Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

The comparative literature on base politics often suggests that stable base politics in Okinawa were achieved, thanks to Japanese compensation politics. These claims mostly focus on the central government’s strategic use of compensation politics toward Okinawa from Tokyo’s perspective, ignoring the influence of local decision makers. Through a case study of the Futenma relocation process and in-depth interviews with the decision makers at the Henoko relocation site, this study highlighted the role of the local district government (Henoko) under the framework of Tokyo’s strategic use of compensation politics for multilevel local governments (Okinawa Prefectural Government, Nago City Government, and Henoko). The study not only adds to the importance of local Henoko decision makers in strengthening compensation politics but also provides more nuanced views of base politics in Okinawa, which is essential to understanding how Japan managed to stabilize Okinawa’s base politics in the context of anti-U.S. military bases.

Keywords

U.S. military base Okinawa Japan compensation politics base politics

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Allen

M. A.

Flynn

M. E.

Machain

C. M.

Stravers

(2020). Outside the wire: U.S. military deployments and public opinion in host states. American Political Science Review, 114(2), 326–341.

Baxter

Jack

(2008). Qualitative case study methodology: Study design and implementation for novice researchers. The Qualitative Report, 13(4), 544–559.

Calder

(1988). Crisis and compensation: Public policy and political stability in Japan. Princeton University Press.

Calder

(2007). Embattled Garrisons: Comparative base politics and American globalism. Princeton University Press.

Casula

Rangarajan

Shields

(2021). The potential of working hypotheses for deductive exploratory research. Quality & Quantity, 55, 1703–1725.

Chen

C. C.

Shimizu

(2019). International relations from the margins: The Westphalian meta-narratives and counter-narratives in Okinawa–Taiwan relations. Cambridge Review of International Affairs, 32(4), 521–540.

Chief Cabinet Secretary (CCS) of Japan. (1996, August 19). “Okinawa Beigunkichi syozai sityouson ni kansuru kondankai” no kaisai ni tsuite [Regarding to holding “Commission on Okinawan Cities, Towns and Villages hosting U.S. Bases”]. Ministry of Defense. https://www.mod.go.jp/j/approach/zaibeigun/saco/r960819a.html

Cooley

(2008). Base politics: Democratic change and the U.S. military overseas. Cornell University Press.

Cooley

Marten

(2006). Base motives: The political economy of Okinawa’s antimilitarism. Armed Forces & Society, 32(4), 566–583.

10.

Davis

(2011). The US military base network and contemporary colonialism: Power projection, resistance and the quest for operational unilateralism. Political Geography, 30(4), 215–224.

11.

Dudden

(2014). Okinawa today: Spotlight on Henoko. In Kingston

(Ed.), Critical issues in contemporary Japan (pp. 177–186). Routledge.

12.

Emma

C. A.

Ian

E. R

. (2012, August 3). The U.S. military presence in Okinawa and the Futenma base controversy. CRS Report for Congress. https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/pdfs/ADA585507.pdf

13.

Emma

C. A.

Ian

E. R

. (2016, January 20). The U.S. military presence in Okinawa and the Futenma base controversy. Congressional Research Service. https://sgp.fas.org/crs/natsec/R42645.pdf

14.

Emma

C. A.

Mann

T. C.

Williams

A. J.

(2019, April 9). U.S. military presence on Okinawa and realignment to Guam. CRS Report for Congress. https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF10672/2

15.

Hennink

Hutter

Bailey

(2020). Qualitative research methods. SAGE.

16.

Hiyane

Piao

(2022). Political stability and relocation of U.S. military bases in Okinawa: A case study based on in-depth interviews. The Korean Journal of Defense Analysis, 34(3), 475–492.

17.

Hook

G. D.

Song

K. Y.

(2013). A tale of two “alliances”: Internal threats and networked civil society in Japan–US and South Korea–US base politics. Pacific Focus, 28(1), 17–42.

18.

Hoshino

(2016). US military bases and human security in Okinawa. In Ishihara

Hoshino

Fujita

(Eds.), Self-determinable development of small Islands (pp. 3–32). Springer.

19.

Inoue

M. S.

(2007). Okinawa and the U.S. military: Identity making in the age of globalization. Columbia University Press.

20.

Japan Cabinet Office. (1999, December 28). Futenma Hikoujyou no Isetu ni kakaru Seihu Houshin [Government policy regarding the relocation of Futenma Air Station]. Cabinet Office. www8.cao.go.jp/okinawa/7/7212.html

21.

Japan Cabinet Office. (2018, November 20). Policies on Okinawa. Cabinet Office. https://www.cao.go.jp/en/pmf/pmf_6.pdf

22.

Japan Cabinet Office. (2022, January 1). Okinawa Shinkou Tokutei Jigyou Suishinhi [Specific Project of Okinawa Promotion Budget]. Cabinet Office. https://www8.cao.go.jp/okinawa/tokutei/gaiyou1.pdf

23.

Japan Cabinet Office. (Undated). Hokubu Shinkou Jigyou no Gaiyou [Outline of Northern Promotion Project]. Cabinet Office. https://www8.cao.go.jp/okinawa/6/64.html

24.

Kawano

(2017). Okinawa Beigunkichi wo meguru Ishiki Okinawa to Zenkoku:2017 nen 4 gatsu “Fukki 45 nen no Okinawa” Chousa [Attitudes toward the U.S. military bases in Okinawa: Comparison between survey results in Okinawa and Nationwide: From the survey on Okinawa conducted 45 years after the reversion]. Housou Kenkyuu to Chousa [The NHK Monthly Report on Broadcast Research], 67(8), 18–31.

25.

Kawase

(2013). Kichi iji seisaku to zaisei [Policies for maintaining bases and finances]. Nihon Keizai Hyoronsha.

26.

Kawase

(2018). Kichi to Zaisei Okinawa Ni Kichi Wo Oshitsukeru “Minikui” Zaisei Seisaku [Bases and finances “ugly” fiscal policy pushing bases to Okinawa]. Jichitaikenkyusha.

27.

Kawase

Miyamoto

(2010). Okinawa ron: heiwa, kankyō, jichi no shima e [Okinawa theory: Toward the peace, environment, autonomous Island]. Iwanami Shoten.

28.

Kim

C. J.

(2017). Scope mismatch: Explaining the expansion of anti-military infrastructure-siting campaigns. Mobilization: An International Quarterly, 26(1), 109–125.

29.

Kumamoto

(2021). Kousa suru Henoko: Toinaosareru Jichi [Henoko crossing: Requestioned autonomy]. Keisoshobo.

30.

Labor Union of Nago City. (2006, October 26–28). Kichi to Shinkousaku [Base and Promotion Policy]. Jichiken houkokusyuu [Autonomy Report Collection]. https://www.jichiro.gr.jp/jichiken_kako/report/rep_okinawa31/jichiken31/4/4_4_r_02/4_4_r_02.htm

31.

Lummis

(2020, February 1). US marines Futenma replacement facility in Okinawa delayed—For how long? The Asia-Pacific Journal-Japan Focus, 18(3). https://apjjf.org/2020/3/Lummis.html

32.

McCormack

Norimatsu

S. O.

(2012). Resistant Islands: Okinawa confronts Japan and the United States. Rowman & Littlefield.

33.

Ministry of Defense (MOD) Japan. (2006, May 30). Zai Nichibeigun no Heiryoku Kousei Minaoshi tou ni kansuru Seihuno Torikumi ni tsuite [Regarding the government’s efforts to review the military realignment of the USFJ]. Ministry of Defense. https://www.mod.go.jp/j/approach/zaibeigun/saihen/20060530.html

34.

Ministry of Defense (MOD) Japan. (2015, August 19). Saihen Kanren Tokubetu Chiiki Shien Jigyou Hojyokin Kouhu Youkou [U.S. forces realignment-related special community support project expenditures]. Ministry of Defense. http://www.clearing.mod.go.jp/kunrei_data/a_fd/2015/ax20151127_00050_000.pdf

35.

Ministry of Defense (MOD) Japan. (2022, April 20). Defense programs and budget of Japan. Ministry of Defense. https://www.mod.go.jp/en/d_act/d_budget/pdf/20220420.pdf

36.

Nikkei Shinbun. (2015, October 26) Seifu, Henoko Sanchiku ni Shinkouhi wo Chokusetsu Shikyuu: Nagoshichou wo Kensei [Government pays promotion expenses directly to three districts of Henoko: Restraining the Nago City Mayor]. https://www.nikkei.com/article/DGXLASFS26H4N_W5A021C1PP8000/

37.

Nishiyama

(2022). Base built in the middle of “rice fields”: A politics of ignorance in Okinawa. Geopolitics, 27(2), 546–565.

38.

Okinawa Defense Bureau. (2007, October 1). Saihen Koufukin ni tsuite [Regarding to U.S. forces realignment-related expenditures]. Haisai. https://www.mod.go.jp/rdb/okinawa/05haisai/h19/pdf/102.pdf

39.

Okinawa External Affairs Study Group. (2023). “Okinawa Henkan” 50 nen wo koete [Beyond the 50th anniversary of the “reversion of Okinawa to Japan”: Arguments from Okinawa]. Sekai, 966, 140–150.

40.

Okinawa Prefectural Government. (2020, January 14). Okinawa Shinkou ni tusuite [Regarding to Okinawa promotion policy]. Okinawa Prefecture. http://www.pref.okinawa.jp/site/kikaku/chosei/kikaku/yokuaru-okinawashinkousaku.html#okinawashinkousaku

41.

Okinawa Prefectural Government. (Undated). Hokubu Shinkou Jigyou no koremadeno Keii [History of the Northern Promotion Project]. Okinawa Prefecture. https://www.pref.okinawa.jp/site/kikaku/chosei/staff/documents/keii24-2.pdf

42.

Okinawa Times. (2015, October 27) Henoko Shin Kichi: Kube sanku ni Chokusetsu Shinkouhi kei 3000 manen Seifu Dentatsu Kantei de Kondankai [Henoko new base: The government notify direct promotion expenditure to the Kube Three District in total 30 million yen in the panel at the Prime Minister’s Office]. https://www.okinawatimes.co.jp/articles/-/20213

43.

Okinawa Times. (2022a, December 22) Ritou Bouei Misairu 505 Okuen Boueisyou Yosanan Kunrenkoufukin Sousetsu [50.5 billion yen for remote islands defense missiles and establishment of training subsidies on Ministry of Defense budget draft]. https://www.okinawatimes.co.jp/articles/-/1076952

44.

Okinawa Times. (2022b, May 11) Zen Shitsumon to Kaitou Kennai: Fukki 50 nen Kenmin Ishiki Chousa [All questions and answers of Okinawa prefecture: 50 years reversion and opinion poll]. https://www.okinawatimes.co.jp/articles/-/956166

45.

O’Shea

(2019). Strategic narratives and US military bases in Japan: How “deterrence” makes the Marine base on Okinawa “indispensable.” Media War and Conflict, 12(4), 450–467.

46.

Rabson

. (2012, January 16). Henoko and the U.S. military: A history of dependence and resistance. The Asia-Pacific Journal. https://apjjf.org/-Steve-Rabson/3680/article.pdf

47.

Savage

Burrows

(2007). The coming crisis of empirical sociology. Sociology, 41(5), 885–899.

48.

Secretary of State Rice, Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld, Minister of Foreign Affairs Aso, and Minister of State for Defense Nukaga. (2006, May 1). United States-Japan Roadmap for Realignment Implementation. MOFA. https://www.mofa.go.jp/region/n-america/us/security/scc/doc0605.html

49.

Shimabukuro

(2014). “Okinawa shinkou taisei” wo tou [Interrogating the “Okinawa Regeneration System”]. Houritsu Bunkasha.

50.

Shinoda

(2014). Searching for a dream plan: Two-level game analysis of the Futenma relocation issue under the Hatoyama cabinet. Japanese Journal of Political Science, 15(1), 51–67.

51.

Spencer

(2003). Meeting of the dugongs and the cooking pots: Anti-military base citizens’ groups on Okinawa. Japanese Studies, 23(2), 125–140.

52.

Tamaki

(2023). Chiji Syoshin Hyoumei Enzetsu [General policy speech of the Governor]. The Okinawa Times, 15, 6–7.

53.

Tanji

(2006). Myth, protest and struggle in Okinawa. Routledge.

54.

Tanji

Miyagi

(2007, August 1). Okinawa and the paradox of public opinion: Base politics and protest in Nago City, 1997–2007. Asia–Pacific Journal–Japan Focus, 5(8). https://apjjf.org/-Miyume-TANJI–Miyagi-Yasuhiro/2490/article.pdf

55.

Tsuji

(2020). National referendum and popular sovereignty in Japan. California Western International Law Journal, 50(2), 417–457.

56.

U.S. Department of State. (2009, January 20). SACO final report. U.S. Department of State. https://1997-2001.state.gov/www/regions/eap/japan/rpt-saco_final_961202.html

57.

Vine

(2015). Base nation: How U.S. military abroad harm America and the World. Metropolitan Books.

58.

Watanabe

(2008). “Ame to Muchi” no Kouzu: Futenma Isetsu no Naimaku [The composition of “carrot and stick”: The inside story of the Futenma relocation]. Okinawa Times.

59.

Williams

(2013). The YIMBY Phenomenon in Henoko, Okinawa: Compensation politics and grassroots democracy in a base community. Asian Survey, 53(5), 958–978.

Stabilization of Anti-U.S. Military Bases Sentiment: Japan’s Evolving Compensation Policies and Base Politics in Okinawa

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References