Fear of opportunistic customers is an important reason why firms are reluctant to implement service guarantees. This article empirically tests potential drivers of cheating. Potential material gain and repeat purchase intent were tested across three studies, whereas satisfaction, ease of invoking the guarantee, morality, shame, self-monitoring, and Machiavellianism were each tested in a subset of the three studies. The results for potential material gain and repeat purchase intent were consistent across all three studies: potential material gain had no effect on consumer cheating, but repeat purchase intent reduced that tendency. Other findings suggest that high levels of satisfaction, morality, and self-monitoring reduce cheating, whereas high levels of Machiavellianism increase cheating. Furthermore, two three-way interaction effects were encountered. Specifically, Machiavellianism interacted with gain and ease of invocation, and with gain and repeat purchase intent. In both cases, individuals with high Machiavellianism took advantage of certain situational constellations.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abratt, Russell, Deon Nel, and Nicola S. Higgs. 1992. “An Examination of the Ethical Beliefs of Managers Using Selected Scenarios in a Cross-cultural Environment.” Journal of Business Ethics11 (1): 29-35 .
2.
Albrecht, Steve W., Keith R. Howe, and Marshall B. Romey. 1984. Deterring Fraud: The Internal Auditor’s Perspective. Altamonte Springs, FL: The Institute of Internal Auditors Research Foundation .
3.
Axelrod, Robert. 1984. The Evolution of Cooperation. New York: Basic Books .
4.
Becker, Helmut and David J. Fritzshe. 1987. “Business Ethics: A Cross-cultural Comparison of Managers’ Attitudes.” Journal of Business Ethics6 (4): 289-295 .
5.
Bennett, Rebecca J. and Sandra L. Robinson. 2003. “The Past, Present and Future of Workplace Deviance Research.” In Organizational Behavior: The State of the Science, 2d ed. Ed. J. Greenberg. Mahwah, NJ: Laurence Erlbaum .
6.
Blake, Judith and Kingsley Davis. 1964. “Norms, Values and Sanctions.” In Handbook of Modern Sociology. Ed. R. Faris. Chicago: Rand McNally , 456-484.
7.
Christie, Richard and Florence L. Geis. 1970. Studies in Machiavellianism. New York: Academic Press .
8.
Chu, Wujin, Eitan Gerstner, and James D. Hess. 1998. “Managing Dissatisfaction: How to Decrease Customer Opportunism by Partial Refunds.” Journal of Service Research1 (2): 140-155 .
9.
Cialdini, Robert B. 1996. “Social Influence and the Triple Tumor Structure of Organizational Dishonesty.” In Codes of Conduct: Behavioral Research Into Business Ethics. Eds. M. Messik and A. E. Tenbrunsel. New York: Russell Sage , 44-56.
10.
Cole, Catherine A. 1989. “Research Note: Deterrence and Consumer Fraud.” Journal of Retailing65 (Spring): 107-120 .
11.
Corcoran, Kevin J. and Julian B. Rotter. 1987. “Morality—Conscience Guilt Scale as a Predictor of Ethical Behavior in a Cheating Situation Among College Females.” Journal of General Psychology114 (2): 117-123 .
12.
Covey, Mark K., Steve Saladin, and Peter J. Killen. 1989. “Self-Monitoring, Surveillance, and Incentive Effects on Cheating.” Journal of Social Psychology129 (5): 673-679 .
13.
Cox, Anthony D., Dena Cox, Ronald D. Anderson, and George P. Moschis. 1993. “Research Note: Social Influences on Adolescent Shoplifting—Theory, Evidence, and Implications for the Retail Industry.” Journal of Retailing69 (Summer): 234-246 .
14.
Dabholkar, Pratibha A. 1996. “Consumer Evaluations of New Technology-Based Self-Service Options: An Investigation of Alternative Models of Service Quality.” International Journal of Research in Marketing13: 29-51 .
15.
DePaulo, Bella M., J. I. Stone, and Daniel G. Lassiter. 1985. “Deceiving and Detecting Deceit.” In The Self and Social Life. Ed. B. R. Schlenker. New York: McGraw-Hill , 323-370.
16.
Dittenhofer, Mortimer A. 1995. “Fraud Corruption in the Public Sector: The Behavioral Aspects of Fraud and Embezzlement.” Public Money and Management15 (1): 9-14 .
17.
Ekman, Paul. 1985. Telling Lies. New York: Norton .
18.
Ekman, Paul and Wallace V. Friesen. 1974. “Detecting Deception From Body or Face.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology29: 288-298 .
19.
Ford, Robert C. and Woodrow D. Richardson. 1994. “Ethical Decision Making: A Review of Empirical Literature.” Journal of Business Ethics13: 205-221 .
20.
Fornell, Claes and Birger Wernerfelt. 1987. “Defensive Marketing Strategy by Customer Complaint Management: A Theoretical Analysis.” Journal of Marketing Research24 (4): 337-346 .
21.
Fornell, Claes and Birger Wernerfelt. 1988. “A Model for Customer Complaint Management.” Marketing Science7: 287-298 .
22.
Ghosh, Dipankar, and Terry L. Crain. 1995. “Ethical Standards, Attitudes Toward Risk and Intentional Noncompliance: An Experimental Investigation.” Journal of Business Ethics14 (5): 353-365 .
23.
Grover, Steven L. and Chun Hui. 1994. “The Influence of Role Conflict and Self Interest on Lying in Organizations.” Journal of Business Ethics13 (4): 295-303 .
24.
Harris, Lloyd C. and Emmanuel Ogbonna. 2002. “Exploring Service Sabotage: The Antecedents, Types and Consequences of Frontline Deviant, Antiservice Behaviors.” Journal of Service Research4 (3): 163-183 .
25.
Hart, Christopher W. L. 1988. “The Power of Unconditional Service Guarantees.” Harvard Business Review67 (4): 54-62 .
26.
Hart, Christopher W. L. 1993. Extraordinary Guarantees: A New Way to Build Quality Throughout Your Company and Ensure Satisfaction for Your Customers. New York: AMACOM .
27.
Hart, Christopher W. L., Leonard A. Schlesinger, and Dan Maher. 1992. “Guarantees Come to Professional Service Firms.” Sloan Management Review33 (3): 19-29 .
28.
Hays, Julie M. and Arthur V. Hill. 2001. “A Longitudinal Study of the Effect of a Service Guarantee on Service Quality.” Production and Operations Management10 (4): 405-423 .
29.
Hegarty, Harvey W. and Henry P. Sims, Jr. 1978. “Some Determinants of Unethical Decision Behavior: An Experiment.” Journal of Applied Psychology63 (4): 451-457 .
30.
Hegarty, Harvey W. and Henry P. Sims, Jr. 1979. “Organizational Philosophy, Policies and Objectives Related to Unethical Decision Behavior: A Laboratory Experiment.” Journal of Applied Psychology64 (3): 331-338 .
31.
Heskett, James L., W. Earl Sasser, and Christopher W. L. Hart. 1990. “Developing Devices for Achieving Total Customer Satisfaction.” In Service Breakthroughs: Changing the Rules of the Game. New York: Free Press , 87-111.
32.
Hofstede, Geert H. 1980. Culture’s Consequences: International Differences in Work-Related Values. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage .
33.
Hollinger, Richard C. and John P. Clark. 1983. Theft by Employees. Lexington Books, MA: Lexington .
34.
Hwang, Peter and Willem P. Burgers. 1997. “Properties of Trust: An Analytical View.” Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes. 69 (1): 67-73 .
35.
Hwang, Peter and Willem P. Burgers. 1999. “Apprehension and Temptation.” Journal of Conflict Resolution43 (1): 117-130 .
36.
Huefner, Jonathan C. and H. Keith Hunt. 2000. “Consumer Retaliation as a Response to Dissatisfaction.” Journal of Consumer Satisfaction, Dissatisfaction and Complaining Behavior 13:61-82.
37.
Iacobucci, Dawn. 2001. “Editor’s Integration of Discussion on ‘Continuous and Discrete Variables—Treating an Individual Difference Predictor as Continuous or Categorical.’” Journal of Consumer Psychology10 (1-2), 52-53 .
38.
Irwin, Julie. 2001. “Author’s Comment to Discussion on ‘Continuous and Discrete Variables—Treating an Individual Difference Predictor as Continuous or Categorical.’” Journal of Consumer Psychology10 (1-2): 51-52 .
39.
Johnson, Ronald C., George P. Danko, Yau-Huang Huang, Jong Young Park, Steven B. Johnson, and Craig T. Nagoshi. 1987. “Guilt, Shame, and Adjustment in Three Cultures.” Personal Individual Differences8 (3): 357-364 .
40.
Johnson, Ronald C. and R. Noel. 1970. Dimensions of Conscience. Unpublished Manuscript. University of Hawaii, Honolulu .
41.
Jones, Gwen E. and Michael J. Kavanagh. 1996. “An Experimental Examination of the Effects of Individual and Situational Factors on Unethical Behavioral Intentions in the Workplace.” Journal of Business Ethics15: 511-523 .
42.
June, Leslie P. and Stephen L. J. Smith. 1987. “Service Attributes and Situational Effects on Customer Preferences for Restaurant Dining.” Journal of Travel Research26 (2): 20-27 .
43.
Kallis, Jeffrey M. and Dinoo J. Vanier. 1985. “Consumer Shoplifting: Orientations and Deterrents.” Journal of Criminal Justice13 (5): 459-473 .
44.
Kandampully, Jay and Liam Butler. 2001. “Service Guarantees: A Strategic Mechanism to Minimize Customers’ Perceived Risk in Service Organizations.” Managing Service Quality11 (2): 112-120 .
45.
Kashyap, Rajiv. 2001. “The Effects of Service Guarantees on External and Internal Markets.” Academy of Marketing Science Review [On-line] 01 (10).
46.
Katz, Roger C., Jennifer Santman, and Pamela Lonero. 1994. “Findings on the Revised Morally Debatable Behaviors Scale.” Journal of Psychology128 (1): 15-21 .
47.
Kau, Ah Keng, Soo Jiuan Tan, and Jochen Wirtz. 1998. Seven Faces of Singaporeans—Their Values, Aspirations and Lifestyles. Singapore: Prentice Hall .
48.
Kohlberg, Lawrence. 1969. “Stage and Sequence: The Cognitive Development Approach to Socialization.” In The Handbook of Socialization Theory and Research. Ed. D. A. Goslin. Chicago: Rand McNally , 347-480.
49.
Kum, Doreen and Jochen Wirtz. 2003. “Determinants of Unethical and Opportunistic Behavior of Consumers.” The NUS Business School Research Paper Series. No. 2003-039 (Mkt), National University of Singapore .
50.
Lewis, Michael. 1993. “Self-Conscious Emotions: Embarrassment, Pride, Shame and Guilt.” In Handbook of Emotions. Eds. M. Lewis and J. M. Haviland. New York: Guilford , 563-573.
51.
Lim, Vivien K. G. and Sean K. B. See. 2001. “Attitudes Toward, and Intentions to Report, Academic Cheating Among Students in Singapore.” Ethics & Behavior11 (3): 261-274 .
52.
Longo, Tracey. 1995. “At Stores, Many Unhappy Returns.” Kiplinger’s Personal Finance Magazine20: 239-255 .
53.
Malinowski, Carl I. and Charles P. Smith. 1985. “Moral Reasoning and Moral Conduct: An Investigation Prompted by Kohlberg’s Theory.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology49 (4): 1016-1027 .
54.
Marmorstein, Howard, Dan Sarel, and Walfried M. Lassar. 2001. “Increasing the Persuasiveness of a Service Guarantee: The Role of Service Process Evidence.” Journal of Services Marketing15 (2): 147-159 .
55.
Maxwell, Scott E. and HaroldD. Delaney. 1993. “Bivariate Median Splits and Spurious Statistical Significance.” Psychological Bulletin66: 464-472 .
56.
McCollough, Michael A. and Dwayne D. Gremler. 1999. “Guaranteeing Student Satisfaction: An Exercise in Treating Students as Customers.” Journal of Marketing Education21 (2): 118-130 .
57.
McDougall, Gordon H., Terence Levesque, and Peter VanderPlaat. 1998. “Designing the Service Guarantee: Unconditional or Specific?” Journal of Services Marketing12 (4): 278-293 .
58.
Mosher, Dina L. 1965. “Interaction of Fear and Guilt in Inhibiting Unacceptable Behavior.” Journal of Consulting Psychology29: 161-167 .
59.
Mudrack, Peter E. 1994. “Are the Elderly Really Machiavellian? A Reinterpretation of an Unexpected Finding.” Journal of Business Ethics13: 757-758 .
60.
Narayandas, Das. 1998. Measuring and Managing the Benefits of Customer Retention.” Journal of Service Research1 (2): 108-128 .
61.
Nettler, Gwynn. 1982. Lying, Cheating, and Stealing. Cincinnati, OH: Anderson .
62.
Ostrom, Amy L. and Christopher W. L. Hart. 2000. “Service Guarantees: Research and Practice.” In Handbook of Services Marketing & Management. Eds. T. Schwartz and D. Iacobucci. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage , 299-316.
63.
Ostrom, Amy L. and Dawn Iacobucci. 1998. “The Effect of Guarantees on Consumer’s Evaluation of Services.” Journal of Services Marketing12 (5): 362-378 .
64.
Paternoster, Raymond and Sally Simpson. 1996. “Sanction Threats and Appeals to Morality: Testing a Rational Choice Model of Corporate Crime.” Law and Society Review30 (3): 549-583 .
65.
Salamon, S. and Sandra L. Robinson. 2002. “Does Trust Climate Deter Workplace Deviance? An Organizational Level Analysis.” Paper presented at the annual meeting of the Academy of Management. Denver, CO.
66.
Schwartz, R. D. and S. Orleans. 1967. “On Legal Sanctions.” The University of Chicago Law Review34: 274-300 .
67.
Singhapakdi, Anusorn and Scott J. Vitell. 1990. “Marketing Ethics: Factors Influencing Perceptions of Ethical Problems and Alternatives.” Journal of Macromarketing10 (1): 4-18 .
68.
Snyder, Mark. 1974. “Self-Monitoring of Expressive Behavior.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology30 (4): 526-537 .
69.
Snyder, Mark. 1987. Public Appearances/Private Realities. New York: W. H. Freeman .
70.
Trevino, Linda K. 1986. “Ethical Decision Making in Organizations: A Person-Situation Interactionist Model.” Academy of Management Review11 (3): 601-617 .
71.
Tripp, Thomas M. and Robert J. Bies. 1997. “What’s Good About Revenge? The Avenger’s Perspective.” Research on Negotiation in Organizations6: 145-160 .
72.
Tybout, Alice. 2001. Response to “Continuous and Discrete Variables—Treating an Individual Difference Predictor as Continuous or Categorical.” Journal of Consumer Psychology10 (1-2): 48-59 .
73.
World Bank. 1995. World Bank Atlas. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press for the World Bank .
74.
Wirtz, Jochen. 1998. “Development of a Service Guarantee Model.” Asia Pacific Journal of Management15 (1): 51-75 .
75.
Wirtz, Jochen and Doreen Kum. 2001. “Designing Service Guarantees—Is Full Satisfaction the Best You Can Guarantee?” Journal of Services Marketing15 (4): 282-299 .
76.
Zhang, Jianxin and Michael H. Bond. 1993. “Target-Based Interpersonal Trust: Cross-Cultural Comparison and Its Cognitive Model.” Acta Psychologica Sinica25 (2): 164-172 .
77.
Zinkhan, George M. and Kiran W. Karande. 1991. “Cultural and Gender Differences in Risk-Taking Behavior Among American and Spanish Decision Makers.” Journal of Social Psychology131 (5): 741-742 .
