Benefit Segmentation for Fund Raisers

Abstract

This study establishes the applicability of benefit segmen tation to gift giving behavior in American philanthropy. Dimensions of the fundraising 'product' and resultant benefit segments are developed from a sample of donors across the continental United States. Five donor segments are presented that demonstrate face validity, predictive validity, and strategic practicality. Both donor and community-based socio-economic characteristics are important descriptors of differences between donor segments. Implications of these findings are discussed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Americans Volunteer 1985 1986. Washington DC: The Independent Sector.

Andreasen, A.R. 1982. "Nonprofits: Check Yoor Attention to Customers." Harvard Business Review (May-June): 105-110.

— 1985. "A Marketing Challenge for United Way." Community, September: 14-16.

Beik, L.L. and S.M. Smith 1977. "Contribution Segmentation: Improved Fund Raising for the American Heart Association." Dallas TX: The American Heart Association.

Bogdanich, W. 1985. "It's Hard to Tell Good Charities From the Bad." Wall Street Journal January 25: 23.

Bonaguro, J.A. and G. Miaoulis 1983. "Marketing: A Tool for Health Education Planning." Health Education (January-February): 9.

Buzzell, R.D. 1970. How Can Research Contribute to Improved Marketing in Non-Business Organizations, Boston: Marketing Science Institute.

The Chronicle of Higher Education 1988. "Wealthy People Give Less Generously Than Once Thought, Survey Finds ." October 26: A37-A39.

Curti, M. 1983. "American Philanthropy and the National Character." in (ed.) Brian O'Connell , America's Voluntary Spirit New York: The Foundation Center: 161-179.

10.

Danko, W.D. and T.J. Stanley 1986. "Identifying and Reaching the Donation Prone Individual: A Nationwide Assessment." Journal of Professional Services Marketing 2 (Fall/Winter): 117-122.

11.

Edmondson, B. 1986. "Who Gives to Charity?" American Demographics November: 45-49.

12.

Engelman, L. and J.A. Hartigan 1983. "PKM 17.3 K-Means Clustering." in (eds.) W. J. Dixon , et al. BMDP Statistical Software Berkeley, CA: University of California Press: 464-473.

13.

Farhi, P. 1988. "Contributions to Charities Set Record in '87." Wall Street Journal June 23: C1.

14.

Fox, K.F.A. and P. Kotler 1980. "The Marketing of Social Causes: The First Ten Years." Journal of Marketing 44 (Fall): 24-33.

15.

Fraser, C. , R.E. Hite and P.L. Sauer 1988. "Increasing Contributions in Solicitation Campaigns: The Use of Large and Small Anchorpoints." Journal of Consumer Research 15 (September): 284-287.

16.

Funkhouser, G.R. 1983. "A Note on the Reliability of Certain Clustering Algorithms ." Journal of Marketing Research 20 (February): 99-102.

17.

Giving USA 1988. 1988 Annual Report. New York: American Association of Fund Raising Counsel.

18.

Guy, B.S. and W.E. Patton 1989. "The Marketing of Altruistic Causes: Understanding Why People Help." The Journal of Consumer Marketing 6 (Winter): 19-30.

19.

Haley, R.I. 1968. "Benefit Segmentation: A Decision-oriented Research Tool ." Journal of Marketing 32 (July): 30-35.

20.

— 1971. "Beyond Benefit Segmentation." Journal of Advertising Research 11 (August): 3-8.

21.

— 1984a. Benefit Segments: Backwards and Forwards." Journal of Advertising Research 24 (February-March): 19-25.

22.

— 1984b. "Benefit Segmentation-20 Years Later." Journal of Consumer Marketing 1 (2): 5-13.

23.

— 1985. "Developing Effective Communications Strategy: A Benefit Segmentation Approach." New York: John Wiley & Sons.

24.

Haring, A. 1973. "Work or Welfare: An Attitude Segmentation of ADC Clients ," New York: Human Resources Administration .

25.

Harvey, J.W. and K.F. McCrohan 1988a. "Fundraising Costs-Societal Implications for Philanthropies and Their Supporters." Business and Society 27 (Spring): 15-22.

26.

— 1988b. "Strategic Issues for Charities and Philanthropies." Long Range Planning 21 (6): 44-55.

27.

Hodgkinson, V.A. 1985. "Positioning Ourselves as a Sector: Research and Public Policy." Journal ofVoluntaryActionResearch 14 (April-September): 17-24.

28.

Klastorin, T.D. 1983. "Assessing Cluster Analysis Results." Journal of Marketing Research 20 (February): 92-98.

29.

Kotler, P. and A.R. Andreasen 1987. Strategic Marketing for Nonprofit Organizations, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

30.

Krech, D. , and R.S. Crutchfield (1948). Theory and Problems of Social Psychology. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Co.

31.

Lamb, Jr. C.W. 1987. "Public Sector Marketing is Different." Business Horizons 30 (4): 56-60.

32.

Lovelock, C.H. , and C.B. Weinberg 1984. Marketing for Public and Nonprofit Managers. New York: John Wiley & Sons.

33.

Marketing Canada as a Vacation Nation 1977 . In B.M. Rusk , Y. Wind and M.G. Greenberg (eds.) Moving A Head with Attitude Research Chicago, IL: American Marketing Association.

34.

McElroy, K.M. , and J.J. Siegfried 1986. "The Community Influence on Corporate Contributions." Public Finance Quarterly 14 (October): 394-414.

35.

Mindak, W.A. , and H.M. Bybee 1971. "Marketing's Application to Fund Raising." Journal of Marketing 35 (July): 13-18.

36.

Moore, L.F. 1983. "Organizational Imagery and Voluntarism." In M. S. Moyer (ed.) Managing Voluntary Organizations Conference Proceedings, York University, October.

37.

Myers, J.H. , and M.I. Alpert 1968. "Determinant Buying Attitudes: Meaning and Measurement ." Journal of Marketing 32 (October): 13-20.

38.

Punj, G. , and D.W. Stewart 1983. "Cluster Analysis in Marketing Resaerch: Review and Suggestions for Application. " Journal of Marketing Research 20 (May): 122-123.

39.

Rich, S. 1987. "Few Rich Are Exceptionally Charitable, Study Says." The Washington Post September 21: A12.

40.

Riecken, G. , and U. Yavas 1986. "Seeking Donors via Opinion Leadership." Journal of Professional Services Marketing 2 (Fall/Winter): 109-116.

41.

Ryan, D. , and R. Murdock 1986. "Identifying and Nurturing Core Donors." Fund Raising Management 16 (February): 20-32.

42.

Shapiro, B.P. 1973. "Marketing for Nonprofit Organizations." Harvard Business Review (September-October): 43-52.

43.

Smith, S.M. 1980. "Giving to Charitable Organizations: A Behavioral Review and A Framework for Increasing Commitment." in Jerry C. Olson (ed.), Advances in Consumer Research 7. Ann Arbor MI: The Association for Consumer Research: 753-756.

44.

Steiber, S.R. , and J.A. Boscarino 1983. "Qualitative Forecasting Tools Help to Pinpoint Health Care Market Segments." Marketing News October: 4.

45.

Steinberg, M. , G. Miaoulis , and D. Lloyd 1982. "Benefit Segmentation Strategies for the Performing Arts ." In 1982 Educators Conference Proceedings B J. Walker (ed.): 289-293.

46.

Tabachnick, B.G. and L.S. Fidell 1983. Using Multivariate Statistics New York : Harper and Row.

47.

TQ Consultants The Hoover Awards for Marketing 1978 1978. Victoria, Australia: TQ Consultants, summarized in Lovelock and Weinberg , op cit, 1984: 411-412.

48.

Traynor, K. 1981, "A Benefit Analysis of Higher Education Using Multiple Discriminant Analysis." In J. H. Donnelly and W. R. George (eds.) Marketing of Services. Chicago IL: American Marketing Association: 129-133.

49.

Varadarajan, P.R. , and A. Menon 1988. "Cause-Related Marketing: A Coalignment of Marketing Strategy and Corporate Philanthropy." Journal of Marketing 52 (July): 58-74.

50.

Wall Street Journal 1988. Business Bulletin - A Special Background Report On Trends in Industry and Finance. June 30:1.

51.

Yavas, U. , G. Riecken , and R. Parameswaran 1980. "Personality, Organization- Specific Attitude, and Socioeconomic Correlates of Charity Giving Behavior ." Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 9 (Winter): 52-64.