Contractual Governance,Relational Governance,and the Performance of Interfirm Service Exchanges: The Influence of Boundary-Spanner Closeness

Abstract

Academics and managers are confronted with reconciling the social and economic aspects of business-to-business exchanges. In a service context, the authors investigate the relative importance of contractual and relational governance on exchange performance and the influence of the boundary spanner on the implementation of these governance mechanisms and on exchange performance. They test a model of the governance of commercial banking exchanges using interview data with both parties to the exchange (the account manager as the bank's boundary spanner and the business client). Relational governance is the predominant governance mechanism associated with exchange performance. Contractual governance is also positively associated to exchange performance, but to a much lesser extent. The closeness of the account manager to the client company in terms of information gathering is also positively associated to exchange performance. However, this is mediated through both contractual and relational governance mechanisms with relational governance being the stronger mechanism.

Keywords

relational norms legal contract boundary spanners exchange performance relationship marketing structural equation modeling

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Achrol, Ravi S. and Gregory T. Gundlach . 1999. “Legal and Social Safeguards Against Opportunism in Exchange.” Journal of Retailing 75 (1): 107-124.

Anderson, James C. 1987. “An Approach for Confirmatory Measurement and Structural Equation Modeling of Organizational Properties.” Management Science 33 (4): 525-541.

Anderson, James C. and DavidW. Gerbing . 1988. “Structural Equation Modeling in Practice: A Review and Recommended Two Step Approach.” Psychological Bulletin 103 (May): 411-423.

Antia, Kersi D. and Gary L. Frazier . 2001. “The Severity of Contract Enforcement in Interfirm Channel Relationships.” Journal of Marketing 65 (October): 67-81.

Arrighetti, Alessandro , Reinhard Bachmann , and Simon Deakin . 1997. “Contract Law, Social Norms and Inter-Firm Cooperation.” Cambridge Journal of Economics 21 (2): 171-195.

Artz, Kendall W. 1999. “Buyer-Seller Performance: The Role of Asset Specificity, Reciprocal Investments and Relational Exchange.” British Academy of Management 10:113-126.

Artz, Kendall W. and Thomas H. Brush . 2000. “Asset Specificity, Uncertainty and Relational Norms: An Examination of Coordination Costs in Collaborative Strategic Alliances.” Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 41:337-362.

Bagozzi, Richard P. and Todd F. Heatherton . 1994. “A General Approach to Representing Multifaceted Personality Constructs.” Structural Equation Modeling 1 (1): 35-67.

Bagozzi, Richard P. Todd F. Heatherton and Lynn W. Phillips . 1982. “Representing andTesting Organizational Theories: AHolistic Construal.” Administrative Science Quarterly 27 (September): 459-489.

10.

Bagozzi, Richard P. Todd F. Heatherton and Youjae Yi . 1988. “On the Evaluation of Structural Equation Models.” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 16 (Spring): 74-79.

11.

Bagozzi, Richard P. Todd F. Heatherton Youjae Yi , and Lynn W. Phillips . 1991. “Assessing Construct Validity in Organizational Research.” Administrative Science Quarterly 36 (September): 421-458.

12.

Barnes, James G. 1997. “Closeness, Strength, and Satisfaction: Examining the Nature of Relationships Between Providers of Financial Services and Their Retail Customers.” Psychology and Marketing 14 (8): 765-790.

13.

Bello, Daniel C. , Cristian Chelariu , and Li Zhang . 2003. “The Antecedents and Performance Consequences of Relationalism in Export Distribution Channels.” Journal of Business Research 56:1-16.

14.

Bentler, Peter M. 1992. EQS: Structural Equations Program Manual. Los Angeles: SBMDP Statistical Software.

15.

Bentler, Peter M. and Douglas G. Bonett . 1980. “Significance Tests and Goodnessof-Fit in the Analysis of Covariance Structures.” Psychological Bulletin 88 (3): 588-606.

16.

Bergeron, Jasmin , Line Ricard , and Jean Perrien . 2003. “Determinants of Commercial Clients’ Loyalty in the Banking Industry.” Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences 20 (2): 107-120.

17.

Bettencourt, Lance A. and StephenW. Brown . 2003. “Role Stressors and Customer-Oriented Boundary-Spanning Behaviors in Service Organizations.” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 31 (4): 394-408.

18.

Bowen, David E. and Gareth R. Jones . 1986. “Transaction Cost Analysis of Service Organization-Customer Exchange.” Academy of Management Review 11 (2): 428-441.

19.

Bowen, David E. Gareth R. Jones and Benjamin Schneider . 1985. “Boundary-Spanning-Role Employees and the Service Encounter: Some Guidelines for Future Management and Research.” In The Service Encounter. Eds. John Czepiel , Michael R. Solomon , and Carol F. Surprenant . New York: Lexington Books, 127-147.

20.

Brown, James R. , Chekitan S. Dev , and Dong-Jin Lee . 2000. “Managing Marketing Channel Opportunism: The Efficacy of AlternativeGovernance Mechanisms.” Journal of Marketing 64 (April): 51-65.

21.

Bucklin, Louis P. and Sanjit Sengupta . 1993. “Organizing Successful Co-Marketing Alliances.” Journal of Marketing 57 (April): 32-46.

22.

Burchell, Brendan and Frank Wilkinson . 1997. “Trust, Business Relationships and the Contractual Environment.” Cambridge Journal of Economics 21 (2): 217-237.

23.

Byrne, Barbara . 1989. A Primer of LISREL, Basic Assumptions and Programming for Confirmatory Factor Analysis Models. New York: SSpringer.

24.

Byrne, Barbara . 1994. Structural Equation Modeling With EQS and EQS/ Windows. Thousand Oaks, CA: SSage.

25.

Cannon, Joseph P. , Ravi S. Achrol , and Gregory T. Gundlach . 2000. “Contracts, Norms, and Plural Form Governance.” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 28 (2): 180-194.

26.

Cannon, Joseph P. , Ravi S. Achrol , Gregory T. Gundlach . and William D. Perreault Jr. 1999. “Buyer-Seller Relationships in Business Markets.” Journal of Marketing Research 36 (November): 439-460.

27.

Chung, Beth G. and Benjamin Schneider . 2002. “Serving Multiple Masters: Role Conflict Experienced by Service Employees.” Journal of Services Marketing 16 (1): 70-87.

28.

Churchill, Gilbert A., Jr. 1979. “A Paradigm for Developing Better Measures of Marketing Constructs.” Journal of Marketing Research 16 (February): 64-73.

29.

Courpasson, Daniel . 1997. “The French Deposit Bank: Managerial Professions Between Rationalization and Trust.” In Regulation and Deregulation in European Financial Services. Eds. G. Morgan and D. Knights . Basingstoke, UK: Macmillan, 66-85.

30.

Cox, Dena and Anthony D. Cox . 2002. “Beyond First Impressions: The Effects of Repeated Exposure on Consumer Liking of Visually Complex and Simple Product Designs.” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 30 (2): 119-130.

31.

Dabholkar, Pratibha A. , Dayle I. Thorpe , and Joseph O. Rentz . 1997. “A Measure of Service Quality for Retail Stores: Scale Development andValidation.” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 24 (1): 3-16.

32.

Day, George S. 2000. “Managing Market Relationships.” Journal of Marketing 28 (1): 24-30.

33.

Doney, Patricia M. , Joseph P. Cannon , and Michael M. Mullen . 1998. “Understanding the Influence of National Culture on the Development of Trust.” Academy of Management Review 23 (3): 601-620.

34.

Dwyer, F. Robert , Paul H. Schurr , and Sejo Oh. 1987. “Developing Buyer-Seller Relationships.” Journal of Marketing 51 (April): 11-27.

35.

Dyer, Jeffrey H. and Harbir Singh . 1998. “The RelationalView: Cooperative Strategy and Sources of Interorganizational Competitive Advantage.” Academy of Management Review 23 (4): 660-679.

36.

Eisenberg, Melvin A. 2000. “Why There Is No Law of Relational Contracts.” Northwestern University Law Review 94 (3): 805-821.

37.

Fornell, Claes and David F. Larcker . 1981. “Evaluating Structural Equation Models With Unobservable Variables and Measurement Error.” Journal of Marketing Research 18 (2): 39-50.

38.

Gaski, John . 1984. “The Theory of Power and Conflict in Channels of Distribution.” Journal of Marketing 48 (Summer): 9-29.

39.

Grönroos, Christian . 1992. “Service Management: AManagement Focus for Service Competition.” In Managing Services: Marketing, Operations and Human Resources, 2d ed. Ed. C. H. Lovelock . Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, 9-16.

40.

Gundlach, Gregory T. and Ravi S. Achrol . 1993. “Governance in Exchange: Contract Lawand Its Alternatives.” Journal of Public Policy & Marketing 12 (2): 141-155.

41.

Gundlach, Gregory T. Ravi S. Achrol , and John T. Mentzer . 1995. “The Structure of Commitment in Exchange.” Journal of Marketing 59 (January): 78-92.

42.

Gundlach, Gregory T. Ravi S. Achrol and Patrick E. Murphy . 1993. “Ethical and Legal Foundations of Relational Marketing Exchange.” Journal of Marketing 57 (October): 35-46.

43.

Harrison, Debbie . 2004. “Is a Long-Term Business Relationship an Implied Contract? Two Views of Relationship Disengagement.” Journal of Management Studies 41 (1): 107-125.

44.

Hattie, John R. 1985. “Methodological Review: Assessing Unidimensionality of Tests and Items.” Applied Psychological Measurement 9 (June): 139-164.

45.

Haytko, Diana L. 2004. “Firm-to-Firm Interpersonal Relationships: Perspectives From Advertising Agency Account Managers.” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 32 (3): 312-328.

46.

Heide, Jan B. 1994. “InterorganizationalGovernance in Marketing Channels.” Journal of Marketing 58 (January): 71-85.

47.

Heide, Jan B. and George John . 1992. “Do Norms Matter in Marketing Relationships?” Journal of Marketing 56 (April): 32-44.

48.

Hutt, Michael D. and Edwin R. Stafford . 2000. “Defining the Social Network of a Strategic Alliance.” Sloan Management Review 41 (2): 51-63.

49.

Joshi, Ashwin W. and Stephen J. Arnold . 1998. “How Relational Norms Affect Compliance in Industrial Buying.” Journal of Business Research 41:105-114.

50.

Joshi, Ashwin W. Stephen J. Arnold and Rodney L. Stump . 1999a. “Determinants of Commitment and Opportunism: Integrating and Extending Insights From Transaction Cost Analysis and Relational Exchange Theory.” Canadian Journal of Administration Sciences 16 (4): 334-352.

51.

Joshi, Ashwin W. Stephen J. Arnold and Rodney L. Stump .1999b. “Transaction Cost Analysis: Integration of Recent Refinements and an Empirical Test.” Journal of Business-to-Business Marketing 5 (4): 37-69.

52.

Kaufmann, Patrick J. and Louis S. Stern . 1988. “Relational Exchange Norms, Perceptions of Unfairness, and Retained Hostility in Commercial Litigation.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 32 (3): 534-552.

53.

Kaufmann, Patrick J. and Louis S. Stern 1992. “Relational Exchange, Contracting Norms, and Conflict in Industrial Exchange.” Advances in Distribution Channel Research 1:135-159.

54.

Keltner, B. and D. Finegold . 1996. “Adding Value in Banking: Human Resource Innovations for Service Firms.” Sloan Management Review 38 (1): 57-68.

55.

Lam, Shun Lin , Venkatesh Shankar, M. Krishna Erramilli , and Bvsan Murphy . 2004. “Customer Value, Satisfaction, Loyalty, and Switching Costs: An Illustration From a Business-to-Business Service Contect.” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 32 (3): 293-311.

56.

Lambe C. Jay , Robert E. Spekman , and Shelby D. Hunt . 2000. “Interimistic Relational Exchange: Conceptualization and Propositional Development.” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 28 (2): 212-225.

57.

Lambe C. Jay , Robert E. Spekman , and Shelby D. Hunt , C. Michael Wittmann , and Robert E. Spekman . 2001. “Social Exchange Theory and Research on Business-to-Business Relational Exchange.” Journal of Business-to-Business Marketing 8 (3): 1-36.

58.

Lusch, Robert F. and James R. Brown . 1996. “Interdependency, Contracting, and Relational Behavior in Marketing Channels.” Journal of Marketing 60 (October): 19-38.

59.

Macaulay, Stewart . 1963. “Non-Contractual Relations in Business: A Preliminary Study.” American Sociological Review 28:55-67.

60.

Macneil, Ian R. 1974. “The Many Futures of Contracts.” Southern California Law Review 47:691-816.

61.

Macneil, Ian R. 1978. “Contracts: Adjustments of Long-Term Economic Relations Under Classical, Neo-Classical, and Relational Contracting Law.” Northwestern University Law Review 72 (6): 854-905.

62.

Macneil, Ian R. 1980. The New Social Contract: An Inquiry Into Modern Contractual Relations. New Haven, CT: SYale University Press.

63.

Macneil, Ian R. 2000. “Relational Contract Theory: Challenges and Queries.” Northwestern University Law Review 94 (3): 877-907.

64.

Marsh, Herbert W. and Dennis Hocevar . 1985. “Application of Confirmatory Factor Analysis to the Study of Self-Concept: First-and Higher Order Factor Models and Their Invariance Across Groups.” Psychological-Bulletin 97 (3): 562-582.

65.

McKelvey, William W. 1976. “An Approach for Developing Shorter and better Measuring Instruments.” WorkingPaper 76-6. HumanSystems Development Center, Graduate School of Management, University of California, Los Angeles.

66.

Morgan, Robert M. and Shelby D. Hunt . 1994. “The Commitment-Trust Theory of Relationship Marketing.” Journal of Marketing 58 (July): 20-38.

67.

Neilson, Charles C. 1998. “An Empirical Examination of the Role of ‘Closeness’ in Industrial Buyer-Seller Relationships.” European Journal of Marketing 32 (5/6): 441-463.

68.

Nevin, John R. 1995. “Relationship Marketing and Distribution Channels: Exploring Fundamental Issues.” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 23 (4): 327-334.

69.

Newcomb, Michael D. , G. T. Huba , and Peter M. Bentler . 1986. “ Determinants of Sexual and Dating Behaviors AmongAdolescence.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 50 (2): 428-438.

70.

Noordewier, Thomas G. , George John , and John R. Nevin . 1990. “ Performance Outcomes of Purchasing Arrangements in Industrial Buyer-Vendor Relationships.” Journal of Marketing 54 (0ctober): 80-93.

71.

Nunnally, Jum C. and Ira H. Bernstein . 1994. Psychometric Theory. 3d ed. New York: SMcGraw-Hill.

72.

Parasuraman, A. 1998. “Customer Service in Business-to-Business Markets: An Agenda for Research.” Journal of Business and Industrial Marketing 13 (4/5): 309-321.

73.

Parasuraman, A. , Valarie A. Zeithaml , and Leonard L. Berry . 1988.“SERVQUAL: A Multi-Item Scale for Measuring Consumer Perceptions of Service Quality.” Journal of Retailing 64 (Spring): 12-40.

74.

Paulin, Michèle , Ronald J. Ferguson , and Marielle Payaud . 2000a. “ Business Effectiveness and Professional Service Personnel.” European Journal of Marketing 34 (3/4): 453-471.

75.

Paulin, Michèle , Ronald J. Ferguson , and Marielle Payaud . 2000b. “Effectiveness of Relational and Transactional Cultures in Commercial Banking: Putting Client-Value in to the Competing Value Model.” International Journal of Bank Marketing 18 (7): 328-337.

76.

Paulin, Michèle , Jean Perrien , and Ronald J. Ferguson . 1997. “Relational Contract Norms and the Effectiveness of Commercial Banking Relationships.” International Journal of Service Industry Management 8 (5): 435-452.

77.

Peterson, Robert A. 1994. “A Meta-Analysis of Cronbach's Coefficient Alpha.” Journal of Consumer Research 21 (2): 381-391.

78.

Reichheld, Frederick F. 1993. “Loyalty-Based Management.” Harvard Business Review 71 (2): 64-73.

79.

Rindfleisch, Aric and Jan B. Heide . 1997. “Transaction Cost Analysis: Past, Present, and Future Applications.” Journal of Marketing 61 (October): 30-54.

80.

Sawyer, Alan G. and J. Paul Peter . 1983. “The Significance of Statistical Significance Tests in Marketing Research.” Journal of Marketing Research 20 (2): 122-134.

81.

Schneider, Benjamin and David E. Bowen . 1995. Winning the Service Game. Boston: SHarvard Business School Press.

82.

Singh, Jagdip . 2000. “Performance Productivity and Quality of Frontline Employees in Service Organizations.” Journal of Marketing 64 (2): 15-35.

83.

Sirdeshmukh, Deepak , Jagdip Singh , and Barry Sabol . 2002. “Consumer Trust, Value and Loyalty in Relational Exchanges.” Journal of Marketing 66 (January): 15-37.

84.

Sobrero, Maurizio and Stephan Schrader . 1998. “Structuring Inter-Firm Relationships: AMeta-Analytic Approach.” Organization Studies 19 (4): 585-615.

85.

Stinchcombe, Arthur L. 1985. “Contracts as Hierarchical Documents.” In Organizational Theory and Project Management Administering Uncertainty in Norwegian Offshore Oil. Eds. Arthur L. Stinchcombe and Carol A. Heimer . Bergen, Norway: Norwegian University Press, 121-171.

86.

Tyler, Katherine and Edmund Stanley . 2001. “Marketing Financial Services to Businesses: A Critical Review and Research Agenda.” International Journal of Bank Marketing 17 (3): 98-115.

87.

Uzzi, Brian . 1999. “Embeddedness in the Making of Financial Capital: How Social Relations and Networks Benefits Firms Seeking Financing.” American Sociological Review 64 (August): 481-505.

88.

Van Bruggen, Gerrit H. , Gary L. Lilien , and Manish Kacker . 2002. “ Informants in Organizational Marketing Research: Why Use Multiple Informants and How to Aggregate Responses.” Journal of Marketing Research 39 (4): 469-478.

89.

Williamson, Oliver E. 1975. Markets andHierarchies. NewYork: SMcGraw-Hill.

90.

Williamson, Oliver E. 1985. The Economic Institutions of Capitalism. New York: SFree Press.

91.

Williamson, Oliver E. 1996. The Mechanisms of Governance. New York: SFree Press.

92.

Zeithaml, Valarie A. , Leonard L. Berry , and A. Parasuraman . 1996. “The Behavioral Consequences of Service Quality.” Journal of Marketing 68 (April): 31-46.

93.

Zinkhan, George . 2002. “Relationship Marketing: Theory and Implementation.” Journal of Market-Focused Management 5:83-89.

94.

Zinkhan, George , and James A. Verbrugge . 2000. “The Marketing/Finance Interface: TwoDivergent and ComplementaryViews of the Firm.” Journal of Business Research 50:143-148.

95.

Zinkhan, George , James A. Verbrugge and F. Christian Zinkhan . 1997. “The Interface Between Marketing and Finance: Integrated Management in an Unstable World.” Managerial Finance 23 (10): 3-2.