Following the approach of the classic 1974 marital-role influence study of Davis and Rigaux, the present study focuses on differences in decision making (i.e., joint, husband dominated, wife dominated) across 24 product categories as a function of two key factors. These factors are stage of the decision process (i.e., problem recognition, information search, and the final decision) and culture (People`s Republic of China and the United States). The Jacobson Marital-Role Egalitarianism Scale is included to further assess individual differences in husband and wife traditionality-modernism. The major findings are that emphasis on joint, husband-dominated, and wife-dominated decisions vary by stage and by stage-culture interaction. Practical implications are presented with suggestions for future research.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Acock, Alan C.
and John N. Edwards. 1982. "Egalitarian Sex-Role Attitudes and Female Income."Journal of Marriage and the Family (August): 581-589.
2.
Alcoff, Linda
. 1987. "Cultural Feminism Versus Post-Structuralism: The Identity Crisis in Feminist Theory."Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society13 (3): 405-436.
3.
Antill, J.
, S. Cotton, and S. Tindale. 1983. "Egalitarian or Traditional: Correlates of the Perception of an Ideal Marriage."Australian Journal of Psychology35 (2): 245-257.
4.
Arkoff, A.
, G. Meredith, and J. Dong. 1963. "Attitudes of Japanese-American and Caucasian-American Students toward Marriage Roles."Journal of Social Psychology59: 11-15.
5.
Bartky, Sandra Lee
. 1975. "Toward a Phenomenology of Feminist Consciousness."Social Theory and Practice3 (4): 425-439.
6.
Birge, Bettine. 1992. "Women and Property in Sung Dynasty China (960-1279): Neo-Confucianism and Social Change in Chien-Chou, Fukien." Dissertation. Columbia University.
7.
Blood, Robert O., Jr.
, and Donald M. Wolfe. 1960. Husbands, Wives: The Dynamics of Married Living. Glencoe, IL: Free Press.
8.
Bonfield, Edward H.1978. "Perception of Marital Roles in Decision Process: Replication and Extension." In Advances in Consumer Research. Ed. Keith Hunt. Ann Arbor, MI: Association for Consumer Research, 300-307.
9.
Bott, Elizabeth
. 1957. Family and Social Network. New York: Free Press.
10.
Bowen, Gary L.
and Peter A. Neenan. 1988. "Sex-Role Orientations among Married Men in the Military: The Generational Factor."Psychological Reports62: 523-526.
11.
Brunner, James A.
and Anthony C. Koh. 1988. "Negotiations in the People's Republic of China: An Empirical Survey of American and Chinese Negotiators' Perceptions and Practices."Journal of Global Marketing2 (1): 33-55.
12.
Butterfield, Fox
. 1982. China: Alive in the Bitter Sea. Toronto: Bantam.
13.
Callan, Victor J.
and Cynthia Gallois. 1985. "Sex-Role Attitudes and Attitudes to Marriage among Urban Greek-Australian and Anglo-Australian Youth."Journal of Comparative Family Studies16 (Autumn): 345-356.
14.
Chia, Rosina C.
, C. J. Chong, and B. S. Cheng. 1987. "Relationship of Modernization and Marriage Role Attitude among Chinese College Students."Journal of Psychology120 (6): 599-605.
15.
Conable, Barber B., Jr.
and David M. Lampton. 1992. "China: The Coming Power."Foreign Affairs72 (5): 133-149.
16.
Conklin, George H.1973. "Emerging Conjugal Role Patterns in a Joint Family System: Correlates of Social Change in Dharwar, India."Journal of Marriage and the Family35: 742-748.
17.
Craddock, Alan E.1985. "Students' Marital Power Expectations and Control Needs: 1973-1983."Australian Journal of Sex, Marriage & Family6 (3): 153-162.
18.
Croll, Elisabeth
. 1981. The Politics of Marriage in Contemporary China. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
19.
Croll, Elisabeth
. 1984. "The Exchange of Women and Property: Marriage in Post-Revolutionary China." In Women and Property—Women as Property. Ed. Renne Hirschon. London: Croom Helm, 44-61.
20.
Cunningham, Isabella C. M.
and Robert T. Green. 1979. "Working Wives in the United States and Venezuela: A Cross-National Study of Decision Making."Journal of Comparative Family Studies10 (Spring): 67-80.
21.
Dahl, Robert A.1957. "The Concept of Power."Behavioral Science2 (July): 201-218.
22.
Davis, Harry L.1976. "Decision Making within the Household."Journal of Consumer Research2 (March): 241-260.
23.
Davis, Harry L.
, Stephen J. Hoch, and E. K. Easton-Ragsdale. 1986. "An Anchoring and Adjustment Model of Spousal Predictions."Journal of Consumer Research13 (June): 25-37.
24.
Davis, Harry L.
and Benny P. Rigaux. 1974. "Perception of Marital Roles in Decision Processes."Journal of Consumer Research1 (June): 51-62.
25.
Dittmer, Lowell
. 1993. "Mainland China's Position in the Pacific Strategic Balance: Looking toward the Year 2000." In Forces for Change in Contemporary China. Eds. Bih-Jaw Lin and James T. Myers. Columbia: University of South Carolina Press, 70-82.
26.
Doder, Dusko
. 1989. "The Old Sexism in the New China."U.S. News & World Report (April 24): 36-38.
27.
Ferber, Robert
and Lucy Chao Lee. 1974. "Husband-Wife Influence in Family Purchasing Behavior."Journal of Consumer Research1 (June): 43-50.
28.
Foxman, Ellen R.
, Patriya S. Tansuhaj, and Karin M. Ekstrom. 1989. "Family Member's Perceptions of Adolescents' Influence in Family Decision Making."Journal of Consumer Research15 (March): 482-491.
29.
Gardiner, H. W.1968. "Attitudes of Thai Students toward Marriage Roles."Journal of Social Psychology75: 61-65.
30.
Gardiner, H. W.
, U. P. Singh, and D. E. D'Orazio. 1974. "The Liberated Woman in Three Cultures: Marital-Role Preferences in Thailand, India, and the United States."Human Organization33: 413-415.
31.
Goldman, Merle
. 1994. Sowing the Seeds of Democracy in China: Political Reform in the Deng Xiaoping Era. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
32.
Green, Robert T.
and Isabella C. M. Cunningham. 1975. "Feminine Role Perception and Family Purchasing Decisions."Journal of Marketing Research12 (August): 325-343.
33.
Green, Robert T.
and Isabella C. M. Cunningham. 1980. "Family Purchasing Roles in Two Countries."Journal of International Business Studies11 (Spring/Summer): 92-97.
34.
Green, Robert T.
, Jean-Paul Leonardi, Jean-Louis Chandon, Isabella C. M. Cunningham, Bronis Verhage, and Alain Strazzieri. 1983. "Societal Development and Family Purchasing Roles: A Cross-National Study."Journal of Consumer Research9 (March): 436-442.
35.
Green, Robert T.
and Phillip D. White. 1976. "Methodological Considerations in Cross-National Consumer Research."Journal of International Business Studies (Fall/Winter): 15.
Henthorne, Tony L.
, Michael S. LaTour, and Robert Matthews. 1992. "Perception of Marital Roles in Purchase Decision Making: A Study of Japanese Couples." Working paper. University of Southern Mississippi.
38.
Howard, John A.1989. Consumer Behavior in Marketing Action. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
39.
Hui, C. Harry
and Harry C. Triandis. 1985. "Measurement in Cross-Cultural Psychology."Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology16 (2): 131-152.
40.
Iwahara, S.1964. "Marriage Attitudes in Japanese College Students."Psychologia: An International Journal of Psychology in the Orient7: 165-174.
41.
Jacobson, Alver Hilding. 1950. "A Study of Conflict in Attitude toward the Roles of the Husband and the Wife in Marriage." Dissertation. Ohio State University.
42.
Jacobson, Alver Hilding
. 1952. "Conflict of Attitudes toward the Roles of the Husband and Wife in Marriage."American Sociological Review17: 146-150.
43.
Jaffe, L. J.
and H. Senft. 1966. "The Roles of Husbands and Wives in Purchasing Decisions." In Attitude Research at Sea. Eds. Lee Adler and Irving Crespi. 95-110.
44.
Kalish, R. A.
, M. Maloney, and A. Arkoff. 1966. "Cross-Cultural Comparisons of College-Student Marital-Role Preferences."Journal of Social Psychology68: 41-47.
45.
Kim, Samuel S.1993. "Mainland China and a New World Order." In Forces for Change in Contemporary China. Eds. Bih-Jaw Lin and James T. Myers. Columbia: University of South Carolina Press, 13-46.
46.
King, Adam C.1989. "China's Consumer Market: How Are U.S. Products Perceived?"Journal of Consumer Marketing6 (Fall): 51-59.
47.
LaTour, Michael S.
, Tony L. Henthorne, and John B. Ford. 1991. "Marital Role Influence in the Purchase Decision Process: The Chinese Perspective."Marketing Theory and Applications: The American Marketing Association Winter Educators' Conference Proceedings2: 80-81.
48.
Lee, M. C.1984. Feminine Psychology. Taipei: Da Yang Press.
49.
Liu, William T.
Ed. 1989. China Social Statistics 1986. New York: Praeger.
50.
Malpass, Roy S.
and Ype H. Poortinga. 1986. "Strategies for Design and Analysis." In Field Methods in Cross Cultural Research. Eds. Walter Lonner and John Berry. Beverely Hills, CA: Sage.
51.
Nagashima, Akira
. 1970. "A Comparison of Japanese and U.S. Attitudes towards Foreign Products."Journal of Marketing34 (January): 68-74.
52.
Nunnally, Jum C.1967. Psychometric Theory. New York: McGraw-Hill.
53.
Pannell, Clifton W.1988. "Economic Reforms and Readjustment in the People's Republic of China and Some Geographic Consequences."Studies in Comparative International Development22 (Winter): 54-73.
54.
Park C. Whan
. 1982. "Joint Decisions in Home Purchasing: A Muddling-Through Process."Journal of Consumer Research9 (September): 151-162.
55.
Putnam, Mandy
and William R. Davidson. 1987. Family Purchasing Behavior II: Family Roles by Product Category. Columbus, OH: Management Horizons.
56.
Qualls, William J.1982. "Changing Sex Roles: The Impact upon Family Decision Making." In Advances in Consumer Research. Ed. Andrew Mitchell. Ann Arbor, MI: Association for Consumer Research, 267-270.
57.
Qualls, William J.1987. "Household Decision Behavior: The Impact of Husbands' and Wives' Sex Role Orientation."Journal of Consumer Research14 (September): 264-279.
58.
Quarm, Daisy
. 1981. "Random Measurement Error as a Source of Discrepancies between the Reports of Wives and Husbands Concerning Marital Power and Task Allocation."Journal of Marriage and the Family43 (August): 521-535.
59.
Rank, Mark R.1982. "Determinants of Conjugal Influence in Wives' Employment Decision Making."Journal of Marriage and the Family (August): 591-604.
60.
Rodman, Hyman
, 1972. "Marital Power and the Theory of Resources in Cross-Cultural Context."Journal of Comparative Family Studies1: 50-61.
61.
Rogler, Lloyd H.
and Mary E. Procidano. 1986. "The Effect of Social Networks on Marital Roles: A Test of the Bott Hypothesis in an Intergenerational Context."Journal of Marriage and the Family48: 693-701.
62.
Rogler, Lloyd H.
and Mary E. Procidano. 1989. "Egalitarian Spouse Relations and Wives' Marital Satisfaction in Intergenerationally Linked Puerto Rican Families."Journal of Marriage and the Family51 (February): 37-39.
63.
Rosen, Dennis L.
and Donald H. Granbois. 1983. "Determinants of Role Structure in Family Financial Management."Journal of Consumer Research10 (September): 253-258.
64.
Safilios-Rothchild, Constantin
. 1969. "Family Sociology or Wives' Family Sociology? A Cross-Cultural Examination of Decision Making."Journal of Marriage and the Family29 (May): 290-301.
65.
Schaninger, Charles W.
, W. Christian Buss, and Rajiv Grover. 1982. "The Effects of Sex Roles on Family Financial Handling and Decision Influence." In Proceedings of the Winter Educators Conference. Chicago: American Marketing Association.
66.
Schell, Orville
. 1988. Discos and Democracy: China in the Throes of Reform. New York: Pantheon.
67.
Sharma, K. L.1971. "Attitudes of Indian Students toward Marriage Roles."Journal of Social Psychology83: 299-300.
68.
Sharp, H.
and P. Mott. 1956. "Consumer Decisions in the Metropolitan Family."Journal of Marketing21 (October): 149-156.
69.
Shukla, Archana
. 1987. "Decision Making in Single-and Dual-Career Families in India."Journal of Marriage and the Family49 (August): 621-629.
70.
Sin, Olivia
and Paul Sham. 1986. "The Pitfalls of Joint Ventures with China."World Press Review331 (November): 51.
71.
Spiro, Rosann L.1983. "Persuasion in Family Decision-Making."Journal of Consumer Research9 (March): 393-402.
72.
Sullivan, Gary L.
and P. J. O'Connor. 1988. "The Family Purchase Decision Process: A Cross-Cultural Review and Framework for Research."Southwest Journal of Business and Economics6 (Fall): 43-63.
73.
Tull, Donald S.
and Del I. Hawkins. 1987. Marketing Research. Fourth Edition. New York: Macmillan.
74.
Udry, J. Richard
and Mary Hall. 1965. "Marital Role Segregation and Social Networks in Middle-Class, Middle-Aged Couples."Journal of Marriage and the Family27: 392-395.
