassination attempt on Sultan Said bin Taymur. Arabian Peninsula Background Note.
67.
PetersonJ. E. (2007). Oman’s insurgencies: The Sultanate’s struggle for supremacy. Saqi.
68.
PetersonJ. E. (2021). Arabian Peninsula historian, political analyst and former official historian of the Sultan's Armed Forces (email ed.).
69.
PimlottJ. (1985). The British Army: The Dhofar campaign, 1970-1975. In BeckettI. F. W.PimlottJ. (Eds.), Armed Forces & modern counter-insurgency (pp. 16–19). Croom Helm.
70.
RisseM. (2019). Community and autonomy in southern Oman. Springer.
71.
RosenfeldH. (1965). The social composition of the military in the process of state formation in the Arabian desert. The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland, 95(2), 174–194.
72.
RossiterA. (2020). Security in the Gulf: Local militaries before British withdrawal. Cambridge University Press.
73.
RoyK. (2013). Race and recruitment in the Indian Army: 1880-1918. Modern Asian Studies, 47(4), 1310–1347.
74.
SarahV. P. (2007). Mercenaries: Strong norm, weak law. International Organization, 61(2), 367–397.
75.
ShepherdA. (1961). Arabian adventure. Collins.
76.
SteelC. K. (2021). Commander DDF, 1971-72 (email ed.).
77.
TakritiA. R. (2016). Monsoon revolution: Republicans, sultans, and empires in Oman, 1965-1976. Oxford University Press.
78.
ThomsonJ. E. (1990). State practices, international norms, and the decline of mercenarism. International Studies Quarterly, 34(1), 23–47.
79.
ThwaitesP. (1989). The Dhofar campaign, 1967-70. The Newsletter of the Sultan’s Armed Forces Association, 38(March), 22.
80.
UK Foreign Office. (1953). Historical summary of events in the Persian Gulf Shaikhdoms and the Sultanate of Muscat and Oman, 1928-1953. Foreign Office.
81.
UK Foreign Office. (1993). Foreign office annual reports from Arabia, 1930-1960: 1938-1953 (9781852073459). Cambridge Archive Editions.
82.
WalcotT. (2006). The Trucial Oman Scouts 1955 to 1971: An Overview. Asian Affairs, 37(1), 17–30.
83.
WalkerJ. F. (1960). Composition of Trucial Oman Scouts (FO 371/149048). TNA.
84.
YatesA. (2020). The formation of military intelligence in the United Arab Emirates: 1965–1974. Journal of Intelligence History, 20(2), 1–21.
85.
YatesA. (2022, June). Britain’s key counter-subversion instrument before the 1971 withdrawal from the Gulf: The voice of the coast [Sawt Al Saahil] Arabic radio station. Intelligence and National Security.
86.
YatesA.HughesG. (2022). Operation Intradon in the Musandam, 1970-1971: What this counterinsurgency operation says about British military operations in the Arabian Gulf. Small Wars & Insurgencies, 33, 1236–1258.
87.
YatesA.RossiterA. (2020). Intelligence collection in Arabia: Britain’s roaming information-gathers in the Trucial States, 1956-1971. Intelligence and National Security, 35(6), 767–786.
