The authors examined the crowd sections of 20 introduction to sociology textbooks, coding them for the presence of seven crowds myths—claims about crowds that have no empirical support and have been rejected by scholars in the field. The number of myths per book ranges from five to one. The authors conclude by making suggestions for rewriting these chapters and for improving the book reviewing process.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AltheideDavidJohnsonJ.1977.
“Counting Souls: A Study of Counseling at Evangelical Crusades.”
Pacific Sociological Review20:
323–48.
2.
AminzadeRonMcAdamDoug2002a.
“Emotions and Contentious Politics.”
Mobilization7:
107–9.
3.
AminzadeRonMcAdamDoug2002b.
Special issue on Emotions and Contentious Politics.
Mobilization7
(2).
4.
AndersonMargaretTaylorHoward2000.
Sociology: Understanding a Diverse Society.
Belmont, CA:
Wadsworth.
5.
AtkinsonJ. Maxwell1984.
“Public Speaking and Audience Responses: Some Techniques for Inviting Applause.”
Pp. 370–410 in
Structures of Social Action: Studies in Conversation Analysis,
edited by AtkinsonJ. MaxwellHeritageJohnCambridge, England:
Cambridge University Press.
6.
AveniAdrian1977.
“The Not So Lonely Crowd: Friendship Groups in Collective Behavior.”
Sociometry40:
96–9.
7.
BakerPaul1988.
“Sociology Textbooks: Managing Clones or Writing Works of Distinction.”
Teaching Sociology16:
381–3.
8.
BeemanM.ChowdhryG.ToddK.2000.
“Educating Students about Affirmative Action: An Analysis of University Sociology Texts.”
Teaching Sociology28:
98–115.
9.
BergerPeter1963.
Invitation to Sociology.
New York:
Doubleday.
10.
BestJoelSchweingruberDavid2003.
“First Words: Do Sociologists Actually Use the Terms in Introductory Textbooks' Glossaries?”
The American Sociologist34:
97–106.
11.
BrushStephen G.1996.
“Dynamics of Theory Change in the Social Sciences: Relative Deprivation and Collective Violence.”
The Journal of Conflict Resolution40:
523–45.
12.
BryanJohn1981.
Implications for Codes and Behavior Models form the Analysis of Behavior Response Patterns in Fire Situations.Department of Fire Protection Engineering, University of Maryland,
College Park, MD.
13.
BryanJohn1982.
An Examination and Analysis of the Dynamics of Human Behavior in the MGM Grand Hotel Fire.Department of Fire Protection Engineering, University of Maryland,
College Park, MD.
14.
BrymRobertLieJohn2003.
Sociology: Your Compass for a New World.
Belmont, CA:
Wadsworth/Thomson Learning.
15.
CantorDavid1980.
“An Overview of Human Behavior in Fires.”
Pp. 224–34 in
Fires and Human Behavior,
edited by CantorD.New York:
Wiley.
16.
CarterGregg Lee1990.
“Black Attitudes and the 1960s Black Riots: An Aggregated-level Analysis of the Kerner Commission's ‘15 Cities’ Data.”
The Sociological Quarterly31:
269–86.
17.
ClellandDonaldHoodThomasLipseyC.MWimberlyRonald1974.
“In the Company of the Converted: Characteristics of a Billy Graham Crusade Audience.”
Sociological Analysis86:
984–1014.
18.
CouchCarl J.1968.
“Collective Behavior: An Examination of Some Stereotypes.”
Social Problems15:
310–22.
19.
DamasioAntonio1994.
Descartes' Error: Emotion, Reason, and the Human Brain.
New York:
Putnam.
20.
della PortaDonatellaReiterHerbert1998.
“The Policing of Protest in Western Democracies.”
Pp. 1–32 in
Policing Protest: The Control of Mass Demonstrations in Western Democracies,
edited by della PortaD.ReiterH.Minneapolis, MN:
University of Minnesota Press.
21.
Dennick-BrechtM. Kathryn1993.
“Developing a More Inclusive Sociology Curriculum: Racial and Ethnic-Group Coverage in 30 Introductory Textbooks.”
Teaching Sociology21:
166–71.
22.
DoobChristopher Bates2000.
Sociology: An Introduction.
Fort Worth, TX:
Harcourt Brace.
23.
DrabeckThomas1968.
Disaster in Aisle 13.
Columbus, OH:
Ohio State University Disaster Research Center.
24.
EdgertonRobert1979.
Alone Together: Social Order on an Urban Beach.
Berkeley, CA:
University of California Press.
25.
EisingerPeter1973.
“The Conditions of Protest Behavior in American Cities.”
American Political Science Review67:
11–28.
26.
EvansRobert1969.
Readings in Collective Behavior.
Chicago, IL:
Rand-McNally.
27.
FarleyJohn1998.
Sociology.
Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Prentice-Hall.
28.
FerreeMyra MarxHallElaine1990.
“Visual Images of American Society: Gender and Race in Introductory Sociology Textbooks.”
Gender and Society4:
500–33.
29.
FerreeMyra MarxHallElaine1996.
“Rethinking Stratification from a Feminist Perspective: Gender, Race, and Class in Mainstream Textbooks.”
American Sociological Review61:
929–50.
30.
GiddensAnthonyDuneierMitchell2000.
Introduction to Sociology.
New York:
W.W. Norton.
31.
GillhamPatrick F.MarxGary T.2000.
“Complexity and Irony in Policing and Protesting: The World Trade Organization in Seattle.”
Social Justice27:
212–35.
32.
GoffmanErving1963.
Behavior in Public Places.
New York:
Free Press.
33.
GoffmanErving1971.
Relations in Public.
New York:
Harper Colophon Books.
34.
GoodwinJeffJasperJames M.PollettaFrancesca2001a.
“Passionate Politics: Emotions and Social Movements.”
Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press.
35.
GoodwinJeffJasperJames M.PollettaFrancesca2001b.
“Why Emotions Matter.”
Pp. 1–24 in
Passionate Politics: Emotions and Social Movements,
edited by GoodwinJ.JasperJ. M.PollettaF.Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press.
36.
GrahamFranklin1988.
“Some Observations on Sociology Textbooks: An Editorial Perspective.”
Teaching Sociology16:
356–65.
37.
GreerD.L.1983.
“Spectator Booing and the Home Advantage: A Study of Social Influence in the Basketball Arena.”
Social Psychology Quarterly46:
252–61.
38.
HallElaine1988.
“One Week for Women? The Structure of Inclusion of Gender Issues in Introductory Textbooks.”
Teaching Sociology16:
431–42.
39.
HallElaine2000.
“Packaging Poverty as an Intersection of Class, Race, and Gender in Introductory Textbooks, 1982 to 1994.”
Teaching Sociology28:
299–315.
40.
HamiltonRichard F.FormWilliam H.2003.
“Categorical Usages and Complex Realities: Race, Ethnicity, and Religion in the United States.”
Social Forces81:
693–714.
41.
HenslinJames2001.
Sociology: A Down-to-Earth Approach.
Boston, MA:
Allyn and Bacon.
42.
HeritageJohnGreatbatchDavid1986.
“Generating Applause: A Study of Rhetoric and Response at Party Political Conferences.”
American Journal of Sociology92:
110–57.
43.
JohnsonNorris1987a.
“Panic and the Breakdown of Social Order: Popular Myth, Social Theory, Empirical Evidence.”
Sociological Focus20:
171–83.
44.
JohnsonNorris1987b.
“Panic at ‘The Who’ Concert ‘Stampede’: An Empirical Assessment.”
Social Problems45:
362–73.
45.
JohnsonNorris1988.
“Fire in a Crowded Theater.”
International Journal of Mass Emergencies and Disasters6:
7–26.
46.
JohnsonNorrisChoateDavidBunisWilliam1984.
“Attendance at a Billy Graham Crusade: A Resource Mobilization Approach.”
Sociological Analysis45:
383–92.
47.
JohnsonNorrisJohnstonDrue1988.
“Role Extension in Disaster: Employee Behavior at the Beverly Hills Supper Club Fire.”
Sociological Focus22:
39–51.
48.
KeatingJohn1982.
“The Myth of Panic.”
Fire Journal77:
57–61,
147.
49.
KendallDiana1999.
“Doing a Good Deed or Confounding the Problem? Peer Review and Sociology Textbooks.”
Teaching Sociology27:
17–30.
50.
KendallDiana2001.
Sociology in Our Times.
Belmont, CA:
Wadsworth.
51.
KornblumWilliam2000.
Sociology in a Changing World.
Forth Worth, TX:
Harcourt.
52.
LandisJudson2001.
Sociology: Concepts and Characteristics.
Belmont, CA:
Wadsworth.
LewisJerry1982.
“Fan Violence.”
Pp. 175–206 in
Research on Social Problems and Public Policy,
vol. 2,
edited by LewisM.Greenwich, CN:
JAI Press.
55.
LindseyLindaBeachStephen2002.
Sociology.
Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Prentice-Hall.
56.
LoflandJohn1981.
“Collective Behavior: The Elementary Forms.”
Pp. 411–46 in
Social Psychology,
edited by RosenbergMorrisTurnerRalph H.New York:
Basic Books.
57.
LucalB1994.
“Class Stratification in Introductory Textbooks—Relational or Distributional Models.”
Teaching Sociology22:
139–50.
58.
MacCannellDean1973.
Nonviolent Action as Theater,
vol. 10.
Haverford, PA:
Haverford College Center for Nonviolent Conflict Resolution.
59.
MacionisJohn2003.
Sociology.
Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Prentice Hall.
60.
MannLeon1969.
“Queue Culture: The Waiting Line as a Social Problem.”
American Journal of Sociology75:
340–54.
61.
MannLeon1973.
“Learning to Live with Lines.”
Pp. 42–61 in
Urbanman: The Psychology of Urban Survival,
edited by HelmerJohnEddingtonNeil A.New York:
Free Press.
62.
MarquezStephanie Amedeo1994.
“Distorting the Image of Hispanic Women in Sociology: Problematic Strategies of Presentation in the Introductory Text.”
Teaching Sociology22:
231–6.
63.
MasseyDouglas S.2002.
“A Brief History of Human Society: The Origin and Role of Emotion in Social Life.”
American Sociological Review67:
1–29.
64.
McAdamDougSnowDavid A.1997.
Social Movements.
Los Angeles, CA:
Roxbury.
65.
McPhailClark1989.
“Blumer's Theory of Collective Behavior: The Evolution of a Non-Symbolic Interaction Explanation.”
The Sociological Quarterly30:
401–23.
66.
McPhailClark1991.
The Myth of the Madding Crowd.
New York:
Aldine De Gruyter.
67.
McPhailClark1994a.
“The Dark Side of Purpose: Individual and Collective Violence in Riots.”
The Sociological Quarterly35:
1–32.
68.
McPhailClark1994b.
“Social Behavior in Public Places: From Clusters to Arcs and Rings.”
Pp. 35–57 in
The Community of the Streets,
edited by CahillS.LoflandL.Greenwich, CT:
JAI Press.
69.
McPhailClark1997.
“Stereotypes of the Crowds and Collective Behavior: Looking Backward, Looking Forward.”
Pp. 35–58 in
Constructing Complexity: Symbolic Interaction and Social Forms,
edited by MillerDan E.KatovichMichael A.SaxtonStanley L.Greenwich, CT:
JAI Press.
70.
McPhailClarkMillerDavid1973.
“The Assembling Process: A Theoretical and Empirical Examination.”
American Sociological Review38:
721–35.
71.
McPhailClarkPowersWilliam T.TuckerCharles W.1992.
“Simulating Individual and Collective Action in Temporary Gatherings.”
Social Science Computer Review10:
1–28.
72.
McPhailClarkSchweingruberDavid1998.
“Unpacking Protest Events: A Description Bias Analysis of Media Records with Systematic Direct Observations of Collective Action—The 1995 March for Life in Washington, D.C.”
Pp. 164–95 in
Acts of Dissent: New Developments in the Study of Protest,
edited by RuchtDieterKoopmansRuudNeidhardtFriedhelmBerlin, Germany:
Sigma Press.
73.
McPhailClarkSchweingruberDavidMcCarthyJohn1998.
“Policing Protest in the United States: 1960–1995.”
Pp. 49–69 in
Policing Protest: The Control of Mass Demonstrations in Western Democracies,
edited by della PortaD.ReiterH.Minneapolis, MN:
University of Minnesota Press.
74.
McPhailClarkTuckerCharles W.1990.
“Purposive Collective Action.”
American Behavioral Scientist34:
81–94.
75.
McPhailClarkWohlsteinRonald T.1983.
“Individual and Collective Behaviors in Gatherings, Demonstrations and Riots.”
Annual Review of Sociology90:
579–609.
76.
McPhailClarkWohlsteinRonald T.1986.
“Collective Locomotion as Collective Behavior.”
American Sociological Review51:
447–63.
77.
MilgramStanleyLibertyH.J.ToledoR.WackenhutJ.1986.
“Response in Intrusions into Waiting Lines.”
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology51:
683–9.
78.
MyersDaniel J.2000.
“The Diffusion of Collective Violence: Infectiousness, Susceptibility, and Mass Media Networks.”
American Journal of Sociology106:
173–208.
79.
NealDavid M.1994.
“A Further Examination of Anonymity, Contagion, and Deindividuation in Crowd and Collective Behavior.”
Sociological Focus26:
93–107.
80.
NewmanDavid2002.
Sociology: Exploring the Architecture of Everyday Life.
Thousand Oaks, CA:
Sage.
81.
NolanPatrick D.2003.
“Questioning Textbook Truth: Suicide Rates and the Hawthorne Effect.”
The American Sociologist34:
107–16.
82.
OlzakSusanShanahanSuzanneMcEneaneyElizabeth H.1996.
“Poverty, Segregation, and Race Riots: 1960–1993.”
American Sociological Review61:
590–613.
83.
PersellCaroline Hodges1988.
“Reflections on Sociology Textbooks by a Teacher, Scholar, and Author.”
Teaching Sociology16:
399–402.
84.
PhillipsSarah Rengel1991.
“The Hegemony of Heterosexuality: A Study of Introductory Texts.”
Teaching Sociology19:
454–63.
85.
PopenoeDavid2000.
Sociology.
Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Prentice-Hall.
86.
PowersWilliam T.1973.
Behavior: The Control of Perception.
Chicago, IL:
Aldine.
87.
QuarantelliE.L.1954.
“The Nature and Conditions of Panic.”
American Journal of Sociology60:
267–75.
88.
QuarantelliE.L.1981.
“Panic Behavior in Fire Situations.”
Pp. 405–28 in
Proceedings of the Japan Panel on Fire Research and Safety.Tokyo, Japan:
Ministry of Construction.
89.
QuarantelliEnrico1957.
“The Behavior of Panic Participants.”
Sociology and Social Research41:
187–94.
90.
QuarantelliEnrico1960.
“Images of Withdrawal Behavior in Disasters.”
Social Problems8:
68–79.
91.
ReicherStephenPotterJonathan1985.
“Psychological Theory as Intergroup Perspective: A Comparative Analysis of ‘Scientific’ and ‘Lay’ Accounts of Crowd Events.”
Human Relations38:
167–89.
92.
RenzettiClaireCurranDaniel2000.
Living Sociology.
Boston, MA:
Allyn and Bacon.
93.
RitzerGeorge1988.
“Problems, Scandals, and the Possibility of ‘Textbookgate’: An Author's View.”
Teaching Sociology16:
373–80.
94.
RosenfeldMichael J.1997.
“Celebration, Politics, Selective Looting and Riots: A Micro Level Study of the Bulls Riot of 1992 in Chicago.”
Social Problems44:
483–502.
SchweingruberDavid1995.
“A Computer Simulation of a Sociological Experiment.”
Social Science Computer Review13:
351–9.
97.
SchweingruberDavid2000.
“Mob Sociology and Escalated Force: Sociology's Contribution to Repressive Police Tactics.”
The Sociological Quarterly41:
371–89.
98.
SchweingruberDavid2005.
“Looking for the Core in the Wrong Place.”
Teaching Sociology33:
81–9.
99.
SchweingruberDavidMcPhailClark1999.
“A Method for Systematically Observing and Recording Collective Action.”
Sociological Methods and Research27:
451–98.
100.
ScottBarbara MarlieneSchwartzMary Ann2000.
Sociology: Making Sense of the Social World.
Boston, MA:
Allyn and Bacon.
101.
ShellyRobert K.AndersonLeonMattleyChristine1992.
“Assembling Processes in a Periodic Gathering: Halloween in Athens, Ohio.”
Sociological Focus25:
139–49.
SimeJonathan D.1980.
“The Concept of Panic.”
Pp. 63–82 in
Fires and Human Behaviour,
edited by CantorDavidNew York:
Wiley.
104.
SimeJonathan D.1995.
“Crowd Psychology and Engineering.”
Safety Science21:
1–14.
105.
SmelserNeil1963.
Theory of Collective Behavior.
New York:
Free Press.
106.
SmithMichael1983.
Violence and Sport.
Toronto, Ontario, Canada:
Butterworth.
107.
SnowDavid A.PaulsenRonnelle2000.
“Crowds and Riots.”
Pp. 553–62 in
Encyclopedia of Sociology,
edited by BorgattaEdgar F.MontgomeryRhonda J. V.New York:
Macmillan Reference.
108.
StonePamela1996.
“Ghettoized and Marginalized: The Coverage of Racial and Ethnic Groups in Introductory Sociology Texts.”
Teaching Sociology24:
356–63.
109.
StottCliffordReicherStephen1998.
“Crowd Action as Intergroup Process: Introducing the Police Perspective.”
European Journal of Social Psychology28:
509–29.
110.
SullivanThomas2001.
Sociology: Concepts and Applications in a Diverse World.
Boston, MA:
Allyn and Bacon.
111.
TaubDianeFanflikPatricia2000.
“The Inclusion of Disability in Introductory Sociology Textbooks.”
Teaching Sociology28:
12–23.
112.
ThioAlex2000.
Sociology: A Brief Introduction.
Boston, MA:
Allyn and Bacon.
113.
ThompsonWilliamHickeyJoseph2002.
Society in Focus.
Boston, MA:
Allyn and Bacon.
114.
TierneyKathleen1994.
“Property Damage and Violence: A Collective Behavior Analysis.”
Pp. 49–173 in
The Los Angeles Riots: Lessons for the Urban Future,
edited by Baldas-sareMarkBoulder, CO:
Westview.
115.
TierneyKathleen2002.
“Strength of a City: A Disaster Research Perspective on the World Trade Center Attack.”
Social Science Research Council.
Retrieved October 5, 2004 (www.ssrc.org/sept11/essays/tierney.htm).
116.
TillyCharles1978.
From Mobilization to Revolution.
New York:
Random House.
117.
TillyCharles1993.
“Contentious Repertoires in Great Britain, 1758–1834.”
Social Science History17:
253–80.
118.
TillyCharlesTillyLouiseTillyRichard1975.
The Rebellious Century: 1830–1930.
Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press.
119.
TischlerHenry2002.
Introduction to Sociology.
Fort Worth, TX:
Harcourt.
120.
TuckerCharles W.SchweingruberDavidMcPhailClark1999.
“Simulating Arcs and Rings in Temporary Gatherings.”
International Journal of Human-Computer Studies50:
581–88.
UseemBert1985.
“Disorganization and the New Mexico Prison Riot.”
American Sociological Review50:
667–88.
123.
UseemBert1997.
“The State and Collective Disorders: The Los Angeles Riot/Protest of April, 1992.”
Social Forces76:
357–77.
124.
VaughanEd2001.
Sociology: The Study of Society.
Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Prentice Hall.
125.
WhyteWilliam Hollingwood1980.
The Social Life of Small Urban Spaces.
Washington, DC:
The Conservation Foundation.
126.
WimberlyRonald C.HoodThomasLipseyC. M.ClellandDonaldHayMarguerite1975.
“Conversion in a Billy Graham Crusade: Spontaneous Event or Ritual Performance.”
The Sociological Quarterly16:
162–70.
127.
ZillmanD.BryantJ.SapolskyB.1979.
“The Enjoyment of Watching Sports Contests.”
Pp. 297–335 in
Sports, Games, and Play,
edited by GoldsteinJeffreyHillsdale, NJ:
Earlbaum.
