The decade of the 1990s saw advances in democratization and civilian control of the armed forces in Latin America, but there are warning signs on the horizon. Civil/military miovements developed in Venezuela and Paraguay and continue to pose a threat to democracy there. Moreover, these later-day versions of military-based populism serve as a warning to the region as a whole. While most scholars have focused on the issue of democratic consolidation in the region, the twin case studies of Venezuela and Paraguay demonstrate the renewed relevance of Juan Linz's breakdown paradigm. Although Venezuela and Paraguay are atypical of the newly emergent democracies in the region. they may, in fact, be leading indicators of likely problems elsewhere.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
1. Samuel P. Huntington, The Third Wavle: Democratization in the Late Twentieth Centuril (Norman, OK: University of Oklahoma Press, 1991).
2.
2. Howard J. Wiarda, Corporatism and National Development in Latin America (Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1981).
3.
3. Alain Rouquie, The Military and the State in Latin America, trans. Paul E. Sigmund (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 1987), 98-104; and Paul W. Zagorski. Democract' versus National Securitv: Civil-Military Relations in Latin America (Boul- der, CO: Lynne Reinner Publishers, 1992), 58-64.
4.
4. Alfred Stepan, Rethinking Military Politics: Brazil and the Southern Cone (Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1988).
5.
5. Felipe Agbero, [The Military and the Limits to Democratization in South America,' in Issiies in Democratic Consolidation: The Newv Sototh America, ed. Scott Mainwaring et al. (Notre Dame. IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 1992), 153-198; Joao Martins Filho and Daniel Zirker, “Nationalism, National Security, and Amazonia: Military Perceptions and Attitudes in Contemporary Brazil,” Aroned Forces (and Societs 27, 1 (Fall 2000), 105-129; J.M. Filho and D. Zirker. “The Brazilian Military Under Cardoso: Overcoming the Identity Crisis.” The Journal of Interamnerican Stuidies band World Affairs 42, 3 (Fall 2000), 143-170; Claudo A. Fuentes, “After Pinochet: Civilian Policies Toward the Military in 1990s Chilean Democracy.” The JIourncil of Interainerican Studie.s and World AfJfiirs 42. 3 (Fall 2000), 111-142; J. Patrice McSherry, Incomiwplete Trausition. Militars Poiter and Demiocr;acv in Areention (New York: St. Martin's: 1997).
6.
6. David Pion-Berlin, Through the Corridors ofu Poi er: Institution.s Oid Cii'il-Militor;, Relafion:s in Ar-gentina (University Park, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press, 1997): Harold A. Trinkurnas, “Crafting Civilian Control in Emerging Democracies: Argentina and Venezuela,” The Journail of lhiteranerican Stadie.s and World A/its 42. 3 (Fall 2000), 77-109: Wendy Hunter, Erodoig Military Iflnhueuice ia Brao il: Pohliticions Against Soldiers (Chapel Hill. NC: University of North Carolina Press. 1997): and Paul W. Zagorski, “The Military,” in Richard S. Hillman, Understaidinlg Latin Amierican Politics (Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers. 2001). 107-134.
7.
7. Juan J. Linz, Crisis, Breakdowvn, aind Reequilibration. in Juan J. Linz and Alfred Stepan (eds.), The Breakcloiin of Democratic Regimes (Baltimore. MD: Johns Hopkins t nierisity Press, 1978), 16-24.
8.
8. MaLrtau Lagos, “Between Stability and Crisis in Latin America.”loatrnal o'f Dfeo sccX 1'. 1 (January 2001), 137-145.
9.
9. Arrentina had a tailed coup in 1990. Peru heid a successful self-coup (coup by the executive against the legislature and courts), followed by a failed counter-coup in 1992. Venezuela had two coups in 1992, and one in April of 2002: all failed. Guatemala suffered a failed self-coup in 1993. P3araguay had:i coup attempt in 1996. And Ecuador's coup in 2000 was a partial success: The president was deposed. but the civillan-military junta had to gi;e way the elected vice president.
10.
10. Samuel P. Huntington, Political OQrler in C('haniino Societies (New Hasen. CT: Yale [-University Press, 1968). 192-208. 219-237.
11.
11. Nancy Bermeo. “lOemocracy and the Lessons of Dictatorship,”Cooiparatil't PolitiCS 24. 3 (April 1992). 273-291. For an analysis ol how military government was discredited in the eyes of some members of the armed forces themselves, see Altred Stepan. Rethiinking Militar N, Politics.: Bral. il aid the Souothern ('one (Princeton. NJ: Princeton Unixersity Press. 1988), 30-44.
12.
12. J. Samuel Fitch's analysis of political developments in Ecuador froir 1941 through the 1970s is instructive here. Fitch notes that apolitical professionalism developed after Ecuador's 1941 defeat by Peru. Military officers became convinced that the military's involvement in politics and politicians interference in the military was the cause ol the disaster that cost the country half its territory. The generation of 1941 developed a professional ethic that demanded military officers stay out of politics. However, this ethic was gradually eroded by developments in the 1960s, and Ecuador developed the sort of institutionalized military rule that typified much of the rest of the region. See Fitch's The Military Coup uas a Political Process. Ecuador, 1948- 1966 (Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1977), 129-145.
13.
13. For a discussion of explanatory and other sorts of case studies, see Robert K. Yin. Ca.se Studs, Research: Devsign and Methodls,2nd ed. (Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, 1994), 3-9.
14.
14. Alfred Stepan. The Militara in Politics: Changing Patternss in Brloil (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. 1971); David Collier. ed., Tue Neva Authloritarianisma in Latin America (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1979).
15.
15. Herbert Herring, Latin America: A Histor N fi-rom the Earliest Time(s to the Pe.s-ent. 3rd ed. (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1968), 520-523.
16.
16. Michael Coppedge. “Venezuela's Vulnerable Democracy,.”Journal of Deniocracy-3.4 (October 1992), 33-35.
17.
17. James Brooke, “Venezuela Recounts How Coup Failed.”Neil York Times.6 February 1992, page A3-A3.
18.
18. Latin American Weekli? Report (lAWR).“How ILuck Saved the Day for Perez.”20 Fehruaiv 1992. 4-5.
19.
19. LAVR.“Just Who Are These 'Bolivarianos'?”20 February 1992. 5-5.
20.
20. LAWR'“Perez Survives Second. Bigger Coup Bid: December Elections in Doubt.”10 December 1992. 1-1.
21.
21. Econoomist, “The Impatience in Venezuela.”8 February 1992. 35-36.
22.
22. Dia 1o dle Caracas, “Results of Congressional Elections Analyzed.” 9 December 1993, in Forei(n Broadcast Information Service (FBIS). January 26. 1994. 37-38.
23.
23. Inter-American Development Band, Latin America After a Decade of Refors: Econooaaic w(ad Social Pr ogress 1997 Report (Baltimore. MD: Johns Hopkins Univers.ity Press. 1907). 293-293.
24.
24. Cuba Vision Network. “Castro Delivers Speech at FElJ Ceremony,” Hasana. Cuba. 16 December 1994. in FBIS. 20 December 1994. 12-19.
26. Bart Jones. “Insersionistas temen a Chavez”. El Nuevo Heralt]d24 April 1998. 3B-3B.
27.
27. Fiancisco Olivares. “Fl EFecto Chas ez.”El Umlii rsal.19 April 1998. at s%20vs%20.eluniversal.coni.
28.
28. Cailos Subero. “Encuesta Nacional Datanalisis de abril Chavez aventaja en 5 puntos a Saez.”El llli iresal.30 April 1998. at www.eluLniviversalA.comi.
29.
29. Aneel Bermuidez and Taynem Hernandez. “Chavez llaino a la unidad del MAS.”El,i on(5sall13 June 1998. at www.eluniversal.com.
30.
30. Jorge Calmet Wagner. 'Llego Ia hora: 'los otros' s s Hugo Chaivez. El 2'aiesasl,22 ScptC1mbca-19908. art WvvN.svsclalmciVC-Sal.com.
31.
31 Jane Bussey, '.Venezuelan Candidate Has Image Problem.“Miami Hetrald,19 Septernber 1998. page 11A-11A.
32.
32. El Nuevo Herald. ”Venezuela elegira pot separado presidente. Congreso y alcaldes.”23 May 1998, page 2B-2B.
33.
33. El Nteiao Herald,“Polo Patriotico sera primera fuerza en el Congreso venezolano.'14 November 1998.
34.
34. El Nacional,“Chavez anunciara el viernes plan cisico-militar de desarrollo.”8 February 1999 at sswww.el-nacional.com.
35.
35. Lirry Rohter, “In New Role, Venezuelan Army Runs Clinics and Shops,”Nerta York Tibn s-. 13April 1999, page A9-A9.
36.
36. El ULniiversal,“Chavez ascendio a los oficiales vetados,”3 July 1999 at www.eluniversal.comn.
37.
37. EcLonomaist,'Chavez Cleans the Slate,“31 July 1999. 29-30.
38.
38. El Nac:ional,“Constituyente acuerda reorganizacion de todos los organos del Poder Publico,”13 August 1999 at www.el-nacional.com.
39.
39. El Nacional,“La Constituyente evaluara todos los organos del Poder Judicial.”20 August 1999 at www.el-nacional.com.
40.
40. ElI Nacianal,“'Impugnaron ante la CSJ decreto de emergencia judicial,”27 August 1999 at www.el-nacional.coni.
41.
41. El Universal,“Decreto de reorgariización del Poder Judicial,”7 September 1999 at Wvs%20W.C%20lUnisersal%20.com.
42.
42. Cenovia Casas, Alcides Castillo, Maria Jose Mairena, Solbella Perez, “Constituyente suspendio a] Congreso y asumio funciones de Comision Delgada,”El NacioW1a. 31August 1999 ait www.el-nacional.com.
43.
43. Larry Rohter, “Crisis Deepens in Venezuela as Legislators Spurn Accord.”Nett York Times,29 AugUst 1999. section 1, p. 4-4.
44.
44. Fl Nacional.“Asamblea no abrira frente de batalla contra gobernadores a alcaldes.”2 September 1999 at www.el-nacional.com.
45.
45. Alberto de la Cruz, “Una disposicion transitoria estableceria el cese de actividades del Parlamento y una resolucio'n especial retringira las funciones del Senado y Diputados. El UIniverval,19 September 1999 at www.eluniversal.conm.
46.
46. El Nuevo Heralld,”La Asamblea Constituyente tarnbien 'consviira' con el poder judicial.”13 September 1999, p. 2B-2B.
47.
47. Fl Nulci aHerald, “(Chasvez piensa ya en 'nomas de dos mandatos,”'12 Januars 1999.
48.
48. El Nciaonal,“Chavez rechazo que se trate de un golpe de Estado,”5 January 1999.
49.
49. II NOL conal,“Proponen eliminar Ia Casa Militar y el empleo de edecanes y ayudantes. 14 Auaust 1999 at www.el-nacional%20.com.
50.
50. El Aacional, “Listo el nuevo perfil del juez en Venezuela,”9 December 1999 at www.el-nacional.comn.
51.
51. ElI Nwcionatil “Los tres comandantes recomiendan a Chavez desprenderse de Rangel. Miquilena y Arcaya,” 5 February 2000 at www.el-nacional.coniE, Ibid., “Chavez dicto linea al MVR: Bajen el tono en la pugna,” 15 February 2000.
52.
52. Norberto Ceresole, “El modelo venezolano o la posdemocracia: Caudillo, apostoles. pueblo,” originally published 11 January 1999, reprinted in El Univelrsal, I11 September 1999 at www.eluniversal.corn.
53.
53. Department of Defense, Paraigioa: A Courvti Study (Washington. DC: Department of Defense. 1988).
54.
54. Paul C. Sondrol, “The Emerging New Politics of Liberalizing Paraguay: Sustained Civil-Military Control Without Democracy,”Journal of Iter Americanl Studies and (worl,4/fair-s 34, 2 (Summer 1992): 130-132.
55.
55. f/he New; Yoj-k Times,“Coup in Paraguay Ousts Storessner: General Sworn In.'4 February 1989. sec. 5-5.
56.
56. Alan Riding, ”Paraguay Chief Shakes Up Army to Consolidate Grip,”Nelt York Iinic s. 8 Febriary 1989, p. 2-2.
57.
57. Lativ Amer-ictan Regional Repvorts. Southei'n Cone Repo, “Tensions High in Para-guLay After Assembly Bans Re-election of the President,” ' July 1992, 2.
58.
58. ABC Color.“Law on Political Membership for Military Annulled,” 21 October 1994 in Foreign Broadcast Information Service (FBIS). 28 October 1994, 53-54.
59.
59. Claudio Camargo, “The Man Who Knew Too Much,”Lstoe, Sao Paulo, 11 Decemher 1996, in FBIS. II December 1996 at www.newsbaniks.com/public/fbils/htnml.
60.
60. Andiew Nickson, “The Wasmosy Government,” in Peter Lamber and Andrew Nickson, IThe Triasition to Deinocrs'aev in Parag'uas' (New York: Saint Martin's Press, 1997). 189-192.
61.
61. ABC Color, “Ministro acuso .a Wasmosy de haber montado tin teatro. 1] 2 September 1998.
62.
62. ABC Color, “TSJE declaro a Oviedo 'no elegible,”' 19 April 1999.
63.
63. Diana Jean Schemo, “Ruling Party in ParaguLiay Maintains Grip on Presidency,”ws Y'ork Timnes,y1998, p. All.
64.
64. E-1 /Assevo He-rald, “Paraguay reincorpora a militares golpistas forzados a retiro en 1996,” 1(0 October 1998. p. 3B.
65.
65. Pedro Sersvin, “Se agrava Ia crisis polhtica en Paraeuav.”El Nuevo Heraald, 25 August 1998, p. IB-IB
66.
66. Jorge Benitez. “Paraguay, autoritarianismo v democracia.”El Nuevo Heraild. 27 August 1998, p. 2B-2B
67.
67. ABC' C(olor.'Nuevo tribunal militar libero de culpa a Oviedo.“ 2 September 1998.
68.
68. Pedro Servin, ”Ministro afirma general Oviedo 'obra milagros,“' El Nuevo Herald, 16 November 1998, p. IB-IB.
69.
69. ABC Color,”Ahora debe ser resuelta la inconstitucionalidad de decreto 117,“ 2 September 1998.
70.
70. ABC Color,”Cubas pasa a un coronel resolucion de la Corte,” 5 December 1998.
71.
71. ABC Color,“Ejecutivo espera renuncia de sus dos representantes en el Consejo de la Magistratura,” 12 January 1999.
72.
72. El Nuevo Herald, “Atacan en Paraguay residencias de jueces,” 28 January 1999, p. 2B-2B.
73.
73. El Nuevo Herald, “Ordenan encarcelar a Oviedo,” 6 February 1999, p. 3B-3B
74.
74. El Nuevo Herald,“Cubas al borde del juicio politico en Paraguay,” 9 February 1999, p. 12A-12A.
75.
75. ABC Color,“Una esperanza de salida de la crisis politica prendio ayer,” 12 February 1999.
76.
76. Pedro Servin, “Oficialistas se enfrentan a Cubas en Paraguay,”El Nuevo Herald, 30 October 1998, p. 2B-2B.
77.
77. ABC Color,“Ejecutivo inexplicablemente no remite lista de ascendidos,” 23 November 1998.
78.
78. El Nuevo Herald,“Huelga general y disturbio contra Cubas paralizan capital paraguaya,” 26 November 1998, p. 3B-3B.
79.
79. ABC Color,“Caceria humana contra los manifestantes en la plaza,” 27 March 1999.
80.
80. ABC Color,“Organizaciones del interior apoyan juicio politico,” 27 March 1999.
81.
81. ABC Color,“Renuncio Cubas y Gonzalez Macchi es el presidente,” 29 March 1999.
82.
82. For a discussion of the concept of critical coups, see Howard Wiarda, Critical Elections a1d Critical Coups: State, Society, and the Militarx in the Process of Latin Anmerican Development (Athens, OH: Ohio University Center for International Studies, 1978).
