Sociology is often portrayed as an errant discipline, driving forward without any apparent direction or purpose. We contend that these perceptions about the central tenets of our discipline derive from a lack of standardization of core material, which reduces the social value of sociology as a scientific field and erodes its credibility as a discipline. Insofar as common conceptual knowledge exists in the field of sociology, one ought to find evidence of it in the introductory textbook. To this end, our study examines 35 introductory sociology textbooks published in the 1940s (n=16) and the 1990s (n=19) in search of common concepts that represent cumulative core disciplinary knowledge. While our findings reveal uniformity in the structure of the textbooks' major chapter headings within their respective decades, our analysis of concepts—the language used to introduce disciplinary content—reveals that the vast majority are referenced by only one text, with fewer than three percent of all concepts shared in common. Moreover, neither the number of concepts introduced only once nor the variability in the total number of concepts referenced declined across the two decades. In sum, while introductory sociology textbooks are structured in similar ways, we find little commonality in the concepts used by texts' authors to frame the discipline, either within the two cross-sections or between them.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AddamsJane1910.
Twenty Years at Hull House.New York: Macmillan
2.
BabchukNicholasKeithBruce1995.
“Introducing the Discipline: The Scholarly Content of Introductory Texts.”
Teaching Sociology23:
215–25.
3.
BarnarttSharon N.1990.
“A Review of Medical Sociology Textbooks.”
Teaching Sociology18:
372–76.
BeemanMarkChowdhryGeetaToddKarmen2000.
“Educating Students about Affirmative Action: An Analysis of University Sociology Texts.”
Teaching Sociology28:
98–115.
6.
BergerPeter L.1963.
Invitation to Sociology.
New York: Anchor
7.
BergerRonald J.1989.
“Teaching the Sociology of Law: Alternative Approaches to Course Organization.”
Teaching Sociology17:
49–55.
8.
BirnbaumNorman1971.
Toward a Critical Sociology.New York: Oxford University Press
9.
CappellCharles L.GuterbockThomas M.1992.
“The Social and Conceptual Structure of Sociology Specialties.”
American Sociological Review57:
266–73.
10.
ColeStephen2001.
What's Wrong with Sociology?New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction
11.
ColeStephen1992.
Making Science: Between Nature and Society.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
12.
“The Hierarchy of Sciences.”
American Journal of Sociology
89:
111–39
13.
CollinsPatricia Hill1998.
“Reflections on Sociology as a Science.”
Contemporary Sociology27:
7–11.
14.
CollinsRandall1986.
“Is 1980's Sociology in the Doldrums?”
American Journal of Sociology86:
984–1014.
15.
CollinsRandall1998.
“The Sociological Eye and Its Blinders.”
Contemporary Sociology27:
2–7.
16.
Dennick-BrechtM. Kathryn1993.
“Developing a More Inclusive Sociology Curriculum: Racial and Ethnic Group Coverage in Thirty Introductory Textbooks.”
Teaching Sociology21:
166–71.
17.
DevoreJay L.1995.
Probability and Statistics for Engineering and the Sciences.4th ed.Pacific Grove, CA: Duxbury Press
18.
DolchNorman A.1990.
“A Review of Social Problems Texts.”
Teaching Sociology18:
385–89.
19.
FeaginJoe R.2001.
“Social Justice and Sociology: Agendas for the Twenty-First Century.”
American Sociological Review66:
1–20.
20.
GiddingsFranklin1896.
The Principles of Sociology.New York: Macmillan
21.
GiddensAnthony1986.
Social Theory and Modern Sociology.Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press
22.
GrahamFranklin C.1988.
“Some Observations on Sociological Textbooks: An Editorial Perspective.”
Teaching Sociology16:
356–65.
23.
GreenwoodNancy A.CassidyMargaret L.1986.
“A Review of Introductory Marriage and Family Texts: Standards for Evaluation.”
Teaching Sociology14:
295–302.
24.
GreenwoodNancy A.CassidyMargaret L.1990.
“A Critical Review of Family Sociology Textbooks.”
Teaching Sociology18:
541–49.
25.
HallElaine J.1988.
“One Week for Women? The Structure of Inclusion of Gender Issues in Introductory Textbooks.”
Teaching Sociology16:
431–42.
26.
HallinanMaureen T.1998.
“Sociology and the Goal of Generalization.”
Contemporary Sociology27:
21–24.
27.
HargensLowell1975.
Patterns of Scientific Research. A Comparative Analysis of Research in Three Scientific Fields.Washington, DC: American Sociological Association
28.
JudkinsBennett M.1994.
“The Changing Nature of Sociological Inquiry: A Review of Research Methods Textbooks.”
Teaching Sociology22:
105–17.
29.
KaplanAbraham1964.
The Conduct of Inquiry.San Francisco, CA: Chandler
30.
KeithBruce2000.
“Taking Stock of the Discipline: Some Reflections on the State of American Sociology.”
The American Sociologist31:
5–14.
31.
KuhnThomas S.1970.
The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
32.
LewisJonathan F.AlshtawiMusa1992.
“Then and Now: The Treatment of Selected Theorists in American Social Theory Texts.”
Teaching Sociology20:
44–50.
33.
LucalBetsy1994.
“Class Stratification in Introductory Textbooks: Relational or Distributional Models.”
Teaching Sociology22:
139–50.
34.
LynchMichaelBogenDavid1997.
“Sociology's Asociological ‘Core’: An Examination of Textbook Sociology in Light of the Sociology of Scientific Knowledge.”
American Sociological Review62:
481–93.
35.
LyndRobert1939.
Knowledge for What?Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
36.
MannSusan A.GrimesMichael D.KempAlice AbelJenkinsPamela J.1997.
“Paradigm Shifts in Family Sociology?: Evidence from Three Decades of Family Textbooks.”
Journal of Family Issues18:
315–49.
37.
MarquezStephanie Amedeo1994.
“Distorting the Image of ‘Hispanic’ Women in Sociology: Problematic Strategies of Presentation in the Introductory Text.”
Teaching Sociology22:
231–36.
38.
Marx FerreeMyraHallElaine J.1996.
“Rethinking Stratification from a Feminist Perspective: Gender, Race, and Class in Mainstream Textbooks.”
American Sociological Review61:
929–50.
39.
MertonRobert1993.
On the Shoulders of Giants.Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
40.
MillsC. Wright1953.
White Collar: The American Middle Classes.New York: Oxford University Press
41.
MillsC. Wright1956.
The Power Elite.New York: Oxford University Press
42.
MillsC. Wright1959.
The Sociological Imagination.New York: Oxford University Press
43.
MulkeyLynn1990.
“Consequences of Too Many Sociologies for Teaching Sociology of Education.”
Teaching Sociology18:
356–61.
44.
NajafizadehMehrangizMennerickLewis A.1992.
“Sociology of Education or Sociology of Ethnocentrism? The Portrayal of Education in U.S. Introductory Sociology Textbooks.”
Teaching Sociology20:
215–21.
45.
NiemonenJack1993.
“Some Observations on the Problem of Paradigms in Recent Racial and Ethnic Relations Texts.”
Teaching Sociology21:
271–86.
46.
OdumHoward W.1951.
American Sociology: The Story of Sociology in the United States through 1950.New York: Longmans, Green, and Company
47.
RismanBarbara J.Tomaskovic-DeveyDonald1998.
“Symposia: A Window to the Discipline.”
Contemporary Sociology27:1–2
48.
RitzerGeorge1975.
“Sociology: A Multiple Paradigm Science.”
The American Sociologist10:
156–67.
49.
RitzerGeorge1981.
“Paradigm Analysis in Sociology: Clarifying the Issues.”
American Sociological Review46:
245–48.
50.
RossEdward A.1907.
Sin and Society: An Analysis of Latter Day Inequity.Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin
51.
SchachtSteven P.1990.
“Statistics Textbooks: Pedagogical Tools or Impediments to Learning?”
Teaching Sociology18:
390–96.
52.
SchuttRussell K.1987.
“Recent Research Methods Texts; Means for Achieving Course Goals?”
Teaching Sociology15:
203–13.
Shaw TaylorYokuBenokraitisNijole V.1995.
“The Presentation of Minorities in Marriage and Family Textbooks.”
Teaching Sociology23:
122–35.
55.
SmallAlbion W.VincentGeorge E.1894.
An Introduction to the Study of Society.New York: American Book Company
56.
StolleyKathy ShepherdHillArchie E.1996.
“Presentations of the Elderly in Textbooks on Marriage and Family”
Teaching Sociology24:
34–45.
57.
StonePamela1996.
“Ghettoized and Marginalized: The Coverage of Racial and Ethnic Groups in Introductory Sociology Texts.”
Teaching Sociology24:
356–63.
58.
TaubDiane E.FanflikPatricia L.2000.
“The Inclusion of Disability in Introductory Sociology, Textbooks.”
Teaching Sociology28:
12–23.
59.
TrevinoA. Javier1998.
“Nine Law and Society/Sociology of Law Textbooks and Readers for the 1990s: A Comparative Review.”
Teaching Sociology26:
354–80.
60.
TurnerJonathan H.1989.
“The Disintegration of American Sociology: Pacific Sociological Association 1988 Presidential Address.”
Sociological Perspectives32:
419–33.
61.
WardLester. F.1897.
The Outlines of Sociology.New York: Macmillan
62.
WeitzRose1992.
“The Presentation of AIDS/HIV Disease in Introductory Sociology Textbooks.”
Teaching Sociology20:
239–43.
63.
WrightRichard A.1987.
“Are ‘Sisters in Crime’ Finally Being Booked? The Coverage of Women and Crime in Journals and Textbooks.”
Teaching Sociology15:
418–22.
64.
WrightRichard A.1990.
“Ten Recent Criminology Textbooks: Diversity without Currency or Quality.”
Teaching Sociology18:
550–61.
65.
“Twenty Recent Criminology Textbooks: Continued Diversity without Currency or Quality.”
Teaching Sociology
22:
87–104
66.
WrightRichard A.1995a.
“Where There's a Will, There's No Way: The Treatment of the Choice Debate in Criminology Textbooks, 1956 to 1965 and 1983 to 1992.”
Teaching Sociology23:
8–15.
67.
WrightRichard A.1995b.
“Women as ‘Victims’ and as ‘Resisters’: Depictions of the Oppression of Women in Criminology Textbooks.”
Teaching Sociology23:
111–21.
68.
WrightRichard A.1995c.
“Was There a ‘Golden Past’ for the Introductory Sociology Textbook? A Citation Analysis of Leading Journals.”
The American Sociologist26:
41–48.
69.
WrightRichard A.DucajiCarolyn M.1992.
“When Pictures Lie: Photographs of Crimes and Criminals in Introductory Criminology Textbooks.”
Teaching Sociology20:
36–43.
70.
ZaldMayer N.1991.
“Sociology as a Discipline: Quasi-science and Quasi-humanities.”
The American Sociologist22:
165–88.
71.
ZinnMaxine BacaEitzenStanley D.1988.
“Transforming the Sociology of the Family: New Directions for Teaching and Texts.”
Teaching Sociology16:
180–84.
